Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Poll

Patron Poll: A New Frontier?

  • FRONTIERS OF EBERRON: I continue to develop Threshold for Eberron and D&D 172
  • A NEW FRONTIER: I use the core ideas of Threshold as the foundation for a new setting. 217
  • 2023-01-25
  • —2023-02-15
  • 389 votes
{'title': 'Patron Poll: A New Frontier? ', 'choices': [{'text': 'FRONTIERS OF EBERRON: I continue to develop Threshold for Eberron and D&D', 'votes': 172}, {'text': 'A NEW FRONTIER: I use the core ideas of Threshold as the foundation for a new setting.', 'votes': 217}], 'closes_at': datetime.datetime(2023, 2, 15, 20, 18, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'created_at': datetime.datetime(2023, 1, 25, 20, 13, 53, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'description': None, 'allow_multiple': False, 'total_votes': 389}

Content

I’m facing a difficult decision, and I’d like to get your opinion on it.

I love Eberron. There are many corners of the setting I've yet to explore and many details I’ve imagined that I’ve yet to share. But the simple fact is that it’s not mine. Eberron is wholly owned by Wizards of the Coast, and that limits what I can do with it. If I make a sourcebook or adventure, it has to be sold on the DM’s Guild, with everything that entails. I can’t write a new Eberron novel. Twogether Studios makes card games, but I can’t create a card game for Eberron. And, of course, I can’t create Eberron content for any system other than D&D. Beyond this, none of us know what is going to happen with Hasbro and WotC over the next year. What if they decide to stop allowing community-created Eberron content? Eberron is my best-known creation and D&D is currently the most widespread system, but there are limits and risks to putting all of my creative energy into developing content I don’t actually own.

Over the last three years I’ve been working on Frontiers of Eberron: Threshold. This adds a new layer to the setting—wandslingers and westerns—as well as creating new locations and adding details to places largely undeveloped in canon. Which raises the question: does it need to be in Eberron? Threshold is a town that doesn’t exist in canon Eberron, mining a resource that doesn’t exist in canon Eberron, next to a trade road that canonically is in a different location, using wandslinging rules that aren’t part of core D&D. It’s intentionally beyond the parts of the setting that have been well defined. The core concept is that it’s set on the border between a nation shaped by wide magic and a nation shaped by wide monster. But given that it’s largely adding more to Eberron canon than it’s drawing on… does it need to be in Eberron?

If I decide to take Frontiers in a new direction, it won’t just be Eberron with the names changed. I love creating worlds, and if I do this I’m going to create something new. It would explore some of the same themes as Eberron, but it will also explore cultures, concepts, and themes that don’t exist in Eberron. It would draw on other ideas that I’ve been working over the last few years that were never tied to Eberron. It would still focus on a frontier between industry and mystery, between magic and monsters. It would still be Threshold. But it wouldn’t be Eberron.

If I do this, it doesn’t mean that I’ll be abandoning Eberron. I’d still answer questions and write iFAQs, and I'd want to share outtakes from Frontiers that wouldn’t translate to a new setting. But I’ll be doing less Eberron because I’ll be devoting my creative energy toward creating the new frontier. However, it also means that you’ll be along for the ride as I create that new world, and get to see pieces of it as it comes together.

So. You are all my patrons. What do YOU want to see? Would you prefer that I remain focused on Eberron, even if that means it’s restricted to DM’s Guild and Dungeons & Dragons? Or are you interested in seeing what I will do with a new Frontier? Again, I’m not going to be bound by the results of this poll—but knowing your gut reaction to this idea is important to me.

As always, thanks for your support!

Files

Comments

michael brooks

I'm lucky enough that my group of friends play both 5e and pathfinder. I love Eberron, and I really loved the books you wrote. I am currently considering the move from 5e to pathfinder, and all that that entails. I can't stay with 5e and not be disappointed in myself because I know I can make the move. I understand that some can't, and I respect that. I also respect that you have to do what is best for you. If you keep releasing content on dms guild, I'll still be there looking at it and seeing if it's something I'm interested in.If you release content somewhere else, ill look into it as well. All I can say is do whats best for you, what ever you decide, I support you, and I know there are others here who feel the same.

Beoric

I think it depends on how core Threshold would be to the new setting. I suspect there are a lot of people who follow you specifically for Eberron content. I know I have a lot invested in Eberron, and am unlikely to make a switch, although I will probably be thinking hard about how to convert you non-Eberron content to Eberron. On the one hand, this gives you a lot more reach if you publish Threshold for Eberron. On the other hand, if you do so you may lose the ability to incorporate it into the new setting. I guess the question is, will you be done with Threshold after Frontiers comes out? Or do you intend to keep building on it? Another issue is the existing relationship between Threshold and WotC's IP. How much of your Threshold content has already been published on DMGuild in one form or another (particularly cultural descriptions), and does that prevent you from using it? How dependent is Threshold on existing WotC IP? You probably lose the speaking stone station and the lightning rail, unless you go modern or full steampunk. I would be happy with a non-Eberron Threshold that was more or less convertible, but I'm actually wondering whether it would be possible to safely create such a thing. You might need some legal advice. In light of all of that, I'm not voting, or maybe I'm voting for both. I suspect in the end legal and practical constraints may have to outweigh the preferences of your fans.

Orna

Just wanted to add to this that I'm glad you're giving us the better part of a month to decide. It feels like this has been an intense month of many quick decisions by everyone, and I'm glad you're giving this time to breathe.

Nathan P Rogers-Madsen

Apologies if something like this has already been covered up above. I need more information to make an informed decision: from DND to where? I personally don't like DND mechanics much at all. But DND brings with it the best quality of all currency: it's fungible. I can sit down at most any table and pick up the game right there. I don't have to explain how the game works, and I don't have it explained to me. If I tell my relatives that I'm going to play DND, then they have a crude enough approximation what's going on. And Netflix has yet to produce a throwback show where a bunch of middle-America pre-teens sit around playing Godbound. I will lose that if I go away from DND, and that's a huge loss. I play RPGs for the social aspects, not for the intricate rules set (I understand some players ride-or-die on these, and that's just fine). And, of course, I can sate myself on Dark Sun to remain within the robust WoTC social economy -which despite any of our wishes- isn't going anywhere. DND won't be near as good with an unsupported Eberron, but also it's had a good long run with plenty Baker artifacts that I can refer to forever. And I can keep exploring that Eberron all the way to the horizon and back. So the real question here is from DND to what? That info matters. If it's like FATE or Shadowrun Anarchy, then sign me up! Where you go I will follow. But if it's like HERO System or Shadowrun Sixth World, then it would be very, very hard for me to follow. I hope the input helps. AND, of course, blessings on the journey... wherever it takes you. I don't envy your decision. You're one-of-a-kind, and we are fortunate to have you among us.

Steve Kunec

I already use Eberron with a different rules system. So, it’s never been about D&D. I love Eberron. But I’ll adapt what I need to…

Jens L

Mechanically I have very loose ties to DnD. I usually do use DnD rules, but out of convenience, not because I think there are no (potentially better) alternatives. I also don't really like the DMsGuild limitations as a customer. I would like to see Eberron Kickstarters and high quality printed books. I will never get that with the current rules. On the other hand, I do love the Eberron Setting, and I would love to get more content for it. Overall, I have strongly mixed feelings about this. I completely understand the desire to work outside of the constraints of the DMsGuild, and there is a good chance that whatever new setting is created, is just as awesome. But I do want more Eberron content... I would suggest you try something new, keep it loosely compatible with Eberron lore, and see how it goes.

Syltorian

Dear Keith: this is, as others have stated, a very difficult question. Not because of my own preferences: the answer is all too clear on that level. I am here because of Eberron, and, what with the pressures of life and work, I do not have the time or energy to become invested in a new setting, and leave all my beloved characters behind. I am also becoming, emotionally, a grognard, refusing to let go of something I know and love. I want support for Eberron to continue. Whether or not Threshold specifically is a part of it is less important, so long as Eberron does get some support, and support by you, Keith, not by people less invested in the world: even if there is less Eberron material, so long as there is any I will support you here on Patreon. But that is, I am freely admitting, selfish. I am aware that what is best for me is not necessarily best for you, and that the question does not have the same importance for me as it does for you. For me, it’s a question of convenience and pleasure: it is not existential, and does not influence my career. I will not move to a new setting for the reasons described above (and, I’ll admit, I am not a big fan of Westerns in particular), but I am only one person. If that is somehow more important than I myself believe, then WotC should be aware that the only items I have bought from them since they stopped 3.5 material is Eberron material, and that if Eberron is no longer supported, I’ll cut my final ties. While I will have regrets for moving on from you, Keith, I have none in doing so from WotC, small as that consolation might be. Whatever option you go with, I will, of course, respect it, and wish you nothing but the best: again, as others have said, do what is best for you, and thanks for sounding us out.

Jesse Williams

I 100% support your move. It's terrible to wonder if one day one of your biggest works just becomes locked away. Also, Eberron started as a way to explore ideas that were absent from normal D&D settings, and now Eberron is so big I think it'd be down right fascinating to see what if you made a world that goes over the things you couldn't do with Eberron! I imagine this is like a family discussing if they should have another kid. In my opinion I think we need more interesting settings, and I'd LOVE to see what you do with your second setting, taking all you've learned and starting again. It'd be really fun!

Jan Bernd ten Berg

I love Eberron. It renewed my love for D&D after spending years in the World of Darkness, Deadlands, and other settings. I really think your setting is the best addition to D&D since Planescape and I would've stopped DMing 5E some time ago if not for the inspiration Eberron gave me. And now I'm more than willing to jump ship with the lot of you. Maybe I'll spend some time in the setting of Numenera, maybe I'll got back to Mage the Ascension. But if you develop something new, I'll buy it, read it, and maybe play/GM it. So, go for it Keith!

PT MacKim

Finally voted, but it’s kind of a “both and” vote in this way: the setting, politics and NPC’s of Threshold really feel like part of Eberron and could make their way into a minor dmsguild publication or something like that to become “kanon.” The way you’re telling these stories, the overall dynamics of the underlying situation, and all the creative ways you’re thinking about how to run these games really seem to push well beyond what D&D is designed to do, so I could see some kind of system agnostic publication or something built in an existing system closer to your style of storytelling, maybe something along the lines of “forged in the dark?” Or it could be even more subversive if you have in mind your own rules-light system that could be easily adapted to any setting by a GM in a home game where copyright is not an issue…

Jeff H

I love Eberron. It's my main D&D setting. I feel fairly confident that this OGL situation will resolve itself. I know this is an unpopular opinion right now, but honestly, I'm not interested in another setting (or another game to be honest), I don't know that I would stick around without the Eberron content.

Farouche

Yes I'd support a new setting! Eberron is amazing, I'm confident the content quality won't be any lower with another universe you/Keith can come up with (and with more liberty to do so at that). Also IMHO as much as Eberron has shed its skin over the years, maybe it's nice to have an opportunity to start afresh with something else; I hope there will be an opportunity for more minority contributors to counsel or help out with the project to have a better chance of "getting things right" from the get go on topics that reflect sensitive real life issues (I know it's too early to talk about contributors, but...). Anyway, you'll have my support, even if that means a little less Eberron stuff here than before.

Matt Brady

I love Eberron because of what you've put into it. Whatever you do, so long as it supports Keith Baker the creator, is the right choice. The setting doesn't change just because it's no longer getting new stuff, and anything new either in a new setting or this setting is a blessing

Chris A. Barney

I feel the tension! And while I personally would love to see more content from you fleshing out Eberron I would support your choice to start something completely new. And if WotC does go more dark side and clamp down on user-generated content then please save yourself and GTFO :)

Bicarb

I can't wait to see what setting & system that you put this out for given all the new systems in the process of actually forking off from the shattered OGL

Jasmino

I'd say release it as an Eberron book. Then, you can start working on a new setting and a new book ;)

Sly Flourish

Hi Keith! I completely understand you wanting better control over your own worlds and your own destiny. I will absolutely support your path towards your own independent lands. 100%

Tyler Dickey

Eberron is my favorite setting ever and has been anchoring me in 5e throughout the past few months as I've grown frustrated with 5e. Eberron is the first fantasy setting that I felt was made for ME, which I have loved. IMO it's the best setting for 5e, and honestly better than many other settings from other systems. All of that being said, every book has its ending. I would absolutely love to see you build a new world that is agnostic of any system. This would allow people from any system to play in the world and not have to use fan created conversions. I say use Threshold as a chance to explore a new frontier and begin the chronicles of a new world. I can't wait to see what you come up with in this next chapter!

Micah Davis

I voted for New Frontier and stand by it - From my perspective, I'm more interested in your blog as an avenue to watch you world build than Eberron specifically (though I really like Eberron!). I bought your last DM's guild outing but honestly don't see myself able to support DM's guild products going forward, so from a purely selfish perspective I'd prefer it if you made something outside D&D. I'll likely stick around as a patron either way, but I know also that Eberron will probably always be your biggest product so it's a difficult choice for you personally.

Michael Z Hawkins

So I love Keith and his work, and when I saw this I literally joined the Patreon just so I could comment. I also posted this on Enworld, but I really wanted to do it here as well. I'm gutted by this, and when the whole OGL debacle came up, literally my first thought was, "Oh no, what's going to happen to Eberron?" I started playing D&D at the end of 2nd Edition, and I really enjoyed it. 3rd Edition came out, and it was even more fun. But it wasn't until Eberron came out that I truly began to love D&D. It inspired every game I ran, whether it was set in Eberron (most were) or not. There's no setting I'd rather play in, and no creator I so whole-heartedly support as Keith Baker. I say this so that people know just what a statement it is when I say that I want to see what new thing Keith can create. Eberron will always be there, and I can always be inspired by and adapt what comes next into my own games at home. But I enjoy Keith's creativity and thoughtfulness too much to have it shackled to the dismal lich WotC has become. I was on board when he created Phoenix: Dawn Command and Gloom, and I'll be on board with whatever he does next.

GhostOfEternalTime

I have barely ever posted here, but I feel obligated to for this. I really hope you stick to having it be in Eberron, just because I fear that if you don't Eberron will wind up cast aside and forgotten. I understand completely wanting more creative control over your products.I'm just really scared that Eberron will be left behind like Greyhawk has been--forgotten in favor of the new hot thing. Or worse, twisted by WOTC into something I don't recognize. I'm in the minority here, and I doubt writing this up will do anything, but I just wanted to get my words out.

Krisky

Hey Keith, I just joined your Patreon, and absolutely love Eberron, both as a setting for my campaigns and as a world to explore. I just wanted to say that regardless of what you do, I plan to support it.

Brandon Fisher

Subscribed so I could vote on this poll. (Had been evening to for awhile) Voting to continue developing for Eberron. Purely for the selfish reason of wanting more Eberron content. In the end do what you think is best for you, but I hope that includes a future for Eberron content.

Sims

Personally, I love Eberron. It's such a great setting. I do understand why you would consider another avenue, but I hope Eberron stays

Thomas Brøgger

I really hope you continue doing the Threshold project in Eberron. It would be so sad if Chronicles was your last Eberron publication. I do understand that making a new setting would be a good thing for you going forward, I just honestly don’t know if I would be interested.

Joshua Cender

Hey Keith, Is there any way to do both books? I read about your idea of the threshold between the industrialized world and the feyspires at the edge of dreams. I LOVE IT, and I'm so excited to explore that new world. That said, Threshold in Eberron may be my most anticipated RPG book ever. I've been running for months in "Threshold" based off your shared tidbits, and my players and I have never had more fun in a D&D campaign.

CJ's Writing Corner

Huge fan of you over the years and the content you've produced. The 4e Ebberon source guide is actually the first DND book I ever owned - barring even a player's handbook, monster manual, or DMG. I didn't understand the rules but I understood that the world I was being introduced to was something special, and I'll always hold it with me. Saw the discussion today on the polling about where content production was going in the future, and wanted an excuse to finally support one of my favorite creator. I wonder if it would be worth it to release Frontiers as a new setting - and put out some sort of supplemental on how to adapt it to Ebberon? Sort of a half-measure, that would allow for the book to be a jumping off point for new adventures, while still fulfilling the initial premise behind it. 

hyperewok1

To be honest in a non-demanding way, it would be a disappointment if it was changed to another setting (though I would greatly sympathize the amount of extra work to rewrite such). I can only speak for myself, but I'm interested in the new or expanded lore of Eberron more than mechanics or other advice portraying western themes. At risk of speaking out of my lane as someone who doesn't, well, write D&D specific content in hopes of paying my bills, there's a lot of stuff that's still in flux, and are going to inevitably still be in flux in the coming months. I absolutely sympathize with the dilemma and do think it's worth fair consideration of what to do for future projects. But, assuming that Frontiers is meant to be published within the next several months, I'm not sure what's actually changed. (And boy do I sure hope WOTC doesn't suddenly change its DMs Guild rates or policies, but it seems -probable- they won't at this point of the immediate future.) So yeah, it's absolutely a valid consideration for future projects, and I'd certainly be curious about something that's designed specifically from the ground up as A New Keith Baker RPG Setting (TM), but I think that this started as an Eberron project and should finish as one.

A. R. DiZinno

Make Frontiers your own thing. If we're still hell bent on playing our versions of Eberron, we can always jam it back in :) I myself am looking forward to attempting a version using Savage Worlds. Possibly a Savage Rifts/Eberron mashup of some sort.

Paul D. Wright

Hello, Keith. The Eberron setting has been my favorite thing about this hobby since it was introduced. I have run more campaigns than I can easily count in the setting, and I'm running one now. I have been following the ongoing OGL controversy, but hadn't stopped to think how it's impacting you, and I'm sorry to see that Hasbro/WotC has put you in such a predicament. I am part of a very small community who loved 4E. My group continued playing the game after WotC rolled out 5E and continued paying a monthly D&D Insider subscription through the end of 2019, even though there hadn't been any new 4E content since 2014. Even when WotC deleted all the wonderful 4E discussion and character-building forums. Until WotC pulled the rug out from under us by shutting down D&D Insider with absolutely no warning. All our characters and customized monsters were gone forever. And we no longer had access to any of the 4E Dragon and Dungeon articles, many of them written by you. And if they'd given us even a day of warning, I could have saved all that stuff in PDF form. We decided we'd never forgive them for that level of indifference to us as people. And that we wouldn't just start playing 5E as they hoped. We switched to PF2E, in no small part because WotC had kicked Paizo to the curb with how they handled the rollout of 4E. So none of the new controversy comes as a surprise to me. I know there are good people at WotC, but unfortunately it is also evident that they don't have enough influence on the way WotC does things. When we switched to PF2E, it only took me a few minutes to realize that there was no reason I couldn't set my game in Eberron. The only inconvenience is coming up with stat blocks for creatures that are Eberron-specific, but it is well worth it to continue using my favorite setting. I am voting for a New Frontier, but know that I will continue supporting you regardless of what you decide. I am just sorry to see what a difficult spot they've put you in.

Ironchestnut .

Wotc attempting to changing the OGL has been a massive blow to the TTRPG community as a whole, and unfortunately I was unable to buy a copy of Chronicle of Eberron before this whole deniable. Now I can't bring myself to buy it because I don't wish to support Wotc financially. I can't say I was shocked to see this announcement. I've been a big fan of Eberron ever since I first started TTRPGs and it has been a major influence on my own expressions of the fantasy genre. I won't pretend if you were to pick Pathfinder 2e as your system of choice, I'd be ecstatic. But whatever Thronehold ends up becoming, I know I'm going be supporting you and your work.

Ryan Nestor

Keith, no matter who OWNS Eberron, those who love it will always know who it belongs to. Ultimately, my hope lies in WoTC realizing their mistakes and pushing back against Ha$bro and supporting this incredible community. If that does not happen, it could open up a whole new world of opensource RPGs where someone of your immense talents and imagination will continue to thrive.

Creative Horror

While it is ultimately your decision, I appreciate you putting this out there for us to consider. I've been anticipating this particular spin of Eberron for awhile, and so much so that I've already got my own group of wand-slinging ne'er-do-wells slowly making their way toward Threshold in anticipation (currently up to some shenanigans in Ardev). Just because of that anticipation, and for how much I love the setting, my vote is to keep on course with having it in Eberron, but I'll support it no matter where it goes.

GM MK

There are some great comments on here already. I want to support whatever you decide, but I’ll admit I love Eberron so much that it may be hard to switch. That said I would definitely still support you and the product. Here’s a lousy compromise - could the material be published as a stand alone product, with an Eberron conversion published after? This is obviously significantly more work and debatably less payoff, but it’s one idea I haven’t seen shared here yet.

Thursday Garreau

I think you should follow your heart. Threshold has been in the works for a long while, and it would be really nice if your 'farewell' to Eberron is a look at Droaam, one of the nations in the world most emblematic of what makes the setting different. I'd love that. At the same time, if your interest and your gut are pushing you to something new, then I say do that! We're all here because we're obsessed with one world you've made; I'm absolutely not opposed to seeing another out of your brain. EDIT: Thinking on it more, I think something new from you that isn't shackled to a ruleset and a faceless corporation is *tremendously* exciting, especially if it can be a more considered take on a Fantasy Western. It gets my vote - but there's no shame in sticking by Eberron, either.

Richard Terry

wow! does this change the voting on things?!

Markus Plate

I would love to see more Eberron content (Frontiers) for 5e. 2024/OneDnD might be a gamechanger though, depends on their license.

Ivan Flis

I completely understand your doubts and the feeling of uncertainty over a company like WotC owning your world and the IP at the core of your own business. I've been solely playing Eberron in DnD since the setting was published, and I absolutely love it, and what you have done with it on your own in the last couple of years. And even though it really saddens me that there might not be as regular Eberron content as I'd wish, I completely understand your reasoning behind it. I'm sorry you're even put into the spot where you have to consider something like this. Thanks for all the Eberron, canon and kanon alike, it was really appreciated, enjoyed, remixed, and played and will still be.

Sean Martin

After the Hadozee fiasco, I made the decision to move my Eberron games over to Savage Worlds. I've been slowly moving away from D&D for a while now, and this OGL debacle has been the nail in the coffin. Eberron is an amazing setting. But people who are tired of D&D, whether that means the game or the company behind the game, can play in the setting with whatever system they would like at their own tables. In the same way, anyone who still wants to play 5e Eberron but likes the ideas that you're fleshing out with Threshold, can homebrew rules to port them into their D&D games if you choose to go the route of building your own system for them. You can even publish articles here to help people with that, similar to how you gave suggestions for adding Spelljammer elements to Eberron. That's the beautiful thing about this hobby that the corporate suits behind this OGL thing don't seem to understand. The only limits to TTRPGs, whether mechanically or lore-wise, are your imagination. So I say, build something new that is entirely yours. How people choose to interact with it is their choice, but you deserve to have complete ownership of your own ideas. Regardless of your decision, I'm excited to see what's next.

Alexander Eldritch

Keith, I’ll admit I voted before reading the post. I voted for continuing to make Threshold for Eberron. I’ve always liked the idea that you were carving out an unknown section of the world and as you said “adding more to the canon than [you] were using existing canon.” But after reading your post, I’m honestly not so sure about my vote. I got a strong sense of your dilemma as I read the post and it made me reevaluate things. I really would like Threshold to be part of Eberron. That was what made me original become a patron. But I’ve maintained my patronage for the better part of a year now not because of an Eberronian Threshold, but because I’ve come to have a deeper respect for you and your worldbuilding. So for you to want to create something new is exciting to me and I will support it. I don’t regret my answer to the poll, but I also am not 100% certain if that is really my final answer. It’s tough.

Jonathan Franke

Now that WotC has walked so much back, please do not abandon eberron and 5e till you feel like the well is dry

Andrew Gibbons

I would absolutely support a new frontier. I also only have one regular game in my life, which is an Eberron game. So to have my cake and eat it I would port the new frontier back into Eberron (Level Up A5e system).

Jesse Riggins

I voted to keep Frontiers in Eberron, but I can't help but to think I'm being selfish. I totally understand wanting to have creative and legal control over your own work, but I'm already so invested in Eberron that I don't think I could follow in a switch over to a different setting. At the same time, though, I don't want our love of Eberron to hold you back from making something new. If you do end up creating a new setting, I would of course love to see it; it's just that I would *rather* explore new areas of Eberron instead. A couple of people mentioned creating an Eberron conversion for whatever new world is created for Threshold. I'm not sure how practical this would be, but I think this would be a good way to bridge the gap and make this new project more "useful" to those of us still running games in Eberron. This conversion doesn't need to be incredibly in depth, but a series of blog posts similar to "IFAQ: Strixhaven in Eberron?" would at least make it feel less like Eberron is being left behind.

Thomas Basgil

I love Eberron. Selfishly, I want to keep Frontiers in Eberron. However, I'm someone who regularly creates things for clients. Things I no longer own as soon as they pay. I get wanting to own something for myself, wanting to be able to do with it what I will. I'll support you either way. This gaming license fiasco has significantly soured me on WotC (along with their continued fails at incorporating diversity). I think it's time you create something else that you own completely. Whatever you decide, I'll still be here.

Will Buck

If this poll (or a future poll) asked something like, “Would you stick around as a patron if I began work on a new campaign setting completely separate from D&D and WotC,” I would answer with an emphatic “yes”. No question. I love Eberron but would love to see what you would create with a blank slate, even if it meant you spent less time on Eberron. That said, I voted for “Frontiers of Eberron.” I’ve been excited for this book for a long time, and I would be disappointed to see it get significantly rewritten/rearranged for a new setting I have no anchor into (yet).

Xavier Parra Pérez

I would prefer new frontiers to be developed for Eberron. But as long as the new setting includes details on how to adapt it to Eberron it's ok for me. What's more, I understand the need to make your own setting altogether in this context.

Jens L

After having thought about for a few days I went from 'on the fence' to 'strongly in favor of a new IP'. Eberron doesn't go anywhere, and there is enough material out there to fill lifetimes of adventures. I only ever used a fraction of the available material in my games yet and I am already mixing and matching other campaign settings with Eberron. There is no reason I could not adapt cool ideas from a new setting to Eberron as well, should I choose to stay with Eberron. If you decide to build your own setting, I am on board.

Jessie Harris

If you release Frontiers setting agnostic, would you release the Wandslingers rules for 5e in a different place? Or would those be abandoned