Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Greetings Patrons!

I don't know how it went for you, but January was a LOT. In addition to the adventure seen above and the Siberspace finale, I've had to ask some hard questions about the future of Threshold and what I'm doing next. I appreciate all of you who've shared thoughts and voted on the poll, and I will have more to say about that next week. I'll also be doing a January Roundup post in the next few days. 

As we've seen, I will not be able to answer every question; simple questions are the best questions. If I can answer a question in five minutes here, I'll probably answer it. If it would take significant research or an hour of work to answer a question, I probably can't. Feel free to ask questions that didn't get answered in a previous month—there are always some good ones I can't get to!—just know that I won't be able to get to them all. In addition, I will only answer one question per patron. You can ASK more than one, because one may be easier for me to answer than another, but I'll only answer one.

Thank you for your support!

Files

Comments

Not Mordakhesh

What music do you use (if any) to represent different people and factions when you DM? I use Hans Zimmers the Dark Phoenix theme tune whenever the Dreaming Dark comes up. I’m not a good visual descriptor because I get tongue tied. Music is my way of painting a picture.

House Sivis Echoer Station

Are there any special funeral or mourning traditions through Eberron? I think it was in one of the 3.5 books that the CotSF do cremation, but what about the other religions and regions? Anything out of what we might consider "ordinary"? *Community responses are welcome!*

Patrick Reupert

Is there a relative comparable tradition or herritage to Roma and Sinti in Eberron? Similar to the Vishtanii of Curse of Strahd and Ravenloft

Teettan

Kind of specific, but I'm currently mulling over a fantasy high/strixhaven campaign in Arcanix and was looking through Morgrave Miscellany and noticed that Professor Birra Oak graduated from the School of Seven Silences in the Twilight Court of Thelanis with a Degree in Otherworldly Anthropology. So there is a college, potentially multiple colleges, in Thelanis that people can go to and get degrees? What's the story there?

Jarrah James

What would the attitude of a Thranish Flame worshipper to an Aasimar whose power comes from Syrania? Would they get sent to Rellekor as a planetouched, or possibly be mistaken for a gift from the flame?

gonzolikesmovies

Kathuran is a named location in every published Aerenal map to date, yet in all of my research it has never even been mentioned in a single entry. It's also particularly unique since it doesn't follow any of the usual naming conventions found in other locations across the continent, suggesting that it's either older or newer than the Aereni. Were there original plans for this location that didn't make the cut, and if not, what's your take on this weird spot on the map?

Zachary Butler

Do you think there is an in-world explanation for differing levels of power between different colors of dragons or types of giants? (Like the Ordning)

Thomas Brøgger

In Eberron campaign setting it stats that the city of Vathirond in Breland deals with monsters coming out of the Mournlands. Correct me if I’m wrong but somewhere I think it says that the monsters of mournlands dosn’t attack beyond the mist. How does this work and what threats are Vathirond dealing with after the Last War?

AnotherOne

We know the people of the Dhakaani Empire are generally less religious than later civilizations (because the Uul Dhakaan partially serves a similar function imho) but what about the religions that were present in their society? Do you imagine them to be mostly isolated groups that have very personalized religions or was there some variations of the religions that spread under human occupancy of Khorvaire e.g. the Sovereigns and the Dark Six (but in this particular case probably closer to the Cazhaak tradition)? And do the Kech Dhakaan see "current" religions as perversions (if they knew them before) or simply superstition and/or as weird quirks of these "new" cultures? I don't remember having read anything about that...

The Indie Fox

For context, currently working on stating out all the Dragons who inspired some tales of the Sovereigns and Six, and along the way hit a bit of a snag with Boldrei. Someone on the Discord suggestion Genie Warlock for the Hearth motif. I've really enjoyed the idea, but I'm curious on your thoughts. What is this Efreeti like? Why did they choose to work with Boldrei? What are they doing now? What name would they have? Things of that nature, I'm very curious how you would handle a patron like that for a Greatwyrm of legend.

Diarmuid McCourt

Do the “moderately evil” liches of Ebberon (Bloodsails and Seekers) need to eat souls, and if so where do they get them?

Spike Hemphill

Is there any chance for spotlight on Lluora Quori and/ or Aurashala Quori this month?

FelixCatus

I would really love to hear your thoughts on Fairhaven in Aundair. What kind of magic and technology is part of the daily life there? What's the culture? Are there any sources of inspiration for it? (I was thinking maybe Belle Epoque Paris?) I've hunted down all the existing material about it that I can find, but there's comparatively little for such a hotspot of magic and (presumably) culture! I'm particularly curious about what the fey presence and influence looks like in such a big city, since most of the content out there concerns fey in the wilderness or interacting with villages. Are there urban fey?

Khadorek

Are there any other groups that study psionics? I know the kalashtar and inspired use it regularly, but does the arcanix have a wing dedicated to it? Maybe the mages of aerenal, or is psionics too far removed from traditional magic

Jamie Gardiner

Likely a longer "question", and therefore totally understandable if you don't answer it, but shy bairns get nowt as they say here! So after running 2 Eberron campaigns, 1 current ongoing, both online. I am setting up to finally run an in person one! Custom table built, anxiety meds taken, 100s of mini's 3d printed, the works. I am just looking on a little GOD CREATOR input on my setup. So the Players will all be from Eberron, in whatever capacity, but at some point in the last 15 years or so (prior to 998yk, so a reasonable variation on world state origins but not *too* much), they were "removed" from the world and placed in the Astral Sea (not putting the who or why here in case any of my players are reading! And if you are, stop reading now!). At some point, they were picked up by Spelljammers and all ended up on the rock of Bral. Their initial raison d'etre is just to get back home (this gives me a platform for them to build the characters, flavour them potentially with different worlds and give them an outright goal to give a good backstory starting point). I'm going for player agency, input and flavour driven so several ways to get back, and then the world opens up once they are there. To deter (or rather deny), them just jumping back on the ship and harvesting Siberys dragonshards for easy income for the next 10 years, I am flavouring the spelljammers crystal rod to have been shattered (as have all others who have tried) by the resonance of the Ring of Siberys, and they will instead be required to make a crystal rod from dragonshards if they wish to get back up (Eberron shards increase a vessels water speed, kyber gives flight equivalent to a Lyrander airship, Siberys grants space travel, combined for a fancy helm etc.). This way the players get a spelljammer arc, an Eberron arc and back to a spelljammer arc with differing potential group patrons, threats, stories, background, home bases etc along the way. With regards to connecting the universes, I loved your "space race" article, I'm just looking to connect the cosmological wheels via an axle as it where, I was thinking of a chirality sort of style where each material plane is on the right and left hand side of the astral sea so to speak but I would love your input and suggestions on my ideas!

Spike Hemphill

Could you help me come up with name for Quori type that inspires envy and jealously?

GhostOfEternalTime

The factotum, a Dungeonscape class, has long felt like one of the most inherently Eberron-y classes ever printed. It's essentially a professional adventurer, a fantasy Indiana Jones. What do you think? Any tips for slotting this into Eberron?

Ohiska

Dragons of Eberron briefly discusses the draconic religion of Thir and their particular approach to the Sovereigns as 'mantles' that one might ascend to claim, before presenting eleven such 'Sovereign paths'. This has lead to confusion regarding whether Thir acknowledges fifteen Sovereign archetypes (Host + Six) or eleven that correspond directly to that paths, blending together particular members of the Host and Six in the latter case. I'm sorry if this has been asked before, but what is your opinion on the matter?

Sam Hakel

I just finished reading The Dreaming Dark trilogy. Do any of the other novels set in Eberron or other media follow up on those characters? I'm wondering to what extent the remaining mysteries about those characters are answered versus being up to our interpretation (though I'll not ask detailed questions here to avoid potentially spoiling people).

Not Mordakhesh

Keith have you ever thought about writing a completely unrelated set of novels set in a world called “Beberron?” For example let’s say there’s a guy called Baine; and he’s trapped in a world called Qual Dor, and we hear if he ever made it back home to Charn the City of Big Thin Buildings (towers for example)

Baron Legi

Rhiavaar in Sarloma had a past full of fae deals with their cousins of Thelanis but seeing they’re a different culture than the nations of Khorvaire what form did fae we’re used to now (Second Son,Forest Queen) look in their Rhiavaaran costumes? How did the values of Rhiavaar change the stories, morals and “happily ever afters” of Thelanis.

Earth Seraph Edna

Whom would you make Wild Beyond the Witchlight's Iggwilv/Tasha in Eberron? Sora Kell, who has been missing anyway? The Lady in Shadow?

Travis

Do you envision a niche for perytons in Eberron? They’re one of my favorite magical beasts. At first glance they could be an Avatar Last Airbender hybrid eagle-stag but then you start reading their description – a rotting human scent, casting a humanoid shadow, proclivity for eating hearts, and rumors of being cursed and shapechanged beings. Very cool monster design. Side note, brand new supporter here. Thanks for all you do Keith! Eberron was my first exposure to D&D campaign setting back in high school and now I’m enjoying collecting all the older sourcebooks I couldn’t pick up at the time.

Spike Hemphill

Industrial magic appears to be favorite concepts for you. Any advice on creating setting with industry as a focus?

Eric

New supporter, long time fan! Question: Considering the importance of understanding the magic in the "war industry", what class/role would you see leading the most successful armies in Eberron? Using 4e D&D terms, would grand leaders look more like Warlords with Arcane/Divine/Psionic advisors OR do you think the "most important person in the army" would be someone like a Valorous Bard (Arcane Leader) with a military advisor? I ask because I enjoy inserting flashbacks to the Last War for my veteran players (think Highlander TV show flashbacks). I did look at your website and only found the "Houses at War" article. I may have missed any other reference. Thank you for darn near 20 years (is it 19 now?) of my all-time favorite RPG setting since I started playing RPGs in 1982.

Jamie Bernstein

Since the end of the Age of Giants, what has been watching over the trapped Lurker in Shadow, and/or battling to keep it sealed? (I'm assuming there were giants doing it beforehand, maybe that's an incorrect assumption)

hyperewok1

What does a warforged's voice sound like in your Eberron?

Will Buck

Could you tell us a little more about Karrnath's Ministry of the Dead? Are the Corpse Collectors a division of this government agency? Have your thoughts on the Corpse Collectors / "the Kind" / Count ir'Omik etc evolved since the Fort Bones dungeon article?

Joseph Meehan

Arms and Armor question. A5E by EN Publishing added a new type of bow - the Composite Bow is 4x the price of a longbow (200 vs 50 gp) and has the Compounding property, which says "You use only your Strength modifier for attack and damage rolls made with this weapon." Is there any particular culture you'd associate this with? Is this the real secret sauce of Thranish militias?

Joe Burgos

Hi Keith, new patreon and really enjoying the contents you have here! Quick question: with the new Keys from the Golden Vault, is there a similar organization in Eberron that operates similarly??

Jeremy Callister

A friend of mine and I have had a debate about a point of mechanics that has interesting lore implications that we can't seem to come to a consensus on. In 5e the Sending spell is capable of reaching out to anyone the sender is familiar with, including across planes. It was suggested this could be used to reach out to the spirit of a dead loved one in Dollurh. Setting aside the issues of time when it comes to the effects of Ennui, I argued about whether or not the spirit of someone you knew is a "creature you are familiar with". Which led to further contemplation. Does the physical form matter, or is the personality more important? On one extreme you have a change in creature type making it impossible to reach out to someone, say you knew someone before they became a vampire but because they are now typed as undead you don't know them anymore and can't contact them. On the other extreme is the shared personas of changelings, where when you try to Send to that person, you get whoever is currently portraying the person right now and not the specific changeling who you met that one time. In the first extreme, dying and becoming a spirit means you can't Send to them, while in the other, as long as their personality is still intact, you could probably reach out to them. I apologize for how confusing my thoughts can be, but I hope the examples can get the gist of the issue through. Do you have specific ideas about what the people of Khorvaire's experience has been with Sending and attempts to reach people in Dollurh? In your Eberron, how do you handle the requirement of "familiarity" when it comes to issues of identity?

Yan-Jie Schnellbach

What are (visually) distinct features or architectural quirks of Zil cities? The reason I'm asking is mostly to figure out how to describe a city like Trolanport or Korranberg to players while giving it an unique feeling that sells it as "Zil".

Felix Shafir

How does the Atur Academy (described on page 103 of the Player's Guide to Eberron) differ from other magical academies in the Five Nations (like Arcanix) because of its unique ties to the City of Night? Is this the kind of magical institution that might teach the esoteric magic of dunomancy?

Inquisitor Thomas

So I was having a discussion with my party regarding our Changeling bard almost being roasted and eaten like a marshmallow by a dragon, and the question has come up: What does Changeling taste like? Like what's the consistency?

Jamie Gardiner

So my players have been deposited in the Astral Sea, picked up on various spelljammers and ended up on the Rock of Bral. What ways would you suggest to get them home to Eberron?

Joey Norwood

Keith! I am a huge fan of your Eberron novels and would love to see you write more of them! Can you offer any personal insights into what the process was for authors (including yourself, of course) to publish Eberron novels between 2005 and 2012? I'm also curious if there is a way to view your novella which coincides with DDO Eberron? I'm not an online gamer, unfortunately, so I've missed that content.

Peter S.

Daelkyr in Khyber vs Daelkyr in Xoriat. Are the Daelkyr sealed in Khyber a manifestation of the same beings in Xoriat, or are them a subset of the xoriat overlords (the ones who invaded Eberron)? What would it be to meet or even fight a Daelkyr in their plane of existence?

Tobias Pundsack

How do you imagine the accents and mannerism of the various nations of Khorvaire and beyond? How would an Aereni Elf sound compared to an Brelish elf? Sound the citizens of the Eldeen Reaches like rednecks? How could the DM distinguish the various nationalities during roleplay?

Simon

Given that 5e srd is now part of the creative commons, is frontiers more likely to be released as a standalone setting with 5e srd mechanics, no mechanics or paetron votes/ the blackflag project. Edit: also what will happen with the overlord(s) of threshold

gonzolikesmovies

I once described Argonth to my friend as an "80-year-old hunk of junk held together by, like everything else in Breland, nothing but duct tape and a prayer." But this led me to wonder: what would the duct tape of Eberron be? Something so accessible, easy to use, and wide in its application that the common artisan adept would use it in anything and everything? Is it a particular House Cannith adhesive, or something similar? Regardless, I think this kind of tool has Breland written all over it lol

Chance

So the Tairnadal Elves of Valenar want to be invaded by a great army such as Karrnath or Darguun so they can recreate as closely as possible the lives of their patron ancestors by fighting against a powerful army as guerilla fighters. How then would they react if the Khunan people of Valenar were to rise in rebellion against them, treating them as foreign occupiers in their land and more or less putting the Tairnadal in the exact opposite position their patron ancestors were in?

WebbRosson

What’s special about the Diresharks? Do the Emerald Claw and Lyrandar provide them with special services that set them apart from other principalities, besides the elemental galleons?

Geoff Berman

I really like the idea of magewrights being able to be sidekicks, how would you go about turning magewright into a sidekick class

Kaci Petri

How is the Dragon Mark of Herding related to the Plane of Risia? What would you like to see happen if all the moons aligned?

Spike Hemphill

If players made it to Dal Quor, how difficult it would be avoid the Dreaming Dark attention?

Máni Þórarinsson

I assume that for Vassals of the Pyrinean Creed, Boldrei and Arawai would be the primary patrons for healers, be they mundane or magical. But what about the Cazhaak faith, or others that revere the Dark Six? I know that for some of the people of Droaam, such as the trolls, healers might not be strictly necessary when it comes to injuries, and illnesses might be viewed as something to tackle alone, but what about things like birth? Surely there would be midwives and the like, right? Which of the Six do you think would be considered the patron, so to speak, of those professions?

Carlton Anderson

IYE, how much can Seekers *really* trust the Oathbound? For example, given his (presumed) Oathbound duty to guide and protect other Seekers, how do Hass Malevanor's loyalties align and/or conflict with Lady Illmarrow's agenda? If he *is* bound by such an obligation to other Seekers *and* to obeying the dictates of the Crimson Covenant, how would/could he resolve a circumstance in which those two oaths conflict? Would he be able to reveal a secret entrusted to him by a fellow Seeker to the Covenant if he had reason to believe that doing so would lead to the Seeker's death?

Lewis Pascoe

How powerful is Bel Shalor? It looks like there are three tiers of overlords. Baseline (30 class levels in 3.5), above-average (40), exceptional (50). -Katashka is baseline going by 30 class levels in Dragon 337. Ashurak and the Spinner of Shadows are implied to be baseline in Chronicles. -Eldrantulku, Rak Tulkhesh, Sul Khatesh, and Tul Oreshka all had 40 class levels in Dragon #337 and would be above-average. -Dral Khatuur is exceptional if she has 50 class levels in 3.5. Chronicles suggests the Lurker in Shadow, Ran Iishiv and Sakinnnirot are exceptional. Where was Bel Shalor on this scale? Was he a baseline overlord who made a power play to get into a better position? Was he above-average, or even exceptional?

Micah Peltier

I realize this is near the end of the month, so I’ll ask it again in a few days if need be, but in your games, what is the limit of using something like a disguise kit on a Warforged? I seem to recall an Envoy Warforged you describe as having a built-in disguise kit to help them (her?) infiltrate and whatnot. Does that basically only work to make a Warforged look like a different Warforged/be unrecognizable as the same Warforged without the disguise? Or do you allow a sufficiently high roll to pass off a Warforged as a human? If so, to what degree of scrutiny does that hold up?

Adam Hardy

Is "crew cart" just the Lightning Rail term for what would in our world be the engine room of a standard locomotive? I'm trying to figure out whether it would be the one at the head of the train.