Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Hello all,

Some of the common misinterpretations from the last video are really getting stuck in my craw. For better or worse, I made this Connextras video to hopefully clarify this for anyone who needs it.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZA_EifQu6is

It's not scripted, so you'll have to wait for auto-captions, unfortunately. I'm planning to release this in an hour or two.

Files

HVAC sizing follow-up (shared walls, sizing for heating, "runs all the time,'" aux heat, etc)

The original video this is in response to: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DTsQjiPlksA The condensed version: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_hAuKtoRxJI

Comments

Kevin M. Wing

One note about the propane storage. I discovered recently that a you have to consider how much a propane tank can vaporize. Ambient temperature and the current content of a tank limit the btu/hr a tank can output. So, if you're thinking of using a 20lb grill tank for your furnace you may not be able to vaporize enough propane to feed a furnace. You'd probably need a 100 lb tank, and may not be able to keep it running under a certain percentage fill.

Aleksei Besogonov

VRF systems are cool! And you _can_ get their benefits in residential applications, although it's a bit on the cutting edge. Basically, you need a hydronic heating/cooling system with cold and hot water tanks. Then you can use the cold water tank as the secondary heatsink for the heatpump. In essence, you'll be pumping energy from your cold water tank into your hot water tank if it's possible. Coincidentally, hydronic systems (especially radiant floor heating) are tragically unpopular in the US. It's a real shame.

Jerrad Pierce

Re: continuously running around 31:00, you're often not expressly giving the caveat about single-stage versus multi-stage with all of the repetition. It should be obvious enough, but the types of folks having problems with these concepts in the first place may not be able join those items up if the breadcrumbs are not laid out for them.

Jerrad Pierce

Radiant heating is popular in high end homes in the Northeastern U.S, and I assume also upper Midwest. However, they are less common elsewhere because the expense of the radiant system is wasted if you are already installing a forced air system for cooling. Radiant cooling is technically possible, but challenging (esp. for residential) in most non-desert climates due to condensation.

Crash Cash

When my power's out, I have to shovel the damn coal myself...

AngryPanda

One question I have from the b-roll footage, is how does the unit contend with blown snow and drifts. The units are mounted a little closer to the ground than I expected.

AngryPanda

The funny thing with the controversy is that if a person is concerned with being conservative, then they can easily take your sizing and increase it by 1.5 to 2x for a safety factor. That's still way smaller than the way they are being sized currently.

Aleksei Besogonov

Yeah, radiant cooling is a bad idea. I'd love to see hydronic cooling with split units, though. The end result is not that more expensive, and you can use tricks like pre-cooling the water tank during the time when the electricity is cheap.

Andrew Maltby

I can't believe some people thought that running a heater half the size for twice as long would cost twice as much. Education System! If I get paid halve as much but work twice as long, will I earn twice as much? (like the heater takes twice as much)

Andrew Maltby

I live in North Australia where I do not need heating at all in winter but need very good colling in summer. I built my house 8 years ago and the only options I had for split system Air cons were inverter run revers cycle. Meaning the system runs at whatever 'power' it needs to maintain the temp.

Ed Bratton

Regarding run time. One major consideration you didn't take into account is air handler fan. Mine draws 500 watts just to run the fan. If my gas furnace had to run 24 hours per day it would use 12 kwh of electricity just to run the fan.

Jerrad Pierce

Most blowers are 0.5-1 horsepower. 1 horsepower is 746 W, so 500W is not egregious. You can certainly do better than the classic split-capacitor design with an ECM, reducing that by about half, but most people are not familiar with them. Air handlers are also generally integrated into the furnace, so it's not as simple as "get a new one." However, my understanding is that you can retrofit an X13 motor (ECM intended for this purpose) into many models of furnace. Indeed, many utilities have programs which incentivize this.

Technology Connections

There are two reasons I chose not to consider this: first, that wattage becomes heat in the end. It's slightly more expensive heat than the gas, sure, but it's only helping with the task at hand. But also, smaller furnaces will usually have smaller blowers. Or, if they don't have their own part, they can safely be set to lower speeds since you aren't dissipating as much heat. I'm all but certain that doesn't scale quite linearly, but as with everything here - it's too complex to give blanket advice.

Technology Connections

Yeah, I'm not happy with that but I think the reason I was struggling is that... it was never actually a real problem or a real scenario. I was trying to tackle both the fact that 100% output is a rare thing in the first place and that equipment is actually safe to run at 100% occasionally, when I should have separated them. To be honest this whole thing has been frustrating - there are several things which feel obvious to me but apparently aren't. And when it comes to educating folks on those things... I'm running out of tact.

Technology Connections

I was aware of this, but I was actually thinking of keeping the bottles indoors. Not sure whether that's a good idea, but even still - the equivalent of a crankcase heater could be wrapped around a tank to keep it vaporizing even if stored outdoors. I'm totally just getting heat strips, especially since my heating needs are so low. But I can see a future where people have a little box next to their air handler that they keep a small tank in. Could be there's a code thing against that, really don't know. But propane is a nearly drop-in backup sitting right under our noses.

Cory Benfield

FWIW, I’m not sure installers and manufacturers are using VRF the same way you are. At least Fujitsu in Europe seem to call their entire AIRSTAGE line VRF, but only a subset (VR-IV) do heat recovery. At least according to their brochure: https://www.fujitsu-general.com/shared/pdf-feur-support-ctlg-3ef037-2401e-vrf-01.pdf This confused me no end when my J-IVS system, which I had called a “multi-split”, was referred to as a “mini-VRF” by the service tech.

Technology Connections

My understanding is that Daikin has the trademark for VRF and uses it to mean heat recovery, but other manufacturers can't call it that. That could very well be a US-only thing, or possibly even completely incorrect! But if it is incorrect, that's how most technicians are using it.

Technology Connections

Are you talking about the unit I installed or some stock footage? Practice now is to elevate the outdoor unit on some sort of stand. With AC-only machines, you can just have it sit on the ground. Doesn't matter if it gets buried because you're not using it. Another thing the industry is going to need to relearn. But - cold climate heat pumps have heaters in the bottom of the pan to melt ice that builds up internally and allow it to drain out. That doesn't make them immune from snow drift problems, but it does minimize the number of scenarios that are problematic.

AngryPanda

Cool. That all makes sense and answers my questions. Having heaters in cold climate ones makes a lot of sense and was the core of my question.

Cory Benfield

I thought Daikin had the trademark on VRV. It does look like Daikin uses VRV to mean heat recovery. This seems unnecessarily confusing from a terminological perspective! Anyway, this video is great. My very stressful renovation led me to take my eye off the ball and only realise late that the AC guys had almost certainly oversized my system. I’ll be doing some heat loss calculations in the coming weeks to try to work out how bad, but for now it’s been ok this winter. Thanks for the heat pump content! I’ll try to throw a few blog posts together about my new system but it’s basically your long-standing recommendation but in the UK: a gas boiler replaced with an air-to-air mini-split/mini-VRF. It worked great through the winter!

Kevin M. Wing

I found it funny when I first learned that they make electric heaters expressly for out door propane tanks, another example of needing electricity! I ran into the problem when I upgraded my home to heat pumps for water heating and HVAC. The only propane equipment that remains on my property is the pool/hot tub heater (talk about first world problems). Astonishingly it's 400,000 btu. I wanted to eliminate my large tank, and was hoping I could run it from a 100lb tank, but for that much output I would need to manifold together multiple 100lb tanks. Obviously, the solution will be more pumping more now, and I'll replace the pool heater with a heat pump. It was just something I recently ran across and had me thinking when I saw this update. I'm not sure what happens to a furnace when it's fuel starved. With all the safety cut outs in a furnace it may cut off before a tank empties. So the estimate of how long you can run a furnace on a 20 lb bottle may have to take into account that it may only be able to supply energy for a portion of the tank fill. Probably just another reason to right size the furnace and not install a 60kbtu monster when you can do 20k.

Steven Nicklas

Mitsubishi also has two model lines: one with heat recovery and one without (this ignores the hybrid systems and other variants). The one w/o heat recovery has piping that just splits off to multiple indoor units and the outdoor unit varies the compressor to keep up with the total loading. The heat recovery system is similar, but adds a box called a branch controller that handles the distribution and re-routing of heat within the system. They both rely on a variable-speed compressor and a "smart" control system.

Sean Aaron

I’m enjoying these - very informative, but given I live in rented accommodation, I have no control over the fact that my flat has radiators and a condensing boiler. I have noted that electric plug in heating has a new (to me) option: the infrared panel heater - anyone have experience of these or know how they stack up efficiency-wise against conventional storage space heaters (silly expensive from past experience)? I figure if I can’t replace my combi, I could maybe buy a plug-in alternative, but if it uses massive amounts of electricity, it won’t be cheaper than gas.