Testing the active Motor Cooling (Patreon)
Downloads
Missing 1 file, as this post has not yet been imported.
Content
OK, now that the first motor tower is assembled, it was time to do a bit of testing. I wanted to know how much air the fan could move through the tower and also how the sound profile of the fan changed when it was inside the motor case.
The good news is that the cooling is strong... and when I say strong, I mean way overpowering ;-) I could feel the airflow 15-20cm from the exhaust. Also, the air pressure on all 3 exhausts feels exactly the same, so I assume that all 3 heatsinks are cooled equally.
The fan I chose is noisy. It has a power of 4.8W, which is too much now that I have tested the motor tower, so I may get a smaller fan for the final BOM. What I like is that the noise profile of the fan is almost identical to that of the free-spinning fan. There is no hissing or whistling, no resonance noise, so I am happy with how that turned out.
One good thing about the fan I chose is that it starts spinning at around 9V, so there is plenty of room to throttle the fan. For me, the sound profile at 16V is identical to 24V, with only a quarter of the noise.
I also added a small slot in the motor tower for a 100K, NTC 3950 temperature sensor. With this sensor we could throttle the fan based on the motor temperature.
I am pretty sure this is overkill for 98% of the people who will build this printer, my gut feeling is that even at 9V the motor cooling will be sufficient for normal fast printing. But it might be a nice addition for people like me or Volgger who want to push the printer to it's limits.
And also for debugging, the collected data could help. Knowing that one motor is significantly hotter than the others might give us clues that we could use to diagnose the problem.