Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Hello hello,

Before I get cracking on the captions, I'm going to add a voiceover section which explains why I keep referring to what most people would call journals as bearings. Essentially I got hung up on a technicality and let that override common language and, well, probably shouldn't have done that. Thank you to Ryan for leaving a YouTube comment pointing that out.

It is absolutely not worth me re-shooting anything — the point is the bearing surface and not which part gets called what — but it does feel like this will be very annoying to certain brains so I'm going to at least explain myself.

I wasn't planning on releasing the video today anyway but this will slow down the captions process. I will update the original post with the new YT link and tell Patreon to email you when I've done that and captions are complete.

-Alec

Comments

Max Fenton

This video was TREMENDOUSLY helpful and I will basically share it forever with every person I know who owns a car. Thank you for doing this.

Markus Strobl

Yeah, as an old gear head it irked me when you called the crank journals "bearings", and the bearings "bushings". Also, if we are nitpicking, the correct term for what you call "harmonic balancer" is "torsional dampener". I don't know if it needs mentioning, but besides the 2 and 4 stroke engine there also the very weird "atkinson cycle" that the Toyota Prius uses. I believe it is a 5-cycle?

Michael Cunningham

I only got to see the first 20 min and as someone who has rebuilt an engine at least once, still learned a few things.

Technology Connections

Oh we're getting to the Atkinson cycle eventually, so don't worry about that. But it's still four-strokes, the difference is that the power stroke is longer than the intake stroke (in a true Atkinson cycle this is done with some kind of wild linkages in the crankshaft but that's silly so real cars use a "modified" Atkinson cycle which just adjust valve timing to accomplish the same thing).

Markus Strobl

Neat. Never paid much attention to the Atkinson cycle so don't mind learning more. Are you going to talk about engine balancing? I always thought that was interesting. 1st, 2nd order vibrations and how some engine layouts are naturally balanced such as the inline 6 and the 90 degree V8. If you want to bounce ideas or concept let me know. I've rebuilt several engines and converted from carb to aftermarket EFI. I also did all the tuning myself so familiar with tuning concept. For example, I spent a lot of time on finding the best time to inject fuel which depends heavily on the camshaft lobe profile. For instance, a stock, short duration, cam wants fuel injected onto a closed intake valve, but this doesn't work at all with a long duration (performance) cam as much of the fuel will be sucked straight out the exhaust during valve overlap. The rabbit hole is deep.

Jason Thorpe

According to Sreten, the correct term is “harmonic dancer” 😂

Jason Thorpe

Oh that bearing vs journal vs bushing thing had me yelling at my screen 😂😂😂

Jou (Mxyztplk)

I haven't watched it yet, but I do get the nerd-gene kicking in when something is not right enough. I earn my money that way securing Windows Server and AD.

Circuitmike

Remember, technically correct is the best kind of correct!

Shadow Duck

Another option would be to abuse the audio tracks and add a "klingon" audio track for the really nerdy details! Would that be more convoluted, confusing, and all around worse than adding a voiceover section? Absolutley, but it'd be *fun*! (though it would give us a good reason to watch the video twice lol)

Jorg Jorgensen

The fact that you corrected yourself for calling "journal bearings" "bearings" instead of journals just shows how much you care about your videos. In my opinion, calling them bearings is just fine for your target audience. Anyone that knows what a journal bearing is and what journals are likely does not need to watch a video on the importance of oil pressure. 🙂 I have rebuilt exactly one engine in my 58 years on this planet, and the folks I dealt with to learn how and the folks I bought the replacement bearings from just called everything related to the "main bearings," bearings or bearing surfaces. They used that for the bearing surface on the crank, for the actual replaceable bearings, and even the bearing caps. Besides you were talking about all the bearings in the engine, not just the ones for the crank.

Al Davis

While calling a journal a "bearing" certainly sounds funny to my professional ear, your explanation reminds me that I, like pretty much everyone else, also use nonconventional names for things all the time and so my brain should just shut up and enjoy the video. Been watching for years. Refreshing, so hope you keep doing what you're doing - even the political POV. Just watched Still TBD podcast which made me think to add my itsy bitsy bit of Patreon support for you.

Stephen Pope

Great video. As an automotive enthusiast, it's clear to me how much you've researched this by what you didn't say. I don't know which direction you plan to take this series of videos, but automotive engineering is truly fascinating. Some suggestions, although I'm sure you've already thought of many. -The difference between a two-stroke and a four-stroke engine in terms of both cycle and lubrication. Two-stroke engines are rapidly going away (fortunately) but it's still interesting tech. -Automotive sensors, but specifically delving into how they function. Simple on/off switches (oil pressure), resistive sensors (temperature), hall effect sensors (position sensors), pulsed sensors (abs sensors), position sensors (fuel float, steering angle), so many more. -Anti-lock brakes and how that enable electronic stability control to be relatively easily developed. -Vehicle wiring. This is getting into the weeds a little, but I like it. The insane complexity that car wiring harnesses reached before the advent of CAN. -Instrumentation - this follows from wiring, but how cars used to literally have a wire running from a sensor to a bulb in the dash. And now everything is an encoded data stream that goes around the entire vehicle and the dash is a complex computer that can be programmed to show all sorts of stuff, or not. On another note, you mentioned oil pressure gauges, and the lack thereof in the last few decades. Obfuscating information from the driver is something that rustles many jimmies, but I land firmly on the side of "it doesn't matter". For a normal every day car, the driver does not need to know the temperature, or the RPM, or oil pressure, or battery voltage, and so on. The driver needs to know the speed they are travelling and how much fuel/charge they have. The car should warn if any issues arise, but otherwise none of that is information that is needed in the day to day experience. I look at the HUD in my car as an example, it shows me my current speed, the current speed limit, the distance of my auto-cruise setting (and if it sees a car) and if my lane guidance is on. That snapshot is all I need to drive the car almost all the time. It would also give me navigation guidance if I used the built-in GPS, but I don't, because why would I when we have google maps?

Woofy

"damper", unless you're meaning to get something wet. (Sorry, pet peeve...)

Creator Supporter

I'm pretty anti-car and find combustion engines to be especially boring but the explanations were clear, the visual examples were very cool, and the general production value on this video was excellent. I learned a few things I wasn't already aware of when it came to how an engine functions. Good job Alec and death to the combustion engine! Loved the gag at the start with the electric drill.