Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout
haven't archived this post yet. have a subscription? use the importer!

Downloads

  • 341621933.txt

Missing 1 full-res photo, 1 file, as this post has not yet been imported.

Content

After another day of debugging, I realized that the fan covers were causing a howling noise when running at speeds above 50%. I tried softening each edge on the fan cover by sanding them down, but the noise only got marginally better.

Normally I would say that this issue is not important enough to hold up an alpha release, but since I am a perfectionist... I decided to spend a little more time developing better fan covers.

What's your opinion on such minor issues, should I fix them before the alpha release or put them on my todo list for the beta version?

Files

Previews only

Comments

Christopher Gray

Is that the fan cover or resonance? Sounds like it could be a vibration/resonance when mounted against the fan cover? Do u have an bits of rubber (like noctua pads)?

Egan Dritz

in my opinion i would leave them for the alpha release, it seems like an issue that should be worked on between the alpha and beta. Or possibly one of the alpha testers finds a solution for

Andrew Basson

VHB Tape? TPU gasket? Leave the issue for Beta, as it is already known. Better to spend the time finding if there are other areas that need adjustment.

Tenaja

Leave it be; fix it later. There are more important issues to address. JMHO.

Christian Koschmieder

Yeah, these kind of problems should be left for later. Perfect is the worst enemy of done (or so). I am pretty bad at that myself, but as long as it doesn't impact the functionality, it should be left for later. Who knows, maybe there's something else you need to change which will make the whole part obsolete?

Glen McQuarters

Sound like rubbing to me maybe a small spacer will stop it

Nate Fansler

Maybe it just needs some type of isolator (rubber, foam etc.) to isolate the fan from the frame, but maybe it's another piece of the frame that is vibrating due to resonance. Printing a new fan shroud is easy enough for everyone to do later, but if the issue requires revising how all the lower frame parts are assembled or extra room in the electronics area for the fans, then it would be better to fix now. We expect revisions will be needed to the beta build, but it's best to find major redesigns now. This issue could probably be diagnosed and solved relatively quickly. Once everyone starts printing whole machines, there will be reluctance for major changes and we will be incentivized to stick with less optimal designs that require less reprinting.