Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Greetings Patrons!

Welcome to 2023! I'll be posting a round-up for some of last month's questions in the next few days, but it's a new month and I want to get a new thread going. Over the next few months I've going to be making decisions about Keith-Baker.com and the Patreon, and you can expect a few polls regarding future content; looking forward over the year I want to come up with a sustainable plan that provides you all with satisfying content. In the meantime, I'll be running the Siberspace Finale at the end of this month, and then it will be time to get back to Threshold! 

So, questions thread! As always, I will not be able to answer every question; simple questions are the best questions. If I can answer a question in five minutes here, I'll probably answer it. If it would take significant research or an hour of work to answer a question, I probably can't. Feel free to ask questions that didn't get answered in a previous month—there are always some good ones I can't get to!—just know that I won't be able to get to them all. In addition, I will only answer one question per patron. You can ASK more than one, because one may be easier for me to answer than another, but I'll only answer one.

Thank you for your support!

Files

Comments

Kaci Petri

In Dragons Of Eberron, it says the dragons following the religion Thir seek to pursue being an embodiment of a Sovereign archetype to ascend. The Archetype list the the Sovereign/Dark 6 associated with it, my question is what Draconic god relates to which Archetype? My apologies if it is listed anywhere, I feel like I have scoured!

Sam Hakel

So I understand that in the current era the limits of the Korth Edicts are being tested, but is the allowed existence of Stormhome prior to this as simple as "Without the Mark of Storm this island is uninhabitable so they might as well have it" or is there more of a story pertaining to Lyrander's de facto if not de jure ownership of the island?

WebbRosson

Are there any shifter communities in the Principalities? Maybe some ships decked out in plants and trees?

Joseph Meehan

While you may not have time to write a FULL Deneith Families article, is there a "short version" you could do with just say names and One Neat Thing/Region?

Sierra

Sneaking in at the last moment: ...what is your TSL character like, Keith?

GhostOfEternalTime

What do you suggest for a factotum (Dungeonscape) in Eberron? It's a "professional adventurer" class if you don't have the book.

Thursday Garreau

Have you ever played a Forged in the Dark game (Blades in the Dark, Songs for the Dusk, Girl by Moonlight, etc)? I've fallen head over heels for the system and all its various hacks. Blades's setting, Doskvol, feels like if House Cannith had to build a city to survive especially-nasty manifest zones of Dolurrh and Mabar at the same time.

Jamie Gardiner

Could the Progenitor Dragons be used as Warlock Patrons?

Charley Meink

Did you use Theodore Roosevelt as a basis for King Boranel of Breland?

Jessie Harris

When a specific draconic prophecy is completed, is the affiliated Overlord immediately released, or is there like an intermediate period?

Jason PB

I hope there’s not too much of a deep dive required for this one, but why do you think warforged only have three fingers? Was that an intentional choice, or a quirk from the artists?

EllieSF

If a Gith were banished, what plane would they go to? Kythri, or their undisclosed place of origin? And do planetouched people get sent to the plane they're connected to?

Not Mordakhesh

What would the quori do first if they managed to reestablish the connection with Eberron? My players are far more inquisitive than Daine ever was in the novels. The Lunar Crystal has been taken into Dal Quor via the plane shifting sphere in Karul’tash. My party have taken their own sphere into Thelanis (that was not planned, they just really like fey stuff I guess). They will soon meet a very knowledgeable NPC that will inform them that they must go find a monolith and use Kin’s ritual to destroy the sphere once and for all etc. But what should I tell them will happen if they fail? Where would the horde of nightmares strike first? Is there some other magical macguffin you recommend I add to make the stakes of the final boss higher? I asked a similar question months ago but then my subscription ran out. Great to be back, by the way! Love chronicles!!

Dirin

Pretty sure you didn't work on the book they were introduced in, but do you have any ideas of what the Hornblade Clan from Faiths of Eberron would be like, and how they might be different from the mainstream Blood of Vol found in Karrnath?

Eric Smith

I have flirted a lot with the idea of Magewright apprentice PCs, kind of like Steamfitters' Apprentices. Essentially, someone who studied a trade but never got all the way through. I think the best way for that is the Artificer Initiate from Tasha's, which gives a tool prof, a cantrip and a first level Artificer spell. An example being a Lamplighter's Apprentice with Tinker's Tools, Light and maybe Faerie Fire. My weird question is, what might that mean in the world. Clearly, two of the three choices there fit the Magewright perfectly but the Faerie Fire is more of a fluke. How would you choose to explain that? That they could not complete the course but somehow, drinking one night, they met the Traveler?

Zachary Butler

You've said that Sarlona is more alien dystopia than far-east proxy. Is there somewhere in your Eberron that you think is a good fit for wuxia fantasy or East Asian inspired adventures?

Marker Mage

You didn't answer any of mine last month, so I'm copy and pasting them again. 1. What place, short of Fernia itself, would one go to for spicy food in Eberron? 2. What would you say is the "collect them all" souvenir that every tourist location in Khorvaire seems to have some variation of? 3. What would be a popular Sharn souvenir? 4. A lot of old noir detective stories have a lead come in the form of a branded matchbook that indicates the last bar the victim visited. Do you have any alternatives for this classic clue? 5. Would the people of Eberron consider a cloak of billowing to be a variation of glamerweave for having its enchantment being purely aesthetic instead of functional, or would the term not apply due to the cloak of billowing making no use of illusion? Is there a term in the setting for purely aesthetic enchantments regardless of if they use illusion or not? 6. You've mentioned that you "generally see wandslingers wielding staves like we would wield rifles". Do all of these instances have the handle end pointed at the enemy, or do a few of them have the heel pointed at the enemy? 7. One of my favorite firearms to base a spellcasting implement on is a sawed off shotgun. At the moment, I'm still undecided on how a sawed off staff should be different from a typical staff besides it now being rod-sized. Think you could come up with an explanation of what the sawed off part would have been for?

Earth Seraph Edna

Your 2022 article on the overlords, and its reprised version in Chronicles of Eberron, are somewhat vague on maximum extent of an overlord's geographical reach. How far can the reach of a "regular" overlord (i.e. not as powerful as Dral Khatuur, Ran Iishiv, Sakinnirot, or Surash Ka, and likely represented in the Lords of Dust) extend? Is covering half of a continent possible, or is it limited to an area roughly the size of one of the Five Nations? Are the overlords' fiends and knowledgeable mortal cultists aware of such geographical limitations, or do they optimistically believe that their patron na-vakhti can extend their influence over the entire world once released?

Eric Smith

I know we are only supposed to ask one question but I thought of another: What did Breland do with Cyran POWs during the war? Could you have a young Cyran soldier captured in the first 4-6 years of the war and then imprisoned for most of it or did they do prisoner exchanges?

Jesse Williams

1.I am reading through your old articles and I saw one that mentioned the Hammerfest Dwarves in the Demon Wastes. They sound very fascinating, would you ever elaborate on them like you did with some of the various gnome societies? 2. So Sibrys is the source of arcane magic, Eberron is called out as the source of primal magic, is Khyber the source of a type of magic? how does khyberian magic different from the others? 3. Is the Umbra a force of evil? what is the Umbragen belief on what happens when their soul joins the Umbra? 4. is there any reason for a non-kalashtar to follow the path of light opposed to other faiths? or is the path of light just a philosophy? 5. I see a lot of fans in there games running a campaign where a brand new dragonmark emerges and it got me wondering, if you had to create a brand new dragonmark, what ideas would you have? 6. I like Kalashtars but I'm a bit intimidated by how their behavior and body language is "strange and alien". what tips would you give on roleplaying one?

Joe Burgos

Hi! New Patreon, long time Eberron fan: Im planning on using Eberron for my group's next Spelljammer campaign, any tips for adapting the Rock of Bral to Eberron?

Chris

I recently finished my first big adventure as an Eberron DM, culminating in the party saving the missing Noldrun Dwarves who were being controlled by a BBEG mindflayer who called itself the Harbinger of Dyrrn. After the session I started to ask myself how the economy would change now that the Noldrun (who I flavored as Duergar due to their prolonged corruption) has access to the largest supply of Khyber shards in Khorvaire? Maybe ally them with the Aurum, rather than House Kundarak, to give the Dragonmarked houses a literal run for their money? I would love to hear your ideas on how some of that would play out.

dirDav3

There's still a lot of Lhazaar islands without lore. Beyond the named Principalities we have, I wondered if you ever had ideas or drafts for Principalities, princes, fleets, etc that were never published? Or do you imagine most of the islands without named Principalities are controlled by one of the big boys?

Inquisitor Thomas

So in the original 3e Setting book for Eberron Atur is described as a bit of a party city with lots of Bordellos and taverns, how true is this in your modern conception of Eberron and the Blood of Vol? Is the party nature of the city an offshoot of the Seekers trying to enjoy their mortal lives to the fullest, is it a Las Vegas situation where Tourism is main source of income because the environment is so hostile to other sources of revenue, or is this a vestige of when the Blood of Vol and Emerald Claw were treated as interchangeable terms, and thus Atur was made to be seedy and decadent?

Will Buck

Would it be possible to get a patreon preview of Shaarat Kol and Kethelrax the Cunning? I'm working on a one-shot with pre-made characters, and I'd love some additional ideas I could weave in to the kobold player character. Thank you!

BonesBoy

So I've been working on idea of Eberron meet Stardew Valley kind of game, which makes me wonder about what kind of magic has been developed to help with farming, and how the Dragonmarked houses might be involved.

Caelan Scott

What is the Ashbound sects' relationship with fey? Are they opposed to them because they are extraplanar and thus unnatural to the world, or do they take it on a case-by-case basis? Would they be positive toward the Forest Queen and negative towards the Mother of Invention?

Jarrod Taylor

A few small related questions: On the Eberron side of things, manifest zones are quantifiable, measurable, and dependable. Is the same true for the denizens of the planes? Do the angels of Syrania kick most of their radiant idols down a 300 pit that they know leads to Sharn? Does the Lady in Shadow bank upon a chamber in Whitestone opening into the monarch of Karrnath's privy midden? If the planar side of manifest zones are just as reliable, how have immortals and extraplanar denizens responded to the rifts in their worlds caused by the Mourning?

Kevin Macku

Question on the Blood of Vol! Does the BoV have any saints? Or something like saints---living practitioners canonized in the faith as exemplary. I understand this is a bit of a curiosity because of the Divinity Within, prayer to an outside figure seems like a self-contradiction, but as Divine Magic (assumedly fueled by the Divinity Within) has been witnessed by Seekers, have any rose to such fame/power that they are "canonized" and held up as examples of the Divinity Within made manifest, even after their death?

Peter S.

Dhakaani shelters. Mentioned both in rise from the last war and exploring Eberron as organizing for getting back into action after thousands year. Are their activities already visible, or known perhaps in Darguun or somewhere else?

Spike Hemphill

In Dragons of Eberron it says there were incursions from Risia and Fernia that cause environmental changes on Argonnessen. What were these incursions? Risia and Fernia don't seem like planes that would invade the material world. We're they cause by powerful manifest zones?

Spike Hemphill

I think the religions in Eberron are best in DND.Any advice how to create just as compelling religions in homebrew worlds?

The Indie Fox

Given Sardorians were from another version of Eberron, where there was still 13 moons, and they saw Dal Quor intact, what would there perspective be on Eberron's Quori? Would their versions be different since the collective subconscious would be very different in a psionic-dominated world? Would they have records for how turnings of the age actively affected Quori? What would they think of Kalashtar?

Jamie Bernstein

The ECG notes that Xen'drik has (or had) cultures of giants and drow who worshipped the Silver Flame. Do you have any thoughts on what that might look like compared to other groups such as the Ghaash'kala and CotSF? I assume they'd be geared towards fighting the influences of the Spinner and Sakinnirot in some way?

Earth Seraph Edna

In your "Spelljammer in Eberron" article, how populous and advanced do you expect the greatest of the lunar empires to be? Do you expect the largest of the lunar empires to have exceeded Breland in terms of population? Do you expect the most advanced of the lunar empires to have exceeded Aerenal in terms of magical advancement? Or do you expect the lunar empires to lag behind in these respects, due to lacking key assets such as the dragonmarked and the Undying Court?

hyperewok1

What ground mounts are common in Khorvaire, besides horses and Talenta dinosaurs?

Dan Smith

In the past you've mentioned that Forge of War doesn't really align with your vision of the Last War. After rereading the article on the Argonth I was wondering in a general sense what were the major phases/developments in military doctrine during the Last War? The presence of flying fortresses and warforged colossi infers that there was a phase where "super-weapons" that acted as displays of power were considered more important, while the growing presence of wandslingers implies a shift towards mobile squad based tactics in modern times.

Parker Wimberly

Will we learn more about Kech Nasaar in frontiers?

Vani Srinivasan

Is there anything about Syrkarn (or Sarlona in general tbh) that you wish the canon had done more justice to? Alternatively, what's your favourite thing about that part of the setting?

Earth Seraph Edna

Do immortals of opposing planes have a natural rivalry with one another, in the event that they come into contact? Would a Fernian angel feel a compulsion to provide warmth to the frozen immortals of Risia, if the Fernian angel somehow ended up in the Plain of Ice (e.g. summoning and other forms of conjuration)?

James McConnell IV

Many of the things you've written about NPCs in Eberron are far more interesting than anything that could be put down in a stat block. When you run games with powerful but not godlike npcs how do you show their influence and power? And alternatively, how do you limit their influence and power without taking away from the fantasy of the character?

Joana

Hello Keith! Keith is there any sea where the Locathah aren't subjugated, but have a thriving civilization? Asking this because a player gave me the prompt of a PC rich Locathah wanting to explore the surface Khorvaire.

DnDisForTheHomies

Hello Keith Baker! I have a question about Greywall, which I can't wait to see in a blog post or in your new upcoming book that actually covers the area! My question is about Xor'chylic, what does he bring to the table when it comes to Greywall/Droaam besides being a very brutal warlord? Is he helping the sisters in making psionic warriors, and adding to the whole wide monster concept that is delved into in Exploring Eberron? Or if you have any interesting information you have on him. Thank you so much for you time!

Rodrigo Kuerten

Hello, Keith! In retrospect, what would you to the Eberron canon? (like Dragonborn were added in 4E to Q'barra). Blood hunters? Haregons? Firbolgs? Thank you for your time!

Michael Hughes

Hi Keith! I very recently subscribed to the Patreon since Ebberron has always seemed like such an interesting setting! I've got all the 5e books, and I see that there are a lot of articles on your website, and there's the Patreon stuff as well! My question is, what is a good starting point for someone getting into Ebberron? I'm planning on eventually running a game in it, so I figured starting with the books made sense.

Matthew Johnson

You often suggest questions for new players starting a campaign to spark some character motivation. "Why do you owe/need 200gp?" "What is something you regret?" What would you suggest a good prompt would be for a campaign set in the Principalities?

EllieSF

Is there any way to reverse Mabaran Corruption? At least the effect it has on personality? I was thinking something with Irian magic, likely something that the Undying Court may have learned of and hasn't shared with the world.

Jarrah James

Probably a bit late to the party, but... What can you tell me about Fort Orcbone? Five Nations states it has a popualtion of 450 - is that ONLY soldiers, or does the fort have civilians that live in or around the walls as well? How suspicious would the soldiers be of visitors?