Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout
haven't archived this post yet. have a subscription? use the importer!

Content

OK, so I finally did a city visit to a city where I actually know what I'm talking about! Portland is coming today. So, one of the questions I get asked on my channel is, what kind of projects did you work on when you were a professional urban/transportation planner? Well, you'll get a few answers in today's video, because I worked on A LOT of projects in the Portland area. And, spoiler: not all the plans you spend years of effort and millions of dollars in staff time getting adopted at city council actually get implemented the way they're supposed to. Yes, huge shocker, I know. I won't spoil it here, but Portland has really struggled to build on its identity as "America's Bike Capital," to the point where it likely ceded that crown years ago.

Here's a bigger question that I pose in the video and I don't have great answers for. A lot of US cities' downtowns are struggling in the past couple of years, either because of work-from-home sapping central cities of foot traffic and vitality, or any number of other reasons related to housing affordability, income inequality, etc. This was evident in Minneapolis, and certainly Portland. I don't think there's a silver-bullet solution here, but if you have a theory or brilliant idea for how to get US downtowns back on track, drop it in the comments here!

Files

Previews only

Comments

Kyle

Like many others in the comments, it comes down to "there's few reasons to go downtown". I hope you get something from Brooke's comments; that sounds interesting. Since you mentioned the drivers ignoring traffic signs, I'd be interested in hearing about: * What solutions do traffic engineering/planning have to make disobeying traffic rules difficult/designed to make it impossible * (Most?) effective ways for the general public to submit feedback to traffic/planning departments A bunch of streets near me in Seattle have been declared a "Healthy Street" (1), and part of the change is cars aren't supposed to turn left across traffic onto the Healthy Street. So, of course some cars ignore the traffic signs and turn left. I've considered giving feedback asking for flex posts/similar to be installed across the middle of the street, so it's more obvious drivers aren't supposed to turn left compared to "just" a sign. But I also don't know if unsolicited feedback will go into the digital trash. 1: https://www.seattle.gov/transportation/projects-and-programs/programs/healthy-streets/bell-street-park-stay-healthy-street

CityNerd

Yeah, depends on the city how much of a response you get but there's usually an online portal for alerting the DOT of issues and making suggestions. If you make the case that it's a safety issue, that's usually when you get the best response. If I remember, the healthy streets were introduced during covid using the cheapest possible materials. Yeah, for an actual neighborhood greenway or bikeway, you'd want to filter out those left turns, and you'd usually do that with some sort of nontraversable median or flexposts.

Courtney

New here - What’s up city nerd! I absolutely loved your Portlandia video! I’m an ex-Portlander myself, I was so thrilled to see some of the newer bridge projects come to forwishen like the Flanders and … the other one you covered. It was so throwback to see the MAX light rail and tilikum crossing area (I miss Elephants so much, I hope that’s still over there!). Anyhow thanks for the nostalgia. PS I would have loved to see Slabtown, Forest park, and the Central Eastside and NE in your video (easy, right, maybe on the docket)? But awesome work, sir. I would also love to suggest an urban park video or list of the best from you! Now, to address your 2nd part, how to save struggling Downtowns. This is the golden question right now, especially in San Francisco where I live now. If you want my take (coming from a person who studied urban planning in undergrad) and is now a real estate office worker… I think the answer is simple… and if you ask any of the great planners and sociologists of the last century - the might suggest something simple, like there’s needs to be more of a mix of equity and social classes living together in community. San Fran has a 30% vacancy office rate in FiDi. I suppose to fill these spaces, we need social reforms. My idea is to convert these vacancies into nurse education centers and emergency care facilities (for the rampant fentanyl epidemic). People need care, our populations are aging. Our cities should reinforce love and dignity to all people. Instead they are cement nightmare with death traps infesting every crevice. Multimodal transit and people need to live closer to where they do things. Not to mention, there’s a dire need for nurses (not to mention the Kaiser strike of 75k workers right now), we have a need for nurses, and people who need real care and long term solutions. You might be asking, “how on earth will we fund all this” I say get the federal government involved. Remember all those ppl with student debt? Employ worker / live programs to revitalize downtowns. San Francisco is doing a lot of really cool things, like populating storefront with trendy local pop-Ups called “vacant to vibrant”. I’ve already seen a huge turnaround in fidi over the Covid years. Ultimately I think America is in a huge bind with the auto industry addiction and dependence on oil. Our infrastructure and downtowns are built around it and suffer because. We create spaces catered to tourist and bridge and tunnel folk. If we want better, healthier downtowns and cities we need less freeway to city core proximity and barrier pedestrian and multi modal transit streets. Not to mention affordable housing and medical care for all. These issues are all connected. Thanks for reading my rant 🤭 Anyhow, thanks for all great content! Would love you take in SF and Oaklands, Bay Area in general!

CityNerd

I actually did sneak a bit of Slabtown into the video (when I was talking about the Pearl). I'll probably be back soon, and I do intend to cover eastside neighborhoods!