Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

It's a good thing I only said it was "quite possible" this one would be ready before the end of yesterday. There's always something unexpected that throws me off schedule.

Files

Actually, You CAN Own Digital Games - The Redstone Ned Zone (For Patrons)

Credits Music Anxiety Release and Vertigo from the Look Outside soudtrack by Eric Shumaker https://store.steampowered.com/app/3580350/Look_Outside_Soundtrack/ Brinstar Theme from Smash Bros. Ultimate https://youtu.be/-4XZHHek-uo?si=PHvaa35jfylcWmb2&t=128 The Redstone Ned Zone Theme by Jake Eyes https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GSg5rYn484g Sound Effects Door Slam by DSOADigital https://freesound.org/people/DSOADigital/sounds/362256/ Various alarm bell rings, harsh metallic 08.mp3 by TRP https://freesound.org/people/TRP/sounds/575236/ Hammering on Anvil by SamsterBirdies https://freesound.org/people/SamsterBirdies/sounds/363169/ DR05___0205_sandau_fähre.wav by miguelstar2 https://freesound.org/people/miguelstar2/sounds/198470/ Doorbell A by kwahmah_02 https://www.freesound.org/people/kwahmah_02/sounds/275072/ Ambience - morning - window - city - calm - pigeon.wav by ValentinPetiteau https://freesound.org/people/ValentinPetiteau/ cobblestoneroad 1 car 01 140807_01.wav by klankbeeld https://freesound.org/people/klankbeeld/sounds/245282/ Tape Deck Play and Stop Buttons by j_soundeffects https://freesound.org/people/j_soundeffects/sounds/845648/ angry mob loop.aiff by benjaminharveydesign https://freesound.org/people/benjaminharveydesign/sounds/316640/ Hevoset laukkaavat ohi, hevosjoukko / Horses galloping, passing by in the forest, single horses and groups, mix by YleArkisto https://freesound.org/people/YleArkisto/sounds/342329/ Strong Wind 03.wav by Tim_Verberne https://freesound.org/people/Tim_Verberne/sounds/518090/ Cracking Earthquake (cracking soil, cracking stone) by uagadugu https://freesound.org/people/uagadugu/sounds/222521/ rumble.wav by Corsica_S https://www.freesound.org/people/Corsica_S/sounds/94114/ Images Glitch, Green Screen, Transition. by saadelm on pixabay.com https://pixabay.com/videos/glitch-green-screen-transition-167765/ Screenshots from "The Simpsons" Season 6, Episode 18, "A Star is Burns" by Fox Broadcasting Company Screenshots from "The Simpsons" Season 12, Episode 16, "Bye, Bye, Nerdie" by Fox Broadcasting Company Footage from "God of War" (2018) by Santa Monica Studio Footage from "Marvel's Spiderman Remastered" by Insomniac Games Picture of Krumm from "Aaahh!!! Real Monsters" by Klasky Csupo Screenshot from "Fallout 3" by Bethesda Game Studios Fonts Minecraftia by Andrew Tyler https://andrewtyler.gumroad.com/l/minecraftia Crazy Killer by The Font Emporium on dafont.com https://www.dafont.com/crazy-killer.font We The People by K-Type on dafont.com https://www.dafont.com/we-the-people.font

Comments

mikee stash

I’ve been so excited for this one. Can’t wait to see Ned absolutely leather Sony.

MatrixPie

This video has actually changed my perspective on the whole disc thing. And that what I love about your content, always managing to be insightful in some unexpected way. Keep up the good work.

SecondtoInfinity

Good rhetoric on this one. You covered a ton of the standard counterarguments and the actual means of persuasion, the stuff we need to actually be doing as a culture.

SecondtoInfinity

And I have to ask how long that chunk corruption took. Did that whole thing run lagless?

Jake Eyes

That part had to be done with stop-motion. Every extra layer of the random wall took a few seconds to generate with Worldedit and there's supposed to be 30 of them every second. Ned and the nearest lamp post are the only live-action components of that shot.

mae

1. This video has enlightened me, as it has others, solid reasoning here. To be honest, piracy is really just stealing, and someone who isn't fooling themselves with moral justifications of "refusing billion-dollar companies their profits" know they're stealing. Then again, being broke is a fine enough reason; giving a tiny $30-or-so-sized 'screw you' to slimy publishers is icing on the cake, but it's not really hurting their bottom line in any way that matters, as, like Ned points out here, the average customer is far from willing to deal with all of that to get out of paying. 2. Using Ned as the persona for this type of video is a genius idea in my opinion. It's like a sheen of self-awareness/self-depreciating satire, but doesn't detract from the point. The absurdity of a fictional Minecrafter doing the commentary reminds people you're not an expert, which I think is likely to decrease the amount of angry reception as it may help people remember the nearly inherent pointlessness of petty online arguing. Also, what's with making Ned analogous to a climate change denier? That was obviously some sort of commentary... Maybe it'll hit me someday. 3. How do you do your stop-motion animations? Have you always just used worldEdit for them? Though maybe newer tools like Axiom could make it much easier. regardless, I remember the falling windmill rotor from a Thomas & Friends joke in one of the earlier 50 Ways videos being particularly impressive

mae

,sory for long comment.,

Clippy

Louis Rossman also made a video on how physical media is nothing. He even used the Crew as an example. One of the biggest games to kick off Stop Killing Games, and THEY HAVE A PHYSICAL DISK. 4 weeks later and he hasn't seemed to change too many people's opinions. Don't really understand. The problem is the corporate controlling how we play our games. Not disks. Sadly, even Minecraft isn't safe from this problem, in fact it's one of the worst offenders. You don't even "buy"(rent) the game itself, you "buy"(rent) an account. Absolute lunacy. It's really frustrating. And no, as a Steam user I'm not going to defend Steam from requiring games to launch through Steam either. Step 1 to to stop using the term "buy" where it doesn't apply. If a game requires connection to a corporate-owned server, that's renting. NOT ownership, so not a purchase.

Jake Eyes

1. When determining if any given act of piracy is like stealing, you need to consider whether or not anyone gets cheated out of anything by it, so piracy needs to be judged on a case-by-case basis. For example, if someone bought a digital game that's restricted by DRM, then pirates that same game so they can still play it even if the verification servers go down, then no one's getting cheated out of anything. Same goes for if someone were to buy a physical game on Ebay, then pirate the same game over the internet so they can play it a few minutes later instead of a few days later. In these cases, the only moral consideration left is the risk of exposing your machine to viruses. 2. Ned isn't necessarily a Mass Corruption Event denier as much as he's too focused on the gaming discussion to even care enough to hear the argument out in the first place. Remember that he shut the door on those kids before they even had a chance to fully make the MCE connection, so it's possible that he doesn't even know about it yet. So his crime isn't so much that he's ardently choosing to stay on the wrong side of history as that he just doesn't even care enough about it to find out what's going on in the first place. In real life, the rational reason for me not making a video about climate change or anything as important as that is because I don't think I have anything new to bring to the discussion that's going to change anyone's mind at this point, so it's probably not worth my time, whereas it seems to me that very few people know about GOG, so bringing that up has a better chance of being useful. But on top of that, there's also an emotional reason for choosing to make videos about the physical vs. digital debate rather than something more important. And the reason is that, somehow, I care about it more. Seeing people be ignorant about digital ownership online absolutely infuriates me in a way that these bigger issues don't, even though they're going to hurt WAY more people WAY more horribly. I think it's stupid that my and other people's emotions work that way, so I made Redstone Ned die of his own apathy to make fun of it. 3. I once had plans to make a tutorial series that would go into detail on how to do it, but then I discovered that it was going to be REALLY time-consuming and I'd rather use that time make other videos instead. So without going into too much detail, I use the teleport command to make sure I can put the camera back into exactly the same place for every frame, then I take a screenshot, then make changes to the world, then teleport back into place, then take a screenshot, etc. If an animation requires a 3D model, then I animate it in Blender, export it as a series of .obj files, and use a program called Binvox to voxelize the .obj's into Minecraft .schematic's. After doing that, what I USED to do was make an MCEdit script to import the series of .schematic files into a series of identical minecraft worlds, then use an AutoHotkey Script to visit each world one-at-a-time, teleport into the same place, and take a screenshot. But that method doesn't work for worlds created after version 1.12 because MCEdit was never updated past that point. So now I use Worldedit + an AutoHotkey script to paste the a schematic file into a single world, teleport into place, take a screenshot, then undo the pasting to set up for the next frame, paste the NEXT schematic file into the world, etc.

mae

yes! i accidentally laser-focused on only half of the definition, that is use of piracy in a cheating way, but region locks, games exclusive to older obsolete platforms, and even convenience if you already own a copy of the game are all valid thanks for taking the time to write this !! not much comment other than your words make a lot of sense

Clive Simmons

Hmm. This is certainly one of the more insightful commentaries I have heard on the situation. I will probably be linking this to a few friends once the video is posted to the wider YouTube audience. I will say that I do not have much hope for the viability of proper digital ownership, though. We have had restrictive DRM on everything for decades now. The only markets where we have digital freedom are some submarkets in PC gaming as you have mentioned (because older gamers have been actively burned by rapid turnover in DRM schemes before Steam came along) and music (because Sony BMG messed up their scheme very, VERY badly [1] and caused a big enough stink to scare the industry away for decades). Between movie encryption, license checks, and streaming, average consumers have gotten used to having to verify their ownership, and thus the market has no incentive to change anything. GOG, itch.io, and Tor Books are the only major competitors in all of media that I am aware of, and they simply do not command a large enough share of the market to matter. At this point, "digital ownership" will remain strictly the practice of smaller, more ideological actors. [1]. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sony_BMG_copy_protection_rootkit_scandal

Clive Simmons

Even with the help of WorldEdit, that sounds tedious. I admire your persistence.

Open Source Arras

Can't really say more than what the other comments have. Great video.

Nitjib

I agree, but both digital ownership and disc ownership is good. Why not both?

Natsun

Good vid Solid points 10/10

ParagonOfTorna2907

This video made me join the Patreon! Good stuff and good comments. I hate how so many people jump to dystopian conclusions and post them everywhere (like the "piracy isn't stealing" comment), even when they have logic to them, I just hate the rhetoric behind it. So this was great! I think the only pro-disc argument I've seen this video didn't really cover is the "tangibility". Some people like having the game on their shelf instead of digitally and they make more memories that way - but that will always be a subjective personal thing (and it's not something that really affects me, I'm just mentioning it). I think you hit the nail on the head, the real argument isn't that "discs are better" but rather that "the current way that digital media works is bad". From a theoretically purely neutral observer's perspective it will be fascinating to see what happens in this industry over the next 5 years or so. Uhh sorry for the long comment but I love these stupid videos and this one reminded me to join the Patreon as I should have done that earlier, keep it up :)

Flairey

ditto! Thanks Jake!

othello7

This actually opened my mind when I watched it. I think the main issue that I don't remember being addressed was that it is extremely difficult to be able to resell your games if they are in digital form. Historically you've always been able to sell your used games collection or games you didn't want. Great video though with a lot of excellent points.

Open Source Arras

Is the thumbnail/title gonna get updated soon? I figured you were gonna switch the more baity one out for this based on (iirc) what you told me in DMs, and I'm just wondering if it would perform better with the Patreon version. I feel like it's baity enough without being too long.