Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Greetings, Patrons!

I'm still working on the Session Zero article, but it's a new month and that means it's time for new questions. As always, I will not be able to answer every question. To increase the odds of getting an answer, consider the guidelines below.

Given the volume of questions I receive, I limit myself to answering one question per patron per month. You can ASK multiple questions, because it may be one is easier for me to answer than another—but if you ask seven questions, I'm only going to answer one of them.

If I can answer a question in 2-3 sentences, I may answer it here (as a reply to your comment). If I can answer a question in 2-3 paragraphs, it may be answered as an IFAQ article, but I only have time to post a few IFAQs per month. If it would take 2-3 pages to answer the question, that's a Dragonmark article, and I generally can only write one of those in a month. So in short, the longer and more complicated the question, the lower the chance that I'll have time to answer it. The past few months, I've written Dragonmarks that address multiple questions that have been asked—because there were many questions about the Eldeen Reaches, it made sense to write a big article. So if you ask questions that expand on someone else's question, it may increase the odds that you'll both get an answer.

If I'd have to do significant research to answer a question (whether that's studying a real-world historical movement or third-party D&D supplement) that increases its effective size; even if it will only take three sentences to answer the question, if I have to do three hours of research first, it's going to go to the bottom of the slush pile.

I'm more likely to spend time on a complex question if the topic seems like it will interest a significant number of people. So when you're looking through the thread, like questions you'd like to see answered!

If you asked a question in a previous month that didn't get an answer, you can always ask it again, but consider as to how these guidelines apply. I do my best, but time is always the enemy. As a side note: Questions don't have to be about Eberron! I'm happy to answer questions about Gloom, Phoenix: Dawn Command, world building, my novels, or anything else that I do.

As always, thanks for your support!

Comments

Parker Wimberly

Are there other immortals that mess with or other wise interact with the different slithers of mortals like the shadow gardens of Mabar

Ben

How are the modern giant factions of Xen'drik descended from the mentioned ancient cultures of Xen'drik? Some like the Battalion of the Basalt Towers and their lineage from the Sul’at/Sulat League have this clearly outlined. Others like the Scriveners of the Sky are more unclear—would they be connected to the Group of Eleven or something entirely new?

Jason Godesky

Are there parts of Khorvaire where interplanar trade wouldn't be too surprising, or would that be a remarkable thing no matter where you go? If a caravan of merchants from the Immeasurable Market of Syrania showed up in the Bazaar in Sharn, would that be the talk of the town, or just another day that ends in "ol"? Anywhere where trade negotiations with the City of Brass could be a political consideration?

Jason PB

The Five Nations all have a heraldic animal- Thrane's old boar, Breland's bear, Karrnath's wolf, and Aundair's dragonhawk. But Cyre has always been a bell as far as anyone can tell. What animal would you assign to Cyre? I know a popular suggestion is the peacock, but I was curious if you've ever given it thought! And if I could expand a little bit, what was your inspiration for the other animals? Thanks Keith!

Kevin Macku

This might be something for the Session 0 article, but it's been on my mind lately, and maybe this is the right time for this question: Other TTRPGs often come with a "Suggested Media" section, often books or movies or TV shows that capture that feel or were even direct inspirations for the setting/genre/etc. You've called out Maltese Falcon multiple times but I was wondering what other specific titles would you list for Eberron to say, "This has that mood/tone/theme that I envisioned or pulled from to make this setting"?

David Armstrong

I'm getting conflicting information, and can't keep track of all the various source material, so thought I'd go to the original source, sir: Are dolgrims, dolgaunts, and dolgrue considered daelkyr-spawn, and what plane are they most closely associated with? If it's Xoriat, what other relatively low-ish CR creatures would be found in a Xoriat manifest zone (or if it's not Xoriat, what would it be, and what low-CR creatures would be found there)?

Earth Seraph Edna

In your current conception of Eberron, is there any meaningful difference between chromatic dragons and metallic dragons? 3.5 Dragons of Eberron talks about how chromatic dragons are more vulnerable to Tiamat's influence, how chromatics struggle to gain influence in Argonnessen due to their relatively shorter lifespans, how there is this small movement of metallic dragon supremacists, and how whites are derided for their relatively poor mental capacities. It does not help that in 5e Fizban's, chromatic dragons are objectively weaker as greatwyrms than as metallics, as if metallics were closer to true divinity than chromatics.

Ironchestnut .

How would you expand on Goliaths in Eberron? What are their origins, and how do they view the giants, elves, and drow?

Micah Peltier

I don't expect the answer to this question to have a whole lot of impact on anything, but I'm curious. How "timeless" do you perceive the Archfey as? To expand, for example, the story of the Prince of Frost is, as we all know, that he was once the Prince of Summer until a mortal adventurer stole his love and froze his heart. Was that even an actual historical event (i.e., could a historian say "732 years before the founding of Galifar, this event occurred, transforming the Prince of Summer into the Prince of Frost")? Or is it the case that, no matter /how far back you go/, he always has been spurned in the even-further past by his mortal lover? Does that question even make sense?

C.K.

More Sarlona obviously. Syrkarn or Tashana preferably (don't ask me to choose)

Spike Hemphill

Quori Expanded. Does anyone else want know more about Aurashala , Lluora, and possible other Quori? If so please give a like.

Alexander Eldritch

Two potential questions! Repeat from last month: I’ve been very inspired by your cartomancy in Eberron article and have been imagining other practices that are sometimes considered related in real life. One such practice is the use of ouija boards / spirit boards. Do these have a place in Eberron, and if so, what individuals and / or groups would be likely to make use of them? New question: In your Eberron, how would you introduce and incorporate the Dunamancy school of magic from Explorer’s Guide to Wildemount (And Critical Role in general)? I imagine individuals who deeply study the Draconic Prophecy would have an understanding of such magics, but I’m very curious what your thoughts are.

hyperewok1

How does one read the Draconic Prophecy? I get the concept of the whole Prophetic If/Then Statements and the fact that they can change if the seventh son's seventh son is suddenly hit by a truck, but how does one even find that If/Then prophecy in the first place?

Will Buck

Any of the following: 1) Starilaskur! 2) Families of House Cannith. Were any families split by the division into South/West/East? 3) Specific relics, saints, or stories of the Sovereign Host!

Matthew Johnson

Droaam and Breland were certainly in conflict during the Last War, but was Droaam fighting on any other fronts? I haven't seen lore regarding this. Did Droaam battle with the Marches or Reaches for territory? What is the political relationship with these regions aside from Droaam's business deals with House Tharashk.

Inquisitor Thomas

Is there any information on the origins and society of Duergar and how to incorporate them into a campaign as a society or as a PC? I know they were brought up briefly as residing in a region of Sarlona and helping the Inspired build their monoliths, but they also showed up in a piece of in Dragonmarked fighting House Kundarak, potentially implying they have a population in Khorvaire or at least a demiplane that connects Sarlona and Khorvaire.

Tim Starks

In what main additional ways would you say bugbears are culturally or otherwise distinct from other goblinoids? They mainly seem to be larger/meaner based on Exploring/Rising, depending on whether you're talking Dhakaani or Marguul. I'm open to pre-5E resources that are good on this, if this has already been covered somewhere else.

Juan

In Exploring Eberron there's stories about the Forgotten Prince and the Forest Queen, are these meant to be fairy tales widely known in-universe? Similarly, what level of knowledge have the scholars of Khorvaire compiled related to the fey? Have they been able to categorize at least *some* of the archfey or stablish some sort of relationship with them?

David Byrd

How do you see House Tharashk viewing the other Orcish cultures of Khorvair? Would you see them mediating the disputes between the dwarves and orcs of the Mror Holds?

Dan Smith

In Q'barra, it seems to me that both the remaining demonic ruins and the specialized dragonshards (dawn and dusk shards) have important connections to Masvirik and him being bound. What's the difference between their roles in binding Masvirik? On the same note, how do these differences impact and differentiate the strategies in which the Trothlorsvek and the Masvirik'Uala fight Masvirik and the Poison Dusk? I remember the article in Dungeon 185 said the Dragonborn see the Dawn and Dusk shards as unimportant and are more concerned with the remaining ruins. I imagine this would lead to the Trothlorsvek being more reactive/defensive in their strategy, only focusing on neutralizing threats rising from the demonic ruins. On the other hand, I could see the Cold Sun Federation being more offensive in their strategy, actively pursuing some dragonshards and striking at key points when given directions to do so by the Coatl in their dreams.

Joseph Meehan

What were the borders of Thrane before the war in your Eberron?

Beoric

I have two questions for you to choose from, both relating to worship of the Traveler in Sharn. (1) In Sharn:CoT p. 61-2, Callestan is noted to have a <i>temple</i> to The Traveler. There is also a doppelganger cleric named Zaz who is connected to the Cabinet of Faces and the cult of the <i>Traveler</i>, but is stated to run a <i>shrine</i> to <i>The Keeper</i> out of the Cracked Mirror, which is an inn catering to changelings. I suspect an editing problem here, and that the temple for the Traveler is actually a shrine to the Traveler, and the shrine to the Keeper is actually a shrine to the Traveler, but can you confirm or clarify? (2) Is the temple of The Traveler in Ship's Towers Pyrinean, Children, Cazhaak or somthing else?

Matt Brady

Obviously I'm onboard for Sarlona content, Adar, Syrkarn and Tashana all! Is the Gaa'ran orcs skill with agriculture a product of superior knowledge, manifest zone capitalizing or primal magic? Do they practice irrigation, crop rotation, use "food forests" out in the Barrens?

gonzolikesmovies

With thri-kreen becoming a playable 5e race soon in the upcoming Spelljammer sourcebook, what kinds of thri-kreen culture or lore do you have in mind (if any) that a player could pull from in Eberron? From my own research they seemed to be mainly in Xen'drik, but aside from passing mentions in Secrets of Xen'drik/City of Stormreach there's almost nothing about Eberron thri-kreen in existing canon.

Zachary Butler

You've mentioned the lack of nighttime lights of goblins, and the fact that dwarf resistance to poison makes Mror cuisine more intense. What are some examples of ways in which predominantly non-human societies would be distinctly different from the Five Nations, in ways that are directly correlated to biological differences with humans?

Joey Norwood

Concerning the Eternal Dominion of the sahuagin, even though they don't lay claim to the waters within 6 miles of Khorvaire's coast, do they claim narrow channels, such as the Dagger River (which appears to be at least 20 miles wide for quite a ways upstream)? The area around the Hilt, including Sharn, appears to be a lot like a fjord, which can be as much as a mile deep (on Earth).

Martin Westerberg

What are cyclops in your eberron? Was the eye something born or was it obtained/magebreed with possible ties to belshyrra?

Dark Jedi Princess

Got a couple of questions inspired by a recent TV binge of two of my favourite shows (CSI and Mayday: Air Disasters). 1) Does House Lyrandar have anything akin to IRL Air Traffic Control to help ensure the safety of airship travel? 2) I’m very curious about how forensic science might work in Eberron; I imagine it’s another sector House Medani would dominate. (I saw a couple of other posters asking about this subject on your article about modern medicine’s role in Eberron as well.)

Artemis, a pet rock that might die

If you’re familiar with what Mythic Encounters are, from Mythic Odysseys of Theros, what creatures in Eberron do you see being mythic?

Spike Hemphill

How do you make species have distinct cultural identities and avoid mono cultures for world building? What details do you start with . For example I want Bullywugs in my homebrew world to have least two cultures one that is hunter gatherer society and other build cities in swamps. Is that good start and where you go from there. I thought maybe both societies accept Grungs and Grippli too.

Vincent Brunet

In my understanding, the giants we find in Xen'drik at the moment are dilluded versions of the giants of old (per se from the Cul'sir empire) What would be the typical power/spells of a Cul'sir giant that could elevate the power of the classic dnd 5e giants that we can find in the monster manual?

Thomas Brøgger

In my Eberron campaign the party is searching for Vvaraak’s lair. What do you think the lair looks like and what sort of wards, traps or guardians would you imagine that protects the lair?

Andres Olan-Vazquez

Reiterating my request for the formal structure of the Arcane Congress. Also, a group of us have started talking about the lack of myths regarding the Sovereigns in the setting narratives, so I'll add a new question: what are some of the mainstream myths surrounding the Sovereign Host in the Five Nations' cultures, particularly Sovereigns we haven't heard a lot about such as Boldrei and Olladra.

Jarrod Taylor

My question is twofold, firstly where (if anywhere) are there sea hags in Eberron? Secondly, Eberron gave us the dusk hag and we know of Teraza, but are there any notable non-night hags that people are familiar with? Each Daughter of Sora Kell has legends surrounding their original stomping grounds, but are there any of their less known cousins, in the modern timeline or examples of meddling in the past?

Earth Seraph Edna

In your current vision, how strong do you see the Daughters of Sora Kell as, relative to the other great entities of Eberron? In terms of mystical power? In terms of combat power? Is Sora Katra or Sora Teraza able to outmatch the mystical power of a "generic" daelkyr (that is, the CR 20 ones in the original 3.5 Eberron Campaign Setting book)? Can Sora Maenya outfight a pit fiend?

Not Mordakhesh

Shattered Land questions. SPOILERS AHEAD. 1. Let’s say Lakashtai had succeeded and all that huge horde of quori had made it into the prime material plane. What do you think they would have done first? They don’t just want to kill, they want to survive. 2. Was Lakashtai a Kalaraq? 3. It turns out that Tashana was a Kalashtar all along. What about those people Daine encountered in Stormreach?

Reighndragon

If in your campaign a world exposition like the Great Exhibition in London in 1851 was organised in Khorvaire, what would the different dragonmarked houses bring to the exhibition?

Eric Smith

Are there the equivalent to Alienists (Specialist in mental illness) in Eberron? Would they primarily be tied to House Jorasco?

Only_Pugsley

Considering that a lot of Droaam is littered with the ruins of the old Dhaakani Empire, how would negotiations go between the Daughters of Sora Kell (or one of their warlords) and the Heirs of Dhakhaan go? Would the Droaamites assume they are as bad as the easterners or can they differentiate? Also, would the Heirs see the Droaamites as squatters and be actively hostile?

Jamie Bernstein

The outer islands of Aerenal such as Valen's Isle and Majarin notably have no major settlements, or much info at all. Are these islands similar to the mainland in terms of dodgy manifest zones, or is there something that sets them apart? Thanks!

Joseph Meehan

Reiterating support for another Dragonmarked Families article, perhaps for Deneith this time?

James Edward Johnson III

How do the Dragonmarked Houses deal with someone who abandons the family? As in, say a Character qualified to be a Scion, and perhaps served as an Agent. But their morals conflict with Kundarak's greediness, or with Jorasco's refusal to not help those in need, and so they forsook the name entirely and have nothing to do with the House? What would the House think of them or how would they be treated by the House? And would their opinion change because they Manifest a Dragonmark later on, pwrhaos even a Siberys one? My gut says they'd be treated as an excoriate, since they are literally abandoning family, but no resource I've perused have guidance on this (admittedly unique) circumstance.

The Bard Himself

I'm aware you have already covered Druids in an article, but could we see a Dragonmark in the near Future about Rangers? Or simply a smaller article? Surely there are Conclaves not tied to the existing Druidic Circles

James Edward Johnson III

How would Demiplane work in Eberron now? 5e's version makes no mention of the Spell making a minor Plane connected to another; do you still assume it ties to the Astral or Ethereal Plane? The Overlord's heartplanes and Daelkyr prisons are said to be demiplanes tied to Khyber, so that suggests they still are tied to a Plane. I've had a Player suggest that Demiplane goes to a totally new Plane, immune to Teleport, Etherealness, or other such effects to escape. But if that were literally true, the couatl/dragons/Gatekeepers could have shoved the Overlords/Daelkyr into such a prison and called it a day. How would you say Demiplane works in Eberron; making new and unreachable space in the Astral, similar to what the Progenitors did except on a minute scale? Or something else?

Tyler Nelson

Weird Question: Is Model Railroading a thing in Eberron? In our world, Toy Trains have been a thing since the beginning of actual railroading. Would there be toy Lightning Rials or is the tech too complicated/dangerous to make miniature versions of it? If nothing more, it would be an interesting hobby for a PC to have.

Elly Runnalls

I've been thinking a lot lately about espionage in Eberron. We've got the Dark Lanterns, the Royal Eyes, and the Trust all engaged in their own interests in their own ways and I'm here for it. My question is: in your Eberron, how do these agencies approach *counter*espionage? Sure, they're all spying on each others countries...but what happens when the Dark Lanterns in Sharn know that Thurik Davandi is a Trust agent?