Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Helllloooo!!! I hope you're pumped, charged, cooled off and warmed up because it's time for the conclusion on heat pumps!

https://youtu.be/7zrx-b2sLUs

This video gets a little too deep on a few occasions and there's a TOO DEEP alert thing that I had perhaps too much fun with. It's not that loud - I made sure it wasn't startling - but I know that some folks appreciate warning about that. The first instance is at 7:07. There's also a very subtle (almost too subtle if I'm honest) audio gag that I threw in last minute. 

Captions, end-screen, all that's coming soon as usual. I'll be releasing this to the World Wide Web on April 1st (but actually).

And thank you to everyone who submitted footage for this!

Files

MORE PUMPING MORE NOW

We're gonna deal with this later Heat Pumps Part 1 https://youtu.be/7J52mDjZzto Technology Connextras (the second channel that stuff goes on sometimes): https://www.youtube.com/channel/UClRwC5Vc8HrB6vGx6Ti-lhA Technology Connections on Twitter: https://twitter.com/TechConnectify The TC Subreddit https://www.reddit.com/r/technologyconnections This channel is supported through viewer contributions on Patreon. Thanks to the generous support of people like you, Technology Connections has remained independent and possible. If you'd like to join the amazing people who've pledged their support, check out the link below. Thank you for your consideration! https://www.patreon.com/technologyconnections And thank you to the following patrons! Dolphinhats , Brian Taylor, Arnas , Jacob Kubacki, Steven West, Bob Meyers, BEAVIS, Michael V, Ross George, Kael, Merton Hale, JCRail , Bill Holland, Micah Catlin, AZbytes , Sebastian S, StellarDrift, John Goldhamer, Bob Holt, John-Paul Holt, Ruleryak, Andrew Rogers, Evan Doyle, wholegroanoats , Endless Mike, Torte Hanrahan, Jamie Mastro, Shivan , Ethan Pierce, NQR , Jeff Powell, Anthon Hintzen, Devin Luxner, CJ Mariani, Stefan Kaczmarek, Timm B, Wolf Tolbert, Nhan L, Joon Choi, Sebastien De Groof, Robert T Kirton, Alex Ferriroli, Juha Kuikka, Maggie Danger, Matthew Lowe, An Ho, Steven Byrum-Bratsen, Sean Callinan, Aquinon, Sarah Collie, Maxime André, Chaos215bar2 , Michael Grados, Daniel Nefzger, Matias Mariani, Christopher Barback, yetanothername , Synoiz , Chip , Ulises Vargas, Jennifer Rae Fuchek, Adrian Bridgett, John Gjonola, Chad Gertz, Zhongchao Qian, Sean Murphy, Robey Pointer, Hayden Taylor, Alexander folk, Matt Gibbons, Omnizen, Zach Bean, mstar27, Jack Knight, Peter Bergström, Peter Amling, GGreathouse , Stephen A. Wilson, Sam Becraft, Chris Benejam, Veronica Cary, Vincent Sandstoe, Robert Mikhayelyan, Corey Ogburn, Harlan , Mike Stunes, William Leonard, Cory King, Matt Braun, Eugene Arutchev, Steven Fazzio, Harrison Co, Michael Cafarelli, Gabriel, Justin Patriquin, Olof , Vincent Venezia, Doug Wallace, Brad Quinn, Jim Puls, Zachary W Collins, Ross James, Jonfidential, Lillian Fleming, Kevin McClaning, Keith Ditchman, ventusignis, Michael, Skoddie , Alix Odendhal, bd_, Benjamin Gouveia, Ryan Doucet, Billy, Sean Crocker, Phillip M, Robert Cole, iain , Ross Carter, Jakub Strzyżewski (jeikobu__), Robert Fares, Neptunium Fluoride, Fangzahn Aviation Studios, Aaron Binns, Matthew Yu, Johannes Wüller, Adam Golden, Rustmane Skytrekker, John J Yang, Matthew Hilder, leastbad, Joe Pannullo, Alex Conner, Colin Williams, Alex Lindeman, Jim Gilsinan, Kohana Coyote, Julian Freeman, Ed Torres, Jon-Håkon Røli, Matt Wright, Gunplumber , Bane Williams, vinny rapisarda, Manuel Garcia, Matthew Lucas, Doomerdinger , Udo Strass, Jonathan Polley, SomeonesGonnaPayForThis , Robert Valdimarsson, Atsumari, Alex Canna, Blythe Rathi, Brian Beck, Billiam, LazySpoon, Robert Haynes, David Nelson, Eli Youngs, Paul Hackett, Alex H., John Curley, Benjamin Dykstra, Dan Cortes, Vy-let Cybra, Joseph Fickus, Raymond Ernesto Colón, Mike Berman, Kay Ohtie, Cysioland, Pathite , Frode Hauge, Stu Kabakoff, Carmichael Keane See, Chris Jordan, Steven V, Brian & Laura, Brian Holder, Mindy B., Patrick Köhl, NoFriendsThatSlav , PetesGuide, Jeremy Whaling, VMRosetta, Nathan Walters, Michael Yeo, Massimo Fierro, Grant Blayney, Jake Sanders, William McKinnerney, Elizabeth, Amy Cable, Rafael De Los Santos, heyitsleo , Paul Sutton, Timothy Dunn, Duncan Sanford, Jack Alderson, Eric Kalenak, Lukas Svec, Mike Nichols, Blake Robinson, Roman~1, Ari Kestenbaum, Sean Harding, Bryan Helmig, Luis Calvo Mayo, Felix Huang, 0x0013, Jonathan Cotton, Isaac Evavold, Spencer Golde, William Willing, Vincent McBeigh, Ramon Perez, Xtr3m3 , Steve Fallon, Punkey , Sascha Strauß, Scott Kuker, V. Legrand, Shane Chambers, Jacob Oost, Donald Garwood, Fantastic Mr Socks, CyborgHobbit , Dan Basterfield, Casey Keeney, James FitzGibbon, MegaZone , Brian Ingalls, Aaron Carson, Erik T, Gregg Medley, Zackary Wojtan, Cody Bittle, Patrick, Andrew Hoddinott, Shay Sandik, Daniel Marcinkowski, Jayde Coler, Patrick Kennedy, Jesse S, Oswyn Brent, A tall shade of the color red, Colin Gagich, Mike McCaffrey, Mike Olpin, Michael Steinmetz, Andrew Krew, Devedander, Bryan Countryman, David McGrath, Richie Gaiser, Matt Christensen, Benjamin Albert, Truls Zhong Konstali, Cuervo

Comments

Scott Kemp

Can't wait to listen to this after work.

Zachariah Elliott

Yay! So glad to see my footage in here and the praise for hybrid water heaters

tim1724

Yay, now I have a TMBG song stuck in my head! (This is never a bad thing.)

Aaron Carson

Damn it. Now I want a geothermal heat pump.

Garrett Rabenold

At risk of sounding like a republican, I must declare that as "bad" as R134 is, it's really not THAT bad. The average charge in a vehicle is 20oz. Releasing all 20oz is about the CO2 equivalent of burning 89 gallons of gasoline and that doesn't include the other bad stuff coming out of the tailpipe like NOx, sulfur, etc... ANYWAYS, hopefully it's as easy to convert to 1234yf as it was to convert from R12 to R134A when they phase it out. On another rambling note, when my dehumidifier leaked out all of the refrigerant and started freezing over, I recharged it with propane and it worked for another year before locking up! haha.

rootbound (edited)

Comment edits

2026-09-05 08:00 Great Video! I’m curious why you didn’t mention Hydrocarbon refrigerants like r600a. Climate friendly and no patents! Yea they are flammable but so is natural gas and we have been dealing with that I homes for ages. There are lots of new refrigerators and freezers using this gas and minisplits should be coming to the us at some point.
2021-03-31 03:10

Technology Connections

Ah, so I'll do some more digging and pin a comment but it's my understanding that the reason stuff like isobutane isn't used in A/C systems is just down to the size and thus charge. Leaks have the potential to be much more dangerous so for the most part flammable refrigerants are limited to small systems like refrigerators.

Technology Connections

I agree that it could be a lot worse, but when you consider that the pallet full of cans at every Walmart is only getting sold because enough cars are out there that needed another pallet full of cans and it adds up pretty fast. Luckily the atmospheric lifetime of R-134a doesn't seem to be that long. Although - and this is some inside baseball as I might do a video on refrigerant management as an entire topic - some of the worst offenders are supermarkets and other industries with huge refrigeration systems. The bigger the system, the more potential for leaks, the bigger the charge, and the greater the sunk cost. Loads of these systems get recharged without their leaks being addressed, and it's a huge issue we need to be solving. Personally I'm hoping that C02 refrigeration systems become more widespread, and apparently they're already kind of big in Japan.

Technology Connections

We should all want them! Now all we need is to get some policymakers' gears turning...

C

Heat pump dryers are neat -- but as far as I know, they don't actually take heat from the room to heat the inside, but rather basically act as dehumidifiers with a closed air loop inside the unit that's getting repeatedly dehumidified (passed over the cold evaporator, and then the hot condenser.) I think they might use heating elements, or just the waste heat from the loop, to get that initial heat -- and then they actually discharge excess heat into the room, since otherwise the waste heat from dehumidification would cause the temperature to keep rising! One kinda neat thing to think about here is that a big chunk of the heat is actually coming from capturing the latent heat of the water that's being removed.

Balfa

Do one on the passive house! Do one on the passive house!

Technology Connections

Ah, there is difference! There are condensing dryers which are essentially electric driers with built-in dehumidifiers but heat pump dryers go a step further by replacing the heating elements with the condenser. Miele sells a heat pump dryer that operates on 120V 15A and that's not nearly enough power for a heating element to make meaningful heat. Eventually the energy consumed in a heat pump dryer makes it into the room, of course - it still has an exhaust, but what comes out of the exhaust will be dry as it's passed over the evaporator. The air being drawn in is passed over the condenser and thus heated, with up to 6kW of heat output with 1.5kW's work in the compressor. Edit: I noticed that some of the models that operate on 240V only use the heat pump in "eco" mode and otherwise will operate as condensing dryers with standard heating elements. The Miele I referenced can't do that, though, as there's not enough electricity at its disposal.

Technology Connections

Imagine it like a large dehumidifier that has the hot and cold side separated, and the hot side is at the entrance to the drum and the cold side is at the exit. The space between them ends up getting quite warm but in the end the only heat entering the room is that which the compressor generated. And since we all know what 1500 watts is, it's effectively like the output of a space heater. Having lived with a standard electric dryer "vented" into a wet box, that would be a life changer.

Bill Donnelly

After months of teasing "heat pumps" I must say I was intrigued with this miracle heating and cooling device of the future . . . then all was revealed . . . a reverse -cycle air conditioner that has be ubiquitous in AU for decades . . . I was expecting perpetual motion or some AC equivalent ;-) . . . I enjoyed the history and descriptions, but I won't be rushing out to buy (another one) anytime soon . . . ;-))

Stomat

Heat Pumps 2: Pump Harder

Craig Steffen (Figuring Stuff Out dot net)

The "Too Deep" alert is hilarious! And the audio is quite in line with the rest of it so it's not jarring. Nicely done! (I see that the design is based on 80s/90s Star Trek movies, if I'm not mistaken? Nice throwback!)

Zachariah Elliott

My parents have a geothermal system at their house. Funny enough they also have a hybrid water heater and were the driving factor behind me getting one. As mentioned in the video the install was quite disruptive, but luckily they live out in the middle of nowhere and have tons of acreage so digging up the yard was not a big deal at all. But they absolutely love it and its' been going strong for 10+ years now.

Jonathan OConnor

It's funny that when you talk about electric cars needing to have heat pumps more, the one you show on screen is a Tesla Model 3...... My Model 3 and my police departments two Model Y's are the first with them. It is a great thing.

Kyle Cuzzort

FYI, my 2013 Nissan Leaf has a reversible heat pump. It will handle all the heat down to about 5*F and still takes a lot of the load down to about -5*F. The drilling alone for our ground source heat pump, off the road system in Alaska, cost $27,000. All-in our GSHP system came to $50,000 including drilling, excavation, electrical, and plumbing (we have a desuperheater that handles most of our hot water). We had to remove out tankless water heater to put in a dual tank system. I HATED that tankless heater; it was either hot or cold - not warm. It also didn’t start fast enough to use for laundry. By the time it started up, our high-efficiency washer was full of ice cold water.

C

Hm, I could have sworn I wrote a reply, but it's gone now :-/ "Condensing" driers aren't like dehumidifiers, they don't have a refrigeration cycle at all: They just use room air as a "cooler than the inside of the drier" heat sink in order to condense the water out (rather inefficiently.) This Miele PDF has a diagram on page 4 that seems to show that the heat pump drier basically is a dehumidifier, but with an additional component to _exhaust excess heat_ into the room air (not extract heat from the room air), which is necessary because it's a closed box, and doesn't lose heat (latent and sensible) through exhausting to the outside: http://ebooks.miele.com.au/miele-docs/heat_pump_dryer_brochure/files/download.pdf I think the reason they can get away with 120V/15A is because it's a closed system, so it doesn't have to constantly replenish heat lost to the outside. The owner's manual also has some text describing the mechanism of operation, pointing out the need for ventilation of the unit is to exhaust hot air (not cold air, as it would if it were using the heat pump as you describe): https://media.miele.com/downloads/d1/3b/01_96106053F2151EDAB2CC792CFC0FD13B.pdf

Technology Connections

You seem a little confused by how this would work. Just as a dehumidifier ends up blowing warm air out of itself (that's ultimately the heat the compressor's motor emits as the evaporator and condenser are next to each other) a heat pump drier will do the same. There's no way it could exhaust cold air unless the condenser was outside of the room.

C

Sorry, I must have misunderstood what you were saying. I thought you were saying the heat pump drier is taking heat from the room and using it to heat the interior (like a heat pump water heater), which would necessitate exhausting cold air, which it doesn't do. But evidently that's not what you were saying :) I think we are on the same page: It's basically a dehumidifier, with the waste heat from the dehumidification process (that's compressor inefficiency plus refrigeration cycle inefficiency) going to heat the interior, rather than heating elements heating the interior. So, my initial point was -- it's not quite like a heat pump water heater, where you're using the high COP of heat pumps to relocate heat from one volume to another instead of using heating elements. In the heat pump drier, you're relocating heat _within the same air volume_ to induce water condensation on the cold side, and then reclaiming that heat to continue the drying cycle. You don't really get a greater-than-1 COP heat source out of it -- it's a fundamentally different process from vented drying, and in fact the cold side is perhaps even more fundamental to the process than the hot side.

Arni Bjorgvinsson

That audio gag must have been real subtle, because even though I kept an ear out for... something... I noticed nothing out of the ordinary :D Also, heat pumps are cool! Too bad Iceland has practically free heating and practically no need for cooling, so consumers have neither of the two versions here.

Seán Byrne

Indeed my portable AC uses R290. R290 is also more efficient than R134a in ACs and dehumidifiers. For example, our 20 litre dehumidifier with R134a has a 420W rating, whereas their new identical looking model with R290 gas is rated 320W. Just a bummer we bought ours a year before they switched to R290.

Stephen Gillie

A hair dryer is an electric heater in gun form.

Technology Connections

Ah, OK. I think I see the confusion. The heat pump drier is absolutely making the inside of itself quite hot by absorbing energy from the room it's in. The difference between it and a water heater is that it has no way to *store* that heat. The HP water heater ends up producing cold air because there's a large thermal barrier in the form of the insulation surrounding the tank. The dryer is just pushing that hot air right through itself and back out, and much of the concentrated heat energy gets re-absorbed by the evaporator on its way. It produces a stream of hot, damp air that then gets passed over the evaporator which makes it less hot and less damp. So, the insides of the dryer absolutely can get hotter than the outsides by quite a large margin, but overall the only energy being added to the *room* is that which is consumed by the compressor's motor. However, in the short term, it ends up amplifying that heat, if you will, to warm its insides. I think that there's a semantic difference in how we're perceiving this process to occur, but I believe it is absolutely possibly to imagine a heat pump clothes dryer as producing 6 kW worth of heat on its insides with 1.5 kW of work. That heat, though, is almost in a sense just amplified. Ultimately it came from the room itself, but as it's continually being re-absorbed there isn't an observed difference.

C

Hmm. So you're saying that the air is being taken from the room, being warmed by the condenser, run through the drum, and being dehumidified + cooled on its way back to the room? You refer to an "in" and an "out", and I'm not sure such inlets and outlets actually exist. Note, in this video, the "closed air circuit" the narrator mentions: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IWqNmOLHwt0 Thus, it _is_ actually "storing" the heat inside, though I'm sure it's not insulated and sealed like a hot water heater. The only time room air comes into the equation is: "It's not possible for the system to overheat. When necessary, a cooler is switched on to regulate the temperature." That dumps excess heat to the room via an additional heat exchanger, which wouldn't be necessary if the air loop were not closed. I don't think it's entirely fair to say that that counts as 6 kW of heat being put inside, since it's also coming _from_ the inside. At best, it's whatever the motor input is. I suspect that's why some "hybrid" heat pump dryers have both a refrigeration cycle for dehumidification, and heating elements to get to operating temperature. If the room was in fact part of the air loop -- the filtering would have to be really good to avoid making a mess of lint all over the room. The room would probably also wind up smelling strongly of whatever the clothes were washed with :)

Technology Connections

Adding here for everybody that we've been messaging and figured out where our disagreement is! I wasn't picking up on what C meant about there not being an intake and exhaust and my mental process detailed from there.

C

Ha, you wouldn't want everyone to think we left things contentious, would you! I'm sure everyone was very invested in this debate between strangers :D

Stephen Gillie

At a certain level of efficiency, we get more heat by burning natural gas to create the electric power to run a heat pump, than we would by burning that natural gas for the heat. This is a really cool concept, which is why these videos keep getting made, but the point is a little esoteric and hard to state simply. Golf courses could be a good place to dig up and put the ground loops. These areas are already denuded of arborial blockages.

Stephen Gillie

Electric cars have (I believe) traditional A/C systems. Like you were saying about your home A/C system, these could be made with reversable valves. It's the same situation - save a little bit on parts and make a slightly simpler product at the expense of efficiency that is just becoming known.

Jonathan OConnor

Except the standard vehicle I would have received (Ford explorer) was only 2,000 cheaper and with the amount we idle our cars the savings ramp up quickly. Our Model Y cruisers are only 8,000 more then our Chevy Tahoes which btw get under 6mpg.... so our savings ramp up quick.

Benjamin Kier

FYI to all, the reason that EVs don't have heat pumps is because the AC is used, sometimes even in the winter to cool the batteries and other electrical systems.

coredumperror

It bothers me a good bit that you had a Tesla Model 3 on screen while complaining that some brand new EVs don't have reversible air conditioners... when Model 3s HAVE had heat pumps in them for about 5 months, now.

Jonathan OConnor

Its funny, even without knowing you could almost tell sometimes as it has the same habit of trying to run as long as possible before hitting the heat srip, at which point boom its much warmer.

Hannah Zamora

Another step in heating with a lot of potential that could be talked about is reclaimed heat from data centers. Why purely make metal warm when that metal could be a CPU doing useful work? Could we heat homes with crypto mining? Might be a silly question, but maybe :O

M@trixX

Recently, there are some datacenters connected to district heating.There are people heating their homes with cryptomining and there was also a commercial product available for that, but, obviously, the initial price, need for configuration and unstable crypto prices make it... not for everyone.

Circuitmike

I had high hopes for the dehumidification aspect of hybrid water heaters when I got mine installed. It didn't work out, though. In the summer the incoming water temperature is about 70°F and the heat pump just doesn't have to run very long to heat the tank up to its set point, so it doesn't run long enough to effectively dehumidify my basement and I still have to run a traditional dehumidifer to prevent mold and manage stank. In another house I owned I had a propane-fired tankless heater and it was AWESOME. It was a small house and the pipe runs were short enough that the heat-up time wasn't awful. Someone else here mentioned that it caused problems for their high-efficiency washing machine, which I can understand. I didn't have an HE model back then so I can't speak to that, but if it were a problem I'd just run the hot water for a bit to prime the system (like I do with my dishwasher now).