Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Greetings Patrons!

Each month, I like to post a thread where you can ask questions. As always, I will not be able to answer every question—especially this month, where we've got a holiday, travel, preparation for PAX Unplugged, and more! So simple questions are the best questions. If I can answer a question in five minutes here, I'll probably answer it. If it would take significant research or an hour of work to answer a question, I probably can't. Feel free to ask questions that didn't get answered in a previous month—there are always some good ones I can't get to!—just know that I won't be able to get to them all. In addition, I will only answer one question per patron. You can ASK more than one, because one may be easier for me to answer than another, but I'll only answer one.

I'm still hoping to find a way to maximize the amount of content I can produce for the Patreon in the time I have available, but it's an ongoing process. Thanks for your support! 

Files

Comments

Earth Seraph Edna

In 5e Exploring Eberron, p. 25, you explain magic in Khorvaire as follows: "Magical effects of 6th level or higher are usually the product of more advanced civilizations." However, in canonical D&D 3.5 sources, there are various NPCs in conventional Khorvairian society who can cast 6th- or 7th-level spells by virtue of spell slots alone, without any additional limitations, without any Siberys dragonmarks. Should such an NPC's power be retconned down, or given restrictions? Similarly, 5e Exploring Eberron, p. 37, describes magic in Aerenal as such: "Spell effects of up to 7th level can be encountered in the hands of master wizards and high priests." Tezaera Mendyrian, one of the two Sibling Kings, is a 16th-level cleric in D&D 3.5, able to cast 8th-level spells by virtue of spell slots alone. Is she supposed to be an outlier by dint of her position? Are there actually several other living Aereni who can cast 8th-level spells using spell slots alone? Or is her power supposed to be retconned down, or given limitations?

HushMcQ

I love Eberron, it is my favorite setting, but one thing I miss from Forgotten Realms is hex-crawling with random encounters. Can you provide some guidance on how to DM (locations, circumstances, options, etc.) for how to hex-crawl with random encounters? What might be some good source material? What would be *Eberron* without regressing to FR tropes?

Jarrod Taylor

Before the Silver Purge, were there any rulers/monarchs (Wynarn or otherwise) who were open lycanthropes or has the affliction always carried too much negative connotations and worry?

Khadorek

Is the Uul Dhakaan considered a legitimate afterlife or is it purely a snapshot of those who were a part of the Uul incapable of further development? (Not sure which is canon and which is a product of my old dms interpretation)

Inquisitor Thomas

What is the dating/courtship scene like amongst the Elves of Khorvaire? The initial diaspora of Elves that left Aernal after the line of Vol was destroyed was a fraction of what is already a fairly small race, and only two elves can produce Elf child, and it'd seem like the community most Elven communities outside of Farlnen and the major cities of Khorvaire would be really small. Do Elf parents work to try to arrange matches between their children to maintain an Elf population in Khorvaire or do they mostly let their kids figure out for themselves and assume they’ll marry an Elf after the heartbreak of outliving their previous non-elf partner eventually occurs?

John Barleycorn

Hi Keith! What would Sulat league giant do if it was somehow frozen in time and awakened in 998 near Stormreach?

Mariamow

While there is no canonical maps of where each manifest zone is, would that information be recorded somewhere? Does the Library of Korrenberg contain a map of the Khorvaire with each manifest zone noted and their effects?

Mathias Nordfjord

What allies could the Lord of Blades have outside of his faction of Warforged?

Matt Brady

We know how Mror culture and physiology affects their cuisine and who can stomach it. Same for the goblinoids. But what is anything was introduced by the elves (or on the other hand what foods might they reserve from non-elven palates like the dwarves do for their intense food and drink) to the cuisine of the Five Nations? Are there foods of a enchanting/magical sleep effect which they can resist, or dishes which require exacting techniques and traditions to master, perhaps?

Tyler Nelson

How much of Races of Eberron is c(K)anon? I know you didn't have input on certain 3e sourcebooks, and I remember you having mixed views on Faiths of Eberron, and I was curious what you thought of RoE.

EllieSF

Could one force an evolution out of an Aberrant Mark with Dragonshards? Currently I have a Bloodhunter who is flavored as her Bloodhunter abilities are her mark hurting her in return for the abilities it gives her. She is a very extreme revolutionary, and the mark is slowly driving her insane. I wanted her to attempt to improve her mark artificially. Could she use Siberys Shards, or any other type of shard to do this.

House Sivis Echoer Station

What kinds of books are currently most popular in the different regions/nations of Eberron? Is it a particularly good year for romance novels in Breland, do Thranes tend to love sweeping adventure novels, do Stormreachers like books about the courtly love and chivalry of old Galifar?

The Indie Fox

Journeys through the Radiant Citadel introduced Aurumvorax, an 8-legged Badger-like creature that eats gold, which gets incorporated into their fur. Based on this, in my own games I've introduced the idea that they can eat other materials, including Byeshk the "Purple Gold, which made them effective anti-Daelkyr weapons, and that they're an example of Dhakaani magebreeding. But I'm wondering how you would use them? Be it a Kech that still has them, Mror holds clans that prize them or dispise them, other things they can eat and how that effects them, etc.

Beoric

When are the solstices and equinoxes? Some of the books have references to them, but the dates are unclear. FoE says the winter solstice occurs on 14 Zarantyr and on 27 Vult (within two pages of each other, in the same section!). And a case could be made for the Nights of Long Shadows (26-28 Vult) coinciding with the winter solstice, particularly since Mabar is supposed to be coterminous on the winter solstice (from the ECS).

Jesse Williams

1.I find the idea of people walking the line of dangerous magics in pursuit of truth very compelling, and would love to know more about how a PC could be part of the Court of Shadows but not be Evil. 2.Is the Umbra a force of evil? what is the Umbragen belief on what happens when their soul joins the Umbra?

Teettan

Is Dal Quor the only plane to experience eras? It and the fey realm are both closely tied to and effected by the material plane, but the turning of the last age of Dal Quor doesn’t align with any major events during the age of giants, at least seemingly doesn’t.

Eric Smith

Obviously, the Silver Flame has a Knighthood tradition. Besides them, and maybe Karnath (I know they are very martial), what other nations have such a tradition? Also, how do the Mror view the concept of Knighthood?

Marker Mage

I'm once again providing multiple questions. Feel free to pick whichever is easier to answer. 1. What place, short of Fernia itself, would one go to for spicy food in Eberron? 2. What would you say is the "collect them all" souvenir that every tourist location in Khorvaire seem to have some variation of? Alternatively, what would be a popular Sharn souvenir? 3. A lot of old noir detective stories have a lead come in the form of a branded matchbook that indicates the last bar the victim visited. Do you have any alternatives for this classic clue? 4. Would the people of Eberron consider a cloak of billowing to be a variation of glamerweave for having its enchantment being purely aesthetic instead of functional, or would the term not apply due to the cloak of billowing making no use of illusion? Is there a term in the setting for purely aesthetic enchantments? 5. Do you see wandslingers wielding magic staves differently from how more traditional wizards like Gandalf would?

Demon Hunter 1661

What would happen to the Kalashtars with the next turning of the age?

Blinky

A question about the Aurum, and advancement (or demotion): it stands to reason that every member of the Aurum is ambitious, both within the organization and in their day-to-day life (and presumably successes in broader Khorvaire are weighted when applying to trade in your rings for more precious ones). But what happens when a Concordian is down on his luck, his initial promise was squandered, or fled? What if a promising architect was revolutionizing construction techniques was only so impressive because of a pact he made with the Mother of Invention, and now he is no longer in her favor, and his life's work has literally come crashing down. Is he going to languish in the Copper Concord forever, or is there a means by which he might be asked to turn in his rings? How do the Aurum look at less-useful members who have fallen on hard times and are no longer of benefit to the Order at large? In a similar vein, would it be grounds for removal if an Aurum member is ever convicted of a crime, because of the pall it would throw over the organization (with the understanding that they would likely still maintain connections even if they are publicly severed from the organization)?

Mike Mateer

Any thoughts on what Katashka the Gatekeeper's Heart Plane would look like? (After a 3+ year, Level 1-20 campaign, my players are about to descend into it in order to reseal the partially-released Overlord. I want to make it special!)

Jesse Williams

How many planer celestials and fiends worship the nine and six? If planer forces worship them, and people on the material plane have made contact with them, how does that not prove of their existence?

Andrew Gibbons

I discovered my players are very much into crafting > which I didn't really expect > so what does the independent crafting scene look like in Eberron?

Ben Chance

So we know Kaius the III is (maybe?) Kaius I posing as his grandson, who may be imprisoned secretly by Kaius I. So this brings up two questions: 1. What were the circumstances of Kaius II's rule? and 2. Was Kaius II also the vampire Kaius I posing?

Zed Bundershot

Let us speculate there exists a daelkyr symbiont fluid called Belashyrra's Tears, a potion one drops into the eyes rather than swallows, If you were in the mood to prognosticate what it's boon/creepy-side-effect would be, what would you play?

Selerian

Why the Gilded Labyrinth is called "The Gilded Labyrinth"? Is this some sacred symbol? Or a metaphor for spiritual advancement? Or there is a real maze somewhere in Flamekeep?

hyperewok1

This is obviously a bit broad, but how do you make the Sovereign Host actually feel like the predominant faith for a large portion of Khorvaire and thus a major part of the world? It often feels like they end up overshadowed by other faiths that are more centralized and/or actively engaging in the world, whether for good or ill (namely thinking of the Silver Flame and Blood of Vol, and Path of Light to a lesser extent).

Ben

Hi Keith, can you tell us some of your thoughts about Calderus, the ancient psionic vampire in the Depths of Sharn? Beyond her being an ancient psionic there's not a lot to go on in Sharn: City of Towers and Whispers of the Vampire's Blade. Did some elements of the Beholder (i.e., network of psionic servants) get absorbed by her?

Jeremy Callister

A couple questions that have been posed to me recently. How does Thrane and the church handle Shadow in the Flame corruption on a governmental basis? Is simply proving a Cardinal is actually following the Shadow enough to depose them? Is there laws against fiendish use or is it something the Knights handle without the paperwork? Also, someone brought up the idea of warforged having an innate language, perhaps some remnant of the giant magic that was the basis of the creation forges. I personally don't quite like the idea, as Eberron seems to move away from the concept of innate languages in general. But it did make me think of the possibilities of the warforged developing their own version of Thieve's Cant, some way to communicate among themselves that would be unique to them. What are your thoughts?

JVR

What’s happening with Jorlanna’s (latest) forbidden affair? The one where her secret lover Kkressd from House Orien is actually a rakshasa agent of the Lords of Dust. Do her rivals have any suspicions/evidence of this? Are his manipulations of her causing any damage to House Cannith as a whole yet? Also, apparently Kkressd's father knows all about the affair...and isn't freaking out. I could have sworn inter-house dating was a seriously big no-no among the dragonmarked houses. [resubmitted question from last month]

Will Buck

Would you be able to share some version of the Dral Khatuur write-up you did a few years back? The weather is getting colder after all! (in the northern hemisphere anyway)

Kaci Petri

To keep it as brief as possible: I am setting out to do a steampunk heavy campaign, where it is a mashup of Ravnica and Eberron. The mashup is Jace did a certain something making it possible for Ravnica to become a floating city somewhere on Eberron, where eventually the Guilds and Dragonmarked Houses are vowing for influence. My question is: Where would you put Ravnica as a floating city on Eberron, preferably close to Khorvaire? Of course any other advice or ideas would be welcomed!!

Carlton Anderson

Reposting my question from September, which type (air, earth, fire, or water) of devastation orb (https://www.dndbeyond.com/magic-items/5581-devastation-orb) do you think would be the most effective against each of the following locations and what sort of impact would you expect it to have on them? The Tower of the Twelve (Korth) The Arcane College (Arcanix) Stormhome Fairhaven Alternatively, if you think there are better/more effective location that would advance the Ashbound agenda, I'd love to hear about them, which orb you'd use there, and why (e.g., using an earth orb beneath Sharn).

Thomas Brøgger

I’ve started to play some simple ttrpg with my niece (six years old) and it made me think about how to introduce younger kids to Eberron. How would you go about it and what themes and villains would you use?

dnob_nalon

Hiya! New member here. I saw an interesting question on the Eberron Discord regarding bicycles: do you think they would play any particular role in Eberron/any interesting magical twists?

dirDav3

Hi Keith, glad to be a patron once more! On page 141 of the ECG, the Chaos Fleet is described as an elemental fleet from Kythri in Lhazaar. Body-snatching, soul-binding elemental drudge pirates. I was surprised the chaos fleet wasn't mentioned at all in Exploring Eberron, considering they're the largest interaction with the material plane from Kythri (Gith not withstanding). I think there were some big differences between 4th edition and 5th edition Eberron, and i don't think they've been officially mentioned since. They seem to be a better fit for Shavarath, but I don't know about how I'd work all the elementals into it. So I want to ask what you would change about this group for 5e, or how you would use them in a game, themes, etc?

Iris

In the basic rules for Harpies, they came to be because of a divine curse, a love turned into hate for the gods, bringing on the transformation into the first harpy. In Eberron we have the harpy flights in the Graywall mountains, and we know from Exploring Eberron that they call themselves "children of the Fury". Yet at the same time we have brief references in a few articles saying it is the Shadow that gave them their magical voice. There does not seem to be any account of how harpies came to be in Eberron. Is there an epic story for the first harpy? Was it a blessing or a curse from the Sovereigns/Six?

Joana

Keith, what's the difference between a Thelanis Hag, and a Archfey that usually ends up as an evil antagonist in their stories?

Kevin Macku

You've probably already answered this previously somewhere, but let's say, for fun, we got to make a (rather, a *new*) licensed PC game for Eberron; what genre would you like to see it in? Old school isometric CRPG like Baldur's Gate? RTS? Maybe Total War: Eberron for that Last War redux? Third-person action RPG like Dragon Age/Mass Effect? Oargev Doki Doki Dating Sim? (okay maybe not that last one...unless...)

Joseph Meehan

What was the War of the Mark like in Karrnath?

Vani Srinivasan

Given that tensions between Aundair and the Eldeen Reaches are still fairly high, would it make sense for Aurala to occasionally stop by Foalswood and pay her Vadalis in-laws a visit? How likely would this be to cause an international incident?

Prof Nesbitt

How does the "soul" work in eberron in regards to corporeal and incorporeal undead? Mainly dealing with intelligent undead. I've always assumed incorporeal undead are essentially the soul manifested, and zombies are the bodies essentially being puppeted by some spirit from another plane (mabaran etc). But with intelligent undead like a vampire that have memories of their lives, is their "soul" still in their undead body or in a bizarre case could a person become two distinct undead after death? Because it would be pretty interesting for one person to turn themselves into a vampire but upon undeath their soul being restless becomes a ghost (or specter or whatever) and over time what was one person becomes two distinct beings with its own experiences and opinions different from the other.

Daelkyr Devon

How does one "read" the Draconic Prophecy in a credible capacity? I understand the Prophecy is a roadmap of possibilities, but in what vein can it be perceived? Obviously this isn't the case, but is there a script lying around that can be read or interpreted? Or is it just dragons and demons doing some people watching and seeing the ebb and flow of the world, and using that to predict the future?

Richard Flynn

Quick question - how do you run The Hall of a Thousand mirrors for a cursed character?

Jason PB

Hi Keith! I know it’s late in the month, but questions have floated about the server about pets and service animals in Eberron. We know about familiars, and we know about working animals like tribexes and draft horses. But do the people of Khorvaire have any special customs or practices about pets? What sort of magical pets are there? Is House Vadalis routinely selling purple pooches? How does a magic society impact service animals?

Martin Westerberg

In the ethereal posts the medani are noted as supernatural detectives, would it be that ghosts and supernatural is just common enought that a averadge detective should consider it or would it be a special brand of medani detectives (the X-scrolls), or perhaps both?

Mariamow

Hey Keith, really dropping this at the buzzer but I would forget otherwise: With the One D&D changes to classes and subclasses, old subclasses are not truly compatible. I love the subclasses from Exploring Eberron (My Duur'kala is so flavourful mechanically!) and don't want them to sit as a relic of a past time when the new books drop in a couple years. Do you plan to remaster/errata the subclasses in ExE and CoE when the new edition is published?

Simon

Considering 4/6 daelkyr have stats are their plans for the Orlassk and Kryzin for 5e? Specifically if Orlassk the never statted and least? talked about one will make it into Frontiers since that deals with Medusa and quickstone etc? Alternatively if you don't answer questions about future product info, how powerful/ what does Orlassk represent given it seems to oppose at least half of its breathren, Belashyrra in lore, Dyrrn with change vs stillness opposed by concept, and Kyrrn fludity vs solidity opposed by concept.

Daelkyr Devon

What happens when Kuo-Toa go near the Kar'lassa? I would assume they would continue to consciously dream, but is it accurate to assume their dream shifts to the corresponding plane and not Dal Qour? How does this affect their magic (if at all)?

Matt Brady

I know you said that it would likely get developed further if you ever did an article on Tashana, but did you ever have ideas on what the Tashanan sailors (shifters, dwarves, half-giants, humans?) were sailing all the way to Zarash'ak to trade? Or if that question proves unlikely, going off your old list of common languages in Eberron (Common, Giant, Goblin, Riedran, Elven, Undercommon) what is the general language most people in Khorvaire pick up as a second language? Is Goblin considered useful to its widespread use, or do backgrounds which get an additional language skew towards learning Elven or Draconic? Is Giant a language mostly for academics, is Riedran called for much outside of Lhazaar and the Shadow Marches?