Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Greetings Patrons!

Chronicles of Eberron is out in the wild and I'm on my way home from PAX Unplugged, so it's time for questions. As always, I will not be able to answer every question. So simple questions are the best questions. If I can answer a question in five minutes here, I'll probably answer it. If it would take significant research or an hour of work to answer a question, I probably can't. Feel free to ask questions that didn't get answered in a previous month—there are always some good ones I can't get to!—just know that I won't be able to get to them all. In addition, I will only answer one question per patron. You can ASK more than one, because one may be easier for me to answer than another, but I'll only answer one.

Thank you for your support! 

Files

Comments

Inquisitor Thomas

Hey Keith, can you shine the light of Dol Arrah on this Breland/Blood of Vol Fanboy’s cold dead cynical heart (which may or may not have been secretly replaced by a Kyber Shard Prison of an Overlord or the Dragon who inspired the Mockery) and explain what makes being a follower of her cool and interesting and why I would want to play a character dedicated to her and not the Silver Flame or Aureon or the Other members of the faces of war?

Will Buck

Chronicles is amazing, I'm really enjoying it! Psionic laser guns made out of solidified emotion? Don't mind if I doooo This might not be a five-minute question, but could you give some details about the archfey known as the Nine Brothers of Night and their layers in Thelanis? (from the Gates of Night novel)

The Bard Himself

In a previous Q&A You mentioned the main inhabitants of the Dragonreach Sea may indeed be dragons, as in an oceanic populous of Argonnessen. I am currently working on fleshing out Seren as a setting and am curious to know how dragons living below the waves of the island mind effect the Serena.

The Colonel

At the very end of the war of the mark it’s said that Sharn was under siege by the houses which houses would’ve been involved in the front line efforts of the siege?

Alexander Eldritch

On the Pathfinder 2e subreddit, there was some discussion about who would you love to see write a PF2e book. Your name came up. It made me wonder, have you had any experience playing PF2e?

Matthew Booth

Here's a lighter question: Is the changeling tailor on page 32 of ExE and page 6 of Chronicles the same one? If yes, can we give them a name as a Recurring Character?

Thomas Brøgger

If Ashtakala is an Overlord does it then have a prakhutu and who would that be?

Khadorek

Not sure if this fits, but what is the cuisine of khorvaire like? I know Kaarnath is known for vedbread, but what styles of food could you get elsewhere?

Karma Liljenkrone

Hi Keith, I bought Chronicles of Eberron and saw the section on The Shadow and the drawbacks of casting forbidden magic, but I was wondering a lot about what kind of spells the Shadow would offer?

Dan Smith

I have three questions relating to Q'barra, with the first two being old ones, so take your pick: 1. My understanding is that both the remaining demonic ruins and the specialized Dragonshards (dawn and dusk shards) have important connections to Masvirik and him being bound. What's the difference between their roles in binding Masvirik? 2. On the same note, how do these differences impact and differentiate the strategies in which the Trothlorsvek and the Masvirik'Uala fight Masvirik and the Poison Dusk? I remember the article in Dungeon 185 said the Dragonborn see the Dawn and Dusk shards as unimportant and are more concerned with the remaining ruins. I imagine this would lead to the Trothlorsvek being more reactive/defensive in their strategy, only focusing on neutralizing threats rising from the demonic ruins. On the other hand, I could see the Cold Sun Federation being more offensive in their strategy, actively pursuing some dragonshards and striking at key points when given directions to do so by the Coatl in their dreams. 3. How would you describe the primary differences between the magic of the Five Nations and the magic of the Trothlorsvek? To clarify, do the dragonborn of Q'barra rely upon Dragonshards or have another source of magic (possibly innate) that they use?

Spike Hemphill

Alternative question. Do the Dragons of Argonnessen have mental defenses against Quori or lucid dreamers entering their dreams?

Richard Flynn

When will the Chronicles or Eberron be released on DM's Guild?

Aidan Dunn

How would you stat a giant for a PC? (Looking forward to Bigsby's)

Marker Mage

I'm copy and pasting previously unanswered questions plus a few more. 1. What place, short of Fernia itself, would one go to for spicy food in Eberron? 2. What would you say is the "collect them all" souvenir that every tourist location in Khorvaire seems to have some variation of? 3. What would be a popular Sharn souvenir? 4. A lot of old noir detective stories have a lead come in the form of a branded matchbook that indicates the last bar the victim visited. Do you have any alternatives for this classic clue? 5. Would the people of Eberron consider a cloak of billowing to be a variation of glamerweave for having its enchantment being purely aesthetic instead of functional, or would the term not apply due to the cloak of billowing making no use of illusion? Is there a term in the setting for purely aesthetic enchantments regardless of if they use illusion or not? 6. You've mentioned that you "generally see wandslingers wielding staves life we would wield rifles". Do all of these instances have the handle end pointed at the enemy, or do a few of them have the heel pointed at the enemy like the sniper staves in the game Kid Icarus Uprising? 7. One of my favorite firearms to base a spellcasting implement on is a sawed off shotgun. At the moment, I'm still undecided on how a sawed off staff should be different from a typical staff besides it now being rod-sized. Think you could come up with an explanation of what the sawed off part would have been for?

Tim Edwards

What aspects of Dwarfs would you look to if generating a Five Nations Dwarf character rather than a Mror Hold upbringing?

Beoric

Does the Broken Mirror street gang in Sharn from RftLW have any connection to the Broken Mirror tavern?

Matt Brady

Put this in the wrong month! I know you said that it would likely get developed further if you ever did an article on Tashana, but did you ever have ideas on what the Tashanan sailors (shifters, dwarves, half-giants, humans?) were sailing all the way to Zarash'ak to trade? Or if that question proves unlikely, going off your old list of common languages in Eberron (Common, Giant, Goblin, Riedran, Elven, Undercommon) what is the general language most people in Khorvaire pick up as a second language? Is Goblin considered useful to its widespread use, or do backgrounds which get an additional language skew towards learning Elven or Draconic? Is Giant a language mostly for academics, is Riedran called for much outside of Lhazaar and the Shadow Marches?

Vani Srinivasan

How do you imagine Dhakaani dirge singing to sound? Do you have any references or examples for what to base it on when describing it?

Earth Seraph Edna

If quori can rebel, is it possible for an individual quori or two to decide to serve an overlord or a daelkyr, whether due to personal ambitions, or due to a misguided belief in pursuing an alternate method of self-preservation against the turning of the Age?

hyperewok1

Do the Blood of Vol believe/have myths that some of their past seekers have actually fully unlocked their Divinity Within and transcended into some greater existence?

Daelkyr Devon

How would the Kuo-Toa interact with the Kar'lassa? Would the Kar'lassa affect the Kuo-Toa's "conscious dreaming" in a different way? How might the Kuo-Toa view the Kar'lassa if they were to encounter one (assuming they aren't already aware of them!)

Jesse Williams

1.I am reading through your old articles and I saw one that mentioned the Hammerfest Dwarves in the Demon Wastes. They sound very fascinating, would you ever elaborate on them like you did with some of the various gnome societies? 2. So Sibrys is the source of arcane magic, Eberron is called out as the source of primal magic, is Khyber the source of a type of magic? how does khyberian magic different from the others? 3. Is the Umbra a force of evil? what is the Umbragen belief on what happens when their soul joins the Umbra? 4. are any of the other faiths worshipped by planer entities, angels using the silver flame on shavarath or a Mabaran fiend worshiping an overlord?

dirDav3

Hi Keith! Regarding the Wind Whisperers Principality. Page 138 of the ECG says their HQ is Windlost Island. Page 141 of Exploring Eberron says its Orthoss, and so does one of the Dragonshard articles. Besides the conflicting data, there seems to be a conflicting idea. That being that the wind whispers came from Aerenal and colonized Orthoss instead of Farlnen like the other elves. But the island of Windlost is called WINDLOST. It's tailor-made for this group, and its proximity to Lorghalan allows for the story where they kidnap a Stonesinger to help steal an airship. If they're on Orthoss then they're like 2,000 miles away from Lorghalan and that wouldn't make logistical sense. My question is if you weren't aware of this small seeming inconsistency, which do you go with, and if you stick to Orthoss as the later writings suggest, what's on Windlost? There would be nothing written about that island otherwise even though it's right in the middle of a nice little cluster of named principalities.

Yan-Jie Schnellbach

1. There are several planar invasions in Eberron's history - from Dal Quor in Xen'drik, the Daelkyr bringing down the goblinoid empires. Where these invasions mostly contained/focused on single continents (Xen'drik, Khorvaire) or did they affect all continents? 2. On the topic of continents: are the names we know now (Khorvaire, Sarlona, Argonessen, Xen'drik) the current "Khorvairan" names or the names given to them by their own inhabitants - i.e. would a giant from Xen'drik call it "Xen'drik"?

Jamie Bernstein

It's been mentioned that if you were to revisit the Ring of Storms, it would be sensible to replace the lizardfolk with dragonborn. Given it's at least 40,000 years (probably way more) since the fall of the Qabalrin, how you do picture this Dragonborn society? Would it be similar to Q'barra, with regards to them nominally continuing their role, but eventually expanding?

Parker Wimberly

Hi Keith could you give us some general info on the Talons of Tiamat, the cult to Tiamat thats mentioned in Dragons of Eberron? I'm just curious and since Shadow of the Dragon Queen came out I think it would be useful for people that might want to adapt the advenutre to Eberron.

Caelan Scott

Chronicles of Eberron says that a majority of an Overlord’s minions were bound by the Silver Flame. How does this manifest? Are they bound to the heart demiplane and cannot leave it? Or is it that they are unable to escape from Khyber? Or lastly do they have physical locations where they are bound like the Overlords?

Felix Shafir

Where is the Duke of the Hilt's ducal seat in Breland? Chronicles of Eberron (which is fantastic!) seems to signal that the Duke has little if any authority in Sharn, and it's not entirely clear to me which settlements are encompassed by the Hilt region, so it'd be interesting to know where the Duke is based out of.

Tyler Nelson

So you mentioned in your Eldeen Reaches article(s?) that talking wolves have equal rights as citizens in the Reaches.... Which begs the question, how would you handle a talking wolf PC? I wouldn't mind playing one n a campaign.

Jesse Williams

Yes please! I also had used a different race with a bite attack and just pretended he was a wolf. I optimized him for maximum bite damage.

JVR

Is there a language style guide anywhere? That is to say, a glossary of local terms like you'll see in the Forgotten Realms (breakfast is “dawnfry” and dinner is “eveningfeast,” etc.)

Jarrod Taylor

We know about wolves, rats, and even bears, but where are the wereboars and weretigers in the world?

OHeyItsRick

Question! If you were going to stat an Avatar of Katashka, how would you go about it?

Simon

1. Will the new release after Chronicles include Orlassk? 2. Why does Orlassk's maze change if it is the Daelkyr of hearing and stone and stillness, at least by implivation

Ben

Chaseva ir’Maasat is mostly described in sourcebooks in terms of her relationship to King Boranel, and by how her death made him feel a need for vengeance and answers. How would you elaborate on Chaseva’s life to minimize the “fridging” that happened to make her primarily a tragic part of Boranel’s backstory and future plot hook for House Medani or a conflict between Breland and Droaam?

Tyler Nelson

So Magic the Gathering has already had two DnD themed sets. I am interested in how you feel about the MtG color pie alignment system being used in place of the Traditional alignments in Eberron.

Dan Smith

In the past you've mentioned that Forge of War doesn't really align with your vision of the Last War. After rereading the article on the Argonth I was wondering in a general sense what were the major phases/developments in military doctrine during the Last War? The presence of flying fortresses and warforged colossi infers that there was a phase where "superweapons" that acted as displays of power were considered more important, while the growing presence of wandslingers implies a shift towards mobile squad based tactics in modern times.

Micah Davis

In your mind, how cognizant of alignment are the people of Eberron in 5e? Obviously in 3.5, Detect [Alignment] occurred with some regularity and so they knew about but was that a mechanical quirk that you prefer to eschew?

Joseph Meehan

It's possible this has been asked before; how do people find directions in your Eberron? Is there a magnetic north for compasses? Is this primarily a function of magic?

Rhys Miller

How would the society of Cazhaak Draal medusas interact with a medusa who's been struck permanently and visibly blind? i.e. by an outstanding smite from a Silver Flame paladin. Given how key the petrifying gaze is to medusa culturally, would it be cause for exile? Execution? Or would they be more understanding?

Will Buck

I'm curious what your take is on Skaravojen, the very bizarre guard "dog" creature that protects the Keeper of the Flame. It was introduced in Five Nations (which I know you did not contribute to) and then never mentioned again in canon to my knowledge. I've never actually run a game in Flamekeep so I've avoided the question, but I feel like saying House Vadalis somehow miraculously created a hideous one-of-a-kind perfectly loyal monstrosity that lives for almost a thousand years, and that no one (even during the most oppressive years of the Church of the Silver Flame) ever questioned this fiendish-looking creature being so close to the head of the faith, is just too much of a stretch.

Carlton Anderson

Reposting my question from September, which type (air, earth, fire, or water) of devastation orb (https://www.dndbeyond.com/magic-items/5581-devastation-orb) do you think would be the most effective against each of the following locations and what sort of impact would you expect it to have on them? The Tower of the Twelve (Korth) The Arcane College (Arcanix) Stormhome Fairhaven Alternatively, if you think there are better/more effective location that would advance the Ashbound agenda, I'd love to hear about them, which orb you'd use there, and why (e.g., using an earth orb beneath Sharn).

Daelkyr Devon

Given that elves don't dream (as Thelanis and DalQuor are "opposing" planes), can the same be assumed of other Thelanis denizens? Do archfey, faeries, supporting cast, etc. dream in DalQuor? Do they trance? Or do they have a unique dreaming situation?

Morgaine Barkefors

Quick question as my players are approaching Droaam: What does Vralkek mean, and in what language?

Matthew Booth

Were there spaces in the Age of Demons where the Overlords' direct influence didn't cover? i.e. Could there be gaps between their influences where relatively normal life for mortals could happen, without the influence of a couatl or other great counteracting power?

AnotherOne

As I love playing with extremes (and I did give myself an answer for the other extreme earlier) considering Tairnadal Patronage, do you think there's a "cutoff-point" where a Patron can start picking up a Revenant or would you say it's possible for the Patron to die only days or hours before the coming of age ceremony and have them have the only-just deceased legendary Revenant "assigned" to them? And going even further than that, what do you think about having the Patron have yet be alive (but not that far off of death), could they have some subconcious or prophetic ability to sway the Keepers of the Past or would it more likely be "try again in 10 years" (assuming no other ancestral patron puts forth a claim)? Thank you for all you do :)

JosieShenanigans

Kalashtar are said to never manifest dragonmarks, are they still susceptible to manifesting aberrant dragonmarks? Follow up, is everyone potentially capable of manifesting aberrant marks?

Jesse Williams

Is there any motivation or reason for a non-kalashtar to follow the path of light above any other faiths? Is it more just a philosophy instead of a faith?

Martin Westerberg

Where would you put the Ioun stones? Phonetically it could be linked to aundair, the Aun sounding like ioun so that might be a link?

DaevaDragon

Hey Keith, two questions: First, how are genasi treated in Riedra? I would imagine wild zones would produce some powerful 'touched, but are they well regarded in their homelands, seen as dangerous, thought to be the perfect edgewalkers? Second, how might you handle moving from a high level Eberron campaign to a new low level game in the future of the first, with those high level PCs still hanging around as NPCs blowing out the standard curve of NPCs in Eberron?