Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

WHALE TIME

Files

Rezero 1x10

Watch "Rezero 1x10" on Streamable.

Comments

Crimson Xero

Alicia, I'm not gonna lie, I'm kinda disappointed in you. I thought you'd have the emotional maturity & empathy to understand the "I love Emilia" scene, but instead you acted like Subaru lying to Rem would be the correct choice here. Not only that, but you've been focusing waaay too much on Subaru killing himself as if his life doesn't matter and treating death like it's nothing. I doubt you'll see this comment, but you're better than this... Edit: After reading the replies, I've realized that I sound super entitled & immature. I apologize for that...

TTJek

I believe people only disappear from memories by being eaten, not killed.

MMDXXX

So uh, when are we watching Guardians of the Galaxy Vol 3? (It's much better than Quantumania, I can promise you that)

Derpy

Reasonable crash out, haha

Darklordtimes123

Yeah I would be pissed if my rejection went this way.

Gram

God I love the From Zero scene, everything about it is just amazing. How Subaru understands his flaws, how he doesn't realize other people can truly love him the way he loves them, and even his response. Even though he had so much growth, I think the response he gave is so brilliant to demonstrate that even after recognizing one's flaws, there are always things to improve upon. One of the best anime of all time.

Getes

Damn, I was hoping Alicia would understand the “I love Emilia” scene

Reginald Madtail

Definitely understandable reaction on the confession. I didn't originally watch the series until like a good 7 or 8 years after it aired, but i distinctly remember it became a niche meme for a while. Just the screencap "I love Emilia" followed by someone throwing or breaking something. I didn't have the context at the time, but after seeing that episode it's even funnier in hindsight.

Moon

god... what a peak anime episode, may even be in my top 10 episodes of all time of any anime. i dont know how the patreon redeem system works but i hope to god we get you to watch past season one, truly a gem of an anime.

Matheus Filipe Lenz

From Zero is the episode where everyone tells that the show really starts. probably the best episode of the first season and it really showcases why the characters and dialogues in Re:Zero are so well written. Also, REM only works as she is because of how Subaru is, if he was any other way REM's character just wouldn't work.

Noel

Yep i also think that

Kampela

And thus Alicia understand why there is fight between team Rem and team Emilia shippers

III3NCORE

People acting like Alicia's reaction to the confession scene isn't what majority of the first time viewers were like aswell.

Noel

My thinking is when White Whale consumes you then you cease to exist in any form or shape, just being killed by it doesn't do the same

Anzor Wilson

Okay funny story. They're actually a what if light novel called Sloth if. About what would happen if he went with REM. Evidently he lived a long life and grew old with her. But his save point never updated so when he died he went right back to the moment before he left.

winter north

"Imma kill him" good news on that, rem already did

Lucas_oreki

Ive seen this in the comments here a lot how she "didnt understand it" and tbh i dont know what yall are talking about. Of course she doesnt want him to lie to her, that relationship would never work with that as a basis. She also openly says she appreciates Subaru for rejecting her and making it clear that he loves Emilia, her problem was only that he went on to elaborate that long. That being said, i think this episode is very much supposed to make viewers pick Rem's "side" so to speak, because she is a very lovable character and we want her to be happy. Rejections will always have thoughts of "what couldve been" strapped to it, Rem literally monologues about it. Alicia is just mad at that a character she likes is getting the short end of the stick here, but that does not mean at all that she thinks it is an error in the show. I do agree on the Subaru killing himself part tho, there could be more empathy on her side here, but I wouldnt hold it against a person to try to lighten herself up through this stretch of episodes specifically

Lucas_oreki

What did she not understand about it?

Anzor Wilson

Also I will say no one can make anyone love anyone else. Nothing you say or do will change anyone's mind. You are going to love someone or you aren't period. I never had a problem with Subaru's choice here as it is what it is. I love Rem, but you love who you love.

Schleep

Dude its never this serious. Saying that she “doesn’t have the emotional maturity or empathy 🤓” because of her personal opinion on a show is entitled as fuck. On top of that, she DID understand the scene but since she didn’t react the way you wanted you went straight to bitching and moaning

Anzor Wilson

Yeah you highly offended me in this one Alicia. And that is a hard thing to do to me.

Schleep

Reading some of these comments piss me off so bad. She had a completely valid reaction to one of the most controversial scenes in anime, GET OVER IT

Anzor Wilson

I was merely offended by some of her choice words of Subaru's character. Not even talking about the Rem thing really. Highly misrepresenting his character, which seem to be guided by emotion and bias.

Lucas_oreki

Tell me where she said anything different in her reaction. She does respect his decision, but why isnt she allowed to be frustrated on Rem's behalf for a moment here, a character that is put into this deeply uncomfortable, bittersweet position but is too kind to show her loved one any of that frustration?

Lucas_oreki

Its a bit crazy to me how almost 10 years later, this is still a topic that gets people this riled up. Like why is it not possible to like Rem more than Emilia and want her to be happy and still at the same time acknowledge that this is not the way the story will go. Alicia literally even says at the end that she hopes, Rem gets over it and finds true love down the line, but somehow people here are saying she wanted them to get away together. I'm so confused

Anzor Wilson

Good sir did you not hear the part where. You know what I will just put a timestamp. 27: 22. Is the portion when I wrote this comment.

Sniper Delta

She fully understood the scene. It just is a little weird to include the part where he lists the things he wants to do for Emilia. Its just kinda unnecessary. The scene didn't need it and it really only would serve the purpose of hurting Rem.

Mojo

idk man. Subaru is kinda awful early on. The development happens later on.

Mojo

The comment section here just proves that Re:Zero fans are still capable of being incredibly cringe 10 years later over the 'I love Emilia' scene. STFU and let her form her own opinions & thoughts.

Lunarbeats

Looking at these comments baby raging makes me laugh so damn hard, man. Alicia fully understands Subaru and is valid in the rejection crash out, she even acknowledged it prior when Subaru asked Rem to run away with him stating she wouldn't get with him because he's chasing after Emilia and during Rem's whole confession of how she looks up to Subaru. And I say this cause its after this point that Subaru REALLY begins his character arc of growth and its LITERALLY because of Rem pulling him out of his own self-destructive ouroboros. The Subaru Rem idealizes isn't the one that wanted her to run away with him, tail tucked between his legs, hands over his ears. The Subaru she idealizes is the one who's the problem solver, the one who despite adversity after adversity got back up and managed to save the day. Sure she doesn't know the pain it took to get there, but that's the Subaru she knows. They're both chasing idealized versions of what they want but for Rem, she sees past the façade Subaru puts up, the man she idolizes is there, there's no falsity to that Subaru despite what he says, cause if it was as easy to give up as he said, he wouldn't have tried so hard to fix the very problems that weren't his to fix. That takes bravery. Cause despite all that he is, Subaru still chose to put himself out there to fix the problem. And now, from zero, his character arc begins.

AstralPrime

I say this as someone who's favorite character is Subaru: Alicia was right in everything that she said and that is because of Subaru's decisions. Every single thing she said was fully justified, toxic behavior is not justified by trauma and, even if made up for, her criticisms were 100% fair for what he was doing in the moment. He is a flawed character that becomes better as time goes on, that is the point of the shitty.

Kano Misogi

Saw this live and liked her reaction, but was curious how the comments would be. All I can say is god I'm happy this is a Patreon exclusive. I can image how annoying the YT comments would be if this was posted on YT

Bob Mcblob

We figured out the actual reason Theresia wasn't forgotten in season 3.

King

I'm fully pro Emilia. Rem's just easier to like 'cause she's a simp and ideal waifu material for most Otakus, but her getting rejected won't gaslight me into feeling bad for her haha

Adam

Okay, pro "woman who barely notices you exist" guy XD

King

That's because her character doesn't revolve solely around Subaru. She's a far more interesting character... Also kinda helps that she wouldn't try to kill you on your first meeting

Tallguy605

I saw the crash out from "I love Emilia" coming a mile away and loved every second of it

Kenneth Stai

Valid, though I think you may be misinterpretting a bit what Rem is doing here. This isn't about her confessing or her trying to make Subaru fall for her. Its about her trying to help someone she deeply cares about and be there for them. She isnt saying this to make him fall for her, shes saying it cause shes trying to lift him back up and get him standing again. Also this episode always causes so much debate lol though after looking through the comments, I feel people may be a bit overreacting cause the comments don't feel as bad as some others in the comments are saying they are?

Lucas_oreki

As I said, getting frustrated on the behalf of Rem and playing it up for content. You dont have to take everything reaction streamers say at face value, while ignoring the parts in the reaction where she shares here genuine thoughts and shows understanding

Getes

She was right to say he was infatuated, that he didn’t value Emilia’s opinions and all that, but that’s what this turning point is for him. He does love Emilia, but he was deluded by his sense of being a “protagonist” and his version of her he built up, two things that were torn apart over these episodes with Betelgeuse being a twisted extreme of Subaru’s infatuation with Emilia, with his being directed at the witch. Rem knows he loves Emila, this whole scene she isn’t confessing to make him love her, it’s to pull him from his lowest point. And Subaru ABSOLUTELY loves Rem, as he states later multiple times, holding her on the same level as Emilia. But his self doubt and hatred clouded his views of others and warped together with his self centered views to make it where he got the worst of both worlds. He felt like he could be a hero without having done anything to deserve it, but also that he was unable to be loved by those he cares about. It’s why he’s so confused and asks why Rem likes him so much. The warped view of Emilia fades but he still loves her because he realizes through all his loops she’s still one of the only people who really continuously stayed by his side, from taking his side against Ram or even staying to help him when he couldn’t offer any help in return. They never had as deep a moment as what was happening right then with Rem, but his feelings for Emilia had been there since the start and even clear headed he sees all that she did with him for him to still love her. It just sucks because Rem gets all this screen time compared to Emilia in season 1 so it really makes her look blander in comparison. I will always be team Rem but I get what the author was going for and Subaru couldn’t just lie to Rem in this really open and close moment

thedangmaster

I pray for we all get a Rem in our lives

Ranginald Vagel

This episode had me tweaking on the level of donut man I was flipping out in my college dorm. I don’t think I will ever feel the desire to reach through dimensions and throttle a fictional character Simpson-style that strongly again.

Ranginald Vagel

There are only the stances pro-Rem and other because there are 0 reasons to ship bro with Emilia at this point. I respect getting annoyed with the sheer ferocity of the pro-Rem people though.

frederik wøhliche

true, i feel like alot of people who have seen the show before like myself tend to crash out on others critizizing subaru early because we know how he developes later and how his flaws look like combined with it, it makes sense for a new watcher to dislike subaru early because of how he acts

frederik wøhliche

i think its just kinda funny how we always preach, love who you love and dont be with someone you cannot see yourself with and yet we still crash out on subaru for daring not to pick rem because she said she loves him ? its just as fucking silly as people who get angry at emilia for taking so long to care about subaru, why is it that we cant help ourself from getting frustrated with his choice here of not picking up rem if taht is how he feels at the moment ?

King

I'd have to disagree. Even if at this point, Emilia has no romantic feelings toward him, she's still a friend, and was the first to trust him (maybe second if you count Reinhard?). I have no doubt that Rem murdering him left a sour taste in a lot of people, so it'd be easy to see why someone would prefer the elf waifu, who has been friendly and helpful from the start

Aphro Spuds

I don't strictly disagree with your thoughts, but the disappointed parent approach is wild. It's a live reaction to a fictional story while on camera, this is the bottom of the barrel for places to make moral judgements about a person

Cyric Sherburne

I believe in order for the Whale to erase memories it has to actually EAT the person, since Puck referred to it as Gluttony. If it just kills someone and leaves their body behind people would still remember the person

Karatsuki

I mean you said it yourself, when the white whale eats dudes they get erased but I think theres about a billion other ways the whale can kill you apart from nomming on you. Why instantly go "the guys lying"?

frederik wøhliche

ah yes...another moment of subaru rejects cute rem whom we like so now we dislike him for rejecting someone he does not see himself with, funny how people just cannot accept that he did not want to be with her at the moment

Runelight

I mean Alicia did say she understands that part, but he could of just said he loves someone else. Instead of going on an entire speech about what he loves about the other girl directly to the one he rejected. Like he could of said "Sorry Rem, but I love Emilia" then go straight into asking her for help. Save listing all the things you like about Emilia for Emilia.

Sam Marsh

Rem is definitely best girl, and I hope that one day she finds a man who will treat her like the queen that she is.

VolkFangr

Man, the "I love Emilia" part is the response Rem was trying to get, I don't understand why everyone gets so furious at this part, I thought it was beautiful that she managed to get him back on his feet.

cry_w

Eh, people still remember the Rem v Emilia waifu wars, so they might just be sensitive to the whole thing.

Bologna Amputation

I mean, the patreon comments are a shining example of lack of nuance and media illiteracy too. I dread to imagine what the Youtube ones would.

Bologna Amputation

Christ dude, it's like the anime produces an emotional response or something. Don't be a wiener.

Bologna Amputation

Accepting Rem's happiness even though it's not the happiness she wanted first, or that we would have wanted for her is one of the hardest things in this anime, but it's definitely a lesson in life that we can all stand to learn.

Lucas_oreki

I wouldnt say anyone is overreacting, its mostly a civil discussion considering it is that divisive of an episode.

One G. O A. T. One Dream

"Sorry I love Emilia" still remains as one of the funniest Anime memes. I dont blame most people for being mad down for Rem and cursing the crap out of Subaru for rejecting her. But I also dont think its fair calling him a ass for having a dream and going for it. Like Subaru has the right to like who he wants to, even if you think hes stupid for it. And Rem is not dumb she know he wants Emilia and she wants him to do that. And Emilia is not some bitch, shes a person who truly DOSE need help, who has really no one but a Puk and a PDF clown on her side. lol its funny how heated over this people get, and lets just agree thats becuse its amaizing deep story telling.

DukeGurren

Honestly, it's an understandable knee jerk reaction because we had about a whales worth (heh) of emotion poured into us by focusing on Rem in this episode. And while I half agree with Alicia saying he should shut up about Emila, I think that he wasn't just saying it to Rem but also to himself because he started this whole conversation with trying to, incencerily, run away with Rem.

Lucas_oreki

Sure, i totally agree with that. Subaru has no obligation to reciprocate Rem's love (although he does clearly love her in a platonic way ofc) I also dont wanna say that Subaru doesnt get to have autonomy over his feelings and decisionmaking. But after all he went through, his own self loathing and multiple scenes in the show questioning if his actions are even from a place of true love for Emilia and not from his selfish desires, I think it also is totally valid for the viewer to question if he truly loves her after all. Rem makes him confront all of that in this scene, and without judging if the other outcome wouldve been better or worse for the show writing wise, this choice can go both ways. And Subaru chose to believe in his love for Emilia.

DukeGurren

Going on about Emilia at the end I think is similar to how, after Rem told him all the things she loves about him, he was still in the depths of his self loathing and she had to repeat those things to fully pull him out. Subaru talking about Emilia is not just an admission to Rem about what he really thinks and wants but also to tell himself how selfish it was to try and run away with Rem when he didn't feel the same way about her. Could it have been handled better? Perhaps, but I this was the response Rem wanted to be sure that Subaru wasn't lying or running away anymore... that she really did save him from his self hatred and loathing, just like he saved her.

Lucas_oreki

I do like this viewpoint and agree with it, but i think there is enough room for interpretation here so that I wouldnt really call it "not understanding the scene" when someone arrives at a slightly different conclusion. In my mind, Rem's confession isnt 100% a selfless thing solely done for helping Subaru out of his lowpoint. I think, in a hypothetic scenario where Subaru does accept her confession but they still both make the decision to save Emilia (bc they are both still contracted to her and as you say, Subaru does put both of them onto a very similar level emotionally), Rem would never say "No" to Subaru's feelings. After all, one of Rem's main character themes is about sometimes making selfish choices to achieve her own happiness. Of course, the author chose for Subaru to rlly cement his love for Emilia here, and to me, this decision is what truly ends Rem's character arc for this season

Lucas_oreki

I believe this moment is that divisive completely by choice. The whole episode (plus honestly the entire arc prior to this) is made so much for the viewer to start rooting for Rem and care for her very much. Then this entire scene happens, firing on all calibers emotionally, just to culminate in this flatly stated truth "I love Emilia". Its the ultimate ragebait xD But its also fucking peak

Gai Valentine

And here we see the most infamous and volatile of all the Waifu Wars. Rem vs Emilia raged on for years.

DeathHawk31

Yeah, I don't like subaru, I realize now I just watch this to see him suffer and to watch all the other characters who are much more interesting

Julio Castillo

In another edition of....... "People didn't understand what Rem was trying to do in this whole conversation" - The Episode.

jdoggivjc

First, as heartbreaking as it was for Rem to be rejected by Subaru, Rem gave her confession knowing she was going to be rejected, because her confession was never about landing Subaru for herself; it was about getting Subaru back on his feet and get him back to being the hero hero she fell in love with in the first place - the one that chased after Emilia. Second, this episode is actually the divergence point for an alternate timeline story written by the Re:Zero author Tappei Nagatsuki called Re:If (Sloth), Sloth:If, or Rem:If, where Rem actually agreed to run away to Kararagi with Subaru, and most of the things that Rem fantasized about in her confession actually came to pass in the alternate timeline. Sloth:If is actually a part of Tappei's April Fools' "sins" gag series where Subaru takes up the characteristics of a particular sin, and it affects the story being told. While Sloth:If is really good, some of the other ones are far better - I'm thinking Greed:If is probably the best one - but I can't elaborate on it because it has heavy S2 spoilers.

Getes

I absolutely see where you are coming from and apologize in how I worded what I said, it wasn’t right for me to say she didn’t “understand the scene” just because she had a different view from me. I think I was feeling negative towards her conclusion based on previous things she said like how she kept just telling him to die when a big point is he needs to care about his own life too, and I got ahead of myself. Your take on the scene is a very thoughtful one and I thank you for sharing it. I could absolutely see that as a way the scene could be taken as well

DukeGurren

Happens 90% of the time sadly

BakaSama

The Rem vs Emilia Waifu Wars were legendary and fierce. I like Emilia as a character (even more so post S1), but I still put Rem ahead. I can’t really go into full details as to why as it goes into Spoiler territory, suffice to say Rem’s affection for Subaru seemed more genuine and Emilia’s was more platonic or matronly (for lack of better words).

ZukuUzu

She knows, it's just annoying lmao.

Cory

I believe it has been redeemed up to halfway through season 2

John Grechko

Actually no, the White Whale was simply called Gluttony. Sin Archbishop Gluttony and the White Whale Gluttony, are two different things Just to avoid the confusion

John Grechko

Fun fact Alicia! There is an entire side story, a Sloth What If of rem actually said yes, left everyone to die, and went west, so yes…it was an actual possibility of rem saying yes :V Also…anime cut it out, but Subaru said in the novels and manga he did indeed feel SOMETHING for her, and if Emilia allowed it, second wife (though I'm sure that is just even more upsetting to hear lol)

Grandmasta

not giving the verbal essay on every single reason he loves Emilia, to the face of the girl that loves him whom he just reject, is not lying. What Alicia is saying is he should have left out the verbal essay of why he loves emelia after saying "I love Emelia". He should have just left it at that.

Kap

simparu only likes emilia cuz he has an elf fetish. He knows nothing about emilia and has made 0 effort to get to know her, only constantly simping over her like a desperate incel begging for a crumb of pussy.

Kap

his character arc of being dead weight and needing everyone else to save him? or the character arc of being the perfect representation of simps desperate for a crumb of e-girl pussy?

Kap

dude was going for the MT route. hide the children

Kap

I'm glad Alicia gets the truth of this anime, that Subaru is a fucking loser and Rem is best girl. All the Emilia fans have to use head canons and twitch simp logic to justify why Emila is a good character and not just the authors elf fetish. Subaru doesn't "love" Emilia, he lusts after her. He fell for her appearance back when he felt that the world was just an eroge dating sim. He never once listens to her or gets to know her.

JustThatOtherDude

I WANT REM IN A DIFFERENT ANIME!!! >ma'am may I suggest Loser Heroines? XD

Vincent

from what I assume, if you are eaten by the whale you are forgotten, if you are killed by the whale you are remembered

Mikal Adkins

I'm so excited for Alicia to experience S2 and S3 down the line. It's gonna be awesome.

Kap

The question about the white whale that view think about is how people know it's killed anyone or s even a threat of anyone t kills is erased from memory? Wouldn't it be viewed as just a strange beast that occasionally damages property but doesn't harm anyone directly? Maybe the whale is blamed for a ton of murders, idk

Twisted Fictions

People CAN survive an encountered with it, and THOSE PEOPLE would come back and report it. Further, if entire caravans were destroyed you may not remember the people IN IT, but you'll notice your missing cart of potatoes and go looking. It'd take time to connect every incident and report but EVENTUALLY some would figure it out.

WillGlacier

Idc about Subaru's feelings, even if dude goes with Amelia I'd FORCE him into polygamy with Rem too my girl deserves better 😭

Red Lightning

I just want to know why Subaru loves Emilia so much in this point in time? I just dont get it. I get she was basically the first person that was nice to him and trusted him when he arrived in this world, but is that really it? There has to be more right? Being pretty, nice, and caring couldn't have left such a strong impression on Suburu, right? I keep trying to think of a good explanation that doesn't involve the witch of envy pulling some invisible strings, but nothing sticks. It doesn't feel like love. It feels like infatuation. The only comparison i can make is when a guy briefly encounters a girl who is nice to them, and they suddenly "fall in love" and envision their entire life together with the girl. It just seems a bit much given how many times they interacted and how much info they know about one another. For rejecting rem, I can guess he still has trauma from rem killing him, but it doesnt look like that line of thinking is ever explored, so its only speculation. I just need some definitive answers.

Kap

All they would know is that a large animal destroyed some wagons but never killed anyone. It would be easier to assume that the animal just doesn't like large groups of wagons being under or next to it, maybe views them as a threat, but won't kill anyone because of it. We the viewer know otherwise, but for a character in the world of Subaru's Simping Isekai the whale just destroys wagons. A survivor or 2 would wonder why they tried to lead a caravan on their own and figure they were just being stupid to try this venture

Real Human

I would bet the white whale has killed people without eating them as well and left bodies in rubble of caravans or in some other fashion. That would explain how they know of it as a threat, and how they know several of its victims.

Cheese

He's so attached to her for a similar reason that Rem is attached to him, but I can't fully explain without spoiling early season 2

Cheese

I'm guessing there are often still bodies left behind. People report surviving an encounter with the whale at a certain place and when they investigate it there are a bunch of corpses nobody recognises. They probably put two and two together.

Cyber

I was ripping my hair apart affter the rem love confession and the "i love emilia" But after a few rewatches, at least he's being honest to her, and rem knew from before that she's not confessing her love to him because she expects him to love her... she loves him anyway, she just needed him to find his own goal to fight for again, whatever it would have been.

Cheese

Nah it's the fog that erased the memories of people

Cheese

That could not be more wrong. Subaru's love for Emilia is not completely healthy at this point but he does have real feelings for her, they just don't completely make sense to the viewer until season 2

Cheese

Wait I forgot, this is incorrect. The whale kills several people with methods other than the fog, which is the thing that erases memories/traces of their existence, so it does leave dead people behind who can be remembered. Also people being erased can leave logical inconsistencies. For example, if a squadron has to have say 20 people and after the fight they only have 15, while they can't remember the missing people and will only be able to remember ever having 15 members, they know that doesn't make any sense. The author has stated that if people try really hard they can remember that there was someone that used to exist but they can't remember any details of them. The whale does erase the traces of people existing but doesn't literally rewrite history, it's more of a mental block, so people could figure it out. Also it's possible they did some magical analysis of the fog or something who knows

Cheese

Ok a lot of people here are throwing out theories and asking questions and stuff without knowing the actual explanations, so I'll do the best I can without spoiling anything (you'll learn more later so this is only a partial explanation). First, the whale and Theresia. The actual memory/reality erasing power the White Whale has comes from its fog, the "Fog of Elimination". It can use the fog as a weapon and if it kills someone with it all memory of them is erased along with the traces of their existence. It's been stated by the author that if people try really hard they can remember that there was someone who used to exist but can't remember any details of them, so there are ways to record how many people it has killed. This implies that Theresia van Astrea didn't die to the fog, which it is fair to be suspicious of given the vast majority of people who die to the whale are erased from existence, but doesn't mean she definitely didn't die to the whale. I can confirm it's not a plot hole but I can't say much more since we'll dive into the history of the Astrea family much later. Now for Subaru and Rem. First off, yes, Subaru is being, as Rem puts it, "a cruel man" here. That said, he's not being as much of an asshole as it first seems, and Rem isn't just letting him get away with it because she loves him so much. The reason he goes on a bit about how much he loves Emilia is that while it's harsh he wants to make sure Rem knows she 100% does not have a chance. Subaru basically just offered to elope with her so it is entirely reasonable that if he just said "I'm sorry, but I love Emilia" she might think "yeah, but you're clearly considering me so I'm going to keep trying". He doesn't want to string her along with false hope of becoming the one he loves most, so he makes his feelings for Emilia completely clear, essentially saying "I need you to understand that my heart will always belong to Emilia and I cannot ever completely reciprocate your feelings. Will you help me despite that?" Subaru IS ashamed to be saying this, especially since he just asked her to elope with him, hence the "it's also hard for me to ask this of someone who rejected my once in a lifetime proposal", but compared to the embarrassment of just laying all his self hatred out on the table in front of her it's not that bad, so he says it kind of lightly. Now for why Rem acts the way she does. You might notice that Rem takes it shockingly well. In fact, when Subaru says he loves Emilia, her response is just "yes". She already knew he loved Emilia and has accepted that. Her confession wasn't because she expected him to love her back, it was purely because she saw his self hatred and wanted to counter it with her love. She had been living her whole life in guilt, seeing herself as never enough and just a lesser replacement for her sister. He came along and not only cared about her for her, separate from her sister, but allowed her to care for herself again and overcome her trauma. As such she is incredibly grateful to him, honestly to an obsessive and unhealthy extent, arguably being sort of dependent on him for her self worth (calling him her reason to die for example). When she sees Subaru's self hatred it mirrors her own previous self loathing. What she is really trying to do here is repay Subaru by doing the same thing that he did for her, showing that despite his self hatred someone will still care for him. That's why she's so calm about him loving Emilia, while it still stings to hear she never expected anything different, and in a way she was actually trying to remind him of his love for her. That doesn't make it any less heartbreaking, in fact knowing that Rem is saying all this to save Subaru despite knowing it means giving up on being with him is even more heartbreaking, but she's not stupid or blinded by love, the conversation ended exactly as she intended. I interpret the final bit where she laughs along to his "also hard to ask this of someone who rejected my once in a lifetime proposal" comment to be her thinking "yeah, you're a bit pathetic and kind of an asshole, but I love you and most of all I'm glad you're ok now and I was able to repay you a little". Finally onto the endless debate of whether Subaru should get with Rem instead of Emilia. First off, Subaru's feelings. No, Subaru is not just infatuated with Emilia. His feelings for Emilia are at least as real as Rem's love for him. I can't give the main reason he feels so strongly for Emilia without spoiling early season 2, but I can give some reasons we already know as to why he loves Emilia more than Rem. The most obvious reason is that Rem murdered him multiple times pretty horribly. The final time she killed him she intended to torture him to death before Ram mercy killed him. Emilia on the other hand has always been extremely kind to him. Even when he basically shouted a slur at her in the street she was relatively reserved in her response and when he was being beaten up after humiliating her at the royal selection she still cared for him enough to panic, abandoning the ongoing meeting and rushing to him. I understand that since Subaru has forgiven her and does care for her deeply it's easy to forget the murder and torture, but that trauma isn't going to just easily go away. While the anime cut it, Subaru has already developed self-harming habits to cope with the fear and trauma at this point, he hasn't just completely overcome the things that have happened to him. Also, less important but while Subaru is a horny teenage boy and comments on Rem's chest, he's simply not as attracted to her as he is to Emilia, who is EXACTLY his type (again though it's not JUST infatuation, I can explain when we're further into the show why he's so attached to her). But still, Rem would be a better partner for him, right? Well first off, whether she would or not is kind of irrelevant, it's hard to control how we feel and the heart wants what the heart wants, especially with a man as impulsive as Natsuki Subaru. Remember this is the man who when given the opportunity to ask for incredible riches just asks for Emilia's name and then later to be employed as a servant. But secondly no, Rem would not be better for him. While she is somewhat aware of his flaws and doesn't quite put him on a pedestal like Subaru does to Emilia, she is very willing to overlook them. She lets Subaru go out and make a fool of himself at the royal selection when she really shouldn't have for example. While she won't let him give up she will let a lot of his negative traits slide and I can't imagine a relationship between them would be healthy. On the other hand Emilia has already more than once called out his behaviour. Also, Rem is just too dependent on Subaru and obsessed with him for it to be healthy, there's just a nasty power dynamic there. Rem sees him as the entire reason she's able to have self worth, she is already more than willing to die for him while her feelings are unreciprocated - Subaru would never learn and grow from a relationship with her. Rem doesn't just love Subaru, she has a dependence on him. Emilia on the other hand doesn't even love him yet. It's not that she's necessarily opposed to it, but if and when she comes to love him it will be much more equal. (Well actually if it was with Subaru as he is right now it could be just as toxic with Subaru being the dependent one but that will be addressed later). Despite all this Subaru actually does love Rem, almost as much as Emilia in fact, but Emilia is first in his heart. All this is a very long winded way to say, don't hate the characters. They're very well written and have good reasons for their actions, even if they aren't perfect. So many people just become obsessed with Rem to the point that it kinda ruins their enjoyment of the show. I love this show so much, it's beautiful and has genuinely changed my life and the way I look at the world, I hope you can continue to enjoy it too.

StorytellerDave

You wrote an entire novel, but it is a pretty good one.

StorytellerDave

I think it's important to keep in mind that Subaru has a lot more memories with Emilia thant Emilia does with Subaru. It's interesting that in his first run Subaru knowing nothing of the world actually gave Emilia what she wanted the most, for someone to treat her the same as anyone else. Even when she literally calls herself Satella after the witch of envy, Subaru has no idea what that is yet, so he just goes along with it and sees a side of Emilia that he wishes he could see again.

StorytellerDave

Rem literally murdered Subaru multiple times, Emilia gave him nothing but kindness even when she was angry at him, she is still compassionate and understanding.

StorytellerDave

I think people forget how little time passed. The phone is actually a great indicator, bc it sfill has charge, and people instantly question it, but lile, it's only been about a week? Maybe a few days over. In a similar veib, people really forget that Rem freaking killed Subaru twice jist a few days ago. Yeah he is close with her now, but that doesn't go away. It's like when you get bitten by a stray dog. There will be a little intrusive thought at the back of your mind from then on. Whenever you play with a dog you will have hat tiny feeling that you might just get bitten, even if it's a dog you trust.

WillGlacier

So Alicia is just ignoring the fact that Willhelm INCLUDING LIKE ALL THE OTHERS remember PEOPLE dying to the Whale? I'm suprised the ONLY thinks he is sus and not all the others grieving people who have died

Cheese

Lmao thanks

Kino

Also, there's the Sloth What If side story that does explore what him choosing to run away with Rem means. The Author also confirmed that whenever he dies of old age in that route he's going to restart from the Appa guy. I keep hoping they'll adapt that once we reach Arc 7 or 8, that they'll do all of the What Ifs. Cause you can't do a few of them yet as they introduce characters that won't appear til arc 7 at least

Kino

Satella would probably get envious as is her nature and kill Emilia and then Rem while making Subaru watch

Cyber

I didn't know about the new character of arc 7 as I'm barely keei9up with the anime. But yeah it's interesting to know that if he dies of old age there he'd return to the app guy, because he could continue to fight then with more knowledge but also he could just... Run away with rem again, after he lived his life with her. Especially if she died before him like she wanted. Honestly? I know the sloth alternative may have been designed as a "bad ending" to some from what I heard about the family drama but I'm sorry, at this stage in the anime without knowledge of future character development, Rem is the absolute best girl... I think she ties with Alice from sword art online for me, who herself barely nudged down Asuna to me back then. For nostalgia reasons. I can't think of any anime character right now who's better than best girl Rem. I'm sure I'm missing someone but that's just how hard I have to think about it vs rem being top of my mind as the best girl.

Kap

Rem killed him twice. Both times were due a belief that he was out to harm Emilia and the Roswall estate. Emilia showed kindness simply because she is a kind person, naively so. Rem and Emilia have different personalities; one has dealt with extreme hardship and watched as her village was slaughtered, the other has had to deal with the stigma of being a half-elf. Th is has shaped their views of the world and the people who inhabit it. Rem knows to not take everything at face value while Emilia believes that most people are good to the point where she can be conned by someone’s words.

cry_w

No, it's been about a month or two. His phone is just an older model with a very good battery that he's been conserving the charge of.

Kap

Nice job with spoilers.

Kap

I know the whole story about the whale and inconsistencies Alicia brought up, but I was avoiding spoilers. Keep in mind what episode we are on.

Kap

Dude is a game otaku. I doubt he got much positive attention from girls his age.

cry_w

It was infatuation at first, but I'd venture it became love in Arc 2. She was there to comfort him when he was tearing himself apart. She was someone who continued to trust and have faith in him throughout every loop, despite not fully knowing his circumstances. The issue in Arc 3 occurred because he ended up taking that for granted, treating her as an anchor for his sanity rather than a person who's kindness and understanding does, in fact, have limits. Frankly, if you think the only thing she has going for her up to this point is "being nice," the same could be said of Rem and be similarly correct and incorrect.

Gai Valentine

At this point in the story, yes. Although that heavily changes throughout the show and it’s pure bias to not acknowledge that.

Anzor Wilson

Yo I was going to write some stuff but I read this and could not have put it much better. I thank you from the bottom of my heart for this.

Kap

Alicia does read the comments. Gotta stop with the spoilers.

Kap

For the sake of preventing spoilers, though judging from the other comments that ship has long sailed, I am commenting based on the information we have from the episodes viewed by Alicia. Though my bias for Rem is eternal because Rem is Best Girl in re:Zero

Cheese

Everything I've said here has either already been shown or was cut content from the novels. I suppose you could consider "we'll learn more later" to be a spoiler?

Cheese

This is such a non-spoiler 😭 Spoiler definition: "a description of an important plot development in a television show, movie, or book which if previously known may reduce surprise or suspense for a first-time viewer or reader." How is the fog an important plot development. In fact, how would explaining how the power works reduce surprise, suspense or literally ANY positive emotion. This is not "spoiling" anything for the viewer.

Kalinka

The old meme: I love Emilia. Definitely the wrong choice after everything that happened. And I don't know, but maybe considering how subaru got here and who emilia is, maybe there's more to his obsession with emilia down the line. Though propsfor the author to stick with it.

Kalinka

trust issues with wilhelm? Nah, all those other old warriors have similar pasts with the whale. It probably depends on how the whale kills them if they are remembered or not

StorytellerDave

I can see 1 month at most. First arc was just 1 day in the city, 2nd arc with the mabeasts was less than a week, he celebrated getting past day 3 as a big deal. The travel time was at most a day, so we are at about 1 week when the arc ends. Then they go back to the capital that's 1 more day and spend a few days there and then the first whale encounter would occur. The only variable is the downtime between arcs, so it could be 10 days on the short side of the estimate or 30 on the longer side. Definitely not more than that tho. Even old batteries when not used at all would not last 2 months. Personally I cannot imagine the downtime being more than 3 or 4 days totalled up, so I would say about 14 days from the start to the whale encounter is the closest.

Gildarts1#fan

you should have seen how this episode absolutely obliterated the community when it first came out.

leviathan_13

So, this is basically the meme about the "nice guy" (and I mean an actual nice guy, not the entitled creepy one) ignored by the girl who just chases "toxic relationships", except that the nice guy here is Rem XD.

grimreapercz

Agreed. Absolutely. Cannot. Wait. So excited.

Meur̃ect

between the mansion and capital arc it is mentioned that 1 month has passed. At this point it has been almost a month and a half since he came to this world

Meur̃ect

The fog was already mentioned in this episode, sure they didn't give a powerpoint on it, but they did imply that the fog is the cause of erased memory in the meeting with subaru

Turd Burgle Magelby

This episode always guts me, Rem deserved so much better. I can't stand Emilia myself

Spencer Thomas Randall

Some of your theories about his love or desire for Rem is destroyed by the novels. Rem basically convinces him to let her be his second wife. After the whale fight she pretends to be dead and gets a confession out of him and tells him that polygamy is a big thing in their world and she wouldn’t mind. Subaru agrees as long as Emilia is okay with it. All of this is wrongfully and completely removed from the anime.

MIce1987

Rem is the BEST! Honestly one of my favorite female anime characters ever. She deserves the world and more.

Snowy

I hope she continues watching this series ^^

HeavenlyNoomba

is someone going to tell her about the sloth what if arc pls read the web novel

RussellSD

I highly doubt you will ever read it but in Sloth if (An alternate reality in which he runs away with rem) he does actually put her first and treat her well, he truly has love for rem but he just loved Emelia first/more. Edit: Also always get chills with the alarm/white whale entrance I don't know why but the juxtaposition of the visuals and alarm is super eerie then goes into the distorted alarm as it goes to the whale, soo good.

Supreme

I'm a bit upset that so many people don't like Emilia that much. I think one of the reasons is that her actions aren't always clearly conveyed, but after reading the novel and noticing the details in what she is doing, I completely understand his love for her. There were so many reasons to mistrust Subaru in some timelines. And every single person has at some point mistrusted him. Except for two: Reinhard (because he never had a reason to) and Emilia (even though she had all the reason to). BTW: Saying Emilia doesn't trust Subaru or has empathy for his situation is not true. It probably should be true and every other person would probably be this way after everything that he said and did to her, but not Emilia. And that's why he loves her.

Supreme

Emilia has always been kind to him. In fact, Emilia might just be the most kind-hearted person in the entire world. There were so many reason for her to distrust him. Just think of the last episode were he literally screamed at her to just trust him and come with him. If she didn't care about him, she would have shoved him away right there. Instead she wanted to know what's going on, how she could help him. Another good example is when Rem died to the curse. Everyone was mistrusting him, because he couldn't say anything. Everyone there was suspicious of him, except for Beatrice (for obvious reasons) and Emilia (for literally no reason except for being kind). She is the one person that he could trust throughout the entire series. He had the to earn that status for everyone else, including Rem who literally tortured him and healed his wounds in the meantime just so he suffer more. Btw, the exact moment he moved on from a crush to being in love, is after the lap-pillow.

Red Lightning

So it was just being nice and caring when she could've been distrusting. I guess NEETs don't really get that level of interactions with people. Makes sense I guess

AnotherWeeb

It's crazy to say Subaru doesn't love Rem back. He absolutely loves Rem. He's just not in love with her because he's too deep in his trauma bond infatuation with Emilia

DeVaunBeats

Simply put, Emilia is to Subaru what Subaru is to Rem. Emilia was the first person to help him in this world and saved his life. He saw how kind she was to go out of her way to save and help a complete stranger and fell in love with her during the time they spent together. He was at a low point in his life when he came to this world and Emilia was a beacon of light to him (even if that timeline is now gone, which is why Emilia just doesn't understand why Subaru is so keen on paying her back). Subaru saved Rem at her lowest moment and brought her out of her self-hatred (self-hatred Subaru also has) and she fell in love with him for doing that for her. Rem doesn't really know much about Subaru just like Subaru doesn't know that much about Emilia. She risks her life to save him no matter what, just like Subaru does for Emilia (and Rem too, tbf) And just like Emilia doesn't owe Subaru her love just because he loves her, Subaru doesn't owe Rem his romantic love just because she loves him.. It really frustrates me that people watch this scene and just seem not to get that. The best thing Subaru could do to Rem is be honest with her and let her make her own decision on whether or not she still wants to help him, which he did. Rem deserves better than to be a second choice, and Subaru knows that. He does absolutely love Rem and would risk his life to save her in a heartbeat but how fair would it be to her if he just chose her because she was available and not because he truly felt romantic feelings for her?

yorozuyapetel

"i hope rem goes to a different anime" and the monkey's paw curled

SAEKO

Yall, really just underestimate how much we hate Subaru if you think it's a misunderstanding.

GrimPitbull

Correct me if I'm wrong but its the non cannon what if of Sloth that tells the story of them actually running away. It was so good but proves Subaru can't out run the consequences forever

Bowman C.

Omg rewatching this show, through someone else’s eyes, I can see why I dropped it. I needed someone to express those bad vibes I was unable to verbalise. Now with Alicia’s pauses, I can remind myself this guy is fking 16 and has chose to drop out of school and shut himself in his room. With that in mind, I can now actually stomach his imperfections and even appreciate it from an objective stance, an accurate portrayal of such complex character.

Paul Watson

Yeah because hating Subaru over this is stupid asf