Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Hi Everyone!

I'm on my way back from MegaCon, where I was playing D&D with Mark Meer, Vince Caso, Elisa Teague and more -- you should be able to see those games on Six Sides of Gaming in the future. This week I'm working on the KHORVAIRE IN THE AGE OF GIANTS Dragonmark, but in the meantime, let's get new questions.

Because my time is limited, I will not be able to answer every question; simple questions are the best questions. If I can answer a question in five minutes here, I'll probably answer it. If it would take significant research or an hour of work to answer a question, I probably can't. Feel free to ask questions that didn't get answered in a previous month—there are always some good ones I can't get to!—just know that I won't be able to get to them all. In addition, I will only answer one question per patron. You can ASK more than one, because one may be easier for me to answer than another, but I'll only answer one.

Also, congratulations to the Gargoyle for their long-awaited victory in the Race of Eight Winds! Just remember that everyone wearing Race colors gets 10% off at the Bazaar of Dura until the end of the week. Because whoever actually wins the Race, the Owl is working for you! 

Thanks for your support!

Files

Comments

Joey Norwood

Hi, Keith! I am a huge fan of your Eberron novels and would love to see you write more of them! Can you offer any personal insights into what the process was for authors (including yourself, of course) to publish Eberron novels between 2005 and 2012?

Andrew Gibbons

Hi Keith, us Hawk fans are understandably trying to come to grips with our recent performance or lack thereof. Do you have any thoughts on what loosing the Race might mean for its supporters and what they could do to "turn things around" next year?

Aidan Dunn

Hi Keith! I seem to remember there being some sort of connection between the Children of Winter and aberrant dragonmarks and I was wondering- what are the official stances of the druidic sects on aberrant dragonmarks? Are they seen as natural, unnatural, or what?

Mariamow

I would like to know what makes the 2nd largest settlements in the Five Nations interesting? (Starilaskur, Passage, Karrlakton and Thaliost)

Carlton Anderson

Who is the Duke of Atur and what do his personal agenda and political aspirations look like, either IYE or if you were writing him up? Given his high rank and position among the nobles of Karrnath, his voice is likely to be an important one in Karranath's current political landscape.

Parker Wimberly

I have a few questions so. 1. In exploring Eberron it talks about how the dominion magebreeds animals to act as transport and offensive ships. What is the Valraean protectorate use for ships? 2. Is there any other undersea culture that has ships similar in use to ships used by those on the surface 3. Does the dominion claim all of the shargons teeth like the islands themselves 4. How big is piracy in between Xen’drik and Khorvaire 5. Is there a difference between air elemental galleons and water elemental galleons 6. Did any of the navy build smaller attack ships that would launch form larger sea ships? If so, where they smaller vessels bound with small elementals? 7. Do you have any information regarding the rite and other doctrines of the three faces of war cult?

dirDav3

Hello! I have 3 questions to choose between. First is last month's question (and the one i'd prefer to be answered if I got to pick) 1) Do you have any thoughts on the Wind Whisperers tradition of death and how it might differ from (or be similar to) the other elven groups? There is an *immense* amount of material you've written about The Grim, Aerenal, and the Tairnadal over the years. Given that The Wind Whisperers were originally cut from the same cloth, i was thinking about their relationship with death and ancestry, which hasn't really been talked about. My thought was that maybe they are the group from Aerenal that decided "you know what? death is a part of life, so live and let die." instead of making every effort to extend their lives/undeath or preserving the souls of those that came before ad nauseam. More free spirited, as is the Lhazaar way. They also don't have Aerenal's or Farlnen's manifest zones (at least not by canon). 2) Does the Draconic Prophecy extend to khyber demiplanes, either in prophesied events or by signs? They're supposed to be separate planes entirely from Eberron but the overlords and daelkyr are trapped there. I'm inclined to say no but then we can't get invaders who think it's their destiny to do so, etc. Of course the hard part would be answering how planar invaders from Khyber would be able to understand the prophecy fragments when very few can. 3) Of the 5 nations, do you see each nation viewing warforged a little differently or is it universal that there's that general unease that's described in the books a few times? Beyond Breland being a little more accepting and Thrane & Karrnath seeing them as bought property still, how might Zilargo and Aundair, or others, treat the warforged? Do commoners in Thrane/Karrnath agree with their governments about owning the warforged and treating them as slaves or are commoners' perspectives different from their kings and queens? There's a couple questions in here but they revolve around the same idea

David Byrd

Many Eberron races seem to have their origins tied to the planes and manifest zones. Other then dragons/native outsiders do you consider any other races to be home grown Eberron races with out any additional planar influence?

Chris

How would a Ghaash'kala patrol respond to a group of PCs they meet in Khyber, upon discovering that at least two of them had made binding pacts with fiends (one with an Overlord, the other with an Archdevil from Shavarrath?) Now assume that the Ghaash'kala patrol leader is the long-lost brother of one of the pact-holders. (This is essentially a recap of the session I DM'd last night.)

Diarmuid McCourt

Given that you’ve said the tiger look is probably a fashion choice, do non-Rakshasa fiends working for the Lords of Dust also have tigery aesthetics?

Earth Seraph Edna

Under the idea that the moons of Eberron are manifest worlds that can support civilizations, which moon between Therendor (tied to Syrania, but called the Healer's Moon and associated with the Mark of Healing) and Barrakas (tied to Irian, the plane of life) is more likely to be home to a society that has invented a fountain of youth and immortality? Is it possible for a moon, or at least a section of a moon, to have more extreme versions of its plane's traits, such as a region of Sypheros that completely forbids violence without even allowing a save, or an area in Barrakas where all damage is instantly regenerated?

Jeanne

Hi Keith, one more simple complicated question for April: What's keeping halflings off the Talenta Plains, if it's not duty to clan, spirits, or the Houses? I went through a few sources and suggestions, and most of them go either for extrinsic motivations like the ones above, or with ones that rely on the Talenta halflings' outsider role like curiosity, which isn't exactly the strongest counterpoint to tribal cohesion. I feel like the halfling player at my table wouldn't take very well to either, but could use a good reason to not just go back dinosaur hunting. So, how else do you see the Talenta interacting with the rest of Khorvaire, specifically the independent, less traditional ones? I hope this one works as well as the Crucible one and I can give the hunter at my table something to hunt!

Jacques Patreon

Are there any vignettes or other little things you can share about the Lhazaar Sea? I know it's been in the polls (and sadly losing) for a Dragonmarked Article, but I'd love to hear of any small things/ideas you've had for the Lhazaar Sea.

Baron Legi

What is a monstrous race that you’d put in Droaam that people don’t talk about and aren’t in any lore about it yet? What niche in Droaam do you think is missing as of now?

Jamie Gardiner

Who is the Richest person on Eberron (either gold wealth, dragonshard stock, land, property, influence, assets, horde etc.), how did they acquire the wealth and what do they do, or intend to do with it?

Spike Hemphill

Would Grimlocks in Eberron be the creation of Daelkyr? Would they be people with own culture? Could they be both? Any thoughts?

Jimmy Kedge

Hey Keith, given that house Valadis might work in humanoid mage breeding. What about a version of completely consensual version that lets normally incompatable species have a kid together or let's them specially clone one out of there DNA?

Not Mordakhesh

Shifter types and lycanthropy. Let’s say I’m a foxlike shifter (wildhunt , let’s say) and I get bitten by a werewolf. When I transform do I become a werewolf or a werefox? Is there a relationship between a shifters type and how lycanthropy manifests? And what about lycanthropy in general? Someone bitten by a werewolf must become a werewolf or could they be a wereboar?

Artemis, a pet rock that might die

Since Thrane’s wide divine principle only works when an adept is convinced they’re helping someone innocent, what are Thranish prisons like? I can see them being very secure, but are they filthy and unkept? Or can a Flame adept wash a known killer’s clothes?

Spike Hemphill

I love how you roleplayed and described Rakshasa in your games. How would you roleplay and describe Mindflayers in your games? How do you present their alien nature?

Robin

As an awakened greatpine just how big is Oalian? Do they reach the titanic 250ft heights of their brethren or are they more modestly (and perhaps conveniently) sized?

Spike Hemphill

Could a town in Soldorak clanhold have a Silver Flame church? Would it be more utilitarian than other SF churches?

Travis

I'm curious about Barghests in Eberron. Do they serve as a kind of bogeyman for city goblins? Maybe some other kind of threat to the Darguul and Dhakaani? I remember a previous book (ECS?) specifically tying them to Mabar but I could also see them as a native Shavarathi fiend gaining power on the material to bring back to the Eternal Conflict. In FR, they are magical shapeshifters who are sent to the material plane as young with the goal of consuming the souls of powerful goblinoids. At a certain threshold, they gain enough power to plane shift back to Gehenna to rejoin the territorial conflict against their kind and other fiends. Large bodies of persistent fire could act as a gateway to send them involuntarily back to Gehenna.

Daelkyr Devon

Might've been mentioned before, but how might a Ring of Mind Shielding relate to their dreams? Could you bypass a persons mind protection via Dal Quor? Or would their personal dream island be protected by the same magic?

Inquisitor Thomas

How would you handle a player who wants to incorporate a god from another setting or just a god they made up into Eberron?

Rhys Miller

The talk of the hour (as of this writing) is about Half-Elves and Half-Orcs not returning to the new DnD PHB. If you were making a new setting book for OneDnD/5.5e, would you consider including Khoravar as a PC race alongside the other Eberron-specific ones?

Morgaine Barkefors

There seems to exist a perception of "civilized" and "monstrous" ancestries in Eberron – with humans, elves and dwarves firmly on the civilized side while ogres, gnolls and harpies land on the monstrous side. What's the view on goblins in the Five Nations? I recall from somewhere that they (unlike the other dar) have been citizens of the Five Nations at least since the time of Galifar, though at the very bottom of the social hierarchy.

James McConnell IV

Some of Eberron's advanced technology came from collaborative work between Dragonmarked Houses like the lightning rail and elemental airships. I have four questions. Why did the different houses agree to partner up with their competitors? How did they view each other while working together? Is there a sore spot for House Cannith for not being able to control (literally and in business) these magical inventions? And were there lasting friendships and respect between different house members after working together?

Jamie Bernstein

I have a question about giant religion for a writing project on their civilisations. We have some examples of giant gods (Karrak, Banor, and Rowa) that are worshipped by the Rusheme in Xen'drik, and the descendants of the giants in Sarlona. I was curious how you see the ancient giants approaching religion; are those gods the same as in the Age of Giants? did they worship giant champions who embodied the Sovereigns in the Age of Demons, instead of dragon ones?

Vani Srinivasan

Do the Poison Dusk lizardfolk have any significant musical/artistic customs?

Daelkyr Devon

How might you fit Nilbogs into Eberron? There's always a way to retexture a statblock, sure, but is there a way you would fit an immortal trickster spirit that possesses goblinoids into your eberron?

Jeremy Callister

In Exploring Eberron, we learn about the Solars in Daanvi that are part of the Panopticon, 13 individually assigned to each of the planes besides the Material. One of the few named there is Azazar, the Solar of Xoriat. I was wondering about this particular Solar. Xoriat is beyond the understanding of mortal minds, but what of a planar immortal? Does the fact that Azazar is specifically "created" for the purpose of observing Xoriat mean they are immune to the mind warping of the other plane? We have precedent for planar immortals being changed, with the fallen angels of Syrania becoming radiant idols because of their interaction with mortals and the material plane. But here we have a cross planar interaction and no direct interaction with mortals or the material plane. How would you run Azazar? One of the only sources of Xorian knowledge that you could have a normal conversation with, or a powerful celestial corrupted by forbidden knowledge? Something else?

Tyler Nelson

So you'll never give a definitive answer to The Mourning, but the campaign I'm playing is wrapping up in the Mournland so I have to ask. what is the most out there theory you've heard about The Mourning?

Jesse Williams

1.I am reading through your old articles and I saw one that mentioned the Hammerfest Dwarves in the Demon Wastes. They sound very fascinating, would you ever elaborate on them like you did with some of the various gnome societies? 2. What do followers of the Path of Light believe happens when they die? I don't recall this ever being discussed. 3. I see a lot of fans in there games running a campaign where a brand new dragonmark emerges and it got me wondering, if you had to create a brand new dragonmark, what ideas would you have? 4. I like Kalashtars but I'm a bit intimidated by how their behavior and body language is "strange and alien". what tips would you give on roleplaying one?

Bekah McCue

If Eberron is based off of the late 1800's, does this imply a magical equivalent of the phonograph exists, and if so, is it accessible (even if only to the rich)?

Micah Peltier

On your blog (well, in Chronicle, now) you've explored each of the Dark Six in depth, and especially presented cultures that perceive/revere the Six as good/beneficial deities. Are there any cultures that perceive the Sovereign Host in a similar manner? I.e., as truly evil gods? It's mentioned that the Cazhaak Faith sees them as "cruel and petty" keeping their subjects "small and weak," but is there any more detail you can add? Obviously, one may chafe against Aureon's laws or Dol Arrah's sense of honor, but it's hard to argue with the domination that Vassal society has exerted over Khorvaire. How do the Cazhaak priests reconcile such a powerful culture with the assertion that the Host wants their subjects small and weak? A second question, if you'd rather, why is there piracy in Lhazaar? Looking to our history (and, to be clear, I'm no historian, but this is my understanding), the Golden Age of piracy was the result of a perfect storm of sorts: a high concentration of ex-soldiers abandoned by their respective crowns after a difficult war, vast amounts of wealth in transit, in a region of the world far from the nations that claimed it. In Eberron, we certainly have a difficult war that's just finished, but it feels difficult to justify vast amounts of wealth moving through the Principalities. Even if sailors refuse to sail the Barren Sea, it's hard to imagine that it's more effective to ship something, say, from Scions Sound, through Lhazaar, to Sharn; rather than sending in on a Lightning Rail or a canal or something. Additionally, the Golden Age of Piracy, in its more generous definitions, covers a period of 80 years or so. Lhazaar seems to have been roughly unchanged since the Pirate Queen herself conquered the region. Three thousand years of piracy seems...difficult to sustain, to say the least.

Earth Seraph Edna

Is it possible for a daelkyr to break the rules and make an incursion into Daanvi (e.g. Belashyrra taking an interest in the Panopticon, Avassh being fascinated by the Perfect Grange), corrupting its inhabitants?

Micah Peltier

I know I've had two questions asked and answered, but I was wondering if you have any thoughts about returning to Phoenix: Dhakaani Command (Phoenix: Goblin Wars?)? I recently picked up PDC, and while I haven't had the chance to play it just yet, I'm incredibly intrigued by the core concept. Pair that with my love of Eberron, and your old article about merging the two really sparked my imagination. Any chance we'll see an adventure supplement, or a more formal conversion, or something like that ever?

Will Buck

Alternate question #3: What are the odds of another expansion for the Adventure Zone game?

Iris

My question regards Tsoreva and Usvapna quori that dont have statblocks or representation in 5th edition yet. Assuming that the quori rebellion that resulted in the Kalashtar has contained or could contain any type of quori and that none were fully loyal (meaning that there would be an Tsoreva and an Usvapna lineage of Kalashtar), how would these quori bonds affect the bonded Kalashtar? Tsoreva appear fairly straight forward, with their tendency towards violence and almost cruelty aswell as a past mention of yours tying them to spite. My assumption would be that an Tsoreva Kalashtar holds great potential to empathy, and also towards healing injury as they use their bonds knowledge of battle to mend the wounds of said battle. Is that correct or would an more martially inclined tendency show among the Tsoreva bonded Kalashtar? Similarily, the Usvapna bonded Kalashtar id assume would hold great potential for insight and thus could serve in adar as an sort of anti-espionage when we draw on their quori role as inquisitors. Usvapna dont seem to have as much of an defined realm as the other published quori, so here again: how would their bond affect an kalashtar?

WebbRosson

How do the Q’barran Dragonborn generally regard the Cold Sun Federation? Are they aware of their origins and their shared dreams?

SomeGuy123456

I noticed the skycoach driver at the beginning of The City of Towers novel is depicted with an emblem of a swan on her clothes, which kind of seems like it could be the logo of a skycoach company. So it got me thinking, who actually runs the skycoaches in Sharn? Are the dragonmarked houses involved? If they're not and they're independently run, would say House Lyrandar or House Orien be interesting in encroaching on the skycoach business?

Will Buck

Alternate question #4: What is your personal strategy for organizing and accessing Eberron canon/kanon? Like when someone asks a question, how do you query the vast body of Eberron lore (books, dungeon articles, web supplements, your own blog posts) to find relevant lore tidbits to incorporate and expand upon?

Matt Brady

I've been avoiding asking questions because my previous one was one that just couldn't find an answer, so I wanted to make sure I had a good one before asking something again, but I just thought of one this morning (with 5 days to go in April!). I feel like I might have asked something similar way back in the day focused on the cuisine but here I'm widening the focus a little With the halflings of Eastern Karrnath being a sort of midground between Karrnath and the Talenta Plains, was there any historical fusion between the Mror dwarves of the Ironroot Mountains and the Talenta? Were stout halfling nomads trading with Mror? Is the clan alliances with the halfling dragonmarked houses a post-Galifar thing or does it predate human arrival? And connected but definitely secondary, would trade with dwarves have been the first opportunity for the Talenta to encounter the gnomes (who also traded with the dwarves) or were the gnomes and halflings known to each other?

gonzolikesmovies

The warforged colossi are a fascinating development of the Last War; pumping out a bunch of CR 25 constructs is no small feat. How would House Cannith and Cyre have trained their pilots and/or crews to use such a unique and powerful weapon, and what traits are they looking for in those candidates? As a secondary question, who's REALLY in control of the colossus - the pilot, the elemental, or the master docent?

Shogunbirds

Say you have an Artificer who is an archaeologist delving into Dhakaani ruins in Khorvaire or Giant civilization ruins in Xen'drik or digging up fossils of extinct creatures from the Talenta Plains or Q'barra. How would you see them flavoring their spells and what subclass do you think would fit best?

Joseph Meehan

With Fools Gold/Fools Platinum formally cancelled, can you share details about what might have gone into that project?

Lewis Pascoe

Would it make sense for Belashyrra and his cults to have an interest in painting and illustrating, as they are a visual medium that can evoke thoughts and emotion? Could you suggest a few ways such a painter cult could appear on Eberron and be used?

Skam

Whats the state of/ETA on organised sports are there in Eberron? You’ve discussed Hrazhak before but do you envision an Olympic Games or multinational sporting league coming to Khorvaire’s future?