Script for CMFB: Exploitation (Patreon)
Content
Phew! This one is going to be late. It took a long time to play through, the script took a long time to write... but on the plus side it's going to be an almost 30 minute video with some cool stuff.
**
CMFB: Exploitation
Welcome back to Combat Mission Final Blitzkrieg, where we are heading into northern Germany with 21st Army Group for the Downfall module’s Exploitation scenario. It’s February 1945, Anglo-Canadian forces have broken through the German defences in the Reichswald and are now moving to exploit south-east and link up with the much delayed American 9th Army.
Specifically, for this scenario, our mission is to cut the Kelven Strasse between Goch and Keppeln. That’s about 1200m away from our deployment area, so there’s a lot of ground to cover.
Terrain
That ground is a mix of farmland and woodblocks, almost a kind of checkerboard or slalom.
There are some paths through the woods, but for the most part they are dense, rugged and difficult if not impossible for vehicles to traverse. The fields feature some gentler contours, but there are a few ploughed fields and the ground condition is ‘wet’, so these could be a bogging risk.
Tying all of this together is a road that runs up the middle of the map. At close end in the Allied deployment zone, we have the edge of a village or a town. The road goes through this, past the right hand wood and to our first ground objective.
This is a cluster of six buildings just off the road, in between the left hand wood and a kind of ditch on the right. This forms a bottleneck and the Germans evidently know it: there’s something approximating a checkpoint just past it on the road and it looks like some of the trees next to the road have been cut down. It’s impossible to know when that happened, who did it or why, but given the location the trees might have been cleared to open line of sight and, obviously, any defenders could have used the timber to build bunkers or reinforce trenches.
So this bottleneck is not only a likely defensive position, there’s a good chance it’s a prepared defensive position.
The nearby buildings objective is only worth 50 victory points though. The main prize is the Road Junction objective at the far end of the map where our road intersects with the Kelven Strasse. This objective is worth 400 points and it’s in between a small woodblock and a pretty low density urban area. It looks like there might be some warehouses or workshops or something on the right.
The actual objective area is mostly open and exposed, with some cover and concealment around the edges courtesy of some scattered buildings and the corner of the small wood, so establishing control is going to be an exercise in dominating the open ground and ferreting out any Germans hiding in the edges.
Enemy
There are another 400 victory points on the table for destroying enemy forces, weighted in favour of taking out antitank assets, but the briefing is not clear on exactly what we’re up against. Scouts report the presence of an unexpected prepared German defensive line of undetermined strength, manned by Volksgrenadier infantry of undetermined strength.
So a lot of unknowns. We are in Germany here so ‘prepared defensive line’ could mean almost anything up to and including the Siegfried Line. Practically the one known factor in the briefing is that German armour is highly unlikely to make an appearance, which is good news.
Force
In terms of friendly forces to throw at the problem, we have a very mechanised combined British-Canadian reinforced company plus… element. I want to say Battlegroup or Task Force, though those terms may or may not be a bit anachronistic.
Starting out in the deployment zone jumping off point we have three Otter scout cars, a 3 tank troop of Churchills- 12 Troop- and an FO team in a Loyd Carrier who have a 25pdr troop on call.
The rest of the battlegroup is on the way: 11 Troop with more Churchills will arrive in 5 minutes. 3 Platoons of Canadian motorised infantry in Ram Kangaroos- Platoons 5, 6 and 9- will arrive in 10 minutes, along with support from a 3in mortar section. Then after ten minutes the Churchill’s HQ tank will arrive, accompanied by a pioneer section in Stuart Kangaroos and a Wasp flamethrower carrier.
So we have recce, tanks, infantry in APCs, engineers, mortars and artillery. A very nice, rounded combined arms force.
Plan
In terms of planning… I’ve got 90 minutes to go 1200m. I suspect the enemy is going to be defending the woodblocks- definitely the left wood and the small wood. Potentially the right wood, though that’s very close to the jumping-off point.
Regardless of where the enemy actually are, the basic blueprint is going to be the same. Find them, neutralise their antitank capability to get that overmatch from the Churchills, grind them down, then mop up with the infantry. Rinse and repeat up the map.
Simple as that is, the devil is in the details. I suspect the woodblocks are going to be key for compartmentalising the map and dealing with one problem at a time. As the battle kicks off, I’m already considering an attack across the open fields on the left to seize the left wood and secure that central chokepoint from the flank.
Kick Off
Recce
First, I need to get a handle on exactly what I’m up against. So I’ve stashed the starting Churchill troop out of sight on the road and sent the Otters forward.
I’ve got one- Otter A- out far left, where there’s a path through another woodblock. Otter B is in the centre peeking round the edge of the village and Otter C is on the edge of the deployment zone eyeballing the right wood.
After a couple of turns, it’s pretty obvious I’m being wildly optimistic. The left wood is not only 700m away, but the scenario started at 0745 and we’re attacking east, so the sun is low and the facing edges of all the terrain are in shadow. I’m not convinced the Otters can see all that well anyway.
The crews can dismount at least, so I order Otter A’s crew to hop out, get into the edge of their wood and use their binoculars.
By that time the right wood is obviously not threatening, if not necessarily clear. Otter C has gone right up to it without being riddled with bullets. I haven’t seen anything on the left, but I’m not sure that means anything and there’s no way I’m sending anything out into the open fields there to close the distance and improve their chances of making a spot.
That leaves the road, which is almost certainly covered by something. What I really want to do is send one of the infantry platoons into the edge of the right wood to sneak up on the chokepoint and observe from there. But the infantry isn’t here yet and time is slipping away.
Otter B
So I send Otters B and C up the road to take a look. I haven’t got them on the road itself, because it’s an obvious location for mines: I’ve got them moving alongside. Otter C has been observing the chokepoint from behind the corner of the right wood without making any spots, but again between the roadside trees and the slowly ebbing darkness the crew probably can’t see very well.
Something sees them when they move forward though. Two rounds go straight through the front of Otter C, killing the two men in the cab. The commander up in the turret understandably panics and bails out, but not before he gets a partial spot on a bunker in the chokepoint.
I get Otter B to pop smoke and bug out on the next turn, which is coincidentally when the infantry platoons turn up. 9 platoon heads up to the right wood so they can pass through and recce the chokepoint, but it’ll take some time to get them into position and I really want to confirm what I’m looking at.
Obviously the Otters aren’t up to that and I don’t want to expose the Churchills until I’ve found the offending enemy AT gun. That leaves the FO.
I want the FO into a good observation position anyway: it’ll take him nine minutes to call in the 25pdrs and deluging the left wood and the chokepoint in smoke feels like a very strong option for covering any advance.
He can’t see anything from the top of a three storey building at the jumping-off point because he’s too keyholed, so I decide to send him forward to one of the buildings along the road which has a much better field of view.
Somewhat awkwardly, the doors to that house are on the sides, so the FO has to run out into the open to get inside. Luckily some of the smoke popped by Otter B is still on the road, helping to obscure the FO team from the chokepoint, but they take some machinegun fire from further left.
There’s an enemy tripod mounted MG in some foxholes in the left wood- the first confirmed spot. I roll tank 11A up to discourage them, keeping the FO’s building between the tank and the chokepoint contact.
Bunkers
This turns out to be a good move: when the FO team finally resolve that spot it turns out to be a concrete bunker housing a PaK40. A PakBox, as opposed to a pillbox, if you will. Somewhat unsurprisingly its set up covering the gap cut in the roadside trees, through which it engaged Otter C.
Despite the words ‘prepared defensive line’ popping up in the briefing, I hadn’t really considered the possibility of encountering concrete AT bunkers. That’s a complication. My usual solution to antitank guns is to mortar them out of action: that’s obviously not going to work here. I’m not optimistic about the Churchills being able to penetrate the concrete and although there is obviously a pretty big and vulnerable aperture for the AT gun, that’s also where the AT gun fires from so trying to put rounds directly into it would necessitate the kind of slugging match I would rather avoid.
Of course, that same aperture limits the gun’s traverse so flanking the chokepoint as I’ve been quietly intending thus far seems like a strong option.
Or at least it did until the FO spotted a second PaKbox out far left, next to the enemy machinegun nest. That’s not good news, nor is the fact that the FO appears to have been targeted by some enemy mortars.
Running out of the building to get away seems like a poor decision, not least because the area is clearly under observation, but sticking it out does not end well. One near miss wrecks the FO’s carrier, then a little while later the FO himself catches some shrapnel.
On the plus side, the enemy hasn’t exactly made efficient use of his limited mortar ammunition. That’s little consolation for the fact that the 9 minute call-in time for the 25pdrs has now ballooned to 14.
Otter A an 11A
The enemy quickly gets another hit in as well. The leftmost bunker spots Otter A and puts a round straight through it. The crew were still dismounted and get away ok despite the AP shell zipping overhead.
The shot has attracted Churchill IIA’s attention though. I’d moved the tank back next to one of the village buildings after engaging the MG nest and it manages to spot the AT bunker. It’s first round pancakes on the concrete, but the bunker crew seem to fail to identify 11A in return. The Churchill’s second shot penetrates- somehow- and neutralises the AT bunker.
That’s a nice ray of sunshine. Evidently the Churchill’s 75mm gun can poke holes in the bunker concrete, so I decide to have a go at the central bunker a few minutes later.
11A rolls forward to keyhole between the roadside trees and the FO’s building, where it can engage the bunker from a hull down position. It’s a head-on engagement, but if 11A is reasonably accurate any centre mass shots will hit the PaK40 inside the bunker itself and almost certainly take it out.
11A misses its first shot… the PaK doesn’t. Despite a burst of MG fire rattling on the gunshield, the PaK crew put a 75mm AP shell into 11A’s turret, setting off the tank’s ammunition. It’s a total loss.
9 Platoon’s Recce and Otter B’s Demise
Meanwhile, 9 Platoon has disembarked and started probing the edge of the right wood. They don’t run into resistance until get towards the far side and a German sniper behind a hedge starts taking potshots at them. They quickly get him ducking and start taking potshots of their own at the bunker’s firing slit to no effect.
This isn’t an avenue of attack by any means, 9 Platoon are strictly scouting the chokepoint here, but they’re not seeing very much straightaway.
I decide to give them some time, but on the offchance that the right flank of the chokepoint is not well defended, I could hit this flank instead of the left. So I bring Otter B round to probe a narrow path through the right wood closer to the edge of the map.
There’s a little rise at the far end, giving the Otter some dead ground to peek over, and I decide to dismount to crew to take a look on foot. They take a little MG fire from somewhere to their front as they get into position and things just get worse from there. Pulling back, one of the men steps on a land mine.
They make it back to the Otter and- for reasons I forget- I order it forward to try and get a spot on the MG that engaged them. Instead, the MG blows the commander’s head off, the Otter gets hit by an antitank gun and when the lone survivor bails out, he runs into the woods and finds another landmine.
So that far right approach is a no go. There’s definitely at least one enemy machinegun and an AT gun of some description in depth on that flank.
As the sun rises and line of sight becomes more reliable, things also start to drift sideways for 9 Platoon. The PakBox crew are not fans of the riflemen trying their luck against the aperture and send some HE back, some German soldiers in the closest two buildings are joining in and, almost inevitably, it turns out there are some mines here too. Evidently the far edge of the right wood is just littered with antipersonnel mines.
Punching up
It is otherwise clear though. If nothing else, 9 Platoon have secured the roadside edge of the wood against any lurking antitank threats, meaning I only need to worry about the PakBox in the centre and whatever might be kicking around in the left wood.
The PakBox is the big known problem. I had originally toyed with the idea of smoking it up with the 25pdrs, but they were hardly responsive even when the FO was still available. The 3in mortars are on line, but they only have 8 smoke bombs and they’re not likely to be all that accurate…
But I do have the Churchills. Each tank carries four smoke shells, plus I’ve got 9 Platoon’s 2in mortar in the right wood. So I don’t have to wait for smoke, I can deliver it directly. Smoking up the PaKbox should allow me to close with it and either flank it or have enough Churchills standing by to punch it on the nose when the smoke clears it shouldn’t get too many shots off.
First though, I need to make sure there are no more long range antitank threats in the left wood. So 12 troop comes up behind 9 platoon, stays in defilade from the PakBox behind the corner of the right wood and uses it as a pivot to pie off the left wood.
There’s not much resistance. The previously spotted MG nest has a go at the opened up tank commanders and gets knocked out in return. There aren’t any other signs of the enemy. There’s probably something in the wood- there are signs of trenches and it just makes sense to defend it- but nothing is engaging the Churchills so I probably just need to worry about the AT gun in the bunker.
9 Platoon’s 2in gets it’s smoke out- right in front of the PakBox’s aperture- and while it’s blinded all 5 remaining troop Churchills deploy to engage the bunker. 12 Troop are forward on the right, next to 9 Platoon. The two tanks left in 11 Troop come up further back on either side of the FO house.
The wind is gentle, but the smoke rises faster than I had anticipated and the PaKBox fires underneath it to open proceedings. It’s first shot pancakes on the front hull armour of 11 Troop’s HQ, lightly wounding the commander, who was opened up.
Then both 11HQ and 12B spot the PaKBox and engage. It gets one more shot off, bouncing an AP shell off 12B’s front, but 11HQ puts a round through the aperture at the same time.
Soon all the Churchills join in and riddle the aperture with torrents of MG fire and multiple 75mm shells, swiss-cheesing the gun shield and killing the crew.
Chokepoint Overmatch Achieved
That’s excellent news. The antitank threat is still there: there’s at least one more AT gun out on the right in depth and German infantry always has its effective hand-held antitank weapons, but right now I’ve established local overmatch.
The Churchills get on line and smother the left wood and the chokepoint buildings with HE shells and machinegun fire and there’s nothing the German defenders can do about it. The edge of the left wood is lined with trenches, including the corner with the chokepoint where a Panzershreck gunner gets nailed.
The tanks are shooting the left wood up, but actual targets are few and far between. I’m sure there’s more than I’m seeing, potentially deeper in the wood, so I decide to give the closer side a dose of 3in mortars before sending 6 platoon up to seize it.
9 Platoon hit the buildings, the 88 appears
That’ll take some time to call in, so in the meantime I send 9 Platoon up to grab a toehold in the buildings. 12 Troop is supporting them, but the infantry are delayed first by the need to remount their vehicles and then by rough terrain along the side of the road.
The target buildings did have some enemy infantry in them, but they’re long gone after prolonged attention from the tanks. That encourages me to push 12HQ and 12A a little further forward to better back up the infantry as they go in.
They move out into the open where there’s a gap in the cover offered by the buildings and the left wood. 12 HQ pops some smoke to cover it for the upcoming Kangaroos, but gets hit in the process. Something penetrates the turret, killing the loader and radio operator, but the tank is still in action.
Obviously there’s another antitank gun in depth, keyholed onto that gap. Judging from the angles it’s probably in another wood out in the deep left, but I’ve got no spots for now. I should be able to get some eyes in that direction once the infantry come up on either side of the chokepoint.
9 platoon discovers that the buildings are clear. They occupy them without any problems, but like any sensible defensive position the real meat is not on the outside edge. There’s a line of trenches behind the buildings, on the other side of a hedge, and the scattering of German infantry in there are supported by another trenchline in the edge of the small wood across the field behind them.
9 Platoon are on their own again for a little while. I can’t support them very effectively until I clear the edge of the left wood or neutralise the AT guns in depth. But they’re not in intense contact and their supporting Ram Kangaroos are able to keyhole gaps in the buildings and engage with their hull MGs.
If anything, the small wood looks like a prime target for the 25pdrs and given my timeline- the 3in mortars are only just starting to fall on the left wood and I’ll need to adjust them off before 6 Platoon’s assault even begins- this is probably the best opportunity to start calling the artillery in.
So 9 Platoon’s HQ goes up into one of the attics to get a good view and start the process. While they’re up there, they spot the antitank gun that took out Otter B. It’s another PaK40, just to the right of the small wood. With the desultory fire coming from the buildings I shouldn’t have been surprised that the gun crew decide to get stuck in- there are casualties and I’m really very lucky that although 9 Platoon’s leader goes down, his platoon sergeant is able to continue the call for fire.
6 Platoon Storm in
Meanwhile, 6 Platoon is finally able to go in. I’ve shifted the mortars left to cover their flank and rush up the map under covering fire from the Churchills. They’re aimed at the edge of the left wood between the trench on the chokepoint side and another one leading towards some barns on the other side. I suspect both trenches are clear by now, or at least suppressed, but I’m not inclined to take chances.
So the Wasp is tagging along. It flames the chokepoint trench as the infantry hop out of their kangaroos, then switches to the other side and flames that trench as well. It’s probably redundant: the dismounts are well up the slope and into the wood by that point and their left flank has not only been smoked up the tanks but kept under fire by the Kangaroos.
The infantry secure the trenches up there and push forward, neutralising any potential close range antitank threat from the wood. That allows 12B to come up onto the shoulder of the chokepoint and engage the antitank gun on the right whilst staying in defilade to the one on the left.
At the same, 12HQ and 12A have peeked the right side of the buildings under smoke to engage the AT gun. 12HQ doesn’t seem to be firing its main gun- presumably because the loader position is empty- but between them the troop gets plenty of fire on target.
6 Platoon scores two more achievements by grabbing the edge of the left wood. First, they can now get some flanking fire on the trench behind the buildings and speed up 9 Platoon’s extended effort to pick off the Germans there.
Second, they neutralise another Panzershreck team at the far corner of the wood and- critically- spot the AT gun in the deep left.
Consolidating, the 88
It’s an 88, squatting in a little trench network on the edge of the wood over there. It’s a good 700m away, too far for me to be confident the Churchills will get away with a slugging match. It’s not like I can really bypass it either: it’s not only covering the chokepoint exit, but the plowed field beyond the buildings and the Road Junction objective. In theory I could smoke it up, but I doubt I’d be able to obscure it for anything like long enough with my remaining stock of smoke shells.
So it’s another job for the 3in mortars. They’re still hitting the left wood, but they’re on a harassing mission so they’ve still got a good 12 minutes of firing left. They’ve been called in by the Pioneer platoon HQ way back at the jumping off point, but there’s line of sight onto the 88’s position up at the chokepoint buildings so I chuck him back in his Stuart Kangaroo and send him up to make the adjustment.
That will take time, but it’ll still take effect well before the 25pdrs come in. Hopefully the 88 is the last major antitank threat and I’ll be able to get a move on.
We’re about an hour in at this stage, so there’s not that long left. The last bound forward to secure the small wood and the road junction could be tight.
There’s not much for me to do right now but mop up immediate targets, get organised and, inevitably, watch sand get in the gears.
Now that they’ve been adjusted onto the 88 the 3ins mortars are firing at much greater range and are conspicuously less accurate. It’s hard to tell if they’re doing any damage and if they’re not going to knock the gun out themselves, I need to take advantage of their suppressive effect while they’re still going to try and engage the 88 with my tanks.
At the same time, spotting rounds start coming in from the 25pdrs, but 9 Platoon’s HQ is too far back among the buildings to see them for corrections. They’re high up, but keyholed onto the small wood, with other buildings between them and the spotting rounds which are falling into the big field beyond the left wood.
So I move 9 Platoon’s HQ forward into one of the considerably more dangerous buildings with better line of sight, and bring 12HQ and 12A round to tackle the 88.
Thankfully, both efforts pay off. The Churchills struggle to spot or even engage in area fire thanks to the range and ground, but one of the last mortar bombs lands almost on top of the 88. It’s not clear whether that was enough, but soon afterward 12B scores a direct hit with a HE shell and seals the deal.
The 25pdrs start hitting the small wood on the same turn, so we’re on.
The Small Wood
I want my remaining fresh infantry- 5 Platoon- to tackle the final objective and 6 platoon is both out of position to tackle the small wood and needs to stay where it is to protect that flank.
So 9 Platoon are up again. The Churchills start moving forward into the ploughed field and I start adjusting the 25pdrs off the wood and onto the buildings at the other end of the Road Junction objective.
That, of course, takes time… time in which the enemy starts mortaring the chokepoint buildings again. Luckily they’re not very accurate and elements I have stacking up there for the attack are both somewhat armoured against fragments and mobile enough to scoot out of the way.
9 Platoon goes in alongside a ridiculous amount of machinegun fire with the HQ Churchill and the Wasp angling left across the road to enfilade the edge of the wood.
And they need to. Despite all the fire, there are some stubborn Germans willing to go down fighting and they catch 2 and 3 sections as they try to storm their trench. They’re quickly suppressed in return by the Kangaroos and the Churchills, then I send the Wasp in to flame them. Problem solved, but it might have been smarter to torch the position before the infantry assault got there.
The Endgame
9 Platoon aren’t really in a position to go deeper in the wood and properly clear the roadside and time is running out, so I decide to wing it. 11B and 12B are up on the chokepoint shoulder where they can sweep the wood and the objective with fire. That should help, but realistically 5 Platoon and the tanks going left will just have to deal with any flanking fire themselves.
They have quite a lot to deal with already though. The 25pdrs are still coming in, but there are spots amongst the buildings across the Kelven Strasse, including some mortars and even another antitank gun.
That gun turns out to be 37mm manned by some Volksturm though, so we’re clearly getting into the soft underbelly. The real problem starts to be whether I have enough time to clear out the objective, not whether the enemy can stop me.
One of the pioneer teams has joined 5 platoon’s 3 section in their Kangaroo and between them, some 95mm shells and a little pyromania, they grab the buildings on the intersection corner. There are Germans in the ditches along the main road, but they’re all poorly armed Volksturm. The Churchills roll up and drive them off without difficulty.
The last ten minutes or so look like they’re going to be an exercise in firepower application. I’ve got a toehold in the objective, I just to need to variously machinegun, blow up and flame any buildings across the road that look remotely like they might harbour any defenders.
With three minutes left, the Germans have had enough. The AI surrenders. There were only two living defenders still in the objective area- the Volksgrenadier battalion commander and his assistant up in an attic- and they were only armed with pistols. The Wasp was of fuel by this point, but I had so much combat power in the immediate vicinity it wouldn’t have been long before they went down.
Endex
Of course, I’ll take a surrender any day. And the butcher’s bill was not as high I thought it might be. I lost 33 men overall, plus one of the Churchills, all the Otters and the FO’s Loyd Carrier. The enemy lost 146 men, which is pretty much what you would expect given the mismatch in forces.
That doesn’t mean that the scenario was easy, but it was good fun. The British and Commonwealth force here felt almost like a proto Cold War BAOR force: it’s not that hard to draw a line between Churchills and Chieftains and Ram Kangaroos and FV432s.
But despite having the outline of things to come, we were firmly rooted in World War 2 here. Firepower was broadly less effective, so engagements were less decisive, everything went a little slower. There were options in the mix that I should have appreciated earlier, like the Churchill’s smoke shells, and definitely points where I dropped the ball: I didn’t have to lose the FO, the single Churchill or- potentially- all three of the Otters.
That’s by the by though. Obviously there are things I would do differently in hindsight. This was a solid scenario, it’s definitely got that late war 1945 feel and there are some cool new toys to play with, namely the Ram Kangaroos and- still potentially my favourite- the Wasp.
So, hope you all enjoyed this and found it interesting. If you’d like to see these videos early and support the channel you can do via Patreon and Youtube memberships. Whether you do or not, thanks for watching and I’ll catch you in the next one.