Need your opinion on a Pin! (Patreon)

So I maybe am gonna release some funky new pins in a while but need some advice from you! Do you think the symbol pin is too big? It's 4cm (1.5 inches) diameter (Pufferbunny pin for reference).

For fellow pin collectors would you like something that big or smaller? I'm at a loss on whats best!

I'd prefer to do a Poll here but the blasted thing wont let me add images ;-;