The Fourth Try 16 (Patreon)
Content
Chapter 17: Familial Meetings
The Fuyuki Church stood on its hill, a silent sentinel over the city's spiritual leylines. Inside, the air was thick with the scent of old incense and dust, a perfume of faded faith. Kirei Kotomine stood before the altar, not in prayer, but in a state of quiet anticipation. The hollow ache in his chest, a familiar companion, seemed to pulse with a faint rhythm. The threads of fate were pulling taut. He could feel it.
The great wooden doors of the church creaked open, slicing through the silence. A figure was silhouetted against the deep orange of the setting sun, small and precise, pulling a wheeled suitcase behind her with a soft, steady click against the stone floor.
Kirei did not turn. He had sensed her long before the door opened—a presence both familiar and alien, like a reflection in a distorted mirror.
“Father.” The voice was flat, melodious, and utterly devoid of warmth. It was a statement, not a greeting.
“Caren.” Kirei finally turned, his expression one of mild, detached curiosity. “This is an unexpected… visitation. Has the Assembly of the Church grown tired of its European haunts?”
Caren Hortensia walked forward, her steps measured. She was a young, pale-skinned woman, a more delicate echo of his own, but her lavender eyes held a placid emptiness that contrasted sharply with the deep-seated void in his. She stopped a few paces from him, setting her suitcase down with a definitive click.
“The Holy Church has been formally petitioned,” she stated, her gaze unwavering. “The request, backed by a significant faction within the Clock Tower, comes from one Bazett Fraga McRemitz. The charges are extensive: dereliction of duty as Overseer, malicious interference in the Heaven's Feel ritual, assault upon a Master in the Church, and the theft of a Servant, subsequently making yourself an illegitimate participant.”
She paused, allowing the weight of the accusations to hang in the air. Kirei’s lips twitched, the barest hint of a smile.
“Serious allegations,” he mused. “From a woman who failed to secure her own Servant.”
“The validity of the source does not negate the evidence,” Caren replied, her tone clinical, as if diagnosing a disease. “Your actions have brought the Church into shame and disrepute and threatened the delicate balance with the Mage's Association. Your tenure as Overseer is terminated, effective immediately. I am your replacement.”
She finally delivered the verdict, her empty eyes meeting his. “Consider this a reassignment for the official records. The choice to depart Fuyuki peacefully by giving up your Command Spells or participating as a true Master is yours to make.”
A slow, dark, and genuinely pleased smile spread across Kirei Kotomine’s face. It was the first true expression he had felt all day. It was a development far more interesting than merely presiding over the war. It was a promise of suffering, conflict, and exquisite despair, all delivered by his own daughter. It was… delicious.
The heavy oak doors of the Fuyuki Church opened once more, this time with less ceremony. Three figures entered, their footsteps echoing in the cavernous space and abruptly halting the silent standoff between father and daughter.
Lord El-Melloi II led the way, his modern suit looking out of place amidst the Gothic arches, his face etched with its customary weariness. Behind him, Gray kept her head slightly bowed, the hood of her cloak shadowing her features, one hand nervously clutching the large, wrapped case that held her scythe. Mash Kyrielight brought up the rear, her posture alert and protective, her eyes quickly scanning the environment for threats.
Caren Hortensia turned her placid gaze toward them, seamlessly transitioning from one duty to the next. "Welcome," she stated, her voice flat and efficient. "I am Caren Hortensia, the newly appointed Overseer of the Fuyuki Holy Grail War. How may I assist you?"
Waver's eyes flickered from Caren to Kirei, his magus instincts immediately recognizing a shift in the established order. He gave a curt, professional nod. "Lord El-Melloi II. We are here to register a new Master." He gestured slightly to the cloaked girl beside him. "This is my apprentice, Gray. She will be participating in this Grail War."
"Registration is a simple formality," Caren replied, her tone indicating she had already processed the information. She then gestured languidly toward her father. "For the sake of full transparency, you should be aware that the former Overseer, Kirei Kotomine, is no longer acting in an official capacity. He has chosen to participate as a Master in the War, having formed a contract with the Lancer-class Servant."
The blunt declaration was a deliberate provocation, a surgical strike aimed at exposing Kirei's position to all newcomers. Kirei, for his part, merely offered a deeper, more beatific smile, as if his daughter had just complimented him.
Waver’s frown deepened. Lancer? The calculation ran through his mind in an instant. Bazett Fraga McRemitz was the Association's designated participant. She had prepared a powerful relic for the express purpose of summoning a Lancer. For Kotomine to now be Lancer's Master could only mean one thing: the complaints against him were not only true, but understated. He filed the information away, saying nothing. This was not the place for Clock Tower politics.
"Kotomine," Waver acknowledged, his voice cool.
"Lord El-Melloi," Kirei returned, his voice a low rumble of amusement. "Or should I say, Waver Velvet? It is… intriguing to see you involved in another Fuyuki affair. After what happened to your Rider."
Waver ignored the bait, but Kirei's attention had already shifted, his dark eyes focusing intently on Gray. The girl flinched under his gaze as if physically touched.
"My," Kirei mused, his head tilting. "The resemblance is… uncanny. One could almost mistake you for the Saber Servant of the previous War. A curious twist of fate, or something more deliberate?"
Gray shrunk back, a small, pained sound catching in her throat. Waver immediately stepped forward, placing himself squarely between Kotomine and his student, his expression hardening into a scowl.
"That is none of your concern," Waver bit out, his tone leaving no room for further inquiry. He turned his back on the priest, addressing Caren. "Is the registration complete?"
Caren gave a slight, almost imperceptible nod. "The Master, Gray, is now formally recognized. The rules of the War apply to her. That concludes our business."
Without another word, Waver ushered the two girls out of the church, the large door swinging shut behind them with a thud that felt like a full stop.
Outside, in the clear afternoon air, Mash let out a breath she didn't realize she'd been holding. "Senpai… that man, Kotomine. His presence felt… unsettling."
Gray nodded silently, her hand trembling slightly as she pulled her hood tighter.
"He's a dangerous individual," Waver confirmed, lighting a cigarette and taking a long, steadying drag. "It's good that you felt that. It means your instincts are sharp. Fear him? No. But you should be wary of him in the same way you're wary of a venomous snake. Keep your distance and watch his movements."
He exhaled a plume of smoke, his gaze fixed on the church spire. "My role here is as an observer and a teacher, not a combatant. I cannot fight your battles for you. But I can advise you, and I will be watching the other Masters closely. If anyone attempts to break the rules or gain an unfair advantage," he said, his voice firming with resolve, "I will be ready to intervene. You are not alone in this."
His words were a shield, a promise of support from the sidelines. For Gray and Mash, standing at the precipice of a war of legends, it was a reassurance they desperately needed.
------------------------------------------
The forest was no longer a place of patient strategy; it was a cage of boredom. Illyasviel von Einzbern had been watching the Emiya residence for what felt like an eternity, her small fingers tapping an impatient rhythm on Berserker's stony arm. The initial thrill of the hunt had soured into the frustration of a stalled game.
Three Servants. Maybe more. Their spiritual signatures were a tangled knot around her Onii-chan, a fortress she couldn't simply storm without it becoming a messy, indecisive brawl. Waiting for him to leave felt less like a smart tactic and more like… losing.
A deep, petulant pout settled on her lips. This was no fun at all.
"Berserker," she declared, her voice losing its playful lilt and taking on the edge of a command. "I'm tired of waiting. If Shirou won't come out to play, we'll just have to go in and get him."
The colossal Servant beside her let out a low, ground-shaking growl that was neither agreement nor dissent, but a simple acknowledgment of her will. The air around him thickened with palpable bloodlust, the promise of violence answering her change in mood.
Illya’s logic was as simple as it was terrifying. The Einzberns had created the ultimate weapon in Heracles. His strength was absolute. His Nine Lives made him nigh-unkillable. What did it matter how many allies Shirou had gathered? In a contest of pure, brute force, Berserker was unmatched. All walls could be broken. All swords could be shattered. If the other Servants dared to stand in her way, they would simply become part of the collateral damage on her path to claiming what was hers.
She hopped down from her perch, her white dress a stark contrast to the dark earth and green foliage. She didn't sneak. She didn't devise a clever plan. She simply began to walk, a small, determined figure leading a titan of legend towards the quiet, suburban home.
"Let's go, Berserker," she said, her tone now cheerful once more, the boredom replaced by anticipatory glee. "It's time to crash Onii-chan's little party. I hope he has enough tea for all of us."
Her confidence was absolute. She was the master of the strongest Servant, and she was done playing by rules of caution she deemed beneath her. The time for watching was over. The time for taking had begun.
-------------------------
The plan was set. Shirou had his gloves on, Rin had checked her gems, and Medusa was a silent, watchful presence as they moved toward the main gate. They were moments from stepping out to face the viper's nest of the church.
That was when the world tore apart.
It wasn't a sound, but a sensation—a primal, overwhelming pressure that slammed down on the Emiya property like a physical weight. The intricately layered Bounded Fields that Kiritsugu had woven, which Shirou had maintained for years, didn't just waver or fail. They shattered. It was the sound of a thousand panes of glass breaking at once.
Shirou and Rin froze in unison, their bodies locking up in instinctual terror.
Through the open doorway, at the edge of the property line, stood a mountain of muscle and rage, his dark skin and stone axe radiating pure, undiluted menace. Berserker.
And standing beside him, a small, smiling girl in a white dress, her crimson eyes fixed directly on Shirou.
Illyasviel von Einzbern opened her mouth, a sweet, triumphant smile gracing her lips. "Hello, Onii-chan, I'm here to—"
The air left her lungs in a sudden whoosh. The sentence died, not from an attack, but from a sudden, overwhelming impact.
It was Shirou Emiya.
He moved not as a magus, not as a Master, but as a force of nature. The moment his brain processed "Illya" and "alive," he was gone from the room in a blur of motion. He didn't trace a weapon. He didn't assume a fighting stance. He became a human missile, crossing the distance in a heartbeat and honing in on the small, white-haired girl.
He collided with her, his arms wrapping around her small frame in a hug so tight it was less an embrace and more a desperate act of anchoring himself to reality. He lifted her off her feet, burying his face in her shoulder, his entire body trembling with a relief so profound it momentarily eclipsed the terrifying presence of the Mad Heroic Spirit standing two meters away.
"Illya," he breathed, his voice a raw, choked whisper. "You're here. You're okay."
The sheer, unadulterated shock of the action froze everyone.
Rin's jaw was hanging open, her carefully prepared tactical assessments crumbling into dust. Is he insane?! He just hugged the other Master! One that was here to attack!! Likely the Einzbern Heir from her looks!!!
Behind Berserker, the giant Servant, who had been ready to reduce the entire house to splinters, paused. The mindless rage in his eyes flickered with something akin to confusion. This was not a hostile action. This was… unfamiliar.
And Illya herself was utterly, completely stunned. Her arms were pinned to her sides. Her planned speech, her dramatic introduction, her entire persona of the merciless Einzbern heiress—it all evaporated in the face of this bizarre, warm, and terrifyingly genuine assault. She could feel the frantic beating of his heart against her chest, the slight tremble in his arms. This wasn't a trick. He was… genuinely happy to see her.
For a single, breathless moment, the impending battle was forgotten, replaced by the surreal image of Shirou Emiya desperately hugging his would-be assassin while her nigh-invincible Servant looked on, utterly nonplussed.
---------------------------
The shattering of the Bounded Field and the ensuing shockwave of Berserker's presence sent the rest of the household scrambling. The shoji screen to the garden slammed open, revealing Artoria, still in the casual clothes Sakura had lent her, but with a presence so sharp the air itself seemed to harden around her. In her hand, Invisible Air was already gathered, ready to be unleashed. Behind her, Sakura and Kiara peered out, their faces pale with fear.
And from the rooftop, a flicker of red light solidified into Archer, his bow materialized, a grimace of anticipated conflict on his face. The calamity had arrived. It was time to see if the boy had the mettle to face it.
The scene that greeted them was one none of their minds could immediately process.
There was no battle. No clashing steel. No desperate last stand.
There was only Shirou, kneeling in the dirt of his front garden, his arms wrapped so tightly around the small, white-haired Einzbern heiress that she was lifted clean off her feet. It wasn't an attack. It was a hug. A desperate, brotherly hug, filled with a relief so profound it was palpable.
The collective shock was a physical force.
Archer’s bow arm slowly lowered, his grey eyes wide with a confusion that bordered on disbelief. What is this? This was not the cold, calculating anomaly he was trying to understand. This was… a boy embracing his sister. The sheer, illogical humanity of the act clashed violently with the image of the detached strategist who had projected Rule Breaker. It only deepened the enigma. Who are you?
Sakura’s hand flew to her mouth, her fear momentarily replaced by a wave of bewildered empathy. She saw no monster in the girl, only a child as stunned as she was.
But it was Artoria whose world tilted on its axis.
She knew Illyasviel von Einzbern. She knew her as Kiritsugu's true daughter, the homunculus created to be the Grail, a figure of tragic inevitability. To see Shirou—this Shirou, who was supposedly a stranger from another world—greet her with such raw, personal recognition…
The contradiction was so stark it sent a sharp, lancing pain through her temples.
Why… why does this feel familiar?
And then, like a dam breaking, the memory surfaced—a conversation she had forgotten, buried under the trauma of her summoning and the blackening of her spirit.
"The world you are heading to is a curious one, Artoria," Merlin's voice echoed in her mind, playful yet grave. "It's caught in a temporal eddy, repeating its mistakes until someone gets it right. A time loop, if you will."
A time loop.
She had forgotten. She had arrived in this time, her memories of her own loops intact, but that crucial context from the Mage of Flowers had been scoured away. Was it the corruption of her summoning? The strain of crossing time and space? Or… had something else actively suppressed it?
The pieces, once impossibly scattered, slammed together with the force of a thunderclap. This wasn't another world's Shirou Emiya.
This was her Shirou.
Her knight. Her Master. The boy she had watched die, for whom she had torn through the walls of the World itself to reach.
He had lived through the loops. He remembered. All of it. The memories, the pain, the power—it was all his. The projection, the tactics, the strange familiarity with Illya… it was all because he had lived it before.
He had been here all along, and she, in her despair, had mistaken his hard-won strength for the mark of a stranger. The realization was a lance through her heart, a devastating mix of soaring hope and crushing guilt.
She stood frozen, Invisible Air dying in her grasp, her emerald eyes fixed on the brother and sister reunited, seeing the boy she loved hidden within the man she didn't recognize.
-----------------------------
For Illyasviel von Einzbern, the world had narrowed to a single, baffling point of contact.
Shirou Emiya was hugging her.
The pressure of his arms around her was a physical fact her mind couldn't process. It was warm. Solid. It wasn't an attack. It was… an embrace. Her body went rigid, every instinct screaming that this was a trick, a trap, a prelude to a dagger in the back.
But the dagger never came. Only the hug. And the trembling.
Why?
The questions erupted in her mind like a panicked flock of birds.
Why is he hugging me? No one hugged her. Berserker protected her. Her maids tended to her. But no one… held her. Not since Mama and Papa were gone.
Why is he glad to see me? I came here to take him. To hurt him. To make him pay for stealing my father. He should be afraid. He should be fighting. He should be angry.
Why does he know me? Her name had been on her lips, ready to be delivered with cold, triumphant finality. But he had spoken it first, with a familiarity that felt… old. Worn. Like a favorite storybook.
A terrible, hopeful, terrifying thought wormed its way into her heart.
Did… did Father tell him about me?
The idea was a seismic shock. What had Kiritsugu Emiya said? Had he spoken of a little girl with white hair and red eyes? Had he, in this house that should have been hers, ever mentioned the daughter he left behind in the cold? Did he tell Shirou that she was kind? That she liked birds? That he missed her?
Why is he happy to see me? The thought was a plea. If Kiritsugu had spoken of her, then maybe… maybe she hadn't been completely forgotten. Maybe a part of her father had lived here, after all.
Why is he hugging me? The initial shock was melting, replaced by a strange, unwelcome, and deeply longed-for sensation. It felt… safe.
And then she felt a dampness on her shoulder. She tried to pull back, to look at his face, but he held fast.
Why is he crying?
The tremors in his body weren't just from exertion; they were sobs he was trying and failing to suppress. He was crying for her. For the sister who had come to kill him.
A hot, sharp pressure built behind her own eyes. She fought it. Einzberns did not cry. They endured. They achieved their goal.
But her goal was crumbling into dust.
A single, traitorous tear escaped, tracing a clean path down her cheek through the dust from the shattered bounded field. Then another.
Why was she crying?
She had come to make them hurt.
Then she felt a small pair of hands hug her as well.
Kiara, seeing Shirou hug Illya with such desperation, had come and hugged them both.
Sakura, after a hesitation, did the same; then Saber, remembering Irisviel and her Shirou, did the same. Rin, with a blush, muttered something and hugged as well. Berserker, seeing this as some sort of ritual and sensing his master's emotions, hugged them all tenderly as well, leaving his weapon down.
Archer, after getting several mental messages from Rin, joins the group hug too.
To be Continued.........