Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Hello!

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RMxB7zA-e4Y

That thumbnail is definitely a placeholder because it's awful. I know.

But, here's a video that's been in the back of my mind for ages and that I've finally committed to making. It all started from a Twitter thread where I railed on Tesla as I often do for making their Wall Connectors out of glass and thus turning them into status items. That sort of thing just rocks my midwestern self to the core, so I thought "Well, it's time then. Let's explain what these are."

I tried to keep this less persuasive and more explanatory, and I hope I succeeded with that. The earlier parts of the video are really there to explain what EV charging is and why it's fundamentally different from any sort of "chargers" you might be familiar with. So I hope it can be an interesting video even to those who really don't care about EVs.

Credit where it's due, thanks to a conversation I had privately and some further research, the Tesla Wall Connector does have some genuinely good innovation in there and for load sharing applications it is unquestionably king. We discuss that towards the end, but I was not shy at addressing the reality that is the fact that going forward, Tesla is the single outlier in the North American market not following SAE J1772 / CCS standards.

Now, tomorrow is "battery day" and Tesla will be making some sort of announcement. I'm going to hold-off on releasing this video until after that happens because if they happen to be announcing that new Tesla models in North America will be equipped with CCS combo plugs, well then I need to rework parts of this video. I'm... not exactly expecting that to happen but I would like to plan for that contingency!

Files

Electric car chargers aren't chargers at all – EVSE Explained

Catchy title! But it's mostly true! There's a pinned comment you might want to read, as well. But there's some links down here, too. Firstly and of supreme importance, the video on the Bolt's Bits from Weber Auto - Prof. John Kelly is amazing and you really ought to give that channel a look if you're interested at all in hybrid and EV tech; https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5gDILvW5yMg Then my usual ones; Technology Connextras (the second channel that stuff goes on sometimes): https://www.youtube.com/channel/UClRwC5Vc8HrB6vGx6Ti-lhA Technology Connections on Twitter: https://twitter.com/TechConnectify The TC Subreddit https://www.reddit.com/r/technologyconnections This channel is supported through viewer contribution on Patreon. Thanks to the generous support of people like you, Technology Connections has remained independent and possible. It's how I can make fun of products like these! If you'd like to join the amazing people who've pledged their support, check out the link below. Thank you for your consideration! https://www.patreon.com/technologyconnections And a big heartfelt thanks to the following Patrons! David Gauthier, Jonathan Paz, Ruben Schade, Tyler James, Jason Stielow, Julia Rose, SJ , Cory Durham, Christopher Rebert, Glen Parker, Edward Drozd, Sam Barber, Austin Whaley, Rohan Patil, Nicholas Hubbard, Ryan Bateman, Larry Wheeler, Rob Coleman, Aaron Murray, Liam , Andira Muttakim, Jesus Villafranca, huitz, NextMan , Jace Fuse, Denis Phillips, Jon Adams, Eric Noriega, lastsecondsave , Marcus Congdon, Loni Nix, Bernardo , Damnable Nook, Elijah Gould, Tyler Warren, Kevin Ingersoll, C. A. Patrick Voigt, Andrew Hangsleben, Alex , Mike Jacob, Prashant Sinha, reavisrk ., coudy , Matthew Stoldal, Nathan Lawrence, Charles Gillanders, Danielle Duarte, sheepish.alpaca , Juhani Saarinen, Ashley Hakker, M10360 , Salvatore Nuzzo, Jake Austin, Thibault Martin-Lagardette, Eric Hoppe, Rob Lion, Nikolaus , Ohad Lutzky, Marek Standio, John Julian, Edward Harris, Jean-Baptiste Dubois, Michael Young, Mirror, Rebecca Valentine, Justin Howell, wingee , Cmdr MadMax, Chris Miller, David Cawthon, Brian Taylor, Arnas , Jacob Kubacki, Steven West, Bob Meyers, BEAVIS, Michael, Ross George, Kael, Merton Hale, Nodar Rocko Davituri, Dawn Swain, JCRail , Bill Holland, James , Micah Catlin, AZbytes , Sebastian Schagerer, cody thompson, John Goldhamer, Bob Holt, John-Paul Holt, Alex Nelson, Ruleryak, Andrei Blinov, Andrew Rogers, wholegroanoats , Michael Pecorini, Torte Hanrahan, Jamie Mastro, Shivan , Ethan Pierce, Danila Alpatov, XPEric , NQR , Kelvin Hall, Two Fabulous Lesbians who just bought a house!, Jeff Powell, Anthon Hintzen, Devin Luxner, CJ Mariani, Stefan Kaczmarek, Timm B, Stefano, Harrison Wright, Wolf Tolbert, DeepestBlue , Nhan L, Sebastien De Groof, Robert T Kirton, Alex Ferriroli, Juha Kuikka, Maggie Danger, Jay 'Unionize Everything Except Cops' Logan, Conduit of Queerness, Mage of Life, Matthew Lowe, An Ho, Steven Byrum-Bratsen, Sean Callinan, Scott Schreiber, Mitch Buchan, Anicra , Sarah Collie, Maxime André, Chaos215bar2 , Michael Grados, Daniel Nefzger, Matias Mariani, Christopher Barback, yetanothername , Synoiz , Chip , Ulises Vargas, Jennifer Rae Fuchek, Adrian Bridgett, John Gjonola, Yannick , Chad Gertz, Zhongchao Qian, Sean Murphy, Erica Eagles, Robey Pointer, Hayden Taylor, Aimee Kidrick, Alexander folk, Matt Gibbons, Omnizen, Zach Bean, Myles Hecht, Jack Knight, Peter Bergström, Maximilian Bork, Peter Amling, David Ziemlak, GGreathouse , Stephen A. Wilson, Sam Becraft, Chris Benejam, Veronica Cary, Vincent Sandstoe, Craig P Steffen, Robert Mikhayelyan, Corey Ogburn, Harlan , Mike Stunes, William Leonard, Cory King, Matt Braun, Eugene Arutchev, Steven Fazzio, Harrison Co, Michael Cafarelli, Justin Patriquin, THISGuy, Vincent Venezia, Doug Wallace, Brad Quinn, Jim Puls, Zachary W Collins, Alex, Ross James, Jonfidential, Lillian Fleming, Jason Durbin, Kevin McClaning, Keith Ditchman, Andrew Minior, ventusignis, Jeremy Iamurri, Michael, Skoddie , Onzo Anderson, Alix Odendhal, bd_, Benjamin Gouveia, Ryan Doucet, Billy, Sean Crocker, Phillip M, Robert Cole, iain , Ross Carter, Ted Flores, Jakub Strzyżewski (jeikobu__), Robert Fares, Neptunium Fluoride, Fangzahn Aviation Studios, Aaron Binns, Matthew Yu, Johannes Wüller, Adam Golden, Rustmane Skytrekker, John J Yang, Matthew Hilder, leastbad, Joe Pannullo, Gyiyg, Alex Conner, Colin Williams, Alex Lindeman, Jim Gilsinan, Fox E. Wolf, Michael Goode

Comments

Quinton Wilson

Missed opportunity to get ElectroBoom to say "FULL BRIDGE RECTIFIER" at 5:45.

volty

One thing that irritates me is that J1772 has only very rudimentary communication from the vehicle to the external charger control circuit: to the very best of my understanding, a J1772-based charger has no way of knowing how full the battery of the receiving vehicle is. People living on top of a hill or mountain who charge to 100% thus can’t regenerate on the way down the hill because that recuperated energy has nowhere to go, causing waste: energy is converted to heat by friction braking and heat is vented into the environment. Unless the vehicle itself allows users to configure a maximum desired charge level, users have to pre-calculate expected charge times if they want to avoid charging above, say, 80%. And the home charging station (aka EVSE) can’t help because it doesn’t know the battery level. Compare that to DC fast charging with, say, the bulky CHAdeMO, where much more communication happens, allowing the vehicle to report the actually state of charge to the charging station - but that’s not a home use scenario.

Technology Connections

You're correct that currently J1772 is essentially a one-way communication protocol. However, you might have gotten a glimpse of the "hilltop reserve" function of the Bolt - that's for exactly the sort of scenario you're describing. I think that in most cases, it's better to solve those sorts of things on the car side, but there definitely are cases where two-way comms would be helpful. It looks like that may be coming in the future, but we'll have to see. For what it's worth, the CCS connection does have two-way communication, too. It's not unique to CHAdeMO.

Sierra Mistystep

cost -- patent/tech licensing and LIABILITY INSURANCE

Jeremy Whaling

Volty you may want to look up ISO 15118, it is a newer standard which does allow vehicle to station communications over the wire using PLC communications (same as CCS). It’s a bit of a heavy protocol and most cars don’t support it yet but it is coming and should help for L2 load management. Of course for DC there’s already communications and the station does know things like SOC and battery size but most of the time DC is used for quick charging so load management isn’t really used or desired.

Vladimir S

Actually, that's the point and reason for BMCs to exist... That's why you don't bother now what amps battery consumed, what was the electrolyte density before charging (remember these acid densitometers?), what was the charging temperature (I think there are some Alaskan or Siberian viewers out there who old enough?) and weren't peak amperage exceeded the electrolyte boiling point at the surrounding pressure (now we need to remember WWII submarines).

Jeremy Whaling

Great video! When you want to do a video on DC charging, reach out to me. I work for EVgo and would love to help in any way I can.

Charles Gillanders

Just wanted to let you know that here in Ireland our national utility is by far the largest provider of public charging. We have charge points in many, many locations and it does indeed just add the charge costs to our home electricity bill. We don’t have much of an EV market here yet but we certainly have a really strong start to the kind of public charging infrastructure you called for!

Lennart Sorensen

Well for Tesla, apparently the Model 3 sold in Europe has a CCS connector, not a Tesla connector, while the Model S and X still have a Tesla connector. So apparently Tesla can be convinced to switch eventually. Not the same CCS connector used in north america, but at least there is a standard in each region. Of course the european one supports 3 phase AC charging, not just 1 phase.

Matt Whitlock

Tesla owner here. The Tesla Wall Connector (even the Gen 1) can actually receive firmware updates *from the car*, so there must be some additional signaling happening through the cable beyond just what J1772 prescribes.

Kilrah

That "ehhhhhhh" was mightly hilarious 🤣 I'm totally gonna use that as a meme from now on, and it'll be hard to think of you without seeing that in my head... EDIT: It even starts right on a keyframe, how convenient 😁

volty

Just mentioned it because Nissan has removed the “charge to 80%” option from Leaf vehicles after the first generation. They removed it arguably to suggest that “charging to 100% doesn’t harm the battery” but ignoring hilltop customers’ desire to recuperate on the way down the hill. It’s good to see that other manufacturers have this built in and that CCS supports better bidirectional comms. It’s a work in progress :)

Matt Whitlock

Absolutely. Has been from the beginning. And I say that with disdain for Apple's obstinacy against adopting industry standards. I do cut Tesla a break, though, for one reason: Tesla installed the Supercharger network at enormous cost to itself and operates it essentially at break-even (or even at a loss on the older Tesla vehicles that have free supercharging for life). If Tesla were to start installing/retrofitting Superchargers with CCS connectors, then non-Tesla cars would start charging at Superchargers, and that would be a disservice to Tesla's customers, who ostensibly paid a premium for the privilege of exclusive access to the Supercharger network. I suppose Superchargers could simply refuse to charge non-Tesla vehicles, but then what would be the point of switching to CCS connectors?

Technology Connections

So, forgive my presumptuousness here, but what exactly is the firmware that's running on these and why on Earth would it need to be upgraded ever? I get the point for Gen 3, but *especially* for Gen 1 what functionality is being added to it that the car can't just manage?

Matt Whitlock

Firmware updates for these things appear to be few and far between. I don't know the details of any, and I have never personally observed one being applied to my Wall Connector, but I have seen photos of the UI messages that appear on the car's screens when an attached Wall Connector is being updated. I would imagine that the updates are mostly related to safety, but I could also guess that there have been improvements made to the load-balancing algorithm or perhaps to the wire protocol that the Wall Connectors use to talk to each other.

Sebastian K.

When i drove a tesla S rental a few years ago it had a standard european type 2 plug (without DC port) for charging. It switches to a different pinout when using tesla (DC) supercharging AFAIK

Mark Hesse

In the memorable words of an earlier version of Alec: "A format war's a-brewin'..." Does one choose the Tesla Betamax or the J1772 VHS? At any rate, this was a very informative video and I second your opinion of the Weber State videos. "Go (checks Wikipedia) Wildcats!"

Lennart Sorensen

Right, but apparently the model 3 has a type 2 CCS, not an AC only type 2. Apparently pretty new model S and X can use a pretty cheap adapter to allow type 2 CCS dc fast charging and older ones can be retrofitted to support the adapter and they are even adding type 2 CCS plugs to their european charging stations. Too bad so far they don't seem to care to do that in north america yet.

Avid Stan

When you navigate away from the video (and nav back) and the *captions* have arrived! Much appreciated!

Yana M.

I think I could have done with a definition of "charger" before you went into why an EVSE is *not* a charger. I'm also still a bit confused about the world of teslas and adapters: there's an adapter for charging a non-tesla car with a tesla charger? what about the other way around - can you buy a standard charger and then use it with a tesla car? if there are adapters, why is the tesla semi-walled garden so bad for standardization?

Technology Connections

The main issue is Supercharging. Adapters exist in both directions for level 2 charging, but a CCS to Tesla SC adapter does not exist and likely can't. The North American CCS standard from my understanding forbids adapters because some chargers are so high powered they require active cooling. There are adapters in use in the EU so I don't know if that limitation is really there or not. Basically, at this point, Tesla could start putting CCS combo-connectors on their cars but they're unlikely to do so as long as the Supercharger network remains exclusive to them. From my perspective it seems certain that they're holding onto their proprietary connector for pretty much that reason only.

Michael Dunn

I liked the one last dig in the smooth jazz caption :D

nobody

The thing that seems insane to me is that a lot of people use these outdoors and there is nothing stopping random people from pulling into your driveway for a couple hours while you're at work and plugging in. There is no authentication so there can be no access control. Some people put the control head in the garage and then run the cord under the garage door so they can turn off the charger and still have outdoor access, but then the cord is subject to accelerated wear.

Chatmandine

One great reason to put the charging port in the garage is that in large cities like SF this equipment tends to "walk away" if left outside unattended. The cables for sure are fair game. I used to think the charging port would be fine, I mean who would open something under power, then I realized the home mains panel is often located outside, for everyone to abuse easily.

Technology Connections

A very common design now is for the plug end to be lockable. You can see a little hole in the latch if you look closely - that's to put a tiny little padlock in there to either lock it to a holder or the car. It's by no means an easy solution, but it is one potential way of preventing people from using your charger. There's also the option if you're so inclined to install an in-line timer, and I would imagine that as the technology matures and gets more popular you'll start to see EVSE units with built-in access control either time-based, maybe a PIN pad, or in some other way. Lots of ways to skin that cat.

Circuitmike

My first thought on seeing the thumbnail: "That is the weirdest urinal..."

Paul Malloy

Please 14-50. This needs to be the standard US 240 volt connector. 6-50 is for welders, it needs to go away.

Technology Connections

What's the point of a neutral, though? I responded to someone in YouTube comments about this, and while I think that, sure, there's something to be said for the use of them in RV park hookups, I don't see how it would be beneficial in a permanent installation.

rozboris

Question to EV enthusiasts here: my biggest gripe with an EV is having to plug it in. Isn't it extremely annoying to having to plug in _one more thing_? I already hate to keep my phone topped up all the time, now you want me to be crazy about plugging in the car? Right now when I arrive home I just walk out of the car and walk into the house. Why on earth I would want to deal with ports and cables. Same with driving away. Just sit down and go. Thoughts?

Technology Connections

My response is that this is an extremely small hassle compared to going to a fueling station. It becomes second nature as just a thing you do when you get home, and it takes mere seconds. It's way less work than just unloading groceries from your car. So I don't really see it as "yet another thing to plug in."

Peter Holley

In an RV you use the neutral to have two circuits like in a house. But for an electric car port, no neutral is necessary at all.

Peter Holley

Another interesting thing about some of these fancy switches. Some of them can be plugged to either 120V (hot/neutral) OR 240V (hot/hot). The Prius Prime comes with a 110V charge cable, but by using an adaptor cable it works just fine with a NEMA 6-50 and charges the car in slightly less than half the time. BUT Toyota disavows all knowledge of this interchangeability. They just use the same controller, but put a different plug on it for North America and Europe. And of course they use a different "model" number. And THAT is the reason one of the pins is labelled L2/N. Because the car don't care. AC is AC either way, but on a 110 cable, that would be the N.

Technology Connections

I got the point of it for an RV park, I just meant in a scenario when you know you're gonna be installing an EVSE

binaryfox

The "ventilation required" signal was inherited from the original AVCON connector which was used for vehicles with, as you mentioned, lead-acid batteries. The signaling wasn't changed for J1772.

Galen Thurber

show me your equipment in a new light

Galen Thurber

"EV Chargers cause cancer, autism, ..." wait for the loons to push for banning these

Galen Thurber

It is likely to be deadly in the USA if you're black and holding the plug

Paul Malloy

No neutral needed. Sure, tell that to people trying to install a smart switch in their wall where the switch was wired with no neutral. Now code requires new houses must run the neutral to the switch. It's called future proofing. Just because you don't need it now for your particular application , doesn't mean it isn't a good idea. Plus we need one standard 240 volt connector for everything, and 14-50 fits the bill best.

Technology Connections

I agree with most of your points but if you're installing an EVSE, you're not in need of a neutral. It was my experience not long ago that most EVSEs intended for permanent installation came with a NEMA 6-50 plug. I mean, heck, mine did as well as a unit I was looking at from Leviton. That's the reason I recommended it because it's what I'm familiar with, and frankly as a DIY job 8/3 cable is much easier to deal with than 8/4. And by the way, we have so many dang plugs over here that it's way too late to hope for a standard 240V connector. They tend to be application-specific, and with that in mind I think 6-50 makes perfect sense for EVSE installs.

rozboris

Thanks Alec, I will think about it. My biggest problem is plugging it in every day, compared to getting gas once a week or even less often (if your car is more efficient than an AWD SUV). And I know I don't _have_ to plug it in every time but there is no way I will let it sit at home with less than 100% charge, it's just unnerving. I'm surprised there is not much discussion about drive-in (or wireless) charging and everyone is okay with dealing with bulky cables. It certainly _works_ but is definitely not very _futuristic_.

Jacob Tyler Hooyman

I dont believe code allows for instillation of a double insulated cord inside of a conduit. the conductor is unable to dissipate the heat. a better and cheaper solution is to run stranded 10 ga thhn in pvc conduit 3/4" sch 40. if the run is under 100 ft 10 ga is sufficient for 30 amp 2 pole. if longer than 100 ft run up size to 8 ga. should still be under 80% fill in 3/4 conduit

foophoof

Yeah, there's "CCS 1"/"Combo 1" and "CCS 2"/"Combo 2" or something like that, "CCS 1" is the US standard that use the type 1/J1772 connector plus the 2 DC pins, and "CCS 2" use Type 2 instead of Type 1/J1772, but afaict it's the same 2 DC pins under the connector. And yeah, the Model 3 here uses the Type 2 connector, and the Tesla Superchargers have both the Combo 2 and the Tesla Supercharger connectors as far as I can tell (haven't driven a Tesla here, but have charged near the Superchargers and walked up to take a look).

Aaron the Tinkerer

As a Tesla Model 3 owner, with a Tesla Wall Connector in my garage, I can safely say that plugging in the car is super trivial. Park, get out, plug in, then walk into the house. It takes less than 30 seconds. I'm sure other location arrangements would be more annoying, but it's certainly less effort than getting gasoline on a regular basis. Not to mention never having to change engine oil and all the other ICE maintenance that goes away :)

Aaron the Tinkerer

Oh and it's worth noting that charging to 100% is not good for most lithium-chemistry batteries. For regular commuting (as opposed to long trips), charging to between 60 and 80 percent is best for longevity. I had to get over it being unnerving, so I completely get it 😂

rozboris

I have never tried (and I might soon!) but I still feel that having a good reliable ICE car is still much more convenient. Servicing is just calling your dealer every 5K miles and pay them to pick up the car and "do what they gotta do", it's probably the same with electric. I don't care what exactly they do and nothing breaks if you get a good car (Japanese, not too old is my reliable choice). For me the biggest expense (and definitely research time and anxiety due to HUGE number of options) is tires and not oil/maintenance. I would just buy a new (certified pre-owned) car if this one does not drive. Gas stations are literally everywhere and *always* on the way even if you are devoted to save a few cents going to "that cheap one". It might be worse living in a major city downtown (Seattle gas prices are crazy) but living in the suburbs there is no such problem. Plugging in every night might not be as bad as I picture it. But having an ICE car is likely not as bad as you describe. Looks like I just gotta try it to have an opinion.

rozboris

The "80% is good for the battery" is the worst part: am I now supposed to decide between my convenience (of driving further without a refill) and my expenses (the battery dying earlier)? Ugh, this is real anxiety, right there. >.< Is this what y'all call range anxiety? :-D

Technology Connections

I'd like to add my $.02 here and say that that piece of advice seems to circulate mostly around Tesla circles. GM doesn't give you any sort of guidance around how to care for the battery in the Bolt, which you'd bet they would if it would help given that they've got a warranty on it. In fact, on the Bolt the only control you have over how full it will charge is a toggle for hilltop reserve, and the point of that is simply to not charge completely in case you live on the top of a hill. That way you can top off the battery on the way down. The first two years the Bolt was kicking around this family it was routinely charged to 100%. It's been more in my care lately and I've turned on hilltop reserve (I'll probably turn it off as we head into winter, though) and there's no sign of battery degradation. I really think that modern battery packs don't require much babying at all and frankly I find the levels some obsess over it to be a little... much.

Technology Connections

Oh also, rozboris, the maintenance thing is much more impactful than you might imagine. The Bolt just rolled over to 35k miles. Maintenance costs in the first three years have been literally $0. Not a thing has been spent on this car, and there are basically just two services it requires ever; brake inspection every 50k miles (which the pads are almost certainly 90+% life remaining thanks to regen) and every 5 years or 100k miles its needs its cooling system flushed. That's literally it. Throw in a cabin air filter and you've run out of things which can be serviced other than suspensiony bits.

rozboris

Wow, this all sounds very convincing, thank you for summarizing. I will make sure to bookmark it. Very good points.

Devsci

Isn't there another safety feature where the car has a diode across the signal pin with the square wave, so only half the wave results, That way if the plug is dropped in water or has another fault that happens to mimic the cars charge request resistance, the wall unit won't connect power?

Stephen Gillie

Great video demystifying a crucial part of our future transportation infrastructure. A fascinatingly elegant part of EVs is how the wall charger essentially dumps power into the regenerative braking output, which goes into the battery charger. And given a 3500 lb car, each MPH equals about 158 Joules or 0.044 watt-hours, it's easy to see how some cars equate wall charging rates to deceleration charging rates. It makes me want to retrofit old hybrids by swapping engines for batteries and installing charging ports.

Gary Ostroff

Regarding EVs in general: I like them, and would never argue against buying one, but at the level of national energy policy, does it really make sense to encourage them over the next thirty years? From an engineering management point of view, adding all that demand to a grid and base load system that we are trying to modernize and push towards carbon neutrality seems like a bad idea. Hybrids and small engines seem like a better bridge policy...in an ideal world. Ahem...🤓🙄