HPTD - CH 110 - Trickster Through and Through (Patreon)
Content
Okay, so his magic was still working just fine.
All this time, he'd been afraid of what might happen if he fed the Horcrux to the shop. The answer? A nasty headache and a slideshow of Riddle's life.
Sure, living through those flashes sucked, but at least his magic hadn't gone haywire like it had with that soul-sucking ritual he'd tried before.
Both methods were flawed.
Maybe he could come up with something that had the best of both worlds.
Ben was about to spiral into theoretical nonsense when a small voice cut through the quiet.
"Ben..."
He turned.
Cho's eyes were half-open. Her voice was barely a whisper. She looked pale, exhausted, and scared.
Ben was at her side in an instant. The torches on the wall flickered faintly, casting eerie light over the damp stones. A few feet away, Marianne lay unconscious.
"Ben..." she whispered, her voice weak. "You're okay…"
"Yeah," he said, crouching beside her. "We're okay now. It's over."
Tears welled in her eyes. "I'm sorry, Ben," she said, her voice thin, trembling. "I tried to stop him. From attacking you, from hurting Marianne. I tried. But I couldn't. I—I couldn't move. I was still in there, but I couldn't stop him."
Ben felt the weight in his chest grow heavier than ever. "I know."
She looked at him desperately, like she needed him to believe it.
"I tried my best, trust me," she whispered.
"I know, Cho. I know," he said again, more gently this time. "You were trapped in your own body. It wasn't your fault."
Cho's eyes watered, but she blinked it back.
Ben let the silence sit for a moment, then spoke—quietly, like a confession.
"I'm sorry too."
She glanced at him and shook her head slowly. "It wasn't your fault. Marietta took the diary from your room, and I didn't give it back; you didn't even know what it was."
"I did," Ben said. "It was my fault you ended up in this position."
Cho looked confused now, eyebrows knitting. "What do you mean?"
Ben didn't answer right away. He looked away, eyes fixed on a crack in the stone floor. The guilt he'd buried since summer rose like bile in his throat. No matter how nonchalant he acted, it ate at him that he'd let an innocent suffer—just to test Dumbledore. Honestly, it made him no different from him.
"I lied, Cho. I didn't find it amongst used books."
"Lied? Why? Where did you get it then?" she asked, wide-eyed.
Ben took a breath. "I saw Lucius Malfoy put the diary into Ginny Weasley's cauldron back at Flourish and Blotts. I knew it was cursed, so I took it from her that same day."
"How could you have known it was cursed?" she asked.
"I—I saw it, in glimpses. The diary twisting Ginny, turning her into something else. That's why I took it from her. But I just couldn't destroy it, it had a sort of influence over me too," he said.
It wasn't technically a lie; he was glad he had spent a year building credibility as a Seer.
"When Marietta Edgecombe stole it during the holidays, I didn't go looking for it. I was scared it would mess with my head, so I just… I stayed away."
"You couldn't have known it'd be me, you couldn't have stopped it," she said, less to reassure Ben and more to reassure herself.
"I did know. I was just too much of a coward to face it, to face you," Ben said, lowering his head.
Cho lowered her head. "You saved me in the end."
Ben shook his head. "That doesn't change what you went through."
She didn't speak. Didn't have to.
Ben could see it—how she turned that over in her mind. Realising that the boy she'd once had a crush on had made a choice that led to months of her life vanishing into someone else's control.
He waited for the anger. The hurt.
But there was none. "Why are you telling me all this?" she asked finally.
He ran a hand through his hair, voice low. "I don't expect forgiveness, Cho. Just thought you deserved the truth."
Cho was quiet for a moment, eyes flickering with something unreadable. She looked like she wanted to say more—but wasn’t sure how.
Then her gaze drifted, thoughtful.
"You know..." she said slowly.
"I saw you Obliviate Lockhart."
Ben tilted his head. "You saw that, huh?"
"You didn't even hesitate. You just... wiped him clean."
"Yeah."
She looked at him. "Are you gonna do that to me too?"
"What? Of course not!" he said, taken aback.
"Why not?"
"You're my friend, Cho. I would never do that to you," he said, a bit hurt.
"Even if that means I could get you into trouble?" she said.
"I don't mind getting in trouble for it," he said.
"What if I ask you to make me forget?" she asked.
"NO. Why would you want that?" he said, shocked.
"Wouldn't it be better for both of us if I forgot about the whole thing?"
"What do you mean?" Ben had a bad feeling.
"This whole thing has been a nightmare. It would be best if I could forget it like one," she said, holding her face in her palms.
"Hey," Ben said, holding her shoulder, "I know you've been through a lot, and I know it can be overwhelming, but you can't let it defeat you like this."
He pulled a small bottle from his pocket. "Drink this. It'll help."
Cho took it with a shaking hand. As she drank, colour returned to her cheeks.
Ben moved over to the unconscious Marianne. She was a lot more battered after being taken for a ride by Riddle. Ben used Healing Hands to heal her bruises and her banged-up head and fed her a Health Potion. She was still unconscious, but her breathing became stable, and the paleness finally left her face.
"You like her, don't you?" Cho said, now sitting upright.
Ben blinked. "What?"
"I've seen how you are with her," she said, voice low. "She's funny. Beautiful. You always laugh around her. If I were you, I’d pick her too.”
Ben shook his head. "It's not like that," he said firmly. "She's like a little sister to me."
“Yeah? She’s older than you,” Cho muttered.
"So are you."
She glanced at him. Ben took a deep breath and held it, as if contemplating whether to say the next words or not. But ultimately, he did.
"I'm a Seer, Cho," he said, choosing to be untruthful again.
"Yeah, I know. I don't see what that's got to do with anything," she said, sounding a little annoyed at him flaunting his gift at every opportunity he got.
"I don't just see the future, Cho. Sometimes I see the past as well. I've lived other lives—died other deaths. I might be twelve on the outside, but inside..." He trailed off. "I've felt too much."
"What are you getting at?" she asked.
"I know you feel something, but it’s based on a version of me that isn’t real. In truth, we’re at completely different points in the story. And I… I can’t step back into that chapter, even if I wanted to," he said.
She was quiet for a long moment, then looked at him with a strange softness.
“I'd hoped that maybe you felt something for me too,” she said.
“You’re beautiful, Cho. But that’s not what I feel when I look at you.”
“Let me guess,” she muttered. “Like a little sister.”
Ben gave a chuckle. “Exactly.”
Her eyes dimmed. "That only makes me feel worse," she said.
Ben gave a sad smile. The chamber was silent again. Marianne was still unconscious, and since there was no phoenix around to heal the wounded, Ben got back to healing her.
"You know, when I saw the way you looked at Marianne, I hated it. I wanted her to suffer. I wanted her gone. And I think… some small, ugly part of me still meant it."
Ben frowned. “That wasn’t you. That was the diary manipulating your feelings.”
“But it fed off something already there,” she said. “Jealousy. Anger. Even when the diary wasn't controlling me… even when Tom wasn't whispering things in my head… deep down, a part of me still felt those things."
"Cho—"
"I don't want to live with that," she said. "I don't want to carry that thought around with me. Please. I want to forget that part of me—the version of me that strangled chickens, attacked you and Marianne."
He hesitated. Looked into her eyes. Saw the pain there. The honesty.
She wasn't asking for escape. She was asking for mercy.
He reached into his pocket and pulled out his wand.
"You'll forget everything, Cho. Not just the bad. The diary, the Chamber, Tom Riddle—all of that would be gone. But so would the good things. Your friends. Quidditch. Every memory from this year."
Cho's gaze locked onto his.
"That's the way it should be."
"If that's what you want," he said, pointing his wand at her head.
She looked at him for a beat, then nodded.
"I'm sorry. Stupefy." Ben lowered her gently. A trickster through and through.
"You already lived through it. You survived. You're stronger than you know, Cho."
If you noticed the foreshadowing, congratulations. If you didn't, pretend you did. That's the magic of being a reader.
-End of Chapter-
Alright, guys, a bit too occupied right now to write. Might not be able to update tomorrow either. This is a sort of rough chapter, might make some changes to it later once I get free. Let me know what you think.