Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Greetings, Patrons!

While my IRL situation is approaching a conclusion, it's still taking up most of my time. In April I want to do a general review of the type of content I'm creating and to do some polls to determine if there's more effective ways to utilize the time I have available—whether that's creating videos, more sneak peeks, or something else—but I don't have the time to tackle that this month, so we're going to proceed as we have in the past. However, as always, keep in mind that I will not be able to answer every question. To increase the odds of getting an answer, consider the guidelines below. 

Given the volume of questions I receive, I limit myself to answering one question per patron per month. You can ASK multiple questions, because it may be one is easier for me to answer than another—but if you ask seven questions, I'm only going to answer one of them.

If I can answer a question in 2-3 sentences, I will answer it here (as a reply to your comment). If I can answer a question in 2-3 paragraphs, it may be answered as an IFAQ article, but I only have time to post a few IFAQs per month. If it would take 2-3 pages to answer the question, that's a Dragonmark article, and I generally can only write one of those in a month. So in short, the longer and more complicated the question, the lower the chance that I'll have time to answer it.

If I would have to do significant research to answer a question, that increases its effective size. It may be that the question only takes a few sentences to answer—but if I'd have to do two hours of research and contemplation to answer it, it's going to get passed over. An example of this is "What can you tell us about labor movements in Khorvaire," which has come up a few times. It's a great question; the problem is that I, Keith, know nothing about the history of labor movements, and before I could come up with a logical answer as to how they'd develop in Eberron I'd need to understand how they develop in OUR world—and I don't have time to conduct that sort of research right now. 

Likewise, a question that is about clarifying existing lore is always going to be easier than one that requires me to create entirely new lore. 

If you asked a question in a previous month that didn't get an answer, you can always ask it again, but consider as to how these guidelines apply. I do my best, but time is always the enemy.

As always, thanks for your support!

Comments

Tim Edwards

How do Iredar Kobolds interact with their neighbours in Khorvaire? They're described as skilled miners so likely have surplus metal ore beyond their capacity to use within a community. Do they trade with their neighbours? How are they regarded?

Joseph Meehan

Given that the Dragonmarked Family article, if done in one fell swoop, would probably be rather large, would it be easier to break it up into 3 or 4 parts doing 3-4 houses at a time?

Jason Godesky

What is the basis of nationalism in Khorvaire? In the real world, there are historians who argue that nations emerged from a shared language, but in Khorvaire, all of the Five Nations speak Common. Ethnicity seems like an even sillier way of organizing communities in a world where "Brelish" can mean an elf, dwarf, or a halfling as easily as it could mean a human, let alone a human from a particular ethnic group. If it's about loyalty to a branch of the Wynarn dynasty, then the Swords of Liberty wouldn't be a nationalist group. If it's about shared history and traditions, can an Aundairian adopt Brelish ways and become a Brelishman? If an overwrought Sword of Liberty is setting out on a terror campaign against foreigners, what is he looking for to determine who is and isn't a "foreigner"?

Jarrod Taylor

Asking again about the roster of seasonal lords of the Palace of the Moon!

Pastor Plague

Can you provide any information on the Shadow Schism? Are there any Paelion's still operating out there or are the all Bloody Shadows? What about important named figures such as Tyrellin "Mazrath" Paelion d’Phiarlan, I remember seeing he went to Stormreach but that was all I remember seeing? What made the Paelion family such a believable and credible threat that Thuranni would wipe them out, and why didn't Phiarlan do more to punish Thuranni for their actions? Sorry I have always been fascinated with the Shadow Schism. Such a major shadow event during the Last War and killing an entire family like that across Khorvaire, I just can't find enough information personally.

Jarrod Taylor

Backup question: Who were some Heroes of the Age of Giants, titans or empyreans who Weren't trying to dominate the planes or yoink the immortality out of eladrin? If this represents a fundamentally different physiology and mental outlook than humanity and its ilk, I will ask for Less longterm evil persons. Thank you.

Sunev

What kinds of alcohol / drinks are popular in Adar? Does Khorvaire have the same kind of craze for rare Adaran spirits as they do with Adaran art?

House Sivis Echoer Station

What is the Blood of Vol's/Seekers of Divinity Within's view on menstruation and people who menstruate? (I understand this is a typically taboo topic, so I'll ask somthing else as well)

Joseph Meehan

Given that Thrane seems to be a bit of crossroads for Western Khorvaire, especially the port city and lightning rail station of Sigilstar, what are some plot hooks for crime and smuggling in Thrane?

Matthew Booth

The city-state of Daskaran was allegedly the forerunner of the modern nation of Thrane, However, the Forge of War showed that pre-Last War, the city of Daskaran was in Aundair. How would you reconcile this? King Galifar redrawing the borders?

Micah Peltier

Repeat from last month: TLDR: why don’t elves dream? (I assume the meta-answer is “elf stats say they don’t dream, and so they don’t dream”, but narratively…) It’s called out that, not only is Eberron as a world shaped by the mixture of the planes, but also mortals themselves are shaped by the planes as well. Mortals feel the martial call of Shavarath, tempered by the tranquility of Syrania. Irian brings hope and Mabar seeds despair, and so on. Warforged, Kalashtar, and elves are all mortals that don’t connect to Dal Quor. The first two have some obvious story hooks as to why they don’t dream. But elves don’t seem to have as obvious a reason not to connect to Dal Quor. Could you share some reasons as to why elves might not connect to Dal Quor while still being affected by the 12 other planes?

House Sivis Echoer Station

What is the culture like of the people who live in Valenar who are NOT the Tirnadal elves? Those people who actually work the land, that need governing, but are fine with the Valenar. Would you say they are culturally similar to Cyrans, or did they hold fast to ancient Metrol culture?

Micah Peltier

Secondary question: why are merfolk native to Lamannia? In my musings about them, they seem to be (in our real-life mythology) more akin to dryads and other fey spirits. You've talked about how there's nothing truly natural about a dryad; it's the manifestation of "hey, that tree looks kinda like a beautiful figure in the wind; what if there WAS a beautiful figure that lives in that tree." Merfolk seem to fit that vein of thought for the waves and ocean and such. Can you elaborate on why you chose not to include them in Thelanis? Or, rather, why you chose not to make them native to Thelanis (since any creature conceivably /could/ be found in Thelanis)?

Anthony J. Turco

If you had to pick the location of Katashka's prison, where would you put it and its accompanying influence on the surrounding area. Lair of the Keeper in the Demon Wastes? Boneyard in the Blade Desert? Someplace else? Alt question: What would the true name of the Lurker in Darkness be, in the same vein as "Rak Tulkesh" for the Rage of War

MajorTotoro

I've been reading up on Menechtarun lately and noticed Orcs have a large presence: given Eberron is so good at placing races with clear thought on their origin and development, do you think there's any particular way such a Khorvairian race got there specifically? And on a large sense, given Sandstorm stuff hasn't really remained a staple of DND, would you do anything different with this not very covered part of the world? Apologies if this got long

Kevin Macku

Help me out a bit. Aundair is called out as “the magic nation” and that conjures certain visuals and aesthetics, like using everyday magic to fluff up architecture, fashion, and so on. But a lot of that aesthetic seems to overlap with depictions of Cyre, being flashy, avant-garde, and so on. What is a way or some ways that the two nations iconically differ, to where ordinary onlookers could point at someone or something and go “That’s definitely Cyran” or “That’s definitely Aundairian”?

Andres Olan-Vazquez

This time I remember what I wanted to ask! I would love to know more about the formal structure of the Arcane Congress, as you suggested was outside the scope of the Wizard Circles article.

Spike Hemphill

If a character is physically in Dal Quor, what happens if they rest or sleep there?

Will Buck

(Repeat question) There hasn’t been much written about the city of Starilaskur, despite it being the third largest city in Breland. We know it holds the Martial Temple of Dol Arrah as well as an Order of the Broken Blade monastery, and we know there’s a large Cannith enclave there headed by a viceroy rumored to be a vampire (Haldon). But I believe that’s mostly all we know. Could you tell us a little more about it? Followup: Dylan Ramsey's "Crossroads of Destiny: Starilaskur" suggests the city is sitting on a manifest zone to Thelanis, specifically to the Assembly barony. Any thoughts on that? Alternative question: Who is the overlord of disease worshiped by the Plaguebearers? How is it distinct from Kyrzin?

Sierra

While Eberron has better representation than many settings, it certainly feels a product of its time in LGBTQIA+ representation. Are there any NPCs that you would go back and say "yes, these NPCs are part of LGBTQIA+" or have you had any fun ideas for new LGBTQIA+ PCs sitting in your head waiting to spring out to paper?

Spike Hemphill

Could you give us name or placeholder title for the Quori that inspires greed?

DivertedCircle

Repeat question: What are your thoughts on how the Mourning affected existing manifest zones and portals to Khyber demiplanes that existed in Cyre?

Matt Brady

Repeat from last month: With some groups like elves and gnomes sailing the seas at the same time as Rhiavaar slaver ships, it would be interesting to know what impact or presence western Sarlona had on eastern Khorvaire. Would the Zil merchants have been surprised by human ships coming west? Having navigated around almost all of southern and eastern Khorvaire to trade with the Mror by this time, would they have chanced the crossing of the Sea of Rage (seems the Lhazaar Sea and most of the Principalities lie north of the Tashana Tundra)?

C.K.

Still hoping for the rest of Sarlona, with a preference for Tashana or Syrkarn over Adar.

Zed Bundershot

I'll second Andres Olan-Vazquez's question: in your Eberron, what might a legislature of (mostly magewrights?) do that would distinguish it from a fundamentally mundane deliberative group?

Parker Wimberly

So we know that Daask is a multi national criminal org but is the Boramar clan present in the other five nations. If it is, how is it structured.

Morgaine Barkefors

What's the origin, language and meaning of Q'barra? It sticks out among nation names and descriptive regions. I also find it curious that while New Galifar is recognized as a proper nation and have a seat in Thronehold, it's with the name Q'barra instead of New Galifar. 😁

Ben

What effect might the Kythri manifest zones in the Shadow Marches have on the culture and monsters in the area? Kythri manifest zones seems to have largely fallen off after they were mentioned in ECS alongside the Xoriat manifest zones.

Thomas Brøgger

There is a ruin called Lantern Tower in The Shadow Marches. What kind of ruin is this and what could adventurers encounter there?

Micah Davis

It seems obvious that the CotSF has something like canon law, but do any of the major religions have scriptures? As a totally different question, is the CotSF the first proselytizing sect of the Flame? The only other possibly proselytizing sect would’ve been the Khaleshites, but it’s unclear to me if they were.

Jay Cote

I’m hoping to run a series of sessions, or perhaps even a campaign during the Lycanthropic Purge. I know you have mentioned on The Manifest Zone Podcast that you were considering running a one-shot with a mixed party set during this time- and was wondering what advice or key points would you give when it comes to running a game like that? Would having my players make characters on both sides and alternating between them work or make things to confusing?

The Colonel

Theoretically what would cause the dragons of Argonnessen to raze Io’lokar as they had destroyed its precursor city for magical malpractice essentially would it happen again or since it happened once would it be for a smaller infraction?

叔叔六十四 (Uncle64)

Are Quori from the Dreaming Dark the same as the ones from War with the giants? Like did a transition in Dal Quor happened between the giant war and modern times with Sarlona?

Elly Runnalls

What's your take on the role of Deneith mercenaries during the Last War? I've been partial to the idea of them being called in as added support to shore up regular troops where needed, but I feel like there's a deeper story here than just being the Eberron equivalent of a PMC.

Harvey Clarke

Does the river/bay adjacent to Trolanport have a name?

WebbRosson

In your eyes, have any Dragonmarked houses made major efforts to travel into other planes?

Jason PB

I know you have your qualms with the bodies of water in the map as is, but what is the deal with the river and the lake around Thronehold and Scion's sound? Oddly straight and star shaped in the center of the continent, there's gotta be some sorta fun hook or reason for existence!

Jamie Bernstein

Repeat question from a couple of months ago; what's the fairytale of Shae Joridal and its Archfey, Taranel Tanaer? Thanks!

Chris H. | End Days Engine

Centaurs have been presented as both Monstrosities (Monster Manual) and Fey (Ravnica and Theros) in 5e. in your Eberron, would these variations be similar to elves and eladrin or have a totally different origin?

Elmer Tucker

Are there any cultures within Khorvaire that particularly utilize the Tarokka style deck? Where does this type of augury fit in when you have Dragonmarks of Divination? Is it their purview, more at the magewright level of skill, or something else?

Earth Seraph Edna

Can aberrant dragonmarks appear and function on undead, non-warforged constructs, and immortals, or are they still limited to living mortals? True dragonmarks generally do not appear in Sarlona, but what about aberrant dragonmarks?

Dylan Durrant

Could a Drifter (from Dal Quor) become manifest in the material plane and if so, how?

Not Mordakhesh

Who is the Lurker in Shadows Prakhutu? And if the Lurker were to be released, what kinds of effects would it have on the Thunder Sea? And IFFFFF its tempestuous storms and stuff, is it possible some would mistake it for the Devourer? And how might a Lurker cultist feel about the Devourer? That is more than one question, sorry. Answer whichever you choose.

Joseph Meehan

If you need an alternative to my Thrane Smuggling question Do you use/reference Karrnath's canonically significant halfling population? How does it show up in their culture?

Antti Lax

The recent IFAQ about Prince Oargev made me think about your take on New Cyre as a whole. I've been working on a New Cyre location book for DMs Guild for a while now, and I'd be curious to hear if you've used the town in your games. Are there any specific elements to New Cyre that you'd consider Kanon?

Juan

How common is the practice of Speak With Dead in Khorvaire? It's a relatively low level spell, and I can see it being used for law enforcement investigations, or even people who can afford it to have a small chat with a dead relative.

OHeyItsRick

Hi, Keith! Don’t know if I’m too late to put in a question, but I was wondering; when a dragonmark manifests (be it a regular or a Siberys one)… what actually happens? Is it painful? Does it appear unceremoniously? Any insight would be awesome.

John_Doe_142857

In you book Exploring Eberron you describes the "Three Faces cults" who associate one of the Dark Six and two of the Sovereign Host: Coin/Keeper, Love/Fury, War/Mockery and Wild/Devourer. Is there any divine triumvirates that would include the Shadow and the Traveler?

Aureus Fulgens

I'll ask a mildly stupid question. How high do you envision the Ring of Siberys being above Eberron? Either numerically or otherwise. The only narrative constraint I've thought of is "higher than a Lyrandar airship can go."