Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Hello!

It's been a while. Would you believe that a script got out of hand? I know, unpossible. But that's what happened yet again.

https://youtu.be/ff04ecF9Dfw

This is something that I was genuinely delighted to learn about. I feel almost silly for not realizing that the same control strategy must have been used in older stoves, but I didn't! I had been wondering how exactly the power levels were modulated for some time and finally decided to look into it. And it's much more interesting than I could have imagined.

So... I'm going to try and rush a second video before the month is out. I felt very stuck on this one, especially since the Bright from the Start video was supposed to be the last video of March. And we're running out of April. I have a topic in mind but I need to confirm that my demo works, and if it does then I'll be starting production on that almost immediately.

I hope you enjoy this! I have the set warming up to make a better thumbnail and I'll be working on captions in the meantime. Should have them done by this evening.

Toodles!

Files

Simmerstats: The genius old tech that controls your stovetop

I like that title. Doobly-doo gonna get worked on later.

Comments

PerfectlyAdequate

So can you say this one has been simmering on the backburner for a while now?

Sneffaloken

I love the "I have the set warming up" because it took me a minute to remember the lava lamps in the background

Retro Sean

I have a new favorite saying, "infernal Frisbee" 😁

Mark Hesse

Just took apart a spare simmerstat (sounds like the name of a town in Germany) from my Jenn-Air stove. A bit smaller in size than those you demonstrated and a little different layout of the cams and contacts, but definitely the same function.

Kris Asick

The way the phases are connected in that Simmerstat actually explains a few things... Not too long ago the stove in our apartment failed in a weird way, where the clock went out yet if you turned a burner on the clock would come back to life but the burner wouldn't heat up. The property management replaced the stove but the new stove had the same issue and so clearly the problem was the outlet and thinking about the problem I reasoned one of the phases must've been out but not BOTH phases. Sure enough, that was what had happened but I had no idea why that was causing the behaviour it was... but now I know! :B

Crash Cash

"Turn knob further clockwise!" Seriously though, I always thought it was some sort of simple logic circuit myself, and did not imagine it was 100% mechanical.

Uhm Mu

Super cool! the biggest problem these cause for me in resistive electric stoves with regards to inconsistent heat is in water bath canning. It can go from boiling plenty to not boiling at all and back and forth, and makes the process significantly less predictable. Got a single burner gas module specifically for this for now. Induction stove is a future plan for sure

Ben M

17:00 "I've covered a certain other piece of tech which we use to make lamps flash" - I totally thought this was going to be the twinkling holiday lights! They even also use the same bimetallic strip technique

Aleksei Besogonov

Some notes. You stated that there are two way to control the average current (variable transformers and resistors), but triacs were available for a veeery long time. They just were not super-reliable at high currents. The main problem with triacs was that they mutilate and murder the power factor, and this is actually against the Federal standards. Modern MOSFETs can easily replace relays in stoves, and there are some stoves that do that. This immediately unlocks tons of options, like accurate temperature control regardless of the load.

Jon Adams

What about a triac or similar semiconductor? Don’t understand the need for pulsing

Jon Adams

Sorry meant IGBT

Aleksei Besogonov

Triacs are not a good idea because they have lead to poor power factor. You can fix that by installing capacitors to smoothen the current demand, but that quickly becomes more expensive than a bimetallic strip.

Richard Bevan

Despite the criticism of the touch controls on induction hobs, I am really happy with mine. The controls are just a flat piece of glass and can be easily cleaned. Mine is 10 years old and looks as if it was brand new. I do like these videos about appliances in American kitchens. They remind me of my childhood in 1970's Britain with the chunky knobs, everyone having a cooker (stove) because separate hobs and ovens were not invented yet and induction cooking was something from science fiction.

Jonas

I have a 4-plate induction stove with knobs and I love it! It still has 7-segment displays below the glass indicating the current power level for each plate so you get the best of both worlds. Or well, you cannot turn "everything off" with one button, but that's about it. The only thing that would be better would be a 3-plate stove with one even larger plate. The worst thing with touch controls on my previous stove is that if you carelessly place something metallic on top of the buttons.. like a large frying pan slightly off the plate, plates can turn on. The stove had some "uh-oh, this does not look like a human touching the stove" detection that sometimes worked and turned off the whole stove, but it wasn't fool-proof. My current stove looks pretty much like this: https://www.carlson.fi/media/catalog/product/cache/9b47a4ec1ac8f845f5e674094052a9bf/7/3/7332543457915.jpg

Lennart Sorensen

I certainly agree that touch controls can be annoying. On my current cooktop though I have no idea what control other than a touch screen would work though given it has virtual burners (up to 6 arbitrary shape and size induction burners spread over the total surface of the cooktop using 56 small induction elements in combinations).

MrHammond

Interesting, I always thought these knobs were just thermostats, but hey, that's what they are after all? Just with a local "heating element" instead of using the heat from the cook top... BTW: I also used to have touch controls in my previous apartment, also with a glass-top stove, I didn't have that many problems with it. My best friend asked my what I would do if the pasta water would cook over, I answered: nothing, the thing switches off itself automatically :-P.

Benjamin Kier

Thanks for using my employers outlet in your box (Legrand). Don't worry, i'm just an engineer, not in sales or anything. Since you love to talk about outlet design too, have you seen our pop-out outlets? https://www.legrand.us/wiring-devices/adorne-collection/outlets/adorne-20a-one-gang-pop-out-outlet-white/p/arptr201gw2 We also have a very interesting looking design, that is unfortunately terrible for vertical power bricks https://www.legrand.us/wiring-devices/adorne-collection/outlets/adorne-tamper-resistant-15a-duplex-self-test-gfci-receptacles-white/p/agftr2152w4

Jerrad Pierce

That "pop-out" thing is something only an architect or interior designer could love. More than ten times the price of a conventional product for an inconvenient experience :-P

Benjamin Kier

yeah the employee discount make it a lot more reasonable lol and I would say it's got a coolness factor of hiding the outlet away until it's needed. and hey, it's got a lifetime warranty, that I certainly like.

Greg Smith

Agreed, I figured it was related to the heat trapped (much like the overheating shutoff)

Arthur Robillard

How much deforming and reforming can a bimetallic strip go through? Wouldn't metal fatigue (I think that's what it's called) cause the strip to basically say, "Enough!" and self-destruct, especially if it happens with this amount of frequency? I can see it lasting for quite a long time in your average thermometer given how slowly air temperature changes throughout an entire day, but many times per minute? Obviously, it works, so what would I know.

Juho K

The fatigue of a metal is tied to the stress on the part. A part can withstand a few loading cycles with high stress or hundreds of thousands or millions of cycles with low stress. In addition many materials have what is called an endurance limit. It is a level of stress below which no fatigue will happen. Parts which undergo lots of loading cycles are designed such that the stress doesn't get above the endurance limit. Then the part will at least in theory withstand infinite amount of use if it is not overloaded. The simplest examples are rotating shafts which experience a loading cycle on each rotation. That can mean thousands of loading cycles per minute and millions per day. They would crack very quickly if improperly designed. The bimetallic strip only bends a tiny amount and is made of very thin material. It means that the stress is also very low and fatigue is not a problem.

Frank Schmitt

I'm super curious how the old 6-button GE stove controls worked (with HI-2-3-LO-WM-OFF radio buttons), but not curious enough to spend ca. $150 to buy one on eBay. But maybe someone who can write it off as a business expense could spend that kind of money :). They have L1 L2 and N screw terminals and then four spade connectors for the element. Is it just doing series/parallel tricks? Are there semiconductors (i.e. diodes) involved? Update: found what might be the patent for it: https://patentimages.storage.googleapis.com/63/0a/83/c9a2b88ade1d3c/US2431904.pdf

Michael

A good followup to this video would be talking about Hyper elements. They're in a variety of stoves, including the one in the video as the back left burner (the melt burner) and the front right (The even-heat ultra burner) of your current stove. These use different types of switches and supposedly use a different duty cycle, but I can't find published documents on this nor clear explanations from any manufacturer. Wolf has done something they referred to as "high frequency pulsation" for their radiant elements.