Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Poll

Last S5 Special: Slumber Party | Barre Tab

  • Yes!! It was a good season. 67
  • No, and I am so happy that we're at the end! 228
  • 2026-09-01
  • 295 votes
{'title': 'Last S5 Special: Slumber Party | Barre Tab ', 'choices': [{'text': 'Yes!! It was a good season. ', 'votes': 67}, {'text': "No, and I am so happy that we're at the end! ", 'votes': 228}], 'closes_at': None, 'created_at': datetime.datetime(2026, 9, 1, 14, 59, 15, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'description': None, 'allow_multiple': False, 'total_votes': 295}

Content

Do you personally like Season 5 of Dance Moms? Defend your answer in the comments below!

Comments

AndWhatAboutIt

HELL NO. Season 5 & 6 are the worst! I know this has been said a lot but when y’all left the show really took a turn for the worse and the moms, along with Abby got even more toxic to the point where it wasn’t enjoyable to watch. It was depressing tbh

Rachel B

I’m so 50/50 on this. Season 5 started out horrible. But i feel like it needed to happen the way it did, like a transitional season. Because to me, Dance Moms seasons 1-4 is one show and 6-7 is another show. We needed that transition to make 6-7 good TV. Hope this makes sense lol

Leona

I feel like season 5 was way better than season 4. I also think people stopped waiting for the weekly TV airing and started streaming Dance Moms on Disney+/Lifetime instead. Also I know the BTS was SO much more interesting than what they showed. I think editing was the worst this season.

Holly

Season 5 was definitely a turning point in the series. There was an over-commercilalised shift towards LA and the superficial competition to popstar fame. The behaviour amongst the cast was so much more volatile too as there were severe emotional isolation tactics, especially towards Holly and Nia, and the overall constant blow outs and treatments that led to new nastier extremes. Plus we lost the original spark of the previous seasons with the departure of Christie, Kelly and their girls. The teams dynamic just felt colder and overly competitive rather than familiar.

Delaney Mettey

I will say season 5 had some iconic moments but it was not at the same level as seasons 1-4. MDP with Erin Babbs were great competition and had good group dances. BDA and Candy Apples were also entertaining and it was good to see Cathy win again in a long time along with seeing the girls doing more things outside of dance like the music videos and acting. But the downside was Abby tearing Holly and Nia down and the moms not sticking up for them. Jojo and Jess did bring sass and It's sad and uncomfortable how Abby and some of the moms and girls treated her this season. The drama felt intense and uncomfortable and I also agree there not a lot of funny moments to lighten the season. Season 5 without Christi and Kelly and the girls just felt empty from there on.

STOP THIS IS ABOUT DANCE ARE YOU PEOPLE INSANE

Season 5 I feel like is the last one with re watchability tbh. no where near seasons 2-4 but when I need to switch things up i dont mind re watching season 5 but thats the latest ill go! I love kalani and jojo which is why i dont mind season 5!

i just love taylor swift and kelly hyland

SOOOO HAPPY ITS OVER LMFAOOO. unlike seasons 1-3 mainly but some of 4, i looked forward to watching each episode this season was like pulling freaking teeth. it was unbearably boring, edited poorly leaving out what could’ve actually been interesting to see and just heavily infuriating 😭😭😭

Kait :)

Unfortunately they just worse from here

Tori Black

just wait for season 7 ladies if you think 5 is bad LOL

Sharon (Wants the Prenup Necklace)

unfortunately i am in the boat that loves the drama content as well as the dancing, but it genuinely does damage to my health watching how Jill, Mellisa, and Abby act in this season. it seems like Abby’s irl popularity and enablement by others peaked during the filming of this season (before all the shit hit the fan with all of the scandals). so her and Flotsam and Jetsam felt like they were infallible, which was hard to watch.

Barbara Carlone

Is there any possibility you could watch the girl talk that you skipped? You were talking about running out of content and even tho I know it’s hard to listen to the girls mentioning Chloe, it’s still incorporating a family member that Christi can give insight on. And then you can say you did every episode in season 5 :)

Kwinn Perkins

I wanted to see what your thoughts were and there were dances i really did like but seasons 1 through 3 really were the ones i enjoyed

katelyn mcneill

Part of me is divided in my liking of this season. Chloe, Brooke and Paige and Christi and Kelly were always my favorites so the first full season without them sucked. I also hate the hypocrisy of Holly because as soon as she gets the treatment Christ and Kelly and their daughters did, she’s upset at the moms for not sticking up for her and Nia. She didn’t stick up for Christi and Kelly and Jill and Melissa for sure never did so for her to be surprised is crazy to me. I hated seeing Nia excluded like Chloe was and I love Nia, but this season as a whole was bad. Bad dances, Abby was on another level, and stupid fights.

Lucia

I mean i like just because Nia and Kenzie improve so much and Jojo came but I have to say that it is still a bored season.

Hannah Newman

I have such a hard time watching the seasons after 1-4. They are just conflict the whole time without the fun balance of the first 4 seasons, and I can't watch more than one episode at a time because it's just so stressful. It's also awful how everyone blames the ogs who left for everything when they were the ones who made the show good and did the right thing. Everything about the season rubs me the wrong way, and I pretty much stop watching and start season 1 over at this point.

Helen Adams

I don’t like the way Holly and Nia were treated. I think Abby should have been held responsible.

Helen Adams

I also didn’t like the they pit Kendall and Nia against each other

Tracee

I don’t like season 5 for a very good reason! My favorite 2 moms were gone! I am a Jill fan as well but no one could replace the 2 of you! Once season 4 was over, I would rewatch seasons 1-4. Season 5 became more ugly and hateful, even between the moms. Also, once the show left Pittsburgh (Go Steelers!), it became about who can make it bigger and better and it stopped feeling like a group of friends dancing together and more like who can make it in LA first. I have never ever seen season 8, can’t bring myself to watch it but I will when you ladies do. I love you both! Loved seeing you in SF! I was the mom who cried when I met you and then asked about Jill being called “Cookie” lmao! Love you both so much! Thanks for doing what you do everyday!

DaniRyder

Season 5 was not as memorable. I hope you see this change in season 6, where the producers try to use the old concepts from earlier. Brynn is Maddie’s rival, Kalani is the big sister who is flexible, Jojo is the sassy has dancer, etc. the producers literally try to replace Chloe, Brooke, and Paige. But it simply doesn’t work.

Kyle Colasurdo

Can you guys react live to the episodes like u did with the lost episode in season 2 it was the best episode of the podcast and I laughed out loud!

Zainab

My thing is, I will watch the season. I do think it had good drama, but it just seems so dark and the show was heading in such a negative and toxic direction if that can even be said because yes, it was already a really sad show it still had its moments but by the time season five came I felt like it was just negative and for the money there is nothing fun about it and they ran off the two people who made the show what it was in season one a lot of of the others who claim they are a part of dance moms aren't actually a part of dance moms because even Kendall I will say is an OG. After all, she was there for the majority of it, and she is what I think of, but I don't think of JoJo or Brynn, so I just hate when people act like they were a part of the show when they really weren't, and they got what they wanted and left, in my opinion.

curdled_ranch

i like season five, but it’s a totally different vibe than seasons 1-4. particularly seasons 1-3 still had SOME fun moments. season four was tolerable simply because we love a christi moment, but season 5 was rough. while it’s still entertaining, it’s not as fun. we still get lots of OG lore and stories, but much fewer fun events.

kkkpopXx

didn’t really like the season but it had some of my favorite dances this season

Christine Walker

I hate season five for the treatment of Holly and Nia. all the subtle micro-aggression shown irks my nerves and makes it a hard watch cause I get so mad and upset for them. When I do my many rewatches I purposely skip season five cause that's how much it upsets me. it almost makes me uncomfortable to watch.

giselle magadan

Season five was so dark and mean spirited. I’m ready for season six only because it’s so nostalgic for me and it was so exciting at the time that the cast was on the west coast

Que Jr

i was entertained by this season

It fits in my big one

I feel like bringing the show to LA just kind of ruined the relatability of the show. When I was younger I related to the girls because they were just little kids in Pittsburgh, and I’m from Ohio so not much of a difference lol, dancing at their studio. Once they moved to LA, it was just different. I feel like there was so much unnecessary drama with the music videos, etc. that it almost felt too staged. Once season 6 rolls around i feel like it gets better, content wise. But I did kind of enjoy abby going off the deep end in season 5 lol.

Kelly’s screenshots!

It wasn’t as good as the first seasons, but I continued to watch. As much as I hated seeing Nia and Holly being abused, I loved watching Nia become a strong young lady.

FrostyAli

Yes I liked season 5, But heres what ill say! Seasons 1-4 were truly the GOLDEN ERA of Dance Moms & Reality TV overall which is why I always say that the OG Seasons 1 & 2 felt so pure & perfect + seasons 3 & 4 were amazing because we got to see the same OG girls get older, grow as dancers and related to them more as teens/pre teens. And of course season 5 felt way different but compared to the worst season ever 6! it was pretty good lol. Then season 7 came along with the best surprise ending ever, AKA Chloe & Christi returning which is why 7 is better than 5 & 6 combined!

Evelyn

After season 4 the showed should have been cancelled . There is no show without Kelly and Christy

Kait :)

I cansee the yes and no part. Yes it would’ve been cool to see ain’t no moms allowed in season one through season three. But then again I think the only person that lifetime with a liked on there would be Brooke because I could be wrong but kids usually don’t develop a filter until they’re about a teenager and even then they still don’t have a filter. And for the no side, the girls already knew what to talk about and what she wanted them to talk about. But it would’ve been cool if they were allowed to really go off script and discuss the production and clarify the majority of the stories are fake, and majority of the arguments were scripted

Shae Howard

I loved S5 because Nia came into her own. Season 6 was great because Nia got even stronger as a dancer from taking lessons from other teachers in LA. She took back the "weakest dancer" narrative that Abby as well as production tried to assign to her.

mia pia

So happy season 5 is over. Melissa and Jill along with Abby and whatever she had going on …❄️? were terrible this season made it a hard watch. Jill and Jess make season 6 miserable with their bullying of Ashlee and Brynn so idk which is worse.. can we just skip to season 7 for Christi and Chloe’s return+ Cheryl Burke feature?????😭😭

MissDiscoBush

I like season 5 because of the resilience the girls have built but I do not like the drama that happens every time Nia tries to succeed.

Jill's Fedora

It definitely felt like a completely different show and I missed you girls and your kids. There were definitely some fun parts but the overall vibe COMPLETELY changed. Seasons 1 to 4 were 100% better.

Caitlin Killarney

I Personally felt like it wasn’t the same show anymore I enjoyed the show more when You and Kelly and your Girls were on the show