Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Hello! I’m still here and kicking, despite all the everything. And though it took me much longer than I wanted for various reasons, I have a new video today.

https://youtu.be/OOK5xkFijPc

For those who have been following my work for a while, I doubt much of the information in here is new. But I have noticed an increasing number of folks getting very worried about their energy use… while also not really understanding it at all. Part of what took me so long when making this video is that I kept making revision after revision - this topic clicks so neatly in my mind that it took a lot of work to step outside of what’s intuitive for me. And since I’ve never made a video specifically exploring energy, it felt like an important topic. If nothing else, I hope some of the comparisons I made here add something new to how you might think about energy. 

Now, I both want and need to update you on what’s in the works next but I will probably wait to do that until Monday. This weekend I want to honest-to-goodness figure out and test my live-streaming setup. An embarrassing degree of procrastination is the main reason that’s never happened. I’d like to make that something of a regular affair for Patreon - something like a hang-out, AMA type deal.

OK then, well, since this is a longer one it’s going to take me some time to do captions. That will probably be my project tomorrow so apologies to those who rely on them. I’ll get the script pasted into YouTube which makes them better but I really, really can’t stand how the captioning system handles the timings from a script…

Toodle-oo!

Files

Power isn't energy. The difference matters more than you may know.

Maybe that's a good title?

Comments

Sean Hearrell

Power vs. Energy is such an odd distinction that people constantly mix up. Glad you added your own “personal touch” to help explain the differences!

Michael Ford

Just in time to wind down for 💤

Bunny

watt?

Earl Plotner

Something like what Chris Boden does would be fun. Live stream making a video. Those who've not saw Chris should. He does mostly educational videos about electricity.

BrandEver

I hope you explain what Power Factor is. I've seen it mentioned in videos and don't quite understand what exactly it means, even after trying to look it up

Will Josephson

I read "This weekend I want to honest-to-goodness... " and I gotta tell you I was thinking you were leading up to UNPLUG, because that would be exactly the joke I'd expect from you. I'm not disappointed in the idea of live streams, quite the opposite in fact. Look forward to your next update!

DrumBrakes

This reminds me of the video that DeccyWeccy made at the independent a T£$L@ Roadster workshop where the owner/expert assured us that electric motors give full power at 0 rpm and then told us the battery energy capacity in kW.

Technology Connections

Power factor is weird and indeed very difficult to explain, but for the most part you don't need to think about it unless you're an industrial power customer - capacitors on the grid distributed at the neighborhood level provide enough correction for it to functionally not matter to the grid nor the power company.

Marc Ethier

Automatically generated subtitles at about 10:54 read "a 10 watt light bulb consumes 600 Jews every minute". That's... well, I'm not sure what to say about that.

Bunny

that's a lot of jews for 10 watts

BrandEver

That's kinda what I gathered, ut I still occasionally see people bring it up when talking about household appliances for some reason.

BSJ

Sing the Body Electric. Look it up. (Sci-fi reference)

zorg24

Thank you so much for doing a video of us, the amount of times I've had to explain this to people is well way too much, so clearly a video that needed to be made.

Brian Deschene

Power Factor (PF) only applies to Alternating Current (AC) electrical circuits like the electricity to your home. It does not apply to Direct Current (DC) electrical circuits from batteries. The ideal PF value is 1 (one). Many devices that reduce PF from 1 are those that convert between AC and DC (e.g.: LED light bulbs). Most places in the world, PF is not taken into account for your home energy bill so it can be ignored. It will matter, however, if you are sizing a portable generator. To be able to understand PF, I recommend EEVBlog 1417 - AC Basics Tutorial series. It’s available ad-free on Odysee and he posts here on Patreon as well. To understand PF, a good understanding of AC is required.

Kevin Bost

That was a wonderful video, Alec. Thank you for making it and everything you do

Veronica Explains

Can't wait to watch it! I find YouTube's caption editor to be terribly unintuitive. I wish they allowed a bit more in the way of keyboard customization so certain activities like slicing a subtitle segment could be a quicker affair.

Martin Lock

Well done not going down the rabbit hole of explaining why your 220kW electric car doesn't eat through its 77 kWh battery in 20 minutes. Also did you know you can make scrambled eggs in a microwave...

Mark L

Hey is your t-shirt part of the mural from Epcot (from Spaceship Earth)?

Scoott

battery pank

Crash Cash

Energy is basically power integrated over time, right? That's how I think of it. And now I'm going to rate everything in grams of propane per minute!

Crash Cash

Huh... I use 22-31 kWh/day here in Florida, which is about 40% of what I used before upgrading my heat pump from 9 SEER to 19.

Carl de Billy

Glad you're not going down the rabbit hole of kW vs kVA (real vs reactive power) Absolutely no mention of PF (Power Factor) in this video. :-)

Carl de Billy

Here in Montréal, it's 60-80kWh per day during the summer and 175-200kWh per day during winter. I'm owning a duplex (2 apartments) and using a mix or resistive heating & heat pumps. Without the heat pumps, it would be more than that!

MrHammond

I'm wondering about something, maybe you know more Alec? I recently moved to a brand new apartment (newly built, with state-of-the-art equipment, things like stove, oven, dishwasher and washing machine and dryer come with the apartment here in Switzerland), and of course, I got all A+++-rated equipment. The washing machine however takes a very long time for washing, and I also figured out that the connection is just a plain 10A-rated grounded Swiss plug, so the washing machine can use only up to 2300 kW theoretically, older machines I used either had 3-phase power or a 16A connection. Somebody once told me that the washing takes that long (more than 3 1/2 hours!) because of the low power consumption. To me, it's clear that less power means more time to get up to the correct temperature, but I was also wondering: don't you have more losses because you wash for a longer period? The dryer takes just a little bit shorter, but it's clear that that machine uses a heat pump, I would say: cool the outcoming wet air, the water condenses and gets pumped away, the hot side heats it again and blows it back into the machine, pretty easy and efficient. But in the end: having a longer turnaround time with less power, does that save energy? Do you know more about that? Might be interesting stuff for another video!

MrHammond

BTW: when I was shopping for displays for my home office setup, I ended up buying B-rated monitors instead of A (or higher): I figured out that the figures they presented on the energy label were too high, because the displays have a "gaming mode" that consumes considerably more power... None of the A-rated displays had such a thing... My complete home office setup (i7 laptop, 3 24" QHD displays and some background lighting) consumes less than 60W when fully active, less than most desktop PCs anyway...

Killianti

Oh man, corn ethanol really sets me off. It wouldn't be quite as bad if we had pipeline infrastructure for ethanol on par with petroleum, but there are still better crops for ethanol production even if that were true, and current subsidies are not intelligent and flexible.

DrumBrakes

I've finally got round to watching this. You've turned the Snark up to 11 quite a few times. I love it, but you're going to get some irrate Ignorance Signalling muggles in the YT comments when it goes public.

Circuitmike

I make scrambled eggs in the microwave! If you don't want them to be the consistency of rubber erasers you have to be really careful about timing but it works surprisingly well.

Martin Lock

30sec, whisk, 30sec, whisk, let it stand to firm up 👍

Matt Deres

FYI, there is a weird video artifact at about 13:13. There's a brief spate of compression artifacts. Again at 21:18, 30:09, 41:30, etc.

Matt Deres

Okay, I watched the whole thing. I've seen all the TC videos on YouTube - yes, even those really old ones - and I've gotta say that this was the least enjoyable. We all like the snark when it gets used judiciously, but this was... not that. This was more like condescension and 50 minutes of it is a LOT to take on. By the time the mini-rants came up near the end, I was about ready to quit. I'm glad I hung on for the battery panks, though. The tone used here is not your usual one. Normally, your voice is more dynamic and it seems to reflect your level of interest. The measured tone here makes it sound like you're trying to hold on to your patience and then the snarky bits push it over the edge. It's like you're sick of explaining it to us idiots.

Technology Connections

I'll be real with you, Matt. The world is frying my brain at the moment and it may have come through in this more than is ideal. It has been a very, very frustrating month and watching the world get run by incurious people who don't want to understand anything may have colored my tone more than it should have. But that's the reality we're in. I'm going to re-watch the video with a critical eye given your feedback, but I will say that my choice to inflict the exasperated tone of "think about this" in a very directed way was deliberate. The world needs more thought right now.

BrandEver

American washing machines don't heat their own water (some fancy machines have heaters for steam functions, but not the general wash). Our washers get hot water from the hot water line of the home. They often have generic "Hot/Warm/Cold" settings instead of exact temperatures, and get warm water by mixing water from both hot and cold lines. Top loading machines are pretty common here and are generally much faster than more efficient side loaders, which from what I understand are much more popular in Europe. So because our wash water is heated separately in the hot water tank, the only energy the washer is using is for the actual agitation and spin functions. As far as I'm aware, basically every washer here runs on a standard 120v plug.

BrandEver

I watched the video, and thought it was great. Idk if you plan on doing a follow-up, but if you do could you talk about how Volts and Amps figure in?

Matt Deres

Well, I can sympathize. I'm Canadian - it's ludicrous to me that my country suddenly finds itself in an unwarranted trade war and the literal threat of forced annexation and invasion. If you want to scream at the sky, I'm right there with you! I'm not sure that the tone used in this video has ever helped anyone be convinced of a point of view, though. I'm no expert on power/energy, so I would be a good audience for this video, but I only stuck with it because I'm already vested in the channel. If this was my introduction to TC, I'm switching off ten minutes in due to the unpleasantness. Think about every awesome explainer you know: David Attenborough, James Burke, whoever you like. Would you have responded to them so well if their tone was like the tone here? Can you picture Sir David rolling his eyes while exasperatedly explaining climate change for the Nth time? Probably not, right? It's not because he's not frustrated; it's because he knows it won't help.

Frank Schmitt

Maybe a topic for another video, but a factor that makes most non-heating loads even less of a factor during heating season is that any inefficiency ultimately shows up as heat in your house, which you're already paying to heat. The huge exception to this is hot water, whose energy literally goes down the drain (unless you have one of those heat exchangers, but I hear they don't really pay off for most scenarios).

Phil Roberts

I'm afraid I'm with Matt on this one. I haven't been a very (or at all...) active member of this community, so I don't offer this as more than just one random's opinion, but you should know that I've now cancelled my Patreon membership, and not just over this video. There's been a consistent pattern over the last few where I feel like I'm just sat on the sidelines watching as you yell at unseen people you've been engaging with on social media, and to me that is neither entertaining nor edifying. I don't disapprove of any of the change you're trying to effect in the world, but I seriously doubt you're going to achieve it if you go on as you are. I've seen enough of your videos that I'm fairly sure you don't actually think you're the only person in the world who knows anything, but I wonder if someone who's only come to your content more recently would be as confident about that.

Matthew

Ha, I purchased a solar system to sit on my home. It has been addicting to see how much energy its taking from the sun, as well as seeing how much energy is being used while doing daily tasks in the home while using the enphase app.

William Thal

Not dissing Matt's point of view because I agree with the criticisms, but this was one of the best videos for me. It's 100% correct that it could have been leaner and the tone was more "condescending" I guess. However this topic, specifically the kWh explainations, was something I never quite got and this did it for me. As for the tone, I quite like Angela Collier and she's been qualified as "condescending" too, so maybe I just gel with that style ? Anyway, the explainations were top notch as always !

Martin Ibert

Actually, one of the every-day activities that draw a surprising amount of power is showering. A typical shower has a flow rate of about 12 litres per minute. If you (like me) like your showers hot, you will want to heat up your cold tap water by about 30 Kelvin before enjoying it (1 Kelvin, as Alec will know, is a temperature difference of 1 °C). Heating up six litres of water by 1 Kelvin takes almost excatly 7 Wh of energy, so heating 12 litres of water by 30 Kelvin takes 420 Wh of energy. 420 Wh per minute is 25,200 Wh per hour or 25.2 kW. Yikes! That would more than max out your electricity feed. I hope you have a gas burner for hot water. Our two-person household runs on average at about 1.2 kW in total, with 1/3 being electricity and 2/3 being gas, BTW.

Some Ed

I think it's worse than them not wanting to understand things. They want to understand things, but they don't want to take the time and effort to do that. Instead, they want to understand things by forcing them to be how they'd been told they were back when they were little kids. This is less of a forcing the square peg in the round hole and more insisting that things are pegs and holes when they aren't. This my little cousin back in the day smashing his remote control car into tiny pieces so that it would fit in the square hole. No, that wasn't recoverable. Unfortunately, I don't think this will be either.

Filipe Gomes

Should we start calling power lines energy lines?

Gregory Harbin

I think the good explanations could have come across in a much shorter video, without the condescending, repeating, and arguing with people who may or may not exist

Jason Pagliaro

I honestly this is the best written and the best acted video you've done to date. Well done.

Some Ed

This is why most water heaters have a giant insulated tank. The tank gets heated at whatever rate it can be heated at most efficiently with the power source the water heater uses and then remains hot due to the insulation, with only occasional reheating as necessary. If you have a gas water heater, that water is probably heated much quicker than 420Wh per minute, if you have an electric water heater, it's probably a lot less than that, due to circuit limits. This tank business is why one can run out of hot water. There are on demand water heater systems, but those tend to be less efficient since they need to be able to heat the water at the exact rate you need the water heated. They can't look for the sweet spot in the efficiency curve based on their particular energy source's heat transfer curve.

Some Ed

A waste water to incoming water heat exchanger would probably require ones waste water to not follow the straightest path downward. I would think that would probably result in more clogs than it would be worth for anyone with longer hair. Alternatively, the waste pipe goes straight down, which leaves very little time for the heat exchanger to work its magic. I could conceive of a system that tries to get the best of both worlds, by having a filter in front of the heat exchanger. Everything that doesn't make it through the filter gets passed through a line that isn't wrapped up in heat exchanger. When the filter clogs, that's everything. So it only works when the filter's kept relatively clean. But when the filter's relatively clean, it could work pretty well, and that filter would be a lot easier to clean than the heat exchanger itself. These would probably get a bad rap because most people wouldn't remember to clean the filter.

Some Ed

Unfortunately, the people Alec was arguing absolutely exist. That said, they're probably not people who will watch Alec's videos and won't be convinced by them if they do.

Some Ed

Thinking about who I can mention without getting too political. One of my coworkers tried using a heat pump back in the 1980s. The unit he got then had been old when he got it, I don't know when it was made. It wouldn't stand up to Texas winters. To be clear, that's the Texas winters of 40 years ago, not the ones we have now. My coworker and I work in tech. You would think someone who works in tech would realize the technology we're working with has changed remarkably over the last four decades, so maybe other technology has also. But he doesn't see it that way. Instead, he chooses to complain about how no technology outside of our focus area ever seems to improve, and refuses to accept that's because he doesn't look for improvements outside of work, and he quickly forgets all of the ones that he can't ignore. He's one of the guys who now drives a car with a backup camera, because they're in all new vehicles these days, but he still turns around to back up. I will admit, I may not be quite as old as him, my professional career only goes back three decades not four, but I sometimes forget myself and turn to back up. But I know the camera is there and I use it most of the time. I don't use incandescent light bulbs and don't miss them. That said, I was one of those people who realized that humans living all over the globe meant we'd be having global impacts on weather and stuff back at the start of his career, while he sees how little he is and thinks nothing he do could ever effect the whole world, completely discounting the 8 billion other people involved in making global warming happen as well as discounting all industrial activity because he doesn't personally do any of that industrial activity, he just triggers some of it.

Martin Ibert

Ours is an on-demand gas-powered heater (the usual combination unit for room heating and hot water that many Europeans have). We don't have space for an insulated tank.

Nicolas Pereira

Something worth considering in future videos (especially ones like this) is that not everyone can juggle numbers in their head easily, especially if they are watching while eating dinner or something. Every now and then it would be nice to plop the previously shown numbers back on screen just for a quick reference. Like, when you calculate the cost to boil water or cook eggs, you do *mention* the daily/monthly costs and how it stacks up... but it would be nice to re-show the values on screen for those of us who need the reminder..

Some Ed

There may be some performance gains from washing slower. I'm not an expert, I don't know the details. But we at one point had an energy efficient washer that took twice as long to wash. Part of that process was it would spin a little then stop and pause for a moment. Spin the other way, stop and pause for a moment. Other washing machines we've had would switch directions frequently, but they wouldn't pause. They'd also move quicker during the agitation cycles. Taking over 2 hours to do the washer part of a load of laundry was a big pain, but I have to admit it seemed better at getting stains out than prior washing machines. We had to get rid of it because of reasons unrelated to its long washing cycle. The washer we have now is not quite as energy efficient. It doesn't have the pauses, but it does have slower agitation cycles for longer, as compared to a regular washing machine. We've not noticed any substantial performance differences, it's still pretty good about stains, and it does that on the delicate cycle in about an hour. Note that I'm also in the US and thus haven't had to deal with washing machines needing to heat their water.

Some Ed

I've been present for a number of lectures on that particular subject, but I don't think I ever really understood it. I think it may have to do with power transmission, which Alec didn't really talk about. I think it was my gut feeling that the topic was mostly analytical hand wrangling to make theoretical physics answers for power transmission line up with what we actually measure happening. I don't know if that gut feeling was right. The people who have talked to me about it seemed to think it was really important to understand. My main takeaway from it was that I was really glad that I didn't go into electrical engineering, because I also had the impression it was something I would have needed to understand and care deeply about if I had.

Some Ed

I think Alec explained why it doesn't go through its battery quite adequately even while not actually talking explicitly about that. It's peak load versus typical load. Once a car reaches its cruising speed, it doesn't take a lot of power to keep going, and regenerative breaking recovers most of the energy it took to get up to speed when one stops, so long as one stops closely enough to the ideal rate for regenerative breaking.

MrHammond

I have only once actually used an American washing machine (while I was in California for my work), it looked like something I'd never seen before here in Europe, instead of having a rotating drum it hat some kind of "3D-fork" agitating the laundry... (yes, you may laugh about that 😅) I didn't realise that it would use water from the hot tap, but I know that instead of a temperature indication, you only get •, •• or •••. My A+++ European washing machine also has options for faster cycles, but the manual clearly states that they use more energy, so I would only use them in an emergency. I guess then the 10A connection is still a limiting factor. More than 20 years ago, I lived in a house where another guy had an old Miele machine from 1967. It was broken, so I repaired it. The manual had actually exact descriptions of how the programs worked (using a large mechanical clock switch), you could also switch between 2 different rotating/waiting cycles: for delicate laundry programs, it used more water and less agitation but longer waiting periods. It had a 16A connection, which was at that time the standard in the Netherlands, but could also be connected to three phase power for faster heating. It would simply heat until the set temperature was reached, and only then advance the program wheel.

Some Ed

I think the microwave gets dissed as a cooking appliance because it's sufficiently different from other cooking appliances that most recipes aren't really portable between other cooking appliances and the microwave. If you understand how a stove works, an oven works, and a convection oven works, all at the physics level, you can convert recipes fairly easily between them. Of course, that only really works for mostly hands-off recipes, as you can't easily stir the dish every couple of minutes when it's in an oven. Microwave cooking adds at least one additional factor that can be difficult to work out. With a microwave, you need to worry about thermal penetration. You can heat the outside of the food you're cooking at least an order of magnitude faster than any of those other devices. The inside has to be heated with good old thermal conductivity in most cases, which is far slower than the rest of it. Also, when talking about the inside and outside of food, it's different than with other cooking appliances. With an oven, the inside and outside are really intuitive. The outside of any piece of the food is the part you can touch. With a stove, it's almost as intuitive, once you understand how the stove works. The inside is the bottom of each of the pieces, but it's still something you can touch if you pick it up. With a microwave oven, the outside is the outer perimeter of the mass of stuff you're cooking. It's basically all stuff you can touch still. But there may be a lot you can touch that's not the outside. For example, if you're cooking a tray of crab cakes, the ones on the outside perimeter will get cooked a lot faster than the ones on the inside. Also not intuitive to a lot of people, the bottom of the microwave isn't the thermal source. It's the sides. There's nothing visual there to explain why this is, because microwave ovens are made opaque, and if they weren't, most people still wouldn't recognize the operative bits. At the same time as all of this complexity makes traditional cooking rather interesting with a microwave oven, they were quickly determined to be amazing at reheating already cooked food. With already cooked food, there's no need to make sure all of the animal-sourced stuff gets heated to 165 degrees Fahrenheit. As such, especially towards the beginning of the microwave era, microwave cooking was reheating. We've had time for a lot of experimental chefs to work out how to convert recipes to microwave ovens. Not nearly as much of that happened as would have without microwaves being disdained as cooking appliances, but some has. The rate of recipes getting converted will probably increase as microwaves ovens are used for more first pass cooking, rather than just being used to reheat stuff.

Frank Schmitt

My understanding is that in a vertical pipe water tends to cling to the pipe walls, so vertical heat exchangers are pretty effective (with counterflow the preheated fresh water can be even warmer than what's going into the sewer). The main issues I found are that you need enough vertical clearance to make it work, so it's often not practical for a ground-floor shower, and that the materials (mostly copper) are relatively expensive, so the ROI is pretty marginal.

Steve King

As if to emphasise the amount of confusion this article appeared on slashdot: https://www.theverge.com/tech/638559/watt-vs-mah-battery-measurement Though I agree Watts is somewhat important, and you need it to calculate the battery life, I think the author is confused. "Consumers are regularly exposed to wattage measurements when buying light bulbs or reading their power bills". Nope. That is exactly the point that Alex was making: that power bills are in kWh, not W

Jerrad Pierce

If you've not see it, PBS SpaceTime has a new apropos T-shirt/hoodie: ttps://crowdmade.com/collections/pbsspacetime/products/pbsspacetime-unisex-with-great-power-tee

Arthur Robillard

But the sun goes away each night and doesn't tell us where it's going! Solar energy is HARD! Wah! Wah! If I had the money, I would have started installing panels years ago. Unfortunately, with the way THINGS are...I don't know if I'll have a job soon.