Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

July was a challenging month, between COVID, personal matters, and catching up on all the work that I fell behind on because of those things. I'm getting back on track now and we'll see some Sky Pirates soon. Beyond this, I'm considering a number of changes to what I'm doing on Patreon, to make sure you're getting something for being a patron while not stretching myself too thin. 

But while that all comes together, let's do a questions thread. As always, I will limit myself to one question per patron and I'm not going to be able to answer every question. Because of this, simple questions are the best questions. If I can answer a question in five minutes here, I'll probably answer it. If it would take significant research or an hour of work to answer a question, I probably can't. Feel free to ask questions that didn't get answered in a previous month—last month was tough!—just know that I won't be able to get to them all. 

Thanks for your support!

Comments

gonzolikesmovies

If somebody decided to fire off the Moonbreaker again to sever another plane (say the gith want to sever Xoriat by 'breaking' Lharvion), what could be the potential repercussions of such a deed? And by extension, would severing most or even ALL the planes cause this Eberron to lose its status as the Prime Material for another Eberron to take its place?

Peter S.

Sorry if the question was already answered. How would the lore of Changelings change, if at all, if I wanted to use the new races from “Monsters of the Multiverse” (mostly about being a fey)?

Martin Westerberg

In your eberron who did the thranes send to karrnath as part of the relative exchange, and who did the karrns plan to send to aundair would aurala accept?

Only_Pugsley

Another Medusa question (lest one, I promise): I know you will be releasing rules for monstrous adventurers along with threshold but how do you think you'll balance their petrifying gaze while keeping it culturally relevant (avoiding gaze in specific ways to status, freezing people to find them treatment later, and preserving they're elders)?

Only_Pugsley

That makes sense, thanks for getting back to me and I look forward to seeing the next article. :D

Retias

How firmly set is a Znir Gnoll's place in one of the clans? For examples, whether someone might be born to parents from two different clans, or if someone is born into one clan but feels they'd be better suited in another when they become an adult.

Teettan

Where does the worship of the Six among the goblinoids come from? If the Dhakaani were atheist and didn’t worship any gods, did they still have tales of the Six as great heroes and eventually began worshipping the tales after the daelkyr twisted their minds? One smaller question, I can’t remember where I read it, in a sourcebook or one of the novels, but is it “canon” that was there a central god in the goblin’s version of the Hosts that humanity erased?

benjamin kuhns

Are there any ties either through lineage or practice from the Umbragen and Vol families of elves?

Margo

What is the most likely scenario for new Dal Quor invasion that includes Dreamspace and warforged technology from Xen'drik?

Tahina Andale

Who holds judicial power in the smaller cities and towns in Breland? Would the crown delegate it to a local noble, or a judge? Either or depending on the town in question?

Rodrigo Kuerten

If Eberron would be detached from D&D to become its own RPG, what would you change from D&D mechanics?

Spike Hemphill

How do you handle mechanics of a dungeon in your games? Do you create your own maps? Create original traps ideas? Do borrow ideas from other sources?

Spike Hemphill

Do newspapers in Khovaire have comic strips or political cartoons? Are there comic books in Khovaire? If so what genres are popular?

Inquisitor Thomas

So questions all about the Quori: 1. How exactly are Hashalaqs and Kalaraqs spirits of Nightmares when they represent the emotions of Pleasure and Pride, those seems more like emotions evoked during good dreams? 2. Why is it assumed that any Quori killed will reform with Loyalties to Dreaming Dark? The Kalashtar Quori are acting against their nature, but is carving out a huge section of their plane so they can beam uplifting Reidran propaganda into the dreams of mortals and building Happiness factories really in line with the original purpose of the Quori? 3. What if a Quori is the spirit of an emotion and dream that is contrary to the core principles of the Unity of Reidra and the Dreaming Dark’s plan, like a Du’ulora that’s the spirit of being really angry at your stupid boss or a Kalaraq who dreams of one day being King? Even if those spirits are useful now in spreading chaos in Khorvaire to potentially expand control over Khorvaire won’t there inevitably be a time where those Quori need to be tossed aside because they threaten the greater whole? 4. If the core goal of the Dreaming Dark is to stabilize Dal Quor so the age won’t turn, won’t restoring Cyra and having the Quori invade Eberron on Mass risk triggering a new Turning with the sudden mass panic? It seems Dreaming Dark is being super careful to make itself as safe from harm as possible, but is also fiending to just engage in the most wildly self destructive binge the moment it’s able to.

The Bard Himself

In rising from the last war, Trebaz Sinara is said to have not been seen in over 500 years. And yet, it is on the map of khorvaire in the same book. Is it simply that this is a sivis cartographer's guess at its location, or is this lore incorrect?

MajorTotoro

Hi Keith! At one point, your thoughts on a conversion of Rime of the Frostmaiden to Eberron made it into the polls, unsuccessfully. While that may never become a thing, there is one specific question regarding converting that module that I'd wish could be specifically covered: with no deities walking Eberron, what would you make the Frostmaiden herself be in Khorvaire? I'm changing her into a Archfey, but would love to hear your take. As always, thank you!

John_Doe_142857

A question about Queen Aurala of Aundair: Since she seems to genuinely believe that restarting the war would be a good thing, did she actually ever set a foot on a battlefield? Did she witness the pain and the death of her soldiers on the frontline? Or does she keeps thinking that War is Glorious because she was sheltered from the horrors of the Last War?

Eric Smith

The 5E book for Eberron says no expeditions have returned from Everice. If I wanted to tell the story of a previous expedition with a few survivors some years back, what might you recommend. Also, could there be Ice themed creatures a la Mephits that speak Aquan? Why might some groups want to return?

Beoric

How would Daask typically approach an assassination, and what creatures/classes/levels would likely be involved?

Joey Norwood

Hi, Keith! I'm so glad you are feeling better! The PCs in my Eberron campaign just found a "backdoor" into the Immeasurable Market of Syrania. I had them come in through what I call the Moon Pavilion, which cycles through the various moons as they make contact with (i.e., eclipse or are eclipsed by) Therendor, so this portal is transitory. The last Therendor contact with this particular moon was almost 40,000 years ago (implying a certain dark moon!), so I thought they should arrive at the most sparsely populated "corner" of the Market (though Jabra's tent was lying in wait for their arrival!). My question for you is concerning your idea of the general layout of the Immeasurable Market and the nature of its portals to the other planes, with a specific question about which planes, in your view would NOT have "backdoors" into the Market. I ask mainly because my PCs are not likely to be able to get back through the exact portal they came through, due to its transitory nature.

Zed Bundershot

What's the fashion equivalent of wearing a Cowboys jersey in the home section of the Eagles stadium? Many Khorvairan nations share a cultural trait; because they have a significant majority in one sentient type (humans, dwarves, goblins, etc.) It's mentioned that many use clothing as cultural signifiers. What clothes will get you hissed out of the cathedral in Flamekeep. What hair or beard style will get beer doused in any Soldorak inn? Are Darguun forced laborers wearing orange jumpsuits? Do Kech banner symbols get screened onto t-shirts (bonus: which member of the Aurum is making the most profit off of merchandise sales)?

Parker Wimberly

I know a how to fit radiant citadel in Eberron would require a Dragonmark post but I a related question. The book says that two of the cultures could be placed in Xen’drik. They are predominantly human culture (Shanhabumi culture of in the mist of manivarsha and the Sensa empire of Gold for Fools and Princes). How would you incorporate human cultures of Xen’drik other the those coming from modern khorvaire like stormreach

Giuseppe Taverniti

Does form of worship alternative to the Pyrinean creed survive in the Lhazaar Principalities?

Castier GM and Actor

Now that you are feeling better Keith. I would like to formally ask you what kind of economy does eberron have. In terms of how quickly magic items can be created how much faster can an uncommon item be made than a rare one in the DMG given that the houses have discovered ways of mass producing them. And lastly I'd like to know what you think a bag of holding would cost or a simple +1 weapon excluding vanity of course.

Ben

What sort of entities might take the role of "the Traveler" through divine/celestial channeling within the Cabinet of Faces?

Introlo

What are your thoughts on leylines in Eberron? Have they ever been talked about, and do they serve any sort of specific purpose in the world? I read something once about the Lightning Rails actually following the leylines of the world

Thomas Brøgger

In Don Bassingthwaite’s book The Binding Stone the reachers are using the work “tak” when saying thank you. Tak is actually the danish word for thank you. Would you use any other forign language word to make local dialects and what real world languages could be tied to specific parts of Khorvaire?

Harvey Clarke

Hey Keith, hope you're doing well! My question of the month is: Does House Deneith have any Eldritch Machines? Myself and a friend have been trying to think of some and the closest we have achieved that doesn't feel in the wheelhouse of another House is a Moral Machine. Do you have any Eldritch Machines for House Deneith in your games?

Earth Seraph Edna

What happens to a Dragon Below cultist who, knowingly or otherwise, swears themselves to multiple daelkyr or overlords? What about swearing themselves to one daelkyr and one overlord? What about a Belashyrra-crafted aberration deciding to also swear themselves to, say, Tul Oreshka? In other words, what happens when someone attempts to swear themselves to multiple great entities sealed in Khyber?

James Edward Johnson III

How would the Ghaash'kala have a Flamekeeper equivalent? I know you've mentioned it in posts as possible, but what would that look like? Do they have a column of fire that their 'Keeper' communes with? If not, how would such an idea function?

Joana

What are the citizens opinions on a possible return of the last war? Is there a popular desire for it's return in case the mournland wasn't caused by the war, or do most citizens(non-cyran of course) think that the day of the mourning was a "blessing" in horrifying disguise?

Marc Simon

On the topic of regular citizen vs the war, how widespread was the experience of the Last War among them? Were the five nation using drafting of all citizens (male and female since the setting is sex-equal) during most of the 100 years (even if it is just to do border patrol and not necessarily fighting), akin to the WWI but much longer, or was it more like the 100 years wars (a few units of drafted people when needed, very rarely, with much of the warfare done by professional troops that meant trouble when they were raiding around your town, but you could possibly spend a lifetime without having one in your surrounding). The first solution evokes widespread destruction and nations in real shambles, the second is milder but feels less "end-of-19th-century".

John Barleycorn

Hi Keith! Glad you are getting better! Would you say it would be possible to formulate an oath for Oathbound that will allow him to be a player character/adventurer? What that oath may be? Thanks!

Simon

3 options would love an answer for any of the 3. 1.you mentioned in a different reply that severing Shavarath would sever aggression from the eberron psyche in a potentially extreme way, do you have any ideas on what dreams were before Dal Quor was removed to distinguish them from the unconscious dreams eberron has today? 2. As khovaire's biggest landmark lake Galifar only has the implication of something dangerous in the middle that can take flying ships out of the sky, have there ever been any lore beyond that for the lake 3. Of the remaining seas that haven't been heavily expanded on Cannon or Kannon, Bitter, Sea of Lost Souls, Dark, Rage, White, etc - which is your favorite and whats a quick fact for why?

Will Buck

I'm glad you're feeling better! I would love to know more about any of the following. 1) Some Eberron fans have made alternate/homebrewed versions of the map of Khorvaire in which Scions Sound has been expanded into a large bay, to allow for more naval adventures as well as to enhance the separation between east and west Khorvaire after the Mourning. What are your thoughts on this change? What are some reasons you might prefer the canon "asterisk" version? 2) Specific relics, saints, or stories of the Sovereign Host. 3) The families of House Cannith. Were any families split by the division into South/West/East? 4) The marids of Thelanis, and the "Ocean King" who rules them. 5) As always: Starilaskur!

Morgaine Barkefors

Khorvaire doesn't adher to patriarchal lineages, so how does it work within the nobility? Is it established whose "line" a noble child is part of? And can either spouse choose to take the other's name or is there some other rule – such as only the two eldest children being able to carry on their line – in place to avoid the ducal families exploding in members?

Jarrod Taylor

A re-ask from last month: What can you tell us of Kellan the fabled hero?

Kristian's Foundry VTT Modules

I was looking through the Heir of Siberys prestige class from the Eberron Campaign Setting, and I noticed that both the Mark of Storm and the Mark of Scribing have very dangerous and harmful powers. This seems extremely opposite of the usual theme that true dragonmarks are usually utility spells that help with industry while aberrant marks are the ones that are dangerous causing destruction and death. Were these spells chosen for a reason? Is the Heir of Siberys intended to be potentially dangerous as well?

Dan Smith

What advice and tips do you have for running a (D&D) game with a 'man vs environment' and survival/exploration focus? Is there anything specific to Eberron that would affect how you ran a more survival focused game? I'm running a hex-crawl in Q'barra with some strong 'man vs environment' elements, and while I've ran games with such a focus before I'm curious what your experience with those sort of games are?

Matt Brady

Already asked my question but asking this one so I can reference back next month (or maybe someone knows) what was the general feeling about orcs and half-orcs before they were associated with Tharashk and the Twelve? The next most accessible areas with orcs are the Barrens and Lhazaar (or Mror), where the majority are warriors and pirates, not the "genre defying" druids of the Gatekeepers or mercantile prospectors of Tharashk Were orcs seen like goblins, gnolls and such? Or more like shifters and changelings (outsiders but still "human" adjacent)?

Jamie Bernstein

With how long they ruled over Khorvaire, it seems pretty inevitable that the Dhakaani dealt with a released Overlord at some point. Given their lack of Silver Flame belief, how do you think they would have dealt with the problem of rebinding it?

Nicholas Geier

Not sure if this is too late to warrant an answer. Regardless, I hope this month is starting off better than the last for you! Siberys, Eberron, Khyber Good, Neutral, Evil Above, Between, Below I’m thinking of another way to consider these from a dragon shard/ theoretical perspective. Siberys is unshaped energy from a dead progenitor. Their crystals enhance latent energy in mortals. Eberron is differentiated energy actively used in giving life/ containing Khyber. Their shards are used in active magical effects. Khyber is used energy, all possibilities already manifested in demiplanes and overlords. Their shards are used to house entities. So would something like this make sense from a more arcane academic standpoint?: Potential magic, Kinetic magic, Inertial Magic

Walt

So, I had an idea for the origin of genasi in Eberron. The giants of Xen'Drik, before the fall of their empire, experimented on their elven slaves. One of these experiments included summoning elementals from Kythri and combining them with the slaves, thus creating the different types of genasi. The race then originates from Xen'Drik, and is still rare, due to the different experiments of different elementals being done in different manifest zones to Kythri.

Carlton Anderson

If the Children of Winter got their hands on one or more devastation orbs (https://www.dndbeyond.com/magic-items/5581-devastation-orb) in your Eberron, what would some their top priority targets be for each type of orb? For example, using an earth orb beneath Sharn or a fire orb in the Talenta Plains could be exceptionally devastating, but what are some other targets that would make a particularly big impact and/or advance the Children's agenda?

Marker Mage

I have been thinking about the possibility of a time travel campaign for awhile now with the players using the Draconic Prophecy to identify ways to change the past, and it has had me wondering something: What is there to prevent dragons, the Lords of Dust, and other immortals from using time travel for a second attempt at fulfilling a passage of the Draconic Prophecy?

Simon

With the incoming entry of Ardlings, they seem antithesis to existing on Eberron with their natural ability to heal/ tie to Siberys. Would they be denizins of Irian/Lamanian manifest zones/worlds, the ring of siberys, another race of Githerberron or going for the classic secret race of xendrik/Mordain or even argonessen? Assuming they make a new eberron book for "One DND" and ask you to be part of implementing them

Travis Seetoo

Hi Keith! Hope you are feeling better! Question: who is your favourite Eberron NPC to play?

Max Barry

Hi Kieth In regards to the Power of Purity, I know they are presented as a group who wishes to work with elementals rather than forcefully bind them, but exactly how extremist could they be in their views? Do they actively attempt to prevent elemental binding from occuring? Would they work with the Ashbound (or would the ashbound even consider working with them) in an attempt to further their goals? or are they more focused on simply raising awarenes of the issue and finding a method of binding that is less “inhumane” in their eyes?

Jason PB

Hey Keith! I know this might be a bit too open-ended, but what can you tell us about Shirin d'Deneith? We know he is the head of the Blademarks Guild and that he is allied with the Emerald Claw for his "dream of conquest" that House Deneith will take over Khorvaire. What line is he in in House Deneith? How close to he is Baron Dreven, and how strong is his movement within the House? Thanks Keith!

Daniel Outhier

Hey Keith, how would you work Giff into Eberron?