Reaching out high! (Patreon)
Content
I got a couple message form the community asking if it's possible to break 247's Benchy record with THE 100 so I did a the math to find a theoretical maximum Benchy time.
There are a couple Area's that I found and that I want to share with you as possible improvement on the printer:
- Lighter linear Rods:
- CF Rods: Many of you asked me if it's possible to use CF Rods and after testing dozens of them it's clear for me that this is a stop block. While being way lighter they kill linear bearings in hours. No matter if their balls are made out of hardened steel or chrome based. The only option that seemed to be reliable was CF Rods + Drylins but since the drylins friction is way higher the CF based gantry is in total slower. So CF Rods are out.
- Hollow Rods: I've simulated the forces on the Rods and noticed that there is way more headroom as I expected in the first place. I theory 8mm rods with a 5mm inner diameter would be stiff enough up to 350k acceleration where their flex is under a 1/256 step. I'm not sure if it's possible to manufacture such rods but I will try it this week.
- Smaller Rods: Another easier solution to save weight would be to use smaller rods, for example with a 5mm or 6mm diameter, both would be enough based on my simulation. From the datasheets I've seen that linear bearings at that diameter might be a bit worse but for sure it would be an option to try. A combination might be an option, for example having a 8mm main rod and a 5mm supporting rod to relay the carriage.
- Toolhead: The current toolhead weights 63g, having 2x 5015 blowers each 24g. I plan to build a toolhead with a CPAP that will save about 25-30g weight on the Toolhead and also remove both blowers, which is a save of about 75/80g in total.
- XY Joints & Carriage: The Design is not weight optimized, here 7-8g could be saved compared to the current v1.1 version
- Titan Screws: It would save another 18g when changing all gantry screws to titanium based ones.
- Thicker Y Rods: This might be a bit counter intuitive, but since The Y-Rods are static their weight plays no role in the calculation. If you would change them to 10mm or 12mm it wouldn't change the acceleration of the Gantry but it would give us a bit of headroom for improvements. In the v1.1 version I've used LML8UU's that are 1,5x longer than normal LM8UU. In general this makes the printer slower since they weigh more but since they reduced vibration it was possible to print at higher speed without blocking. With a 12mm rod the tolerances of the linear bearings are way better since the bearings are easier to produce. My idea is to use normal length LM12UU rather than the longer version and it might be that they are stable enough to reach the same speeds as the LML8UU I use currently, which would save about 12g per side. Also it would make the printer a bit more robust since the rods would bring another 300g weight to the mass of the printer making it a bit more robust on faster accelerations.
- 48V: With 48V the A/B Steppers are able to hold their speeds about 3x longer before losing torque. While this seems to be a no-brainer it means that we have to actively cool the motors since they lose torque when going over 80°C. I've tested my Wantai's at such a szenario and they reached 80°C after 3:15min which is a problem for Speedboat racing. Since they need 55min to cool down which means you would have 1 try per hour.. which sucks :-D. I planned to change the stepper motor construction for v2 anyway so motor cooling is in my scope and even at 24V.
In total we are able to save about 40g+80g+8g+18g+24g = 170g weight on the Y-Axis
With that weight reduction a theoretical time of 1:44min would be possible. With a CPAP im sure that part cooling wouldn't be an issue. So the last Puzzle piece would be flow... how to reach 115-120mm³/s of melting performances that would be needed to print that boat with an under extrusion of about 10-15%. I have a couple of ideas and I will team up with one of the biggest hotend manufactures out there trying to solve that.
But one step after the other. Next step Hollow rods.
Stay tuned & thx for supporting my bleeding edge of product development!