Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Videos

  • 649181661.mp4

Downloads

Content

YOUTUBE LINK

Files

Comments

Summer

Whatever anyone says, Voyager is awesome Trek,

Utterlee

I was never a big fan of Voyager and have always been sneery about people who claim it's their favourite Trek series - however watching back with you guys I'm enjoying it more than I remember enjoying it first time around.

Summer

I saw some TNG as a child and the TOS movies, I technically saw Enterprise at 22 but when I found Voyager at 26 I started tobecome a full Trekkie, it, TNG and DS9 are great tv

Laura Thornley

The rewatch for me surprised me with the quality the show had immediately. I always remember season one being 'bad' - but it wasn't bad at all, it was good!

jon bolton

My top 5 are: State Of Flux, and Eye Of The Needle (both S), Learning Curve, Cathexis, and Faces (my only 3 A's). I missed the voting for this, because obviously Cathexis would have got points.

Actuarial Lurker

Rewatching this as a DS9 fan who "sat through" Voyager since his wife (who is also a DS9 fan) likes Voyager I MUST credit the show with having many of its characters- especially the Captain so well formed. I have watched DS9 and VOY at least 7 or 8 times and some episodes from both series 10-15 times. Sort of like a runner who starts a longer race too fast....Voyager stalls and then burns in Season 2...I will try to keep an open mind, given how familiar I am with every episode to look for positive points as I re-watch through with you here, but I am dreading Season 2 and hope that I am able to see some bright spots that I may have overlooked since my opinions are so jaded now.

Imogen S

I cannot express without spoilers just how many things you guys have said that make my brain scream "They must watch The Orville!", and I'm not even halfway through the video. What do I have to do to get it slotted in chronologically with the Star Trek journey?! We're a long way off anything that aired in 2017 atm so I've got time to build my grassroots movement here 😂

jon bolton

The only 2 episodes i don't like are Emanations (D), and Heros And Demons (E).

THE LORE!!!

Regarding Vaughn Armstrong, he is actually 3 for 3 on S1s, as he played the Cardassian Gul chasing the Bajoran terrorist that was friends with Kira in Past Prologue. While the episode itself isn't amazing, his performance is pretty great.

Katie Jackson

This was a really good Top 5. Not a lot of surprises, but that's because some of these where just so amazing that they really stand out. I can't wait for The X-Files Top 10! I hope that'll be out soon, I'm going through X-Files withdraws😂. Curious about DS9's Top 10 too. I don't follow DS9 as closely but I still enjoy it. For me, it's because you can't jump into any episode and just enjoy it on it's own like you can TNG or Voyager. So I don't watch it nearly as much, unless I'm rewatching the whole show.

V G (Zay)

I enjoyed this discussion! Eye of the Needle is my #1 also ☺️ but my 2-5 are The Cloud, Prime Factors, Emanations, and Time and Again

TinMan_7B9

My season one top 6: --------------------- Eye of the Needle (S) Faces (S) Time and Again (A+) Emanations (A) State of Flux (A) Jetrel (A) Watching your reactions made me realize it was a stronger season than I remembered. It really is superior to DS9 Season 1. Still, there's much better stuff coming in later seasons. When? "When the show really starts".

EnigmaticPenguin

Regarding the crew tension and resource plot points and the general audience problem with how they were handled: I wouldn’t mind if they were introduced and used consistently and well or if they were never introduced and a non factor in the series. It’s the half hearted “It’s a thing only when we need it to be.” aspect I didn’t care for.

penoyer79

My top 5 1. Prime Factors (S) 2. Eye of The Needle (S) 3. Emanations (A) 4. The Phage (A) 5. Jetrel (A) ---- my honorable mentions are my B graded episodes 6. Learning Curve 7. State of Flux 8. Caretaker

Matchstick Jose

Question I would be interested to see Josh and Alex answer: If they were just watching Star Trek on their own, would they have already decided DS9 is not for them and stopped watching the series? Because I know big Trek fans who even today have never watched all of DS9 because it’s just not what they’re looking for out of the franchise, which always fascinates me, but I completely get it.

penoyer79

the tension between voyager and the mauqi crew supposed to be a bigger part of the show.

Ryan Caulfield

I already really enjoy Voyager, but watching with you guys makes this first season even better than I remember. My top five would be: 1) Eye of the Needle 2) Jetrel 3) State of Flux 4) Time and Again 5) Cathexis Honourable mention: Heroes and Demons, just because Robert Picardo is so good.

Steven Linden

Bit of a disingenuous argument here when you deride the idea of every episode being about the Maquis/Starfleet conflict, or about survival. I don't think anybody wants that to be EVERY episode. I think what people want is a bit more continuity, a bit more interpersonal conflict bubbling up now and then, a bit less of the Maquis becoming standard-issue Starfleet personnel as quickly and easily as they do. (Note, I say this as a Voyager fan!)

William McRae

For me, the first season of "Voyager" was a solid effort. Stronger than Next Gen's debut year but DS9's first season was the best of the three IMO. The reveal of Seska was a nice plot twist even if the Kazon come off as second rate Klingons. That said, the entire cast establish a good rapport with each other from the outset and settle into their respective characters with ease and confidence

Lost Monk

TOS Season 1 was 59 and a half years ago.... not 30 years. I know.... I was 4 months old when it premiered. I WISH I were 30!

Derek Locke

I agree Sloyan brought the best out of Ethan Phillips, but it can also be said the Phillips brought the best out of Sloyan. Great episode.

penoyer79

30 years from the start of Voyager... not to today.

penoyer79

State of Flux would have been higher for me if we had some scenes with seska/chakotay before the reveal during the season.

Dr. Paul Stubbs

From my perspective, the "outsider" (Spock, Data, Doctor) character of DS9 is Odo, who was perfectly cast and acted by René Auberjonois from early in Season 1.

Some Guy

Warp particles!

JHVJ

My Top 10 1 - Eye of the Needle 2 - Jetrel (basically tied for 1st) 3 - Prime Factors (most improved, didn't evne make my initial top 10 on first watch) 4 - Caretaker 5 - Cathexis (I really don't get the „hate“ for this one) 6 - State of Flux 7 - Faces 8 - Heroes and Demons (sue me, I like old tales and dark age stuff) 9 - Emanations 10 - The Phage

Target Audience

For me (Josh), In real life I would’ve decided to watch all of Star Trek so I would’ve watched all of Star Trek. I don’t look at it as individual shows being skippable

Target Audience

We will be watching The Orville as if it’s Star Trek in release order

Dr. Paul Stubbs

RE Technobabble: It's a great point that Trelane doesn't break my immersion as a technically-minded fan, but Janeway's conversation with B'Elanna about reflections in Parallax does. Why? Because they are two different things: 1.) Trelane, Q, The Traveler, Kevin from The Survivors, etc. etc. are all members of super-advanced species that are constrained by the same natural laws as we are, but have a much more sophisticated understanding of these laws and a much larger amount of control over time, space, matter, etc. due to their more sophisticated understanding. Super advanced alien species don't exist as far as I know, but they could. And, as Arthur C. Clark said, "Any sufficiently advanced technology is indistinguishable from magic." So it's easy for me to maintain my suspension of disbelief while Q materializes a mariachi band on the bridge of the Enterprise. 2.) When Janeway and B'Elanna start stretching a metaphor about a lake to a breaking point to explore a technical idea together, it's obvious they aren't having a real technical conversation. They are explaining plot jibberish to the audience. Think of a technical topic you have expertise in, like lighting, or editing, or fight choreography (I don't know anything about wrestling, please excuse me if this isn't the proper term). Now, imagine you are trying to explain a new, technical concept to someone else with the same core technical understanding as you. You don't speak in metaphor, you speak in the technical jargon of your field. Metaphor is used for explaining jargon to the uninitiated. In TNG, Picard and Riker don't know any of the technobabble Geordi and Data spout, so they ask for a metaphor or a diagram to explain. It works, because the audience can take Picard or Riker's POV and have the technobabble explained to them too. In Voyager, Janeway has scientific/engineering experience, so she understands B'Elanna's technobabble. There is no reason for them to dumb down their conversation with metaphor to arrive at the conclusion. Maybe it would make sense if they were explaining it to Paris, but they always just tell him he's an idiot for not understanding and then move on. I think it all just boils down to that we need someone in charge, like Chakotay or Janeway, to not understand the technobabble so it can be dumbed-down and explained. It just doesn't work for me to have the competent people hold technical discussions in the dumbed-down metaphor so the audience can follow along. It feels... weird.

Imogen S

Woahhh I nearly had to check it's not April Fool's still! What news! Fair warning, if you keep feeding me I'll keep coming back🐈

Matchstick Jose

Interesting. (Editing this because I realized I didn't even do this back during the '90s). Thinking about it, I guess I've never done that. Love Star Trek, but I gave up on some of the series even in this era and only went back years later to finish them. I didn't even watch all the Netflix MCU shows during the height of the franchise. So I guess I always prioritize what I like over being a completist and watching everything. I always feel like I don’t have enough time to watch all the great shows I’ve heard about, so I don’t want to to spend time watching something I’m not enjoying.

Target Audience

I agree for modern stuff, but imo DS9 is miles above anything Marvel has released on TV outside of Daredevil. I stopped watching it in 2022. So yeah.. quality does play a part, but despite what DS9 fans may think from our videos, I enjoy the show a lot.

Carl Williams

Right, there’s a false dichotomy the guys keep presenting- “people say the show doesn’t deal with the Maquis/survival enough - but I don’t care because I don’t want EVERY episode to be that”. I personally didn’t want it to be in every single episode, I just felt it was totally unrealistic and takes me out of the show to have it dealt with so infrequently. As I always say, if you wanted to run away from the premise, why did the producers make that the premise then? I understand the guys position, I just never could give it the same free pass in that way. I’m envious they can and that they can enjoy it for what it is actually!

Lost Monk

Wait? It’s been 30 years since the start of Voyager?! Holy F. That’s many more years than the number of years between TOS and TNG. The years are flying by.

Trillhouse

I mean in some ways, the general vibe from them is kind of exactly mirroring what happened 30 years ago, right? TNG ended, people wanted something familiar, and Voyager came out swinging. It was a familiar premise, took place on a cozy Federation ship, and had an amazing lead who rivalled Patrick Stewart in screen presence. Meanwhile, DS9 had been slumming it for two seasons, everything was dirty and weird looking, plots were starting to get harder to follow becaues of continuity, and Sisko was pretty ill defined other than "he likes baseball" and "he's a dad". Yes, it started to show a little bit more promise in Season 3, but it was still a far cry from the heights of TNG and when it sucked, you had to watch it suck on a dirty Cardassian station. By now, most people had jumped ship from DS9, and honestly, you can't blame them... and I say all this as a "DS9 is the best trek of them all" guy. It was just completley unrealistic to expect anyone in 1995 to anticipate what DS9 would eventually become by the end.

Matchstick Jose

DS9's ratings did decline every season. To be fair, so did Voyager's. So neither show was really retaining audiences, and certainly not growing them every season like TNG had been.

Trillhouse

Yeah, but DS9's ratings decline was due to a different reason than Voyager's. I don't want to get into spoilers for either show, but suffice to say that DS9 almost started *purposefully* shedding viewers by adopting the mentality of "Yeah, we'll lose some people if we took this XYZ crazy risk, but fuck it, no one's watching anyway and the studio gives so little shit about us anymore that we might as well do it". Ironically, I think the lack of people watching ultimately made for a better product in the end.

Dr. Paul Stubbs

My top 5: 5. State of Flux (B) 4. Phage (B) 3. Prime Factors (B) 2. Faces (A) 1. Eye of the Needle (S) Everything else in the season is a C or below for me.

Todd

There have been many channels and forums that have discussed the lack of resources issues and how many Photon torpedoes Voyager has, etc. I like that it doesn’t matter that much to you. There will always be production errors, continuity changes and such. Spot changed from male to female, after all.

ImageMaker

1) Jatrel 2) Eye of the Needle 3) State of Flux 4) Caretaker 5) Emanations HM) Prime Factors, Time & Again, Faces I have a specific episode in Season 2 I can't wait to see you guys react too but you are atleast over 2 months away. It's not the one I suspect most people are waiting on but it's my most anticipated this season based on my perception of your possible reaction. I am excited you guys are so receptive to Voyager and hope it doesn't dissapoint in the future. Mr. Kim .... Fire !

Todd

As far as characterization, I think Voyager did a good job with most of the cast. Chakotay and Harry are a little bland but nowhere near the level of Geordi.

Ryan Caulfield

Yeah, that's fair. I just remember watching the episode with my family and how cool it was, when we were all shocked by the reveal. Good memory.

John M.

You're thinking of the survival and the Maquis stuff in terms of plot mechanics (you wouldn't that to be every episode etc). Why it's disappointing to me and others is because you can have much more interesting character arcs if you stick with those things. The characters should be stressed out yet striving against all odds to hold things together. There should be conversations that are dialled to 11, but Voyager does not seem any different day to day than the Enterprise, which means no matter how good it is I'm always vaguely disappointed about what could have been. To me the best episodes of Voyager (there are two in particular I love) are just cool sci-fi that could have been on any show with different characters, but the best episodes of TOS, TNG and DS9 rely on the characters and feel of those shows. This lack of tension is why BSG and DS9 are to me unquestionably better than Voyager (an opinion I know you don't share). But as my wife says that's a me problem, not a you problem. Just sharing my take because you said it was "ridiculous." Great chat as always.

Brent Morris

As a total Deep Space 9 mark, don't worry Voyager will get much much worse

Mark Simonson

I see the Kazon often compared unfavorably with the Klingons, as if they are supposed to be the Delta Quadrant's Klingons. I think that's unfair. The Kazon are not an empire. More like warring gangs with shifting alliances. Voyager has the bad luck of getting thrown into one of the bad neighborhoods of the Delta Quadrant by the Caretaker.

BN13

I wouldn't want Voyager to be a show like Battlestar Gallactica where the survival stuff and conflict are dialed up to 11. But I do want enough of it to make Voyager feel unique, and not like TNG. Otherwise why not just set the whole show in the Alpha quadrant with an all Starfleet crew? I want more episodes like Prime Factors where they do something different with the Star Trek formula, challenge the Star Fleet way a little, and come up with different solutions with not everyone agreeing all the time. But i also don't want the crew at each other's throats, and I still want the show to have the optimistic themes of Star Trek. I think the survival aspect could have been cool if they relied more on integrating whatever they found in the Delta quadrant to make repairs, and you could see visible changes in the ship due to that. Then the show would have not only been more about doing what you need to do to survive, but also learning how to work harmoniously with whatever or whoever you encounter, showing how you become stronger when you work together instead of conquer.

Avaria

On the "survival" end, I think it's a full series vs. Season 1 perspective thing. It's a bit like a bad hangnail. In Season 1 there's really no reason to be irritated by it. There are only 16 episodes, it's been maybe 6 months. But it wheedles away in the back of the brain so that by Season 5 or 6 it's more noticeable and question worthy. It's a bit like expecting them to care about the Dominion just because it was mentioned while Quark was trying to negotiate tulla berries with Pel in the Gamma Quadrant.

Trillhouse

"Why did the producers make this the premise then?" pretty much sums up my whole feelings on this. The guys brought up "Why would we want to see all this interpersonal conflict? It's sci-fi. They're in a whole new area of space. They can do anything they want, why would they do all this crew drama of all things?". The thing is, the idea of "the Brand New Delta Quadrant" is one big red herring. It actually doesn't matter from a writing standpont. As they say themselves "it's sci fi". There's absolutely no reason the writers couldn't have come up with a show where the crew meets all new species every week, barely ever contact starfleet, but still be in the Alpha quadrant ("Oh.. we are exploring the BleepBlorp region of the Alpha quadrant ... it's uncharted and we'll be out of contact with Starfleet for 7 years ... it's dangerous and deep space!"). Why not? It's Sci Fi. The entire reason for doing the "Delta Quadrant" is purely for new possibilites for character development. It's about being "lost in space" and "far from home" with the "mixed crew that needs to get along and survive". It was literally to create a new concept for Star Trek with possibilities for emotional arcs that were impossible in previous series. Without utilizing these elements, this is literally just TNG again. I'm not saying that's bad, I'm just saying it becomes completely valid to ask, "Okay, then why did the producers make this the premise then?".

Sam Langanke

This was kind of funny. 30 years ago.

Jack Mingle

Space Biker Gang basically

Jack Mingle

It really drops off once the seventh season finishes NGL

Target Audience

Way too early for us to have an opinion between DS9 and Voyager. Unless you’re comparing only season 1 which in that case yes I enjoyed Voyager the most.

Paul

Great discussion as always. Curious, do you find it difficult to become immersed into fiction? I've noticed you say this a few times Josh, where you "don't care" because it's a fictional show, you know they'll survive, etc... I'm not able to immerse myself into everything I watch, there's a barrier to cross there to achieve that, but when I am able to, I no longer think on that meta level at least not while watching the episode (after the fact is different).

Bert

Every series has its notorious stinkers, I just forget when that happens for Voyager. It is a more even series. I experienced a lot of it as comfort food in the early 00s when I'd just moved out and I had DVR so there was always a fresh batch of Voyager reruns in my queue to look forward to. A lot of the show worked for me as safe familiar Trek. But I also experienced the show through the lens of the Opinionated Voyager Episode Guide later known by the creator's handle SFDebris. He's matured a lot but he was savage to that show. You'd think from that description he would be the pinnacle of angry sweaty nerd who misses the point while arguing about how the show's floorplan doesn't match up with the "Official Voyager Blueprints" (which was totally a thing).. But he was a little too smart to be dismissed that easily.

Target Audience

When I’m able to become fully immersed it’s when it’s excellent such as Lessons, Lower Decks, etc. So, it has to be at a very high level of execution and enjoyment for me to do so, but it can happen.

Loot Narsbaar

The point of Voyager being in the Delta Quadrant is so they and DS9 are free to do their own thing. DS9 was hurt badly by being under TNG's thumb for two seasons and never really recovered with the general audience. I would argue on that reason alone setting VOY in the Delta Quadrant is already a tremendous success. As much as MY preferences would be for the show to be maybe as what is described above it purposefully is not that. Remember, Voyager was designed to appeal to fans who did not like DS9 but were willing to watch another show with the Star Trek branding. Being not like DS9 means: -Set on Starship -Episodic -TNG level of serialization -Cozy feel of TNG/ current day TOS The point of the show is to be able to jump into any episode and to easily know what is happening. It's no secret DS9 is my favorite show and I'm not a fan of Voyager. But I'm trying to give it a chance just based on the individual episodes and not get mad at it for what it was never intended to be.

Loot Narsbaar

I give you guys shit sometimes but I do genuinely think you enjoy watching the show as a whole even if you like it like 1/5 as much as I do

Loot Narsbaar

DS9 always had good ratings to the end, but it was a disappointment for the suits because for the first two seasons they had most of TNG's audience and then many people gave up on the show near the end of season 2 when it got consistently good. I love the show but I didn't start watching regularly until season 3. The Search hooked me, the Jem He'dar did not.

Katie Jackson

I just looked and Season 2 aired it's premiere episode on my 11th Birthday 🎂 🥳

Matt Newmark

Lord I am looking forward to the rest of this show with you two - I am so pleased to have been correct all along in thinking that I understood what it was that wound your clocks and TRULY inspired you. It's not always going to be S-tier and amazement, but damn it, the GOD-tier emotionally connecting scenes from this show will NEVER leave your minds once you've seen them and there are so many of them. Great discussion, can't wait to enjoy all these reactions on YouTube! Have a great one gents.

Ken R

Ex Post Facto does not get enough respect. No, Neelix cannot be great.

John M.

Nobody's mad. At least, I hope not. :)

L J

Agreed - I think there is a lot to like in Cathexis. Not a top favorite, but it's a solid episode that's fun to watch.

L J

I am content with the way the show has handled the integration of the two crews and the amount of conflict between the Maquis and Starfleet crew. They address it several times throughout this season, enough that it's still present but not in your face all the time. They could have incorporated it into more episodes and that may have been a neat element to have, but I don't think the show suffers because they didn't do more of it. I maintain the opinion that the fans who complain about this particular element have a misunderstanding about the fundamental nature of the Maquis. The Maquis dislike Starfleet politics - in particular, they were angry with their choice to abandon numerous colonies in a treaty that ceded several planets into Cardassian territory. So they actively worked against Starfleet and the Cardassians in an effort to protect those planets. But that is a very limited conflict. And it is on the other side of the galaxy. It seems unreasonable to me that the Maquis and the Starfleet crew members would continue to take issue over a matter that is completely irrelevant in the circumstances they find themselves in. They may not like Starfleet, and may not be happy to be serving on a Starfleet ship... but that doesn't mean they are going to holding a grudge and fighting with the Starfleet crew all the time. Now, if this had been a Romulan ship or a Cardassian ship that was forced to join the Federation crew, I could understand that leading to a lot more drama and conflict. But the Maquis really aren't that level of adversary.

captveg

In the 90s when I first watched Voyager I was someone who wanted a little more of the Starfleet/Maquis tension and the survivalist/minimal resources struggle. But then the 2000s brought me Battlestar Galactica (which I love) which has that aspect to the nth degree. So now when I watch Voyager I'm glad it's not so tense in that sense all the time. It's, for the most part, classic Star Trek vibes - something I really hope we get again someday.

Loot Narsbaar

almost 40 years from the start of TNG

Loot Narsbaar

Why Voyager was the flagship, but DS9 was first? Two simultaneous starship shows weren't going to fly. DS9 had stand out from TNG. They wanted it to have it's own unique feel. That's why there's a station and that station is alien. That's why they had to wait until the Enterprise went away to introduce the Defiant. The writers wanted to wait another year to launch Voyager in order to avoid Trek fatigue and to force Trek fans to give DS9 a chance, but Paramount needed their starship show now fucking now.

Loot Narsbaar

I would welcome a bit of Starfleet vs. Marquis as far as debating practicality vs. virtue in tough situations... But if they were at their throats all the time? That wouldn't feel like Star Trek. Also, I don't think it's FAIR to harshly criticize Voyager for dropping the conflict of the two crews. DS9 had Starfleet vs. Bajoran Milita and they became a harmonious crew by the end of the three parter in opening season 2, and had mostly stopped fighting before then.

Nolan

Vaughn Armstrong also played a Cardassian in the second episode of DS9, "Past Prologue."

Summer

More and more I like the entire first season as I did when I first watched, Eye of the Needle, Phage, State of Flux, Prime Factors are the best but I like then all. Becaust I started in season 2 with out seeing DS9 or the 2 Maqui adjacent TNG episodes I had moderate interest in what some of the original ideas were. As a writer, plots change, direction changes

Matchstick Jose

I don’t think it’s about being at each others’ throats all the time, more that the setup seemed designed to give us characters with vastly different perspectives and principles, and it’s that clash that would cause some of the friction and thus drama. I think the criticism is basically that they sanded those rough edges off the Maquis characters (except for Seska) almost immediately, such that they might as well have just made it a fully Starfleet crew and designed the show that way.

BN13

I think SFDebris had a huge impact on most people's opinion of Voyager today. As for my experience with Voyager, I first watched it long after it was off the air. Probably 2009ish? I binge watched them all in one go. I really enjoyed the show for what it was, but also wished it were better in places. Then I found SFDebris, and got the impression that most of the fanbase hated this show for being "bad Trek." I was also introduced to the Neelix and Janeway hate which never made sense to me. While he did make some good points, i feel like a lot of his reviews never took the full picture into account, and relied a lot on his humor style of turning every character into a charicatuer, which IMO, didn't actually fit the true characters at all.

Skullman8942

My Top 5: 1. Eye of The Needle 2. Phage 3. Jetrel 4. Faces 5. Emanations Honourable Mentions: Prime Factors, Parallax, State of Flux, Caretaker and Time and Again It's been over 5 years since my first watch of Voyager and the rest of the Berman era shows and I have to say, Voyager's first season is pretty good. Outside of TOS, it's the strongest first season we've had so far. Even though for me DS9's first season had stronger highs in Duet, Captive Pursuit and Progress, this season was more consistent and I would maybe only give one episode a D or a C-

BN13

I saw the potential for conflict that the Maquis represent for the show more as "Federation Idealism" vs "Maquis Pragmatism." Like the two crew would frequently have different ideas on how best to get home, and the Maquis wouldn't always agree with the ideal Starfleet solution. And most of my complaints with this issue really have nothing to do with Season 1. I think Season 1 actually used the premise of both crews very well. Especially with State of Flux, Prime Factors, Caretaker, and Parallax. My issues with Voyager come from looking at the show as a whole, and feeling like a lot of things, like the intial premise, and overall character development, eventually feel watered down except in a few occasional places.

Summer

I started Voyager on my own in 2008 and didn’t know any background issues either

Loot Narsbaar

I was always under the impression Voyager was the popular show and DS9 was for the freaks

Loot Narsbaar

I think you guys convinced me to raise my opinion of the Burger King episode. I can't fully get on board because I think the ending falls flat but I do appreciate the idea of not weaseling out of following the Prime Directive like Picard would. 1) Jetrel (A) 2) Prime Factors (A-) 3) Parallax (B) 4) Phage (B) 5) Caretaker (B) Would probably have State of Flux and the one with the dog as D/D- Floating Chakotay as an E Everything in between falls in the C range Ranking the Season Ones: This season was a much stronger season 1 than TNG. There's only maybe 3 episodes in that season I could recommend. I'd rank it behind DS9 season 1. Even though that season is all over the map it did give us a S+ in Duet giving more peak value. DS9 s1 also had more B/B- level episodes, but did have more Ds. One thing Voyager did well is to not have was an episode so incredibly bad as If Wishes Were Horses. Nothing here gave me second hand embarrassment from watching. Of course TOS season one is the clear winner. That's their strongest season.

Summer

Not to nitpick with beloved fellow fans, but you have Journey’s End the inciting incident, Maqui 1 and 2, Preemptive Strike, and maybe you can count Defiant as actual pre Voyager episodes that have to do with the Maqui, its not that much or that long, I guess you could say Tribunal was adjacent but wasn’t about them. So there’s really nothing to see with the premise of Mqui hating starfleet. I dare say there isn’t enough foundation material to justify the idea of such a premise making it clear why it changed (i imagine hollywood coming up with the premise than one smart writer or director saying “what….that makes no sense.”)

penoyer79

30 years between TOS and Voyager is what they were talking about

penoyer79

ex post facto was the only episode i was bored with i had trouble getting through. Heroes at least had some whimsy doctor moments. Emanations was one of the my favorite episodes of the season... i thought there was a lot of interesting stuff going on there. to inadvertantly shake an entire planet's belief system...

penoyer79

No one will blame you when you pull the rip cord on modern Trek.

penoyer79

it's so interesting...half the voyager fans i see swear by the first 3 seasons and despise everything after. then another subset of voyager fans find the first 3 seasons completely unwatchable and LOVE seasons 4+. very divided fan base. i only watched a little bit of voyager in its original run.. so this is kind of like a first time watch... and i'm really enjoying for the most part.

penoyer79

coming fresh off TNG and coinciding with DS9 revving up into its prime.... Voyager suffered from some unfair expectations.

Imogen S

I find a plenty to like in a lot of modern Trek, there's three entire series in particular that I really enjoyed. So what if not all of it is great? No big deal, that's been the Star Trek way since forever!

SWOLEXX

it does, in fact, get better.. and better... and better... all the way to the end. Dont get me wrong, there are some stinkers to be sure, but that being said, this show solid.

Actuarial Lurker

Matchstick- any serialized show PRIOR to modern social media hype would tend to have declining viewers. You can't jump into DS9 in Season 5 and know what's going on or love it so much and binge watch from the start since you couldn't binge. You CAN watch Breaking Bad mid-way through or hear it's great on the internet and then watch it. If DS9 had been released in the past 5 years with modern PR and modern methods of watching on demand it would have had 3 times the viewers as it did when it first ran...

Actuarial Lurker

I view the lack of need for resource management as the equivalent of a bad cop or military show. In a cartoonish show a cop shoots 50 bullets without reloading. In Breaking Bad or Dirty Harry ("Do you Feel Lucky?") people run out of ammo and know they could so have to be strategic Yes it would be stupid if in every episode they had to reload food supplies and trade away tech to get something. That is why the Kazon not knowing how to make water in Caretaker is so laughably stupid- how can you travel at warp, fly through hydrogen clouds and breathe oxygen and not make H20? But if Voyager shot 200 photon torpedos every week it would be just as cartoonish as the lobby scene in the Matrix where Neo and Trinity each have 50 guns.... is Star Trek supposed to be a super hero comic book like The Matrix or is it supposed to be like the real war we have right now in Iran where shooting $1 Million dollar interceptors to take out $20,000 drones quickly levels the playing field because you run out of weapons or go broke even if you overpower your rival? In my mind you get better story telling if you have to pay SOME attention to resources...

Three Dalmations

Voyager is my favourite Star Trek series is exactly for the same reason that you’re enjoying season one, it understands how to deliver those classic “Star Trek vibes“ that you just don’t get from any other show. It’s the exploration of moral questions, and a captain who has a greatness to them, who can lead the crew through and even make them soar. Anyway, I just wanted to say that I’m so glad you guys are enjoying it, and to let you know that there are plenty of people who think this show starts great and stays great.

SWOLEXX

we have to wait for Kurtzman to leave the franchise and its gonna be messy, hes fighting massive legal battles with paramount for a metric fuckton of money and the rights.. but when its over, I have high hopes

Tim Nikiforovs

The patrons award Cathexis no points, and may God have mercy on it's soul

Actuarial Lurker

I agree- even though I am a DS9 fan- the Voyager series highlights "How does a captain maintain Star Fleet moral values" when there is nobody above you to watch what you do?" Examples would be Seska's Cradassian pragmatism- why not sell or trade technology? Who cares if you destroy the Delta quadrant if you trade replicator tech for better phasers one week and trade something else to the Videans for advanced biotech, and something else to the next week to cut 40 years off the trip home like the pleasure planet they just visited why wouldn't you This series is very much like the Greek myth in Plato's Republic- the Ring of Gyges about a magic ring that makes you invisible- would you still be moral and not murder, pillage etc if you had a magic ring that let you get away with anything? Plato's point is the true test of a moral man or woman is what they are willing to do when they think nobody is looking. And Janeway is basically invisible to Starfleet (but visible to her crew).

jon bolton

I just realised, one thing you guys didn't do was rank your favourite characters so far. As much as i'd love to include Seska, she'd win which seems unfair on the mains so i'll leave her out of my ranking based on Season 1, which i saw a good 10 years before anymore Voyager (the next Voyager i saw after this was when i bought Season 4 on dvd lol, before watching and taping the rest off Sky 1 and 2) anyway my Season 1 rankings first to last: The Doctor, B'Lanna, Janeway, Tom, Tuvok, Harry, Chakotay, Kes, Neelix.

Ryan

If someone had asked me before I started the DS9/VOY journey with you, I would have said that DS9 is the best ‘90s Trek series, even though TNG is the one I’ll always love the most. But I also would have said that Voyager probably had the strongest first season and it also probably had the strongest overall cast. Watching each episode again with you has confirmed that, if anything, I underestimated Voyager on both counts. I’m genuinely looking forward to season 2 and I never expected that. Keep the takes coming!

Summer

For the most part my favorite Trek is the Trek I am watching

jon bolton

I completely agree it was Odo, and Rene played him brilliantly.

jon bolton

I see the Kazon as the Klingons poor relations lol. Technically there's an element of truth in that, remember The Chase. Unfortunately that means us Terrans also share some DNA with them too.

Kt B

If one more person says, “Oh, gee, I wish they would finish reacting to Battlestar Galactica because they love Ron Moore,” I will point them to around minute 25 where they say, “if all the episodes focus on interpersonal conflict (Maquis versus Starfleet) and survival with limited resources, it’d be f-ing boring!” Yeah, BSG is a superbly well-crafted study of human nature under survival circumstances, and the politics, interpersonal dynamics, and survival strategies are central to the show. It’s great! It’s introspective, gritty, and meticulously made. And it’s not what they want from their Sci Fi.

ShazD

They love a false dichotomy lol

ShazD

Time and Again is an A+? I find Janeway suggesting they don't save a planet of billions from self destructing already stops it reaching A lol.

Tim Nikiforovs

Alright, I watched(listened while driving) a few days ago, but a little late with my summary post. At least now it won't get buried in the comments. Patrons Josh Alex 1 - Eye of the Needle 1 - Eye of the Needle 1 - Eye of the Needle 2 - Jetrel 2 - Prime Factors 2 - Jetrel 3 - State of Flux 3 - State of Flux 3 - Time & Again 4 - Caretaker 4 - Jetrel 4 - Prime Factors 5 - Prime Factors 5 - Caretaker 5 - Learning Curve Honorable Mentions Faces Faces Mudd's Women Phage "The Season" The Cloud Parallax Parallax Emanations State of Flux Caretaker Since I didn't find time to send in my own list, I would say 1 - Jetrel 2 - Eye of the Needle 3 - Faces 4 - Caretaker 5 - State of Flux With HRs being Prime Factors Emanations and Phage

Matt-o-Matic

my favorite thing about Janeway, which I don't think I gave her nearly enough credit for when I watched then when it first came out... is her sense of wonder. I absolutely love seeing her nerd out with Torres... Her sense of wonder when she is talking to any number of her crew is contagious. Mulgrew did such a fantastic job of being the embodiment of curiosity and wonder.

SierraNicole

I totally agree. Plus, it's such a small crew. Realistically, these people are spending so much time together and they're ultimately all just soldiers on their respective crews. They might have different political opinions or philosophies but they have more in common than they have in opposition--the same base of knowledge, the same familiarity of worlds and events, the respect for spacefare and exploration, the notion of being a subordinate in a hierarchy with responsibilities to a crew and a ship...that's a lot to build on. And trauma like being displaced to another galaxy and cut off from the rest of humanity necessarily facilitates solidarity through which they would, of course, bond. So I think people who expected more explicit or dramatic tension between the crews were a little unrealistic. I like that Voyager spent less time on that and let that history provide interesting and distinct context for select characters. As far as survival in general, I thought they touched on that enough, too. Even in episodes where it wasn't a capital-letter theme, it was present in the context of the plot and characters. Things like malfunctions are more serious because they can't just get replacement parts. Things like insubordination and conflict are detrimental to the function and survival of the crew on a scale that requires it to be addressed immediately and aggressively. The infection attacking the gel-packs happened because a non-Federation alien brought a never-before-encountered bacteria on board because the crew has to source some of their sustenance from new planets with new risks. Whenever they lose personnel or have to fire weapons, you're keenly aware that they're keenly aware that they have a very limited supply of both and must therefore be judicious in ways that may not always comport with Starfleet protocol. Some episodes are more explicit, of course. Some are them forging allies or exploring anomalies for the sole reason that it's necessary for their survival. But, for me at least, I thought the survival aspect of the show (which is one of its coolest, most original themes) is ever present in the innovation and troubleshooting and inter-personal relationships portrayed in the show. It's part of what makes Voyager so damn enjoyable and rewatchable.