Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Time for something a little more "classic TC" and also important. I've not exactly felt as if my last couple of videos have been my best work, and while I guess I need to do one on the American drip coffee maker (and a script is already in the works on that front) didn't want yet another barely-technical topic to come up next. So here's this!

https://youtu.be/DuAeaIcAXtg

I *might* release this tomorrow for everybody. I'm not sure, though. I'll get captions started soon and assuming I can finish them tonight, I'll release this tomorrow morning or early afternoon. It's been a pretty slow YouTube week from creators I follow, so it might be good to sneak in while I can!

Files

There are two types of smoke alarm. One of 'em ain't so good.

Which one is better? Now that's a burning question. Links 'n' stuff: The 60 minutes programme; https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LT6pFzyAov8 Technology Connections on Twitter: https://twitter.com/TechConnectify The TC Subreddit https://www.reddit.com/r/technologyconnections This channel is supported through viewer contributions on Patreon. Thanks to the generous support of people like you, Technology Connections has remained independent and possible. If you'd like to join the amazing people who've pledged their support, check out the link below. Thank you for your consideration! https://www.patreon.com/technologyconnections Oh, and look at these wonderful patrons! Hargrimm , jay, Syber-Space, Todd Johnson, Nuki Chau, Chris & Anne Nash, Jordi Pakey-Rodriguez, Jim Moores, Ryan Wallmow, Roger Melo, AuroranFilms, RegalRegex, Michael Lehenbauer, James Manes, Mihaly Barasz, Potatoots, Mark Johansson, Lee Dedmon, Berwin Xie, Grey Hodge, Jim Kropa, Tony B, David Collins, Alex Carbone, Ben Golus, Tim Doering, Jonathan Grayum, Kodi , Colin Chan, Mark Komarinski, Jeff Groves, Ryan McLaughlin, J.P. Stewart, NADAV GERBER, Zac Schmitt, Bryce Swearingen, Nathan Fenner, Rittycat , Huub Heijnen, Joseph Dion, Jim Sells, Dustin Gilyard, KoolJBlack, nils m, Damione Moore, Jeremy Weeks, Carolyn Gerakines, Cameron Ross, samukaisan, Kyle Boreing, Ben Waxler, Jason Fortezzo, Andreas Neidlinger, Jason Stonehouse, Andy Warren, Rowan Parker, Steven Dubnoff, Keaton Mowery, Brett and Eric, Alexander Koch, Alipasha Sadri, Jimmy2Guys , Dash Buck, Christopher Schreiber, R. Anthony Lorensen, glw, Adam Zaner, Bob , Emil , Dad , Holden Higgins, Zach Orum, HJ, michael waddle, Tayler Heaney, Ryan, Nate Tangsurat, Jim Cavoli, Scott Waldron, Lars Naurath, Mike SoRelle, BabyET, Nick Blair, Richard Stephens, Ken Kasal, Bryce Chidester, Philip Buonadonna, BoneDepot, Barbara Ganschow, Amanda , Andy , Inkydink , Colin Mutter, Ray Everett, Connor Taffe, Nope, Todd Hawk, Rich Delgado, Brian Hamilton, Caius Worthen, Justin Byers, Falldog , Scott 'Funnyjk', David Guerrero, John Feldman, Ted Ledbetter, Tobias Putz, Caytlin Vilbrandt, Alex Rich, Geo (Overand), Nikhill Rao, Robert Fletcher, William PS, Douglas Geusz, Alexane Desbiens, Nick Kourpias, stateless.eth, Benhart, Sammy Newton, Lew Zealand, Shaitageth, Mason DeBord, Jarocks, Benjamin Richards, Chris Brosz, Stewart , Kyle Burton, Jonas, Woofy, Russell Grant, Dan Simon, cparks1000000 , Kyle, false, David Glover-Aoki, iPaq, Peter Murray, probnot, Mike West

Comments

Rae Ellen Clegg

Steam from showers alarms my ions…and begins the naked towel waving…which alarms others.

Jon T

At the risk of sounding silly, do you have heat alarms in the US? My house here in the UK has smoke alarms in each room other than the kitchen, which has a heat alarm. Great vid by the way! Thanks for all you do.

Technology Connections

Not really! At least, not for domestic uses. It appears they used to be common but once the smoke alarm spread they stopped being common. I've never seen one myself.

Mike Stringfellow

I kinda miss my little bit of radiation. Making toast in the morning automatically tested my smoke alarm. I can see why my new photoelectric alarm is better in the majority of cases, but your point in the closing credits of the video possibly deserves more emphasis. Testing a product using a button on said product isn’t something that we’d usually accept. Why do we accept it on something that we are trusting with our lives?

Jon T

Interesting. I sort of assumed they were the norm and kept expecting to see one pop up in your video. You learn something new everyday. Quite good this internet thing!

Jørgen Aaserud

Don't be so hard on yourself mate. I don't think I've ever watched a TC video I didn't enjoy. Keep up the excellent work. I'm moving into a brand new apartment next year, and I need to buy some smoke alarms, so this video is very useful, thanks!

Duncan

It may interest you to know that in Ireland we get three different types of fire sensor for homes. Ionisation, photocell, and what might be called ambient temperature. The first two are as described, while the third is aimed at kitchens and garages (look up an EI144RC if interested) - it won't trip on burnt toast, or smoking pans, but will trip when the air temperature around it goes above 58 Celsius. I have an ionisation one in my living room. At one point, the paint on the cassette stove was new, and when the fire was busy heating the stove up, the sensor would trip - no smoke in the room, but the paint being baked off was enough. Have to be fast when adding new wood to the stove. Interestingly enough, the manufacturer doesn't list that type any more, so I should probably swap it out for a combined optical+heat, though first I need to check local regs. They're all interlinked on the mains too; they get their own circuit, and do some kind of protocol over the circuit. Radio link is possible too.

Duncan

Also, around here, the commercial sensor testing service is done with a rod with a fancy cup (think big Dixie cup) on the end. I presume it has the same smoke/particle setup, but encapsulates it around the sensor to reduce the amount needed (and perhaps to isolate the sensor).

Vanja

Every rental I've lived in (USA, CA and OR) uses the Ionization technology. I'm in contact with people who know the current tenants of a place I used to live. The smoke detectors in that house had false alarms at least once a week. Apparently the smoke alarms never went off when a kitchen fire broke out, the fire destroyed the entire kitchen before it was noticed and called in. When I was there, a kitchen fire nearly broke out (that we thankfully caught in time), but the ionization detectors never once beeped. I am convinced these devices are mostly useless in real world cases. My present landlord requires the use of the ionization alarms, probably due to cost, based on other experiences with them. It is mind numbingly frustrating, especially with this added context. They also only perform button beep tests. Hopefully this is a trend that will change over time.

Jon Ruud

Thanks for a great video and reminding me to check the batteries of my smoke detectors! It seems like here in Norway ionization based alarms are no longer easily available for purchase. I have no idea if there is any truth to this, but some smoke alarm manufacturers say that you should not test your smoke alarms with smoke as that could cause soot build-up on the sensor thus affecting detection. That being said, at least where I live you can actually easily buy aerosol cans with smoke for testing smoke detectors, so take from that what you will.

Jon Ruud

I should say that they caution against using real smoke, from a lighter or candle, etc. they do not specifically warn against using "artificial smoke".

Tnarg42

Good "classic" TC fare here. One note on "dual sensor" detectors: The Nest Protect smoke detectors are advertised as "dual sensor", but they use two different optical sensors using two different wavelengths of light. They claim this detects a wider range of smoke particle sizes, making it more likely to detect both flaming and smoldering fires. I would assume that means they are arranged in an "either/or" configuration. They are obviously working at a different price point than most smoke detectors, but at least they come right out and explain how the detector operates.

‘Leigh

Eagerly awaiting the captions! (Thank you for always providing them, they help me a lot for neurodivergent reasons.) Many years before I met them, my spouse barely survived a house fire. We moved recently and there aren't smoke alarms in the bedrooms (WTF??) but it's proving surprisingly difficult to find dual-sensor-type ones like we were hoping for with 10-year batteries. I'm eager to learn what your research has uncovered!

Francis

I'd want to know if the test actually somehow simulates the detection of smoke (e.g. redirecting the LED light), or if it just tells the electronics "go beep now".

Jonathan Polirer

Now, not *exactly* a heat alarm, but... There is such a thing as a residential fire sprinkler system. Some localities require them in new construction, many do not. (Builders -- especially spec builders -- have a strong lobby against them because of the increase in cost (rather low at only about $1.35 per sqft).) But, they literally work by a using a low-melting-point piece of material (glass?) to "detect" heat, melt, and allow water to solve the fire problem PDQ. (Yes, then you have a water problem. Honestly, you're going to have a water problem once the fire department shows up, anyway. With sprinklers, you'll likely have a smaller water problem and a MUCH smaller fire problem to fix.)

Kyle Burton

When I moved house, it didn't come with any smoke alarms, so since I was going to renovate it and install hardwired alarms, I didn't fancy splashing out on some 'temporary' battery operated ones. Here we can get free smoke alarms from the fire brigade, so when they came out to install them I asked if I should put them in all bedrooms they said not to, and that one on the landing would be enough

Matt Goldman

I might've missed it, but you might want to add some text telling people not to take their smoke detectors apart since, y'know, it might be radioactive.

Sean Bright

As a former smoker I've always wondered why cigarette smoke never seems to trigger smoke alarms.

Lennart Sorensen

Meanwhile up in Ontario, building code requires all new construction to have them in every bed room and at least one per floor of the house and they have to be interconnected. They too of course won't commit to saying one type is better than the other, just that one is more likely to have nuisance alarms than the other and that they detect different types of fires.

Gradyn Wursten

I swear every time he makes a video about an appliance or a light bulb or whatever I find myself going to the store and replacing the ones I have

thoughtdreams

Why don't they make smoke alarms integrated into ceiling light fixtures, especially those newer flattish led lights? Seems like a natural symbiosis using existing wired thingies on the ceiling of most rooms. Or even ceiling fans. I realize a running fan would disrupt their ability but most people don't run fans 24/7. Now, off to buy photoelectric alarms to replace my radioactive ones.

BrianL

Good to know. I never really trusted those test button fully, so once in a while (maybe once a year), I go around testing with "real" smoke (from a piece of paper)... I might have to rethink that strategy...

Ryan Butler

I disconnected all my smoke alarms because they made me daisy chain them when I did an upgrade and I have the same nuisance alarm issue. Last straw was I made a pizza at 2 am and woke up then entire house and the neighbors. Have been slowly saving up for some Nest ones since apparently you can control for that. But this seems like a much cheaper option. Thanks for the video. And seriously whoever decided 8 daisy chained alarms in a 1500 sq ft house was good governance needs to be tracked down and forced to account for themselves.

Martin Deutsch

I'd suggest that "right now" is not a good time to test your smoke detectors when everyone else in the house is asleep. (I'll do it in the morning!)

Duncan

In Ireland, the available units are much, much bigger than light fixtures. They also have a N-year lifespan, and I don't want to be replacing my light fixtures just because the smoke detector needs to be changed. The detectors I have are on a nice common base, so I just have to turn off the circuit they're on, push a release button, and the whole detector slides off. New detector slides on, power is turned back on, and everything is fine. Dedicated units seems like a perfectly fine state of affairs.

Paul Schuur

+1 internet points for correct pronounciation of "Jaeger".

Chuck Sembroski

Thanks for researching this. Somehow in my mind I had the physics of ionizing smoke detectors exactly backwards in my head. Doh!

MrHammond

I agree! Your pronounciation was very good Alec! Cheers from Switzerland!

MrHammond

In the Netherlands, I used to have an ionization-type detector, it was clearly labelled with "Contains radio-active Americium-241, do not disassemble!" I guess that will be the same in the rest of Europe, including Switzerland.

Compuart

And not only that. They also sound a different type of alarm depending on the degree of seriousness, either 'heads-up' or 'emergency'. And they include carbon monoxide detection, though to some, like me, that might not be too useful.

Michael Dunn

Thanks for the detailed explanations! The house that I grew up in had a nuisance alarm when the oven was on, even though the alarm was probably 30 feet from the kitchen and around a bend in the hallway. I've always wondered why it went off.

Hodgkin LeBlanc

This video was incredibly interesting. Also congrats on getting it on trending once again! I'm happy to support you directly in this small way for whatever content you find interesting enough to cover.

Brian Zimmerman

Awesome video! Didn't even know there was any other method aside from the radioactive method. Side note: Since the toaster was mentioned, I just realized - your sunbeam toaster wiring insulation might contain asbestos. Probably doesn't matter, but just in case you have it apart again, try not to disturb it. 😬

RTT12

Yep, pretty good. No complaints.

Sara, no h

We had a cotton candy machine for a party that we had to bring inside to use on a windy day. The cotton candy threads confused the smoke alarm and caused all the connected alarms in the house. Must have been an ionization alarm! Thanks for the video

Raul Ramos

Now I feel a bit stupid. Some years ago I had to check the performance of an evacuation fan on a complicated chamber. I set a bunch of lasers, sometimes with mirrors and photodiodes to measure the build up an quantify it. Not only I had no clue there was such a technology for home alarms but I never thought it. But it worked very well. Response times were fast and using the raw voltage gave us a very good idea of what was happening and where the smoke was accumulating

Victor Boyer

Yes they exist! At least in commercial alarm systems, a combination photoelectric/heat (called a "rate of rise detector") is common. In my home, I installed monitored commercial sensors (from DSC) that are photoelectric with a 135F (57C) heat alarm, along with some logic, so if the temperature rises suddenly, the detector will go into alarm (and therefore the system will go into alarm).

Asaf Sagi

Checked mine. Photoelectric, placed right above my 3D printer 😎

Darren Pierce

I installed Kidde heat alarms in the garage and laundry room of my house in Atlanta! Bought them at Home Depot. Not common, but not hard to find, either.

Darren Pierce

It shouldn't be too hard to disable either side of a dual sensor alarm and see if any single sensor will trip the mechanism alone. Might have a stab at that if my workload stays light this week.

Jabels

As a guy that works daily with various sensor technologies. The sheer novelty of americium and the way it works wants me to play around with sensor building

toasterking

I just found this video in my feed, so I'm very late. But there's another class of scenarios in which ionization-based detectors are somewhat superior. And that's because the photoelectric ones can trigger on floating particles other than smoke, like water droplets from steam or fog. So if you're going to be steam cleaning clothes or running a fog machine nearby, a photoelectric smoke detector could be pretty annoying. Great video, though!