Testing Pancake Motors (Patreon)
Downloads
Missing 1 file, as this post has not yet been imported.
Content
For the T250, I decided to put the direct drive motor inside the carriage. This way it's right in the center of gravity and therefore generates less skew force compared to a motor on top of the carriage. The disadvantage is that there is only 2mm of space between the motor housing and the carriage.
Pancake motors get really hot over time, 75°C after 30min of printing at 20°C room temperature is not uncommon. So I wondered which pancake motors would run at the lowest temperatures and still deliver high torque.
For my first test, I wrote a GCode that extrudes a filament at 75mm3 for 30 minutes. I ran this test at no load because I wanted to have a comparable baseline that I could use to eliminate most of the motors and narrow it down to two.
Here are the competitors:
- LDO 36STH20-1004AHG
- Moons CSE14HRA1L410A-01
- Fysetc G36HSY4405-6D-30
- Siboor 14STH20-1004A
- Triangle-lab NoName Pancake
- NoName 6byg1204-a-6qht
- Hanpose 36HS2110
- Creality K1 Pancake Replacement Part
I run them at 65% RMS current
And got the following results after 30min
- Moons CSE14HRA1L410A-01 : 68°C
- NoName 6byg1204-a-6qht : 71°C
- Siboor 14STH20-1004A: 72°C
- Creality K1 Pancake Replacement Part: 73°C
- Triangle-lab NoName Pancake: 73°C
- LDO 36STH20-1004AHG: 75°C
- Hanpose 36HS2110: 77°C
- Fysetc G36HSY4405-6D-30: 79°C
My Takeaways:
- Any motor would melt a PLA Carriage.
- Moons run much cooler than LDO's
- Even a carriage out of ABS might be not enough. (If you are printing a speedboat, you should aim for 90-95% rms to get as much torque as possible. Also keep in mind that the room you're printing in may be warmer than 20°C in the summer.
I will be doing more testing with the Moons, the NoName and the LDO. I will keep you informed about all of my results. Thanks for sponsoring me, tests like this where I buy dozens of different pancake motors for scince would not have been possible without your support!