Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout
haven't archived this post yet. have a subscription? use the importer!

Content

Today I did a bit of brainstorming on the upcoming THE 100 v2.0 gantry. There are a couple of changes that will improve it' performance:

1. When you look at the schema of the belt paths you might notice that the idlers on the XY are aligned. That will male the part about 6-7mm thinner and therefore about 6-8g lighter.

2. Also Im planning to change the type of coreXY from DBot style (the current one) to a classic CoreXY approach (like on a voron). This will remove the crossing belts at the front making it easier to watch the printer ;-)

3. The last change and this is one I want to debate with you are the double edged circles in the schema. Currently I plan with 4 Motors driving the gantry. This will have a positive effect on the positional accuracy as it effectively cuts the length of the belt in half. Also it will help getting the motors cooler since the required torque will be distributed over 4 motors. I did a bit of simulation on that and with 4 motors on 0.8A you might get the same torque as with 2 motors on 1.3A current. With 4 motors and the active cooling on the we might drive them with 1.2A-1.6A without melting the frame which would be a 2 Motor equivalent of 2.1-3.2A

But it would also increase the price of the printer by about 250$ So what do you think? Is this change worth it? Please give me your feedback in the comments!

Files

Previews only

Comments

Tony Tillman

Yes! The 4wd!!! I do realize the effort it will take to redesign, but doubling the torque, it may not have any more top speed, but getting there with acceleration will be fun!!!

Eurusd

Very interesting indeed. What leads to the higher cost ? Since motors are cheaps (almost) is it the need for a bigger mcu or other components ?

Jack Wood

Call this the 200, instead of the 100 2.0. Much like trident vs 2.4 variations are acceptable

The100

2 motors more motors a couple more idlers, 2x more 6060 fans, a board that is able to drive them. Maybe not 250$ more like 150$ depending on the parts you choose

The100

Actually I thought of doing this, but this is tough goal.. since T200 means that it has to reach 200k acceleration... that's wild ;-)

Joseph VonDohlen

Worth it to me. Probably useful to use Nema 14 sized motors as well.

volty

I've seen dual steppers in use for platform z axis, where there's one for each lead screw. This can create problems in keeping them perfectly synced (a problem that doesn't exist when using belts instead). Could something similar happen here?

Joseph VonDohlen

They have the right amount of torque to be successful. Nema 17 x4 is really overkill for such a small machine.

The100

Yeah that might be right, never used nema 14 motors besides in voron v0 builds. I will doublecheck

Christian Koschmieder

The syncing would not be that much of a problem, as the two motors driving the same "direction" would be linked via the belt. But for me, this would not make much sense, as I primarily want to have a reasonable fast work horse for smaller parts. I do not need the extreme acceleration this would give the printer, at least not for this price. I do, however, see the appeal in driving it to the max. And parts of me really want to see what this monster could do. The same part that just wants to see the world burn, i guess. ^_^ So for me, i would probably leave the additional motors out and just use normal idlers. If I understand this correctly it should be quite easy to just use normal idlers instead of the addiitonal motors.

Kahl

What do you estimate the performance improvement to be? Is it anything measureable or is it more qualitative improvements like quality of the finish on the parts? Would you have less harmonics so could run higher acceleration and better input shaping?

The100

I think a combination of all, better quality since it effectively cuts the belt length into half, about 40-50% higher accelerations, but I cant say for sure how much of that acceleration could be transformed into real world printing performance, but for sure it would be helpful printing speedboats.

Kahl

I love it, even if theoretical ends up being half of that, the improved accuracy would be worth it for speed printing accurate parts

Andrei Ignat

At the speeds The 100 is doing and the relative short belt, I believe it's possible that having 2 motors on the same belt would cause more vibrations and possibility of them interfering with each other. It's worth a try. I have 500x500 toolchanger with 4 motors. Also a Delta with 6 motors :D

Oleg Anchikov

How it will affect the center of mass? In one of the videos it was said that printer design was born around the center of mass, 2 nema17 weights about 400-500 grams, I suppose weight distribution will need to be adjusted is some way

Aaron Hambek

Also the center of mass mostly only matters for moving parts, since the frame needs to sit still, adding more mass to it should stabilize the printer a bit