Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Congratulation to Maria and Kaga(Kancolle) who won this tournament, Both of them will recieve NSFW fanart that will available in the Reward box this month. ^^

Anyway this is the first tournament we hold  so if you have any suggestion feel free to leave your commend below or message me if you want it to be a private discussion.

Files

Comments

Ecliptix

I found the tournament style selection fun

Captain_Azulle

I liked it but I feel like selections should be from different sources. Like only 1 character from Arcknights, 1 from naruto ect, not 3 from one source and 3 from another. Not enough variation.

Bandog

Are you referring to how all the Azure Lane girls got mashed together in Group C?

Captain_Azulle

That is a fantastic example yes. I like Azure Lane, but having several characters from the same game/manga is bad enough across several groups, but all together in one even randomly just makes it feel like a lack of choice.

Bandog

TL;DR if there are 3 or more nominees from the same series, divide them between no more than 2 groups.Long version: One the one, I'm not a fan Azure lane so the results of the outcome from that, made me a very happy guard dog. But I do see it as unfair that the series with the most candidates can get snuffed out in one round. I proposed if there are more than two candidates from the same series, then they should be split up between groups. That way two (or three) of those candidates have a chance to win without running the possibility that they will oversaturate the final round.

GaiNoob

Hmm...the reason why I put all ship girl in one group because there's a possibility that ship girl or character in the same series may dominate in final round if I put them in all group. So,I tried to grouping waifu that has something similar or relate in one group like in group A that all of them are animal ears waifu and group C that are ship girl to make final round has a various of series or character.

MDashK

Splitting them in any way you like, be it in the same group or not, but as long there is at least 2 chars from 1 source, there's always a chance they end up being both selected, if votes are enough for them.

Captain_Azulle

GainooB, I agree with your method. Putting similar characters together isnt a bad way to do it. I would rather see one character per source, but if we were to have multiple per source then I would want a rule that they cannot be submitted come next competition. Every other competition seems fair. No matter how we end up doing it I want to encourage variety.