Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Poll

Malevolent: Chapter 252 [POLL]

  • Antoine 222
  • Alia 178
  • 2025-02-13
  • 400 votes
{'title': 'Malevolent: Chapter 252 [POLL]', 'choices': [{'text': 'Antoine', 'votes': 222}, {'text': 'Alia', 'votes': 178}], 'closes_at': None, 'created_at': datetime.datetime(2025, 2, 13, 16, 13, 31, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'description': None, 'allow_multiple': False, 'total_votes': 400}

Comments

Marknado

Alia told us she’d die before Antonie

Monster Energie

Alia said she was going to die before Antoine did

Thomas Breijinck

We gotta go with Alia and hope here - she’s powerful and has been truthful and helpful as best we can tell

Axle

As much as I love alia, I think something bad could happen if we mess with what we know to be true. Sorry queen I love you

Comma

Do we know that being stricken with illness guarantees dying? Maybe we’re being too cut and dry with assuming Alia has to die

Scottie

Voting Antoine cuz I think it's more interesting. (Tho I love him and hope he won't die)

Graham

Getting sick doesn’t necessarily mean dying immediately, and we know the person dying by the fire is a he. If we assume it’s Antoine, then it’s possible by him getting sick before Alia we get them both for longer. Also, Alia has been repeatedly emphasized to be the strongest of our party. Don’t we want to have her with a clearer head for longer? I love Antoine so much, but I’m voting him

HD

Vote Antoine! If Antoine is sick we have 2 healing options. If Alia is sick, we only get one.

Autumn

Voting for Antoine I think, my reasoning: - There’s a man dying at the end of 250 and we know Vale has already died so it’s gotta be Antoine - Antoine has been itching his chest for awhile he might have The Rot - Alia is also way more helpful, even if her healing magic didn’t work on Vale it’s still HEALING magic and Antoine is a glorified hatstand for all we know (I’m so sorry ily Antoine but I’ve gotta be so fr rn)

Dani Ruggeri

I want a last dialogue with Alia. So, rip antoine. that's it, that's my logic. Good chalkboard dialogue with a very interesting character. Antoine is great, but Alia is crazy cool.

Alexi

#misogynywin i guess we should vote antoine

Brittney With An E

i dont think theres necessarily a wrong option here; likely Alia will die as she says regardless, but she nay die from something else should we not pick her to be ill. I think Antoine is alive but either ill or injured as we know Arthur is not alone but the person he is with is unresponsive. Im picking Antoine bc I love women tho

Izzy

Let's allow Alia to die protecting those two sickly children from something big, not from the plague. Vote Antoine!

Martina

I feel really bad voting on this help Anyway.

Quinn

For now this is simply asking who gets *sick* next, not who *dies* next. It’s safe to assume the laboured breathing by the fire is Antoine, since John told Arthur “I don’t know if he’ll survive the night” in chapter 251. So I don’t think there’s a wrong answer. If Antoine gets sick before Alia, then we still have her magic to try and help him and/or Jarthur with whatever comes next. She may not have been able to heal Vale, but that doesn’t mean she can’t help with other things — If Alia gets sick first then she is even less likely to be of use. TLDR vote Antoine ✨

Raven Fritz

I think its best if we Allow Alia to protect the rest of us, sorry Antoine

Dirthawker

EDIT: Y'all are right - I switched to Alia! Let's put every possible show of trust behind her hope in us. PREVIOUSLY: Vote Antoine. I trust Alia will get a more abrupt and dramatic death (to fulfill the prophecy) while Arthur is stuck dragging this poor sad loser along.

Sasha

If Mother Darkness was the one trying to take over the mind of Sir Vale while he was sick (rotting flesh and black fluid sounds like her) then do we really want her doing that to Alia? Whatever magic Alia has is powerful but no way is it strong enough to fight off what's essentially a goddess, especially while weakened from sickness. We can fight Antoine when it comes down to it but if Alia were to attack us under someone else's command? Not great. Vote Antoine, please. -Thoughts from the discord discussion

sendts

antoine gotta go 😭👋

Luna_de_maria

Alía said she would fall next, and Lilith is only asking to twist the knife. This could be a point of showing we trust in Alias power of prophecy rather than undermine them

Axle

oh my god yessss. We can't just prolong the inevitable. I don't want alia to just watch everyone else die and wait for her death

Juanita

So many good arguments this vote! I think I am going to have to fall back on my ‘go to’ tie breaker method *closes eyes and randomly stabs finger at phone screen and closes screen before regret sets in*😀

Bird

Alia told us shed did before Antoine. I feel like its not wise for us to play with the prophecy of someone who is (for now) on our side in us staying safe

jam

i hate this i love my king antoine i love him but he needs to get sick. it needs to be done. cries in my sleep

Marknado

Why are we doing this? Before Lilith arrived John says “his breathing is weak” or something like that. We were already told how this goes down. Why are we voting for Antonie?

Marknado

This is the only good argument I’ve seen for voting Antoine but I’m still a little skeptical idk

vol_ctrl

Why would it be a vote if the answer wouldn't change the story? My thinking is that the longer we can keep Alia healthy, the more use we'll be able to make of her power and magic. We're not voting for who will die, but who will get sick next.

Marknado

You know that does make sense. And I’m definitely starting to see why this is a lot more of a divisive question than I originally thought

Amy

I’m throwing Antoine under the bus, gotta try to preserve my girl for as long as possible

Project Worldbuilder

I love how much thought people put into this. I vote purely on vibes😂