Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

YT link:
https://youtu.be/tCVsyY5TRQI

Apparently it's been nearly five years since I made my video on humidifiers. That's wild. Here's a new one!

I've been living with this for several years and putting up with its quirks. The issues/concerns I've had with it is part of why I've not made a video on this topic. But you can mitigate one of their risks and that's what I set out to do, though what should have been a quick afternoon project became a little more involved than I expected.

Truly, the main thing I'd like people to know about these is that they're far from risk-free. I am happy to have one, but it definitely needs attention paid to it.

I'm gonna get cracking on captions in about an hour. I'd like to wish everyone a merry Christmas, and I hope you're able to have a peaceful and pleasant time regardless of what you may or may not celebrate. I'll release this tomorrow morning as my Christmas present to the world. What a weird one!

Stay moist!

Comments

Steets

I just finished hooking up five humidifiers up to Home Assistant, I've been battling that forced-air furnace dryness all season. This couldn't have arrived at a better time -- Merry Christmas!

Aaron Carson

Merry Christmas to you and yours Alec! (And to the whole TC community) 💓 I hope it’s a lovely one.

Crash Cash

www.charlottepipe.com FTW! I love how they say "evaporative humidifier" on the box, like there is any other kind. First, I'm glad to be in Florida, and second, I'd turn that furnace humidifier off permanently, and just use a portable one. It sounds like an absolute bodge job.

j-beda

I think the "ultrasonic humidifier" are what they are differentiating from. Yes, the tiny tiny droplets that the ultrasonic do-dad produces do eventually evaporate and that's how the humidity increases, but they don't evaporate inside the humidifier, but out in the room air. I believe that this is why these types of humidifiers can spread dust throughout the room (impurities from the water, now in the air) and maybe pathogens have an easier time getting spread around.

Crash Cash

Thanks, good point. I totally forgot about those.

vm

Neat, I kind of figured out how to do this with an automation in Home Assistant and aggregating multiple humidity sensors...Not sure how I'd handle the "reduce humidity with lower outside temps" logic, but it would definitely be possible to do most of the job with some wireless sensors, a smart plug, and some computer automating stuff locally

Tim Skloss

I have a similar model from Aprilaire. Mine doesn't have a fan, it has a 6 inch duct outlet on the side which you connect to the return side of the HVAC. Also, mine has two float switches on a reservoir at the bottom which turns off the water solenoid when it fills up. The drain is only there as a safety in case the floats get stuck. The controller also has a hygrometer which is open to the return duct and a outdoor temperature sensor. I also have it supplied with water from my RO system. I strongly recommend installing a RO system, and in a remote location where you can replace the puny 1 gallon reservoir with 15 gallons or more! Feed RO to your sink for cooking/drinking, your refrigerator (ice) and dryer if it has a steam function. The RO will eliminate calcification problems in all of these appliances. My Keurig coffee maker lasted for over 10 years without any scale. RO is also great for aquarium maintenance. If you feed the RO with water from a softener then RO maintenance is also nearly eliminated.

PerfectlyAdequate

You’re not going to tell us what the fire alarm bell does? How could you?

Devon Redekopp

I wonder if the outdoor temperature sensor would get an accurate (enough) reading if it was just at the intake pipe inside the furnace. It isn't the exact same as the outside air, but at least while the furnace is running, it should be close, right? (Happy holidays to all!)

Aleksei Besogonov

I replaced this type of humidifier with a steam humidifier. Essentially, it's an electric water boiler and you get steam out of it. Dry steam. That you can inject into the incoming air so that it can't drop onto the furnace. It's much closer to being completely automatic, you just need to change the humidifier canister once a season. For humidity control, I just use a Home-Assistant-based automation that controls the humidifier with a Zigbee dry-contacts switch. So I can use the humidity reading from my living room and calibrate it to not cause the condensation on my windows.

Max Fenton

Per the note about attics and closets, the HVAC professionals I’ve asked in my last two houses have said they won’t add central humidifiers to attic air handlers because of the risk of flooding.

Deviant Ollam

A Christmas Eve TC video!? This is like getting to open one of your gifts from the stocking the night before Christmas morning! ☺️🎄

PerfectlyAdequate

Never have I ever heard of that in a residential home. Neat

Technology Connections

Most townhomes in my area have been required to have them since... well I'm not entirely sure but based on real estate listings some time in the '90s. At least for our development it's not a central system, each unit has its own. And each home has an exterior alarm with a strobe (same sort of thing you see in public buildings) to get the attention of others.

Jou (Mxyztplk)

What's an "RO system" here? Not USA based, so...

Eivind N

Perfect christmas gift, as I just bought two humidifiers

Michael Cotton

Merry Moist Christmas and Happy Humid New Year!

JockeTF

Merry Christmas!

Andre Pirnat VE3BIC

Merry Christmas! As an HVAC tech, I felt I need to add some tidbits of information. Most of the humidifier kits come with polypropylene tubing. This tubing can't be connected to the hot water side of your water heater. To use hot water, you will need to plumb with copper tubing or risk a burst near the tank end. An alternative control that uses an outdoor temperature sensor is the Honeywell Humidipro. As far as wiring this one compared to the AprilAire, it's the same nonsense. One of the details about humidifiers usually buried in the fine print is that the "gallons per day" delivery capacity is rated at a plenum temperature of 140 degrees F. So, other than steam humdifiers, none of the evaporative humidifiers actually acheive their rated delivery. An additional accessory you might consider is the General Air Water Savor timer. (not a spelling error ). This timer is wired in series with the solenoid valve and times the valve opeing for 4 seconds on and 20 seconds off. It substantially reduces the amount of unevaporated water that ends up going down the drain. I live in Ottawa Ontario Canada, and our water bill has a 150% surcharge for waste water treatment, so minimizing the waste can result in substantial savings. For those of you that embrace smart thermostats, I have found the Ecobee 6 does the best job of managing the indoor humidity while monitoring the local outdoor temperature using internet weather information.

TheEdgeOfRage

I'm just here, waiting for your Home Assistant arc. Yes, it requires a lot of setup and learning, but boy does it solve a lot of automation problems. E.g. the "getting a wire from an outdoor temperature sensor hooked up to the humidistat in the middle of the house is a pain" becomes effortless. And you still get to have control over everything by having it run locally, not depending on any cloud service company that could go out of business tomorrow. Edit: Ah well, I guess I should have watched for 30 more seconds lol. My example may be for naught, but the point still stands :)

Circuitmike

I'm quite a ways down the Home Assistant rabbit hole myself and it's a little absurd when I think about what it takes for me to get the outdoor temperature. I have two wireless temperature / humidity sensors in two different places. An RTL-SDR dongle running rtl_433 receives the signals and sends them over MQTT. Another process grabs that data and shoves it into my 3-node Elasticsearch cluster. A Node-RED process queries Elasticsearch periodically and asks for an average of the temperature readings of the two sensors over the last 5 minutes, then averages those, and sends it over MQTT. Home Assistant listens to MQTT and displays the outdoor temperature. I may have a problem.

Circuitmike

I don't even like fart jokes and I thought that was hilarious!

Circuitmike

Reverse osmosis - pretty much the best possible filter for water.

Circuitmike

Those, and the type that just straight-up boil the water. I'll leave it to the pedants to argue whether or not that's the same as evaporation, but that basically covers the 3 types of consumer-level humidification technology.

Circuitmike

Oh, and I forgot about the really old-school ones that produce a mist of water with a weird wheel, centrifugal force, smashing the water against a bunch of plastic pins.

Circuitmike

OK, so this is the first I'm hearing about turning down your humidity setting in really cold weather. And here I was thinking I was the king of humidification because I manage to keep the house at around 50% humidity in the coldest of weather. Looks like I might want to re-evaluate.

Tim Skloss

I'm down the HA bunnyhole myself. I have about 20 sensors and 10 effectors (switches). I have found the ESP Home integration and EPS32 devices to be a low cost way to make all kinds of smart sensors. My go-to is a ESP32C3 (Xaio, Zero or Mini) with integrated antenna paired with a BME280 temp/humidity/baro sensor board. Have many around the house and outside. The set costs about $12 total and I 3D print the housing. Some are solar powered with LiPo batteries (garden soil moisture and rain gauge). I setup a separate Wi-Fi VLAN and SSID on 2.4GHz for all the HA stuff, and run the HA server on a RPi 5.

TheEdgeOfRage

Elasticsearch??? To get a freaking temperature reading. You do know that you can just get a zigbee usb dongle and direct connect sensors to HA, right?

Brad Wilmot

Shorten your stripped wires... you have way too much copper showing under that terminal block. No, it's not going to nuke the planet (darn...) if something moves and shorts out, but best to not blow something up on either the furnace or humidistat board if you can avoid it.... Also, is this a different house? The HVAC gear looks different from what you showed in the "how a furnace works" video, which I thought was shot in your house/studio...

John S

This video feels like deja vu. I just went through this whole process installing the Aprilaire 800. Same humidistat, same issues with the short thermostat wire, and I also ended up running it through the intake pipe. I also had the fun of wiring up an additional 240v circuit. Can't get enough of those. I had it set up for the recent cold snap here in Chicago about a week or so ago when it dipped below 0 and I did have to dial it back one step to avoid condensation (5 to 4). Overall though, I'm super happy with the system.

Eric Hoch

I too was watching this video thinking that some of these problems could be solved differently, and maybe even more effectively, with Home Assistant or a similar platform that is designed to connect technology together. Don't be scared away by the over-complicated systems involving things like MQTT, Node-RED, and Elasticsearch. You can buy off-the-shelf sensors and devices, and connect them to freely available open source software that runs entirely locally on something as cheap and accessible as a Raspberry Pi. Additionally, with something as simple as a "smart outlet/swtich" you could automate your collection of current and power statistics without having to point a camera at a kill-a-watt, as another example.

John K.

I really liked the Honeywell DG115EZIAQ controller at my previous home. It had an LCD screen that displayed the extra info you were hoping to see. The temperature sensor is in a plastic housing, so it can’t be hidden in the intake pipe, but looks nice on the side of the house.

Daniel Steinmann

are there no hot vapor humidifiers available in the US? Because these really are the closest you can get to "set and forget" especially when fed with lime-free rainwater.

John K.

We have steam humidifiers available but they cost way more to operate because they’re boiling water with electricity. This style steals the heat from the furnace and water heater which are usually more cost effective/efficient.

Daniel Steinmann

As always: trading in convenience against operating expenses ...

Alex Taylor

The system got stuck on at my dad’s house. When they figured that out the went into the crawl space and drilled a small hole in the lowest ductwork. 5 gallons of water drained out.

David Weintraub

Our HVAC people keep harping on us to get a whole house humidifier installed. Your video shows why I don’t want one. We have a room humidifier in our bedroom. I have to fill it up in the mornings and night before going to bed. Once per week, i take it apart and wash it out with vinegar which removes bacteria and calcium deposits. Minimal maintenance and cost. A few questions. We keep at 55% humidity. Your whole house one only goes up to 45%. Why? You mentioned when it’s cold, you need to turn down the humidity. It’s been 19° F here and we haven’t had problems with condensation on windows or walls at 55%. Is this something about whole house humidifiers

Killianti

Alternate take: attics should be nicer.

Ko Yamamoto

Interesting that ERV/HRV don't have options for humidity control (both dehumidifier & humidifier). As we drive toward better sealed houses, that would seem to be the way to go.

Chad Donohue

The sound effect is my favorite part 🤣🤣🤣