Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Greetings, Patrons!

I've just posted an IFAQ covering a few more questions from April, but it's time to move get new questions. Keep in mind that I often receive dozens of questions in a month (66 in April) and try as I might, I will not be able to answer every question. To increase the odds of getting an answer, consider the guidelines below.

Given the volume of questions I receive, I limit myself to answering one question per patron per month. You can ASK multiple questions, because it may be one is easier for me to answer than another—but if you ask seven questions, I'm only going to answer one of them.

If I can answer a question in 2-3 sentences, I may answer it here (as a reply to your comment). If I can answer a question in 2-3 paragraphs, it may be answered as an IFAQ article, but I only have time to post a few IFAQs per month. If it would take 2-3 pages to answer the question, that's a Dragonmark article, and I generally can only write one of those in a month. So in short, the longer and more complicated the question, the lower the chance that I'll have time to answer it. The last two months, I've written Dragonmarks that address multiple questions that have been asked—because there were many questions about the Eldeen Reaches, it made sense to write a big article. So if you ask questions that expand on someone else's question, it may increase the odds that you'll both get an answer. 

If I would have to do significant research to answer a question (whether that's studying a real-world historical movement or third-party D&D supplement) that increases its effective size; even if it will only take three sentences to answer the question, if I have to do three hours of research first, it's going to go to the bottom of the slush pile.

I'm more likely to spend time on a complex question if the topic seems like it will interest a significant number of people. So when you're looking through the thread, like questions you'd like to see answered!

If you asked a question in a previous month that didn't get an answer, you can always ask it again, but consider as to how these guidelines apply. I do my best, but time is always the enemy. As a side note: Questions don't have to be about Eberron! I'm happy to answer questions about Gloom, Phoenix: Dawn Command, world building, Bossy the Cow, or anything else that I do.

As always, thanks for your support!

Files

IFAQ: Working Without Lore, Sovereign Images, Nagpa and Princess Marya!

Every month I answer interesting questions posed by my Patreon supporters. Here's a few more from April! First of all, what's the nation? If it's Aundair, is there something interesting going on with everyday magic or fey? If it's Thrane, how does the faith in the Silver Flame manifest?

Comments

Paul Blank

With advancements like airships, elemental galleons, and the lightning rail, would it be possible/likely for one of the dragonmarked houses to develop Spelljammer-like technology to explore the expanses of Siberys?

Peter S.

Reposting, since it could not be answered last month: What is the best way to help players who are not very familiar with the setting to build PCs who are well rooted in the world? Both ERftLW, and Exploring Eberron have suggestions on how particular pieces of the lore can impact PCs, but in your opinion, can we identify an 'Eberron character starting pack' to build fun PCs for a campaign? I hope it will make the cut, but thanks anyways!

Joseph Meehan

What were Thrane's pre-war borders?

OHeyItsRick

Follow on from your article on the Wild Heart, what more can you tell us about the role of Katashka the Gatekeeper in Eberron? Do they have any other agents operating in the world at large other than Mazyralyx? Is his heart plane located anywhere particular, or is it scattered across Eberron in the broken phylactery pieces? I'm working on an Eberron fiction project involving Katashka as the overarching BBEG, so any more information you could provide would be greatly appreciated. One other thing I am curious about - given the original Dragonmark was written in 2018 - is whether you could offer any further insight into the history of the City of Silver and Bone, and the role it might play in a campaign involving the likes of Erandis Vol and Katashka. Is there anything you would want to add that you didn't cover in the original article?

Parker Wimberly

Are there other immortals in the plane that mess with or other wise interact with the different slithers of mortals like the shadow gardens of Mabar

Jarrod Taylor

We know that Keith Baker exists in the Marvel universe and the Order of the Stick universe, is there any self-insert NPC modeled after yourself (or Bossy) in Eberron?

Eric Smith

In the Thunder Sea piece, in Exploring Eberron, you mention ships having sea speakers who know Aquan and Sahaugin as languages. In the Lhazaar Principalities, would that be just Aquan for most ships or might there be another that applies. Also, if I was running a more Pirates of the Caribbean style game in Lhazaar, what skills do you think such a crew would need to survive?

Tim Edwards

Some of the Eberron planes have mortal residents in them. How widely known is this in Khorvaire outside of the fae of Thelanis? Would hard bitten veterans in Karrnath know it's about to go down if they see a band of Shadar-Kai enter a tavern looking for someone, for example?

Spike Hemphill

How would you reinterpret the lore of Usvapna Quori? (No stats needed) They're judges but who do they judge ? They are inquisitors but what does mean for Quori spirit? Any ideas to make Usvapna Quori more interesting in your opinion?

MajorTotoro

We know many large cities are founded on top of dhakaani ruins, but has the location of the capital / center of the fallen empire been established in canon? Is it also a mystery yet to be solved in-world?

Martin Westerberg

What depictions and weapons would be for the dark six? What sort of folklore characters could they imbue? Say davy jones locker for the keeper in lhazaar.

Thomas Brøgger

There is a ruin called Lantern Tower in The Shadow Marches. What is special about this ruin and what could adventurers encounter there?

Ironchestnut .

I've been on a bit of a kick with wondrous figurines recently so I thought I'd ask. How do you see wondrous figurines fitting into the Eberron setting outside of just finding them in a treasure hoard? and are there any interesting wondrous figurines that you would add to the Eberron setting that are not found in other settings?

Dark Jedi Princess

Hi Keith! Question for you RE: Eberron & Ravenloft/Dread Metrol that I couldn’t find answers to in any of your previous blog posts. It’s probably safe to say Queen Dannel and her lickspittles would not take well to a Karrnathi character showing up in Dread Metrol, but how do you think they’d react to visitors from Aundair, Breland, or Thrane? And a couple of quick other questions that will hopefully be easy to answer in a comment reply: 1) In a setting where it’s been ruled that Eberron is part of the greater D&D multiverse, would you consider Mabar’s Dark Powers to be the same Dark Powers that rule Ravenloft? 2) Would dhampirs hailing from Eberron have the same inherent tie to Mabar that vampires do? That’s about it (for the moment, anyway; there’s lots of stuff I’d like to pick your brain about, but, trying to space all of those out). Thanks for all your hard work!

Harvey Clarke

To my knowledge, Aurula is the monarch who longs for the Crown of Galifar the most, and the elves of Valenar have continued to "break" the Treaty of Thronehold; but my question is: which Nation(s) is instead the biggest proponent for a continued peace?

Castier GM and Actor

What is stationed on the argonth in terms of vehicles and transport. And how do people get aboard? Notable NPCs?

Kevin Macku

With airships still being a rarity in the setting, is there a place for sky piracy (or sky banidtry!) in your Eberron? If so, what does that look like?

RGMD

Can we hear about the exploits of specific dragons and members of the chamber during the Last War? What unfinished business might they have?

Sierra

What are some teen/young adult counterculture movements in Eberron? I'm thinking about how we ALWAYS have a push from the younger generation against the social norms of the older and wondering what this is like in Khorvaire!

Inquisitor Thomas

Where do the Gem Dragonborn fit into Eberron? Do they just live and fight alongside the Gith the way an Elf and Human would or were they specifically created to fill a certain role by the Gem Dragons?

Will Buck

Repeating my Starilaskur question! Any details about the city would be well appreciated. Alternative question: Could you tell us a little bit about each of the Tharashk triumvirate?

Micah Peltier

I may have a shorter question later, but for now I’ll repeat my vote from last month for an in-depth (pardon the pun) exploration of the Lhazaar Sea and the oceans surrounding the Principalities

Spike Hemphill

If Gem Dragons are from Githebberon, did they have own version of the Chamber?

Matt Brady

First possible question, and I apologize for the repetition from last month. Do the dragonborn of Q'Barra have any culinary traditions? Any signature foods or drinks (alcoholic or not)? I imagine the troglodytes and lizardfolk eat fairly raw, and the kobolds also have interesting culture but one thing at a time ;P

Matt Brady

Second question if first is unsuitable, did the changelings have significant presence in the Eldeen Reaches prior to/during the Silver Crusade? Obviously current numbers would put them inside the 3% (other) in the region, and Aundair's 2% (or Breland's 4%?). Historically changeling populations were higher in Aundair and Breland after persecution in Thrane, Karrnath and Cyre (pre-Galifar) but did they concentrate in the urban areas or also live in the wilds?

Joseph Meehan

Gonna reiterate support for a Dragonmarked Families dragonmark!

Beoric

I would appreciate any detail you could give on the sahuagin of Sharn - what district are the sea caves below and what does the physical space look like, or hints respecting the types of interactions they might have that are not strictly related to negotiating passage to Xen'drik.

Andres Olan-Vazquez

I'll reiterate my request for talking about the formal structure of the Arcane Congress, as suggested in the Wizard Circles article!

Alexander Eldritch

I’ve been very inspired by your cartomancy in Eberron and have been imagining other practices that are occasionally considered related in real life. One such practice is the use of ouija boards / spirit boards. Do these have a place in Eberron, and if so, what individuals and / or groups would be likely to make use of them?

Not Mordakhesh

If either House Cannith, Lyrandar, or Orien managed to get their hands on the Sulatar secrets to elemental binding (like Lord Calynden is supposed to be looking for), what repercussions could you see this having on the relations between the Twelve? I've got vague ideas of houses trying to embargo one another, ratting each other out to the Trust. But since you know the personalities of Kwanti, Esravash, and the Cannith Trio, I figured you could tell me best. Which barons are more willing to undercut one another, undercut the Zil, upset the peaceful arrangement they've made regarding elemental binding?

Chris H. | End Days Engine

In your Eberron, did Samyr Kes have anything to do with the imprisoning of Melysse Miron?

Jason PB

I know that we as a fan base tend to be pretty engaged and there is a lot of communication from us to you and vice versa on what we are interested in in terms of further development, but how else do you keep your creative juices flowing? Do you have home games to let off steam, a particular book series you endeavor to read, do you make an effort to enjoy new art and media regularly, etc- in short, what do you do to stay on your A game and stay invested in your creative endeavors?

C.K.

I'll always want to know more about Syrkarn or the Tashana Tundra (more the latter for me but either is fine)

James Edward Johnson III

What kind of dangers could one expect from the Dark Sea? Canon mentions dragonturtles, which seems obvious given Argonnessen bordering it; violent storms and waves; and massive icebergs, which seems to suggest Risian Manifest or even Wild Zones. But what might a Party crossing under the waves encounter besides dragonturtles and maybe dragoneels? Mabaran Zones? Aboleth? The Dominion?

Matthew Johnson

Have the planar effects of Sarlona always been present? Are they natural or made by some sentience such as humans or even quori?

AlDaFoSho

What kinds of tactics did the Quori use when they invaded Xen'drik?

Teettan

I know it would be a whole article by itself, but can you tell us a little about the Sea of Rage. Is there more to it or is it just a lot of manifest zones that make it stormy and dangerous.

Farouche

Bringing this back from last year but as a dragonmark article I would love someday to read more about the relationships between the fey and Aundair, not just in a mechanical "an archfey can be a character's patron for a player" but detailing how much does this impact Aundarian nobility and intrigues on a national scale, where does that leave the relationship between Aundairians with fey bonds and Eldeen Reaches Greenspeakers in a time where there are still tensions between the two countries, and such as. I've loved all of the articles and podcasts touching on the subject of fey so far, as well as the bits in ExE, and would just love more in-depth stuff about fey in Khorvaire (Aundair most of all of course but eventually curious about other nations and how they are NOT like Aundair in their fey population or relation to the fey; vast subject but also interesting).

Earth Seraph Edna

Page 157 of D&D 3.5 Secrets of Sarlona says, "Recently, quori have manifested physically in some of the wild zones of Riedra, though they cannot move beyond these regions." What can you tell us about this phenomenon, and how it intersects with the Dreaming Dark's goals?

Dan Smith

In Exploring Eberron, you gave an overview of the various clans of the Kech Dhakaan, but I'm interested in the clans of the Ghaal'dar. What/who are the major (Kanon) clans of Darguun? The only Ghaal'dar clans I've read about are the Rhukaan Taash in ECG and the Kapaa Dor in the article on Oargev's suitors.

Reighndragon

One of the characters in my campaign is a dragonmarked member of House Ghallanda. She has become an agent in service of the Royal Eyes of Aundair. If her being an agent would be discovered and become public knowledge, how would House Ghallanda react both in public and within the House to a dragonmarked member being an agent of the Royal Eyes? Would they view this as a breach of the neutrality of their House? What repurcussions would you think would be appropriate for the character by the House if any? Would this be the same for a House Cannith dragonmarked heir being a member of the Dark Lanterns? What would the general populace think of a dragonmarked heir being a member of one of the secret services of one of the Five Nations?

Jamie Bernstein

How was Demonglass used by the fiends in the Age of Demons? do different Overlords make Demonglass that reflects their core fear?

Ivan Flis

In my Eberron, I always envisaged Khorvaire as in the middle of the prolonged process of magical industrial revolution, with the Dragonmarked magic slowly trickling down into a lot of artifice and general non-marked practitioner spheres as it is perfected. If that is so, industrial revolutions often entail worker movements, class conflicts, urban devastation etc. Where do you think the first worker rights movement would arise in Khorvaire? What are some of the negative effects of the "magical" industrialization?

John_Doe_142857

How would you fit in Eberron the respective books of Vile Darkness and Exalted Deeds?

Inquisitor Thomas

Since you’ve covered the Gith, I must ask about the objectively best race in D&D that live in the Astral Plane and who’s name starts with G, where do my beautiful gun toting hippo babies fit into Eberron?

Joseph Meehan

Do you remember how the numbers in the Moons Dragonshard from 2005 got picked? Was that you or Chris Perkins?

Walt

Hey! So, I'm trying to get into the boardgame development industry. I've created the first version of my first game, and I'm going to be going around and play testing it. I would love some advice on how to promote my game, and how to really get into the industry. Also, I would like opinions on crowd funding vs. investor vs. publisher.

Simon

Can the overlords be reasoned/talked with? They are their ideals incarnate, but would Rak Tulkesh be able to resist going into a war that will reseal them if fought? How intelligent are they beyond stat scores to prevent themselves being resealed in the future

Westwind

I had a look at a copy of Phoenix: Dawn Command a while ago! I really like the lore, the emphasis on teamwork, and the concept of balancing sacrifice/power! But the card mechanics are quite different to the RPG's my friends are used to. Do you have a quick tip on getting new players into it and keeping things fun, without them feeling pressured to optimize?

WebbRosson

Which official 5e adventure module is your favorite?