Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Poll

Gift of Hedone: Armor Reduction Update

  • Sounds good to me 84
  • I prefer the old way 10
  • meh, not fussed either way. 10
  • 2026-02-02
  • 104 votes
{'title': 'Gift of Hedone: Armor Reduction Update', 'choices': [{'text': 'Sounds good to me', 'votes': 84}, {'text': 'I prefer the old way', 'votes': 10}, {'text': 'meh, not fussed either way. ', 'votes': 10}], 'closes_at': None, 'created_at': datetime.datetime(2026, 2, 2, 6, 42, 34, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'description': None, 'allow_multiple': False, 'total_votes': 104}

Content

Hello you lovely deviants,I wanted to share my updated Armor reduction calculations and get your opinions. I understand that ultimately how it works in practice will be most important, but still wanted to get feedback at this point.So currently the way Armor Reduction works is very simple, and linear.The attacker needs to do more damage than the armor total to do Damage. For Example (If the enemy does 50 Damage, and you have 10 Armor, the result is 40 Damage. If the Armor was 50 it would be Zero Damage - and cant go lower.

Whilst it is nice and simple, I don't like the idea that you could potentially nullify damage completely.

This leads me to my updated calculation, which will change how it is calculated based on if the Armor of the one being attacked is higher or lower than the Attacker

Now, to start - The one being attacked's armor needs to be higher than the damage of the attacker to reduce the damage. What I mean by this is, if the enemy does 50 damage, and you have 50 armor - You would take 50 damage, there is no reduction.

Using the current exponential values (0.4 and 0.3) If you then had 30 armor it would use the "lowerExponent", and you would take 82 Damage (32 extra damage), but if you had 80 armor you would take 41 Damage (only 9 less) using the "higherExponent"

In short, you are punished for having less armor, and not rewarded as much for having better armor, so in this case you would need to to have 600 armor or 1200% more armor to get 32 points of damage reduced. These exponential numbers can be changed easily, and testing what balance is good, or using these for difficulty can be discussed.But I thought this was a more interesting calculation and really places the importance of ensuring you have good armor.

What do you think of this in theory?

Files

Comments

Verhalus

Food for thought, taking your example that the attacker has 50 vs the defenders 50 armor, instead of no damage reduction possibly have it be half damage if it maths out better

xxamp53xx

Two things: 1) Armor penetration - add armor penetration as a stat, where the more one has, the more their attacks ignore armor, or 2) Armor durability - you could add a durability stat to armor pieces. You might start out being able to nullify all damage, but as you keep getting hit, the armor effectiveness goes down until it eventually breaks.

Jiggly Pixels

Thank you so much for the feedback Verhalus, definitely something im happy to consider 😊

Verhalus

I don't know if that would make it harder or not. If it does then don't worry about it. It just it feels like you should have some damage reduction if you have armor unless they have like double your armor then no damage reduction for that

Jiggly Pixels

Thank you so much for the feedback, I really appreciate it, there will be a number of factors from an offensive perspective that will result in your damage likely overtaking the base damage, affinity match up, sub class match up, crit chance, (im also exploring some other stuff that I havent ironed out details yet - but will share once I have things better explored/figured out But I do really appreciate the time you took to provide feedback 😊

Jiggly Pixels

So you would have damage reduction if your armor is higher than the enemies damage stat, it just means if your armor is lower than the enemies damage stat, you would take additional damage. I hope that makes sense, but again happy to review things

Kanji Tatsumi

If it's not to difficult you could try having the armor being a percentile negotiation of the damage like iff the attack was 1000 and we have an armor rating of 50 the player could/ would take like 950 i believe thats 5% or something like that

Urdicil

I prefer the idea that I have an amount of armor I know it is going to reduce the damage by a set amount, it gives a sense of consistency. If you want to go away from the flat reduction I would suggest looking into having the armor equal a percent of damage reduction with the more armor they stack the closer the percentage of DR gets to an asymptote of say 85%.

Jiggly Pixels

Thank you so much for the suggestion and feedback Urdicii, I really appreciate it. 😊

Jiggly Pixels

Thank you for the reply, and suggestion, I really appreciate it. Definitely have plenty to think about 😁

Erik Larson

I definitely agree with that you don't want damage to be completely nullifiable, but if I have 600 armor and something with 50 damage swings at me because I went back to a lower level area, I would expect the damage to be nulled not reduced to around 40% like in your example. So maybe somewhere in the middle?

Arvom (Giulio)

I like this idea it makes starter enemies still have some bite, I'll suggest you use a different scale for damage and armor, let's take 100 for example, 100 DMG is not that much but if I have 100 armor I feel like I would be impenetrable, but if you use like 1 armor equal 5 DMG you don't need crazy armor numbers to compensate for the attack

Jiggly Pixels

I really appreciate the feedback Erik, thank you so much - definitely something I need to consider :)

Jiggly Pixels

I see what you are saying, and I always really appreciate your input Arvom, it means a lot!