Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

YAY MOOOOOOOOOORE

Files

Steven U S2 19+20

Watch "Steven U S2 19+20" on Streamable.

Comments

Ok

Woohoo

Jimmy Recinos

Yayyy I’m ready to cry on my break

Vivica the witch

Cant wait to bust out "rapscalian behaviors" on my cousins kids.

Shino302

Yeah Pearls are basically the Homeworld equivalent to a Gucci Bag. Having one is a status symbol more than anything else.

Crimson wolf

One thing I find slightly annoying is that it's made out to be a race thing, gems are one race with many types, like ants. It's more a caste thing, and Peridot isn't completely wrong. Pearl likes to do chores and served rose, so she still likes what she was made for but has to freedom to express it and do it on her own terms

Shadowsofpain

Peridot isnt evil she just *basically a description evil* lol

RF

I like all the stuff before this with Pearl too. Jasper called a "defective Pearl", and in the episode where she teaches Connie to sword fight she is super hard projecting onto her, including the part in the song where Connie says that she knows she is not meant to fight, but wants to anyways. It's how much Pearl saw herself in Connie, even beyond the Rose/Steven stuff. That this person who by the standards of everyone else around her isn't "meant" to be a knight, but chooses to anyways.

NET_mancer99

The Gem Homeworld maintained a strict Caste System with gemstones having predetermined roles, places, privileges and purposes in the social pyramid.

PrivateXimmy

It’s a caste thing that’s also a race thing: there isn’t much difference when it comes to class warfare. Any system designed inherently to put some above others; and many *below* others, is inherently discriminatory.

PrivateXimmy

Episode 20’s one of my *all* time favorites. Not only is it a lovely show of Pearl’s character and her growth overall, but also really helps to understate in part *why* she’s somewhat insecure, despite her amazing proficiency at almost everything she does. She was born of a culture where her very *existence* is subservient, and she’s obviously gone so far and beyond to prove herself otherwise. But even then, her build is *inherently* not that of a soldier, or a tactician, or a mage. All her skill is cultivated talent. God she rocks

Daniel Wong

I think that's fair, but also given that we don't have a lot of detailed information about gem society at this point, I can see why it may be seen as a racism thing.

Crimson wolf

Okay, but consider this: smart fridge keeps my food cold, a tesla will take me places, a smart oven cooks my food to perfection and my smart tv shows me whatever information I want or need. They all do important jobs, but would all be necessary for a comfortable daily life, but obviously one of these things on the list is more expensive. Now, I will admit having them all be smart devices is redundant and probably inefficient, but they still do what they're meant and probably more effectively too. That's somewhat like what gems are, but sentient and with the freedom to be more, but when gems see cross gem fusion it's like mixing your smart fridge and smart oven. To us, it's love and it's beautiful. To them, it's kind of weird and mind bogging

Crimson wolf

Yeah, thats fair. I just kinda of hope that she'll see the whole and pick up the hints, because earlier she was so focused when pearl and garnet were making up abku there realtionship she completely missed/dismissed what pearl said and the hints about what she was and I may still be a bit peeved about that

PrivateXimmy

But like it *is* a race thing. The castes are determined by the gem archetype you are born into: I.E. race. They literally use the word “gemetics” at one point, it’s not subtle. You might be quick to brush that off on account of race being a “real world” thing, but do these writers, considering their competency so far, seem like the sort to ignore that obvious connotation? Homeworld is meant to be upsetting, there’s a reason it’s dogmatic society is the ultimate bad guy of the series more than any one “villain”.

Gmanjim

so lucky she doesn't read Patreon comments on the Steven universe episodes. you guys are all saying this with the hindsight of watching the show already. spoilers everywhere

Gamer Kane

I just realised how muddy this messaging is. Gems are created with certain abilities and mindsets for specific tasks. Pearl was literally made to be a servant and Peridot was literally made to be a technician, they have their own thoughts feelings and desires but they all do have a set purpose they are designed for. Any gem can do anything (almost) but that doesn't stop the fact that they will always be better at what they are made for. On it's own that's fine but adding a racism allegory to it makes some really uncomfortable implications since it's not just a mindset or social system it is what we are shown and said to be factually how they work.

Crimson wolf

Im also a bit peeved that Alicia treats them like humans when they aren't. They are not more nor less than humans, but they are different creatures entirely, capable of things even their god-emperesses couldn't have known, all while never abandoning what they are which I find even more impressive. It's like instead of running from one thing to do another, they push that one thing in completely new directions that only they are capable of, and I find that beautiful and amazing that they can accept themselves and be more. It's more impressive than something like, let's say, a chef abandoning the food industry and becoming a trucker despite still loving food even if it has bad connotations for their past. The gems stay in food, but still go on the move by making food trucks and chains and so much more, while never losing their purpose, given and discovered. Sorry, I guess I may just be a bit passionate about this. I did not know I was this opinions on this show

Blooocki :3

Turning it around... This makes fusion all the more wholesome because certain tasks and abilities become waaaay stronger.

Dull Dragon

You know, the Cluster is very similar to the Emergence in Marvel’s The Eternals. A Celestial in the center of the Earth, growing from the energy of the world’s large populations over millions of years, and when it finally emerges, it would destroy world. Come to think of it, there are a few other similarities between the show and the movie. In SU, the gems are mass produced, and the Eternals are cloned for every world an Emergence occurs.

Darc Hart94

Despite some things about the steven universe series that bug me its one of the few cartoons I like going back to every now and then. Amphibia, ok ko, old school powerpuff girls, Ed Edd n eddy are also on that list

FreakoNico

I Always took it more like “classism” than “racism”

Not John

That's the problem with race allegories like this. In the real world, among human beings, race is a social construct and our genetic differences are largely superficial. But some types of Gems are just outright objectively better than other gems at certain things by default. Some gems even seem to be better at EVERYTHING than some of the "lower" gems. I agree it's going for a race allegory but I wish it wasn't. I mean, discrimination makes sense in a world where the fire deparement is hiring and some races can make ice/water out of thin air, while others can't. I feel like using beings that actually ARE fundamnetally different as the racial stand-ins kinda unintentionally sends the message "ok, some races ARE better than others, but we should give the lesser ones a shot anyway."

Darc Hart94

That reminds me of one of the funniest and dumbest ads cartoon network ever put out, it was an ad where garnet tells a bunch of kids "hey kids, don't be racist" and then you hear a cut and it shows they're on a set. People made memes about it "Kids it was all a lie! Be racist!"

Technical_Analysis

The big one that always stands out to me is in the episode where she and Garnet finally talk, she says something like "I'm just a Pearl, I need someone to tell me what to do," when I heard that on my second watch, it was a huge "Oh..." moment, she was literally created to take orders, even so much as making a decision for herself for the first time must have been so far outside of her comfort zone.

Alp

Eh. Humans are "made" to be good at certain things too. We're not meant for subzero temperatures but we still WALKED to the north and south pole. Us humans will always be "better" at living in arid environments in tribes of less than 200. We still made it to the fucking MOON. I like the messaging because the gems are limited just like people are, they're just more obvious about it. That doesn't mean they can't do things outside their "programming".

Cody Giovinazzo

No ending song because they're at the barn

Gamer Kane

Not the same at all we aren't programmed to have certain beliefs or systems we gain them based on our experience. We also aren't made to be store clerks or artists or soldiers we take the steps for that. Gems are literally made for those things.

Jachariah

IN defense of those ads they were taken heavily out of context, the ads basically broke down well meaning but ineffective anti-racism ads of the 90s and 2000s and offered criticisms of their rhetoric while still functioning as modern anti-racism ads

Darc Hart94

I think all ads like that are just objectively stupid. Telling people what to think and how to act, even if you have good intentions, is just bad especially when you're trying to do that to malleable children

ThePirateJaz

During the second half of this reaction, I saw a mouse cursor hovering over the recording window, and got super confused thinking it was Alicia's, thinking to myself "There's no way she just left her mouse in the window this whole time, she knows better than that!" Only to find out after the reaction that it was MY mouse the whole time. Not one of my proudest moments. > - >'

Carlos

Alicia: I love Peridot! Peridot: **goes on racist rant** Alicia: O_O

Cole Savoie

I think Peridot's attitude is more like Classism instead of Racism

Filip Ahlers

Peridot isn't racist, she's classist (or casteist, would probably be the more accurate term) Pearls are literally mass-produced servants. When she says Pearl is a "fancy one" she's not saying she "pretty good, for a [X]" she's saying that she's a Gucci purse instead of a basic handbag.

Ivory Morningstar

Yeah but the episode itself isn't an allegory on race that was Alicia's own interpretation all this episode was trying to get across you have the capacity to be more than what others expect of you.

ben elea

that's actually a really good analogy fr. XD

cry_w

It's essentially both, since their class seems to be based on their "race."

cry_w

Eh, a lot of this can be understood from the episode already, although people are being way too explicit about it way too soon.

SweetCandle

Peridot and Entrapta should hang out sometime.

Shilo Wilson

I bet that perdots breath smells like HDMI cable

Speed1247

She can actually be both. It's both racism (because she is a pearl) and classim (I'm of a higher station then her)

Speed1247

Yeah this show's reaction to certain things like racism/classim isn't the best at times. (It's a legitimate criticism of the show) But no show is perfect, we can acknowledge and call out the issues without detracting from the positives. (Intent matters, it's not like the people who made the show are pushing a racist narrative or anything it's just a poorly done attempt to counter racism/classim)

DaniDeFig

Yes Alicia, welcome to Gem Racism ^^' But now that the show has introduced it, it can start digging into some INTERESTING stuff! Especially with Pearl. Look forward to it ;)

Filip Ahlers

It's just... I don't feel like race applies here, simply due to the artificial, function-based diversity of Gemkind. Peridot is being insensitive about her purpose as a servant, not her color or culture. It's like a soldier ant bullying a worker ant, more than anything.

Joey245

One thing I find interesting about the whole "Pearls are a lower status caste" thing is that unlike 99% of the other gems we see, pearls aren't actually gemstones in the traditional sense like garnets or quartzes. Rather than being made in the earth, they come from the sea - mostly from shelled mollusks. So when Peridot said pearls were "made to order servants", she was being literal - pearls are "made" in a way that most gems aren't.

AnotherWeeb

it's also true in like, 99% of cases. Gems are purpose made and the crystal gems only escaped their intended design through experiencing earth. That was rose's like, whole thing. Infatuation with the idea of choosing what you are instead of being built into it from creation

Easy Mode - A.I

19:30 - watching scenes like this and remembering SUF exists and the message it tells.... man

Strawhat_Stevn rr

does Alicia know that when she sang that part of "American Boy" is actually Garnet's VA thats sings it? lol

Something Cool

Ummm this is so backwards because you can't make a racism allagory when the gems are literally created for a purpose. It might be classism in a sense but rasism just doesn't really work

Something Cool

Ummm no, those were my thoughts on my first watchthrough. I think the message is pretty clear and that it's weird to make it a racism allagory.

Speed1247

Different gem types different races. Like a pitbull vs a poodle. Bred for different things but both are still dog's.

DaniDeFig

No! That is how we get a world-ending event on a GALACTIC scale!! xD xD

Englewood Pony

See, Steven can only talk on what he knows and what he’s seen. I don’t think it’d be realistic if he sat down with Peridot and was like “So, due to the systematic-“

Julio Castillo

The Pearl thing could be read as Racism.... but since the Pearls are LITERALLY designed and made to be servants (kinda like Robots) im not sure this specific situation can be defined as "Racism".... Maybe like..... "Categorism"?? The point is... Peridot talking like she's inherently superior to Pearl is not necessarily because of a learned systematic prejudice (although there is a bit of that), it's because ALL gems are "born" to have certain jobs and be good at them. The Crystal Gems are exceptions because they Rebelled against their Homeworld.

Something Cool

In a sense yes but it should still not be viewed as rasism since the differenses are not just superficial but due to their very design. If you want to build a robot you use a peridot since they were made for it. When you need to terraform a planet you use a lapis. Based on their function they get a certain social status. It wouldn't be racist to choose a sentient screwdriver over a sentient knife to screw in a screw, it's just practical. Both can do the job but for one it is infinitly easier

__U

I know this post is two days old but, isn't the whole point of the gem classism/racism is that gems are made for specific purposes but because their individuals, that's no excuse for one gem to discriminate against another.

Colin Darcas

Foreshadowing. They explain this later on. Nobody say how

Colin Darcas

Disney likes stealing ideas. The entire plot of the Marvels is ripped straight from Spaceballs. A villain is stealing other planet's resources because theirs doesn't have enough so the heroes have to stop them. It's honestly pathetic

Colin Darcas

I think that's just alicia adding the allegory of racism. It wasn't designed for that origionally. It was supposed to be an allegory of classism. Alicia just tends to think of things in terms of race

danime

Actually, she probably has no idea what rain is because every other planet colonized by the Gems was strip-mined of everything, including atmosphere. So no weather.

Jachariah

Gem society and gem relationships often serve multiple metaphors at the same time. The Pearl thing is a heavy duty metaphor that can be applied to racism, classism, slavery, and sexism. Also the thing about Peridot's prejudice IS learned systematic prejudice, just because you can logically determine that a Pearl isn't as strong as your average quartz does not therefore justify the objectification and limitations that Pearls are forced into. Gems are designed to have certain jobs yes but they are also systematically forced to conform or face execution.

Jachariah

Can we not give lore spoilers? it's literally explained later in the show just let it happen

Jachariah

They have never explained how Pearl's are made, no not even in the "Volleyball" episode

Dip Ateer

As they are an artificial race I'm hesitant to view what peridot says as racist she basically talking like pearl is a butler-bot. Nvm watched more.

Renn

I know this is six months late, but this whole situation is pissing me off on my rewatch. It’s a metaphor for systematic prejudice, but that doesn’t mean it’s a metaphor for racism. If you throw in racism the entire thing it’s polluted and problematic because these people are in fact, actually built for certain things and are better at certain things. That doesn’t mean that they shouldn’t have freedom with what they do with their lives, but you absolutely shouldn’t feel racism onto that applying racism to where there isn’t any paint the entire moral of the story racist because it wasn’t meant to be about racism. These are aliens you do not have to shove their societal problems into human things like racism, they can stand on their own as messages against societal prejudice in general