Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Hi Everyone!

April turned out to be packed with travel and IRL issues. While I was able to get to a lot of questions and am happy with the IFAQs, I couldn't get to everything and I'm still working on the dragonmark. The next week will be even busier than before, but hopefully I'll be able to catch up as the month goes on. In the meantime, it's a new month and time for new questions. 

Regardless, the simple fact is that I will not be able to answer every question; simple questions are the best questions. If I can answer a question in five minutes here, I'll probably answer it. If it would take significant research or an hour of work to answer a question, I probably can't. Feel free to ask questions that didn't get answered in a previous month, just know that I won't be able to get to them all... and if there's a question I've skipped over a few times it means that I need focus to answer it and I haven't had that focus. In addition, I will only answer one question per patron. You can ASK more than one, because one may be easier for me to answer than another, but I'll only answer one.

Threshold patrons, I will be continuing the Ja'taarka story hour whenever time permits, until we get to the next session; and I'll be rescheduling Session 18 as soon as I know what the future holds. 

Thanks for your support!

Files

Comments

OHeyItsRick

Hey, Keith! If you've the time, I would love to know more about the role of Dol Dorn within the Sovereign Host (and the Three Faces of War). How does his role differ to that of Dol Arrah amongst the Vassals, how do people pay homage to him, and anything else that might come to mind. I am working on a piece of fiction right now involving the Three Faces of War and so any further insight you're able to provide would be greatly appreciated. Thanks!

Tracy Castleberry Knowles

You mentioned in the article about the Shulassakar "… the guardians of Krezent come from a fortress-city in a demiplane they claimed long ago" and when someone asked you responded "That’s the point. They’re not FROM there; they SEIZED it. There’s a story, but if people want to hear it, they’ll have to request a Krezent article…" I'd like to formally request the article and story : ) <3 (I assume this isn't a fast answer and will take a while. I just wanted to refresh it in this months Qs) : )

Afghanis Tan

Hello Keith, first time asker, I wanted to know more about the lower level services of the Courier's Guild and how Orien might deliver their services to more remote regions, if at all. What types of equipment might a Courier make use of in the Five Nations? Does House Orien outfit their marked Couriers with specialized handy haversacks so they can deliver bulk shipments? How might the nature of the Traveler's Curse influence their ability to provide to Xen'Drik? I suppose my question can be summed up as what are the limits of the Courier Guild and what tools do they use to facilitate their work? I apologize for asking more than one question, but I'm very bad at asking questions.

David Armstrong

Hey Keith! Huge Eberron fan, and although you may not remember, you've helped me out with some quick advice on more than one occasion. Here's another question for you... Currently running a campaign in Karrnath, and I read that Regent Morana changed matters about 15 years ago so that the Blood of Vol is no longer the rule of law when it comes to mandated religions. So how does that affect existing churches in the hommlets and villages and towns of Karrnath? If their parents and grandparents believed in the divinity within, then how does that affect the children of a non-cosmopolitan upbringing? Has the Blood of Vol "religion" been banned, or is just no longer enforced as mandatory? And how does that affect the Sovereign Host and Silver Flame? Do we have flocks of missionaries and proseletyzers looking to "spread the word" and build their churches and missions in Karrnath now?

David Armstrong

Completely different question, but far simpler: Can either the lightning rail oof House Orien or the airships of House Lyrandar navigate through (or over) the Gray Wall of the Mourning, or do they have to go around?

Ted Kern

What do merchant/pirate ships in Khorvaire look like? Are ports filled with familiar age of sail designs, or something more unique and modernish (for non-elemental ships)? Are elemental galleons actually galleons or something sleeker, like a clipper or that catamaran looking concept art from Mark Tedin in 2005? I can't help but wonder how non elemental ships look given the presence of people who literally control the wind being somewhat common.

Micah Peltier

It seems fairly well established in Eberron that souls are powerful, and particularly, conglomerations of souls form potent power sources (Silver Flame, the Umbra). Given the sheer number of souls in Dolurrh at any given time, is the plane perpetually thrumming with power? Is the spiritual machinery of the plane ‘insulated’ against that amount of power (as a high-voltage electrical system might be)? Could someone with a sufficient connection to/knowledge of Dolurrh tap into that power, like a cleric would with the Silver Flame?

Jarrah James

If you were to make Eberron again from scratch, is there anything you would do significantly differently? Anything you would not have put in it?

Carlton Anderson

Reposting from April, since you expressed interest in the topic, Keith: Who is the Duke of Atur and what do his personal agenda and political aspirations look like, either IYE or if you were writing him up? Given his high rank and position among the nobles of Karrnath, his voice is likely to be an important one in Karranath's current political landscape. Alternatively, if the Duke of Atur is actually Kaius due to Atur being a Grand Duchy, I'd love some more information about Queen Etrigani. What does *her* personal agenda look like? Is she behind the formation of the Red Watchers? And why does she *really* spend so much time in Atur?

Sir Ender

In 3.5 there were the psiforged, and in Morgrave Miscellany there are the dragonforged. Have there ever been a sort of "felforged", or "fiendforged", where the creator attempts to harness the power of fiends and similar creatures in a warforged? Or perhaps the materials used has been planetouched in a similar way as some tieflings?

Jeanne

Hi Keith, me again with the tricky Talenta questions - the one you passed back to me specifically: Is there anything of value for the Talenta outside of the Plains? I just can't seem to find a lot of knowledge or technologies that are as valuable in a wide primal nomadic economy aiming for self-sufficiency as they are in a sedentary wide arcane one. The Cannith-standard doesn't exactly seem portable, easily repaired without a magewright's workshop, or clawfoot-proof. Alternatively, here's a twofold question (it might be more of a dragonshard though): How do you envision pre-war Plains-Galifar relationships with their respective "capitals" basically within viewing distance of each other, and how do you see the very visible Mournland impact Plains politics? I don't think any c/kanon release ever expanded on that beyond "the Talenta tried to stay out of Galifar affairs" and "the Mournland is a problem for them too". I also feel like these 2,5 questions are complementary in a way I can't quite pinpoint, as if they're partly answering each other, but not quite, or like there's a 3rd question implied in the relationship-question that'd answer them all. If you can find it, I'd love to get an answer to the question I didn't ask instead. And finally one for fun: Do you have a favorite dinosaur?

Peter S.

Hi Keith! What type of contacts could have happened between the Quori and the Dakhaani? For example: would Quori to have particular interest in the Uul'Dakhaan, or were the Dakhaani - in their different approach to dreaming - aware of the presence of Quori outside of the shared dream?

Chance

What advice or ideas would you have to incorporate "monstrous" Dragons, that is mindless, bestial, and closer to animals than people, alongside "Intelligent" Dragons such as the Dragons of Argonessen? I'd be interested in hearing ideas for Eberron or in homebrew settings. I want to have my dragon cake and eat it too.

Xavier Parra Pérez

Hi Keith! Would you tie planes and marks together as they seem to have a connection through the moons in a prophecy like manner? Or is this something a bit odd/not intended?

Leslie Mactir

What is life like in the countrysides of the five nations, are they still occupied by feudal manors or has magical industrialisation ended traditional feudal contracts?

gonzolikesmovies

The warforged colossi are a fascinating development of the Last War; pumping out a bunch of CR 25 constructs is no small feat. How would House Cannith and Cyre have trained their pilots and/or crews to use such a unique and powerful weapon, and what traits are they looking for in those candidates? Also - whose idea WAS it to make these things, Merrix or Starrin or somebody else entirely? As a secondary question (and an alternate option in case you don't feel like answering the first), who's REALLY in control of the colossus - the pilot(s), the elemental, or the master docent, and what is that bond within the network like between all three?

Zac Luchette

Demogorgon vs. Warforged Colossus - who wins?

Patrick Reupert

As someone with a culinary interest I always ask myself what some specialities of a region are. We know Cyre was a melting pot of all the ideas in the 5 Nations, but what would some classic meal and possibly drink be in some of the Nation's of Khorvaire? We got Goodberry wine, Aundairian fine wine and the Dhakaani Blood Ale. What are some other options for the gourmet traveling Eberron?

Tyler Nelson

Two things: I heard you were thinking of making a fantasy western setting? I have been trying to homebrew my own magic wild west setting for years, and I would love to see you make one!

Tyler Nelson

Next: So I'm a train boy at heart and I've always loved the lightning rails. But the term "rails" has always bugged me a little. Do other kinds of railroads exist in eberron? I don't see why Khorvarians would use the term rail to describe the conductor stones if other forms of rail transport existed.

Not Mordakhesh

What is your nice Imaria version of Merrix doing with the warforged he’s been making below Sharn? You said he was trying to help them. Not asking for official Kanon, just info about this particular version

Thomas Brøgger

Hi Keith! I’m consitering starting a Gangs of Callestan campaign. Apart from Boromar Clan and Daask what other factions could have an interest in the district?

dirDav3

Do you have any off the cuff ideas about the overlord that's potentially bound on Tempest Isle? "Fear of bad weather" doesn't sound as "overlordy" compared to some of the others. The Lurker is already fear of the abyss (basically) and is the closest official overlord that themes well with the Principalities

Robin

Thanks for answering my Oalian question last month! I did go with the big telepathic tree in the end, with them using the wind to manipulate fallen pine needles into a map for the party to follow and it worked great! My question for this month is: what would a Soarwood grove look like? I'm hesitantly thinking floating trees and earth motes that their roots have pulled up but would love to hear your thoughts! (To be specific as well this would be a newly discovered Soarwood grove in the Towering Woods as opposed to a cultivated one in Aerenal, though would love to hear about those too if you have time!)

Chris

Hey Keith, thanks so much for answering my question last month (and the one before that.) Here’s my May question: What happens to a Valaes Tairn who “rejects” or otherwise pushes back against their connection to their patron ancestor to the point where you can safely say that they are out of the ancestor’s “grace,” for lack of a better phrase? Are they rejected by their war clan? Excommunicated? Can they find their way back?

Morgaine Barkefors

My players will soon reach an old Dhakaani fort and fight the ogre chib who occupy it. So I'm in full planning mode on the area in question, so to the question – What does a Dhakaani fort look like? Who were they built to protect against? Any significant details I would be remissed to forget when designing it?

Shogunbirds

Hi Keith, I've seen in many places that with the Last War having ended no that long ago, tensions are still up across Khorvaire and if they are pushed on could reignite the War. My question is "What do you think could realistically happen that would reignite The Last War?"

Marcus

Hi Keith, I swear I have other questions but I wanted to continue expressing my curiosity on this particular topic (if you would prefer for me to move on to something else for the time being, just say the word) - Any thoughts on how assistive technologies and treatments would manifest within Eberron for characters living with disabilities? I look forward to your future articles and wish you all the best :D

Jarrod Taylor

What are some of the iconic regional meals found at a Gold Dragon Inn, specifically what is the signature Cyran dish?

Kaci Petri

What was the island of Thronehold to the Goblin Empire before the kingdom of Galifar? Besides the geographic location of Thronehold, was there any other reasoning for Galifar choosing Thronehold to rule from?

Jamie Gardiner

So couple of potentials here! I've named my campaign the Tears of Siberys, as I've speculated that Siberys shards falling from the ring are known as that and that they coincide with Dragonmarks manifesting. The BBEG for my campaign is Lady Illmarrow, and upon her final death (which I intend to be tragically soliloquayed) the Mark of Death will reemerge accompanied by a large amount of Siberys "tears", I just wanted to ask if that passed the creator "vibe" for the setting? And second, is there, through other means, outside influence, prophecy stuff, or just "evolution" per se, a means for the standard dragon marks to appear on not normal races? As in could a mark of Handling suddenly appear on a Tabaxi? I know Eberron is open for DMs to interpret and add things and whatnot, but how would you fit this into your Eberron?

Iris

As requested, heres my question from last month again! My question regards Tsoreva and Usvapna quori that dont have statblocks or representation in 5th edition yet. Assuming that the quori rebellion that resulted in the Kalashtar has contained or could contain any type of quori and that none were fully loyal (meaning that there would be an Tsoreva and an Usvapna lineage of Kalashtar), how would these quori bonds affect the bonded Kalashtar? Tsoreva appear fairly straight forward, with their tendency towards violence and almost cruelty aswell as a past mention of yours tying them to spite. My assumption would be that an Tsoreva Kalashtar holds great potential to empathy, and also towards healing injury as they use their bonds knowledge of battle to mend the wounds of said battle. Is that correct or would an more martially inclined tendency show among the Tsoreva bonded Kalashtar? Similarily, the Usvapna bonded Kalashtar id assume would hold great potential for insight and thus could serve in adar as an sort of anti-espionage when we draw on their quori role as inquisitors. Usvapna dont seem to have as much of an defined realm as the other published quori, so here again: how would their bond affect an kalashtar?

Daelkyr Devon

In Chronicles, you talk about how Overlords can influence and perhaps control planar entities that share the same ideas (provided those entities are on the material plane). How might you see the relationship between an Overlord with aberrant themes , and the Daelkyr? Could the Lurker exert control over, say, Dyrrn? What might that even look like?

Charley Meink

How common is Blood used in magic and crafting of magic items? I have been told by others that this is extremely hard and complicated but I see no proof pointing towards this being easy or hard. I can see certain groups using Blood Magic/Crafting such as maybe some Sects of The Blood of Vol, The Venomous Demesne, The Lords of Dust, and etc. Any help is appreciated about this. Thanks!

Not Mordakhesh

If you’re not able to answer my previous question , would it be possible to answer this one instead? At the Treaty of Thronehold, what exactly were the arguments put forth as to why warforged production should cease, which leaders proposed what, and what might the penalty be for someone like Merrix if they are caught? (Assuming he doesn’t just get away with it)

SomeGuy123456

Hi Keith. We know from the 3.5e Eberron Campaign Setting that Nightwood Ale is popular across Khorvaire but is expensive in foreign markets (pg. 176), but are there any other popular ales served in the taverns of Khorvaire? In particular I'm wondering if other nations have their own local ales or if they rely primarily on imports from Karrnath.

Jamie Bernstein

in Secrets of Stormreach, it's proposed that Thri-kreen might be fundamentally linked to Dal Quor in a similar way to the Kuo-toa, existing in both the Material and Region of Dreams at the same time. I was curious how you would see that impacting their modern culture and beliefs in contrast to the Godshapers. (or, fundamentally, whether it's just not the take you'd go with).

WebbRosson

Is there a history of soft drinks in Eberron? Either Cannith made/Jorasco formulated potions or just tasty beverages

Inquisitor Thomas

Hey Keith: So I have a couple of questions, feel free to pick whichever is most interesting, potentially useful, or quick to answer. 1. What is the relationship between Rekkenmark and Thaliost? They're two major cities that spent a lot of history connected to each other but they're also from two very different cultural backgrounds. 2. How do you get your PCs to utilize House Sivis services without forcing them? I've been running a game based in Sharn for a while and my party will gladly circle the city several times rather than go to the House Sivis Enclave. 3. If Wroat is built on a Manifest Zone what type would it be? 4. How would you make Karlakton, Rekkenmark, and Korth feel different from each other?

James McConnell IV

Off the top of my head I can think of Mordain the Flesh weaver, the Daughter's of Sora Kell, Hektula, Lady Illmorrow to name a few powerful magic casting NPCs but I can't think of any high power magic casters in the Dragonmarked Houses (that are still affiliated with their House, not counting Mordain). Are there any high level magic casting Dragonmarked NPCs that you haven't been able to put into your books yet? I haven't read all the Eberron books so please forgive me if I'm overlooking major NPCs : )

James McConnell IV

Thanks Keith, I really appreciate your responses : )

Daelkyr Devon

I understand both fire and air elementals are used for air travel vessels, but is there a difference/a reason someone would use one over the other? And how might someone use an earth elemental in an elemental galleon?

Spike Hemphill

How would adventurers and Quori navigate Dal Quor ? For example how would a party travel from Uul Dhakaan to il-Lashtavar Fortress? would they travel from dream to dream or fly through a psychic void?

Spike Hemphill

Any thoughts on Ogres in Mror Holds?

Jesse Williams

1.I am reading through your old articles and I saw one that mentioned the Hammerfest Dwarves in the Demon Wastes. They sound very fascinating, would you ever elaborate on them like you did with some of the various gnome societies? 2. In your Eberron, how "evil" or ruthless is House Tarkanan? If I remember correctly you likened them to the brotherhood of mutants, so then is there a more compassionate group? one that still wants to fight back but not hurt or kill innocents? 3. I see a lot of fans in there games running a campaign where a brand new dragonmark emerges and it got me wondering, if you had to create a brand new dragonmark, what ideas would you have? 4. I like Kalashtars but I'm a bit intimidated by how their behavior and body language is "strange and alien". what tips would you give on roleplaying one?

Jesse Williams

Very fair. I appreciate your perspective and emphasizing just how bad the finders of house tarkanan were treated. I personally find aberrant marks one of the most fascinating parts of the whole draconic prophecy, more fascinating then the true marks.

EllieSF

Where can I find Zebras in Khorvaire? Cyre seems great for them. Has the Mourning done anything to them?

Skam

How does Tharashk run a company town such as one from the Q'barra campaign article? Do they take the lion's share of profits?

Matthew Booth

Keith, we're having a debate on aukaraks (reality storms) drawing on Xoriat despite the Gatekeeper seals. How would you reconcile this in your Eberron?

Jessie Harris

Do other in world languages have different names for Eberron (as in, the world they live on)?