Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Poll

S6, E1 - New Season, New Rules - Barre Tab

  • Yes, there are rules for a reason. 195
  • No, and the dance teacher was just being petty by advocating for them to be disqualified. 158
  • 2026-09-13
  • 353 votes
{'title': 'S6, E1 - New Season, New Rules - Barre Tab', 'choices': [{'text': 'Yes, there are rules for a reason.', 'votes': 195}, {'text': 'No, and the dance teacher was just being petty by advocating for them to be disqualified. ', 'votes': 158}], 'closes_at': None, 'created_at': datetime.datetime(2026, 9, 13, 15, 22, 39, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'description': None, 'allow_multiple': False, 'total_votes': 353}

Content

Do you think that BDA should have faced consequences for "breaking the rules" and taking too long to set up their props at the competition?

Comments

Rachel B

Yes but not like what was on the show. No need for the public embarrassment. Sooo unprofessional. Great television though

BlueMuppetFurVest

i’m definitely a follow the rules type of person so i for sure think they should have faced a penalty but at the same time i do think abby was extremely petty the way she acted about it, as im sure she has also taken forever to set up props before

Jenny Joy

I think it was dumb to have the moms set up the chairs. The girls probably knew exactly how they needed to be spaced and would have been much more efficient. I did a chair dance in 2000s and us dancers set the chairs up and never had a spacing issue.

Blue Jai

No shade, but at the ALDC they have danced with lighters and decided Maddie may or may not compete depending on who was there. Melissa ran across the stage. Cathy basically yelled, from the audience, “where the hell are the producers with those chairs.” We have an argument that can be heard in Kentucky every single week. What rules? Was there ever order?

Brianna Nicole

No, bc odds are, it was producer created chaos. Just like how they said they'd get the stoppers for Paige's chair and didnt. They probably set the moms up and Abby saw the opportunity to use it against them and took it. Yes there are rules at a dance competition, but those have never mattered when it comes to the production of the show, why should it now?

Skylar

Rules were bent all the time at competitions for the show. To me, the only difference in this scenario is that it was BDA instead of the ALDC. Had Abby done the same thing, I doubt it would’ve even been a story line 🤷🏼‍♀️

Tori Black

i was a competitive dancer growing up and the rule always was you had 2 mins to set up. most of the time it only took groups like 30 secs so the rule was never really needed, it was only on place to ensure the props were being put out efficiently. i can only remember once or twice where big productions who had like full back drops took the whole 2 mins and i believe they received a small deduction. being disqualified is beyond dumb lol its not the dancers fault?? if they took like 20 mins to set up ya disqualification makes sense but a few minutes is really ridiculous

Eden-Anaya

I think this is a tricky one, rules are generally in place for everyone to follow, but I feel in S5 there were plenty of times it came across that the ALDC got away with murder when they shouldn’t have. I would say nobody should break the rules at all, but if ALDC can (potentially) get away with it, so should BDA. It’s only fair

Kait :)

Yes, there are rules for a reason. But the same thing happened in season two when Cathy did her dance, my hair looks fierce. And she stopped the competition to make sure the chairs were there. And if the chairs have to look a certain way, and the fact that they have to all be in the straight line yeah it’s gonna take some time to set them up. And if I remember correctly, Jeanette didn’t actively stop the competition to set them up, meaning that the people who run the competition already knew she was going to do that

Kait :)

Also, if we want to talk about holding up to competition, we need to talk about how in Abby‘s dance ‘no sign of life.’ The girls arrived last minute and was almost disqualified.

cause we could get disqualified

Do I think it was dramatic? Yes. However, rules, our rules, and in a regular dance competition, this would’ve been taken into account.

emi

there was an aldc group dance where at the end a delicate snowfall descended upon the stage 😭 typical dance competition rules at this point in the show are only ever enforced if it adds drama to the plot like this.

Kelly's my favorite dance mom

I don't see why people think Melissa finally sticks up for herself in season 6. I think that when Maddie started having success, she didn't need Abby anymore. She didn't have to keep her mouth shut anymore. There is a big difference.

Rayleigh Voge

The dance teacher was petty regardless of how the rules should have been followed 😂

Melissa’s Deflection Fly

okay yes but side note, abby filming w her phone had me dead. everyone needs to just come together and hold an L over their heads. loser behavior 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

Bailey Saldana

I voted yes but I would love the see the raw footage that shows how long they took to set up...

Chef Ya-ya

Abby was being petty, because they only showed that part, if they have 3 minutes then show the full 3 minutes not just the petty. They could have sped the video up lol could you imagine stalker running around that fast.......🤣🤣🤣🤣

Jill's Fedora

They definitely should have followed the rules, that's why they are there but... Abby was definitely over the top it was not that big of a deal.

Pinkelephant47

While I agree that under normal circumstances, the rules should be followed, but this is Dance Moms. I’m curious to hear your opinions but it seems to have production written all over it. So in the case, they should have been given grace