The Fourth Try Chapter 19 (Patreon)
Content
Chapter: Three Roads to Ruin
Outside the dojo, Taiga pressed herself against the wall, her hand clamped over her mouth so hard it hurt.
Magic. Holy Grail War. Death.
None of it made sense. Ms. Pendragon—that polite foreign woman who'd been staying at Shirou's house—was talking about impossible things. Battles. Servants. Time loops. And Shirou was just... listening. Like this was normal.
But what terrified Taiga more than the incomprehensible words was the feeling blooming in her chest.
Grief.
Raw, overwhelming grief for something she couldn't remember. Something that felt like it had happened to her, even though she knew it hadn't. Tears streamed down her face before she even understood why she was crying.
Why does this hurt so much?
A sob built in her throat. She choked it down, both hands now pressed against her mouth, her whole body shaking with the effort of staying silent.
She'd come here to surprise Shirou. To drag him out for dinner, maybe tease him about Ms. Pendragon. Normal things. Safe things.
Instead, she was eavesdropping on something that felt like watching someone's soul bleed out.
Above the dojo, unseen by anyone, a hairline fracture appeared in the evening sky.
{{Line Break}}
Inside, Shirou took a deep breath. His chest felt tight—too tight—as Saber finished speaking. Her voice had been steady, controlled, but he could hear the weight behind every word. The love. The loss. The years she'd carried this.
She loved that version of me that much.
The thought was almost too much to bear.
"My turn," he said quietly.
Everyone's eyes turned to him. Rin, analytical and tense. Sakura, already trembling. Illya, impossibly still. Medusa, a silent shadow behind Sakura. Archer, leaning against the wall with an expression Shirou couldn't read.
And in the corner, almost forgotten in her silence, sat ten-year-old Kiara.
The child had been so quiet throughout Saber's story, sitting with her knees pulled up to her chest, that the adults had nearly forgotten she was there. Her dark eyes were fixed on Shirou with an intensity that seemed far too old for her young face.
And Saber, watching him with those green eyes that had seen him die and live and die again.
Shirou closed his eyes.
"I never meant to get involved in the Holy Grail War."
{{Line Break}}
The First Path: Fate
His voice was calm. Too calm. Like he was narrating someone else's story.
"If you'd asked me back then what I wanted, I would've told you something simple. Something naive. I just wanted to help people. I wanted to save others the way I was saved when the flames took everything from me ten years ago. Kiritsugu pulled me out of that hell, and I built my entire life around honoring the ideal he left behind."
Rin's fingers curled into fists. She remembered that fire. The Fuyuki disaster. But she'd never known Shirou had been there. Had been in it.
"But ideals don't mean much when you're bleeding out in your own shed."
Shirou's voice didn't waver.
"That night,Lancer ran me through without hesitation. I should've died. In fact, I did die—if you want to be technical. Something forced me back, though."
He opened his eyes, looking directly at Rin.
"You saved me. With a pendant. An heirloom you threw away on a stranger you didn't even see."
Rin's breath caught.
"And then I accidentally summoned a Servant of my own."
Saber straightened slightly, her expression carefully neutral.
"Saber. A knight, perfect and terrifyingly radiant, who introduced herself like she wasn't standing there after saving me from a supernatural hitman. That was the moment everything changed."
{{Line Break}}
Shirou's narration continued, detached and methodical.
The war. The battles. Rider falling. Caster's machinations. Fighting alongside Saber against Berserker—watching her match a monster blow for blow.
"At first, I didn't understand Saber at all. She was the ideal I claimed to admire—strength, discipline, honor—and yet whenever she stepped forward to protect me, I'd reflexively move to shield her. She hated that."
A ghost of a smile crossed Saber's face. Yes. She had hated that.
"It took time, and arguments, and danger to realize she wasn't just a knight. She was a person. A tired one. A lonely one. And she carried a burden heavier than anything I had imagined."
Sakura wiped at her eyes, already crying silently.
"My ideals were tested hardest when we faced Gilgamesh. He treated humans as ants. He taunted Saber, offering her a place at his side like she was a trophy to display. She rejected him without hesitation."
Shirou's voice softened, just slightly.
"But the Grail... The Grail was the real enemy. It wasn't a wish-granting miracle. It was corrupted, festering, overflowing with hatred. Saber was destined to claim it. She believed that if she did, she could save her kingdom. But that meant throwing away everything she had learned here—everything she had become since being summoned."
His hands clenched.
"So I made a choice. A selfish one, maybe. But it was mine. I asked her to destroy it."
Saber's breath hitched almost imperceptibly.
"She hesitated—of course she did. This was her one chance to undo the tragedy of her life. But in the end, she listened to her own heart instead of her regrets. And with one final swing of her blade, she shattered the Grail and the nightmare that came with it."
The crack in the sky widened.
"When the war ended, she started to fade."
Everyone in the room was frozen.
"I told her I loved her. It wasn't poetic, it wasn't perfect, but it was the truth. She smiled—soft, warm, the kind of smile she never allowed herself as King of Britain. Then she thanked me."
Shirou's voice finally cracked, just slightly.
"And she disappeared."
Illya's small hand found his. He didn't seem to notice.
"I didn't know whether she found peace in the end. But if she didn't... I kept chasing that ideal of mine—broken as it is—until the day I could find Avalon and look her in the eye again."
{{Line Break}}
The Second Path: Unlimited Blade Works
Shirou's voice became even more detached. Clinical.
"The second time, things started the same. Lancer. The shed. Except this time, I knew Rin Tohsaka. We became allies. Not enemies pretending to cooperate—actual allies."
Rin stared at him, her mind racing. This lined up with things she almost remembered. Fragments of dreams she'd dismissed.
"At first, I thought the war was just a twisted tournament. Seven Masters, seven Servants, last one standing gets the Holy Grail. I figured if I fought carefully, I could survive without killing anyone. Naive, I know."
A bitter smile crossed his face.
"Then there was Archer."
The red-clad Servant tensed visibly.
"From the start, he hated me. Not 'dislike'—hate. A cold, quiet, cutting hatred that made no sense. I couldn't figure out why a man I'd never met glared at me like I'd ruined his entire life. Whenever I spoke about saving everyone, he mocked me. Whenever I swore I'd never regret helping someone, he laughed."
Archer's expression was carefully blank, but his hands were trembling.
"I thought he was just cynical. I didn't realize he was me."
The words hung in the air like a death sentence.
"Archer wasn't just another Servant—he was the future version of myself, twisted by the ideal I worshipped. My desire to save everyone, to be a 'hero of justice'... it broke him. He became a man who killed endlessly in the name of peace, until the hypocrisy shattered him. And in his despair, he made a contract to erase his own existence by killing me—his past self."
Rin's hand flew to her mouth.
Illya squeezed Shirou's hand harder.
Sakura was openly sobbing now.
"Facing him was the first time I'd ever really confronted myself. Not the me I wanted to be, not the me I pretended to be—me as I truly was: stubborn, reckless, idealistic to the point of self-destruction."
Shirou's voice was hollow now. Empty.
"And I still chose that path. Even when Archer beat me down, even when he showed me the nightmare I'd become, I stood back up. Not to deny him, but to accept him. To accept that even if the world hated me, even if I ended up a distorted version of my dream, the ideal still mattered."
He looked at Archer directly.
"I told him I'd walk that path anyway. On my own terms. That was the moment he stopped hating me."
Archer slid down the wall, sitting heavily on the floor. His expression was... defeated. Deflated.
"But the war didn't end with an understanding. Gilgamesh was still out there, planning to drown the world in the Grail's taint. Saber fought him head-on. Rin supported me. And I—"
Shirou's hand rose unconsciously, as if holding a sword.
"I finally understood what my magic meant. Unlimited Blade Works. A world inside me. A reality marble filled with every sword I'd seen, every weapon I'd traced. Steel plains. Endless gears."
His hand fell.
"Gilgamesh laughed at it. He called it worthless imitation. He was wrong. In that desert of blades, I fought him not as a hero, not as a martyr, not as some delusional idealist—just as myself. And for the first time, that was enough."
The crack in the sky spread further, invisible branches reaching across the stratosphere.
"We stopped the Grail. We saved the city. Archer disappeared with a smile I never thought he had in him. Saber... Saber thanked me before she vanished. She sounded at peace."
{{Line Break}}
The Third Path: Heaven's Feel
When Shirou spoke again, his voice was barely above a whisper.
"The third time... everything was wrong from the start."
Sakura flinched.
"Shadows moving where no Servant should be. People dying without explanation. Corruption spreading under the surface of the city like a sickness. And it all pointed back to one person."
His eyes found Sakura, and they were full of a grief so profound it was almost unbearable to witness.
"Sakura."
She made a sound like she'd been struck. She felt Shame, Disgust at herself, she....
"I didn't want to believe it. She was the last person who could be involved in something like that. But the truth didn't care about what I wanted. She was a Master. She had something inside her—something planted in her as a child—that was eating her alive."
Medusa's hand tightened on Sakura's shoulder.
"The family she came from, the Matous... they didn't adopt her. They harvested her."
Rin's face went pale. Even after learning this from Sakura, the fact being confirmed sent a ripple of shock and guilt through her.
"The 'Shadow' killing people? That was Sakura. Or at least the corrupted power inside her breaking free whenever she lost control. Every time she told me she was fine, she was lying to protect me. Every time she smiled, she was just trying to pretend she wasn't drowning."
Tears streamed down Sakura's face, but she couldn't look away from Shirou.
"The deeper I went, the clearer it became: saving everyone and saving Sakura were no longer the same thing. In fact, they were becoming opposites."
Shirou's voice cracked again.
"Saber fell. Illya stepped in to help me. Rin tried to warn me, then begged me to let Sakura go. Even Rider—Sakura's own Servant—stood between me and the world when Sakura finally snapped."
His hands were shaking now.
"And I made my choice. Not justice. Not ideals. Just her."
The words were raw. Painful.
Sakura felt ashamed of herself for feeling happy.
"When Sakura was swallowed by the Shadow completely, corrupted by the Grail mud and driven by everything she had suffered, she became almost unrecognizable. Terrifying. Desperate. Broken. But she still cried when she saw me. She still apologized even when she was the one who needed saving."
He closed his eyes.
"So I fought. I fought everyone—Rin, Zouken, the Servants, the Grail itself. I let myself be torn apart piece by piece. I even gave up the one thing I never thought I could abandon: my ideal of saving everyone. Because I realized... she had been abandoned enough."
Illya wrapped both arms around Shirou, burying her face in his side.
"In the end, I destroyed the Greater Grail from the inside. My body was already ruined from abusing my projections, but I forced myself through. Sakura tried to kill herself to stop hurting anyone, and I had to drag her back by sheer stubbornness."
His voice was barely audible now.
"And then everything collapsed around us. When the dust settled, the Grail was gone, the corruption cleansed, and the war ended—not because I was a hero, but because I refused to let Sakura die alone."
He opened his eyes, looking at nothing.
"She survived. I survived. Somehow. Later I realized that it was because Illya had sacrificed herself and used the Third Magic to keep me alive."
Illya made a small, broken sound against his chest.
"Rin forgave us. Rider stayed with Sakura. And I... I stopped pretending the world could be saved with ideals alone."
Shirou's voice was completely flat now. Dead.
He looked at Sakura, and for the first time, his expression showed emotion again. Grief. Love. Regret.
"I just saved her."
{{Line Break}}
Silence
The silence in the dojo was deafening.
Rin had both hands pressed against her mouth, tears streaming down her face. Her genius mind was screaming that this was impossible, but her heart knew it was true. She could feel the phantom weight of knowledge she shouldn't have, memories that weren't hers but somehow were.
Sakura was sobbing openly, her whole body shaking. Medusa held her upright, the Servant's own expression unreadable behind her blindfold—but her hand was trembling.
Illya clung to Shirou like she'd never let go, crying silently into his shirt.
Saber's face was wet with tears she hadn't realized she was shedding. Her hand had moved unconsciously to her chest, where she could almost feel the phantom weight of a contract that no longer existed.
And Archer...
Archer sat slumped against the wall, looking more human than anyone had ever seen him. Deflated. Defeated. His silver eyes stared at nothing.
Archer stood very still, his mind trying and failing to reconcile what he was hearing.
Three missions. Three parallel worlds. He remembered all of them, faintly, the way he remembered all his missions across millennia.
Between the first and second, he'd been summoned dozens of times. Stopped a plague in medieval France. Prevented a war in ancient China. Killed a terrorist cell in modern America. He remembered their faces. Their names. The weight of each necessary death.
Between the second and third, there had been more. A hundred missions. A thousand. He'd walked through countless worlds, killed countless people, saved countless more. It was what he did. It was all he was.
But Shirou was talking about those three missions as if they were consecutive. As if they were loops. As if there had been nothing between them.
As if all three of those Shirous—the idealistic boy who loved Saber, the stubborn fool who'd accepted his future self, the broken man who'd abandoned everything for a single girl—were the same person.
Were him.
That's impossible.
The memories didn't line up. They couldn't line up.
He was EMIYA. Counter Guardian. Heroic Spirit. He'd existed for millennia, been summoned to countless parallel worlds, killed more people than he could count in the name of preventing greater tragedies.
But if what Shirou was saying was true—if those three missions were actually time loops—then what were all the others? What were the thousands of missions between them? The centuries of service? The endless cycle of being summoned, killing, fading, and being summoned again?
What am I?
His head hurt. Not physically—Servants didn't feel pain like that—but something deeper. A fundamental wrongness, like reality itself was rejecting the contradiction he represented.
He remembered being the Archer who'd tried to kill his past self. That was real. Undeniable.
But he also remembered the missions before that. After that. Thousands of them.
Both sets of memories were real. Both were his.
And they couldn't both be true.
Archer slid down the wall, sitting heavily on the floor. His expression—usually so carefully controlled—was cracked. Confused. Almost lost.
The others were crying, reacting to Shirou's story with appropriate horror and grief.
But Archer just sat there, staring at nothing, trying to understand how he could remember living for thousands of years and also remember being summoned only three times.
Trying to understand what he was, if not what he'd always believed himself to be.
The contradiction made his head hurt worse.
And somewhere deep in his core, where his Spirit Origin resided, something began to fracture.
{{Line Break}}
Outside
In her room, Taiga had finally made it inside before the sobs overtook her completely.
She collapsed against her door, sliding down until she was sitting on the floor, and let the tears come. Loud, ugly, uncontrollable tears.
How much has Shirou suffered?
The boy she'd watched grow up. The boy who'd lost his father and still smiled. The boy who cooked breakfast every morning and never, ever complained. That boy had lived through this? Had died and fought and sacrificed himself over and over, and she'd never—
And Sakura.
The guilt hit like a physical blow.
"I'm her teacher," Taiga sobbed into her hands. "I saw her every day. Every single day, and I never—"
Sakura came to the house every morning. Quiet. Fragile. Always so careful, like she was afraid of taking up space. And Taiga had just... accepted it. Never questioned why a girl that young was so withdrawn. Never asked why she flinched at certain things.
"I'm such a failure," she whispered. "Such a failure—"
She was supposed to protect her students. She was supposed to notice when something was wrong.
And she'd failed both of them.
{{Line Break}}
The World Breaks
Above Fuyuki, the cracks in the sky had spread across the entire world.
Invisible to everyone—
Except one.
On a rooftop overlooking the city, Gilgamesh stood with a wine glass in hand, looking up at the fractured reality with an expression of infinite amusement.
"Finally," he said to no one, his crimson eyes gleaming in the darkness. "The World acknowledges its own contradiction."
He took a sip of wine, savoring it.
"Three roads. Three truths. Three versions of the same boy, all equally real. How long will you struggle against fate, faker? How long before you realize that even Gaia herself cannot contain what you've become?"
He smiled—sharp, predatory, delighted.
"This will be entertaining."
And then—
The world cracked open like an egg.