Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Oh boy.

So, one of you lovely lot suggested this video topic by way of asking a question - apparently I touched on this once in a video (can't remember which one, honestly!) and I called the conspiracy partly a myth. Well, here's a long explanation on why that's the case.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zb7Bs98KmnY

As I say in the beginning, I feel a little weird covering this. But, on the other hand, this story gets told sans context far too often. Is this a debunking video? Eh... maybe? If anything it's closer to the format war videos - dispelling a widely-held notion with historical context. It just feels more than a little weird being like "the cartel was right, actually"

Oh, and to anyone who might be headed to Open Sauce this weekend - I hope to see you there!

Files

Longer-lasting light bulbs: it was complicated

Titling adventure to come, for sure.

Comments

Jamie + Lion

Oooo, one to watch as I head to bed :) Open Sauce looks amazing. So many great content creators in one place! I hope ya have heaps of fun :)

Jared Juel

You're the right kind of person with a penchant for non-new technology and pulling a thread of why's until your fingers bleed to tackle this exact topic. I'm eager to watch this video.

Michael Dunn

How do people find out about cons like Open Sauce? The first I heard about it was when Robert mentioned it a few days ago, and by that time, the only tickets left were too expensive.

Crissa Kentavr

It's only a conspiracy when they tried to keep it a secret ^-^

Ewen McNeill

Great video, adding a lot of context that doesn’t always get noted. I did like that the bulb life time versus light output testing was brought to us through the magic of buying 100 of them :-) Ewen

Luke Skaff

Thank you so much for making this! I run halogen bulbs in my bathroom and bedroom as they have very low blue light output as the blue light in LEDs suppresses melatonin production. A big trick to making incandescence and halogens last long is using a smart dimmer that fades the bulb on so the filiment can get hot before coming up to full voltage. The resistance of the filament increases as it gets hotter so the bulbs burn too bright when you first turn them on with a standard switch. I haven't changed the bulb and over 2 years with a smart dimmer.

Michaela Pereckas

I am so happy to see someone cover this! And best of all, you, doing your usual thorough half-hour job!

The Great Quux

That looks like a really cool conference! I’m sure we’d love a Connextras video with some video from there (I’m trying to avoid “footage” since no reel of tape would be involved… presumably).

AArexx AAron Ruscetta

Brilliant points in every aspect of your coverage (pun intended, of course).

thatsagoodbingo

"Everlasting light bulb-stopper" cracked me up

Aleksei Besogonov

Just buy an "extra warm" LED, they have the color temperature around 2200K. Modern LEDs with a good CRI (Color Rendering Index) don't emit more blue light than a tungsten filament at the specified temperature.

Luke Skaff

This is not correct, look up the spectral distribution of even modern leds, they are still very blue shifted

naota3k

That also isn't necessarily correct, Luke. Modern High-CRI (CRI = Color Rendering Index) LEDs can have extremely accurate spectral distributions. Even something like the 5+ year old Luminus SST-20 in 4000K has a minimum CRI of 95, and if you look at professional CRI measurements of it, R12 (Deep Blue) is actually the lowest scoring out of the 15 test colors. You can also get the SST-20 in a 2700K variant, which is also 95+ CRI. https://imgur.com/ldEQbh7 Here's a reading of that exact LED. For reference, our Sun, by definition, has a CRI of 100. https://www.waveformlighting.com/tech/cri-ra-test-color-samples-tcs/ and here's an explanation of each of the test samples. If you go and look something like the Nichia 519A LEDs (which can go as high as 96-97 CRI), they are even better than the SST-20. And you can get them in R9080 (90+ CRI, 80+ R9 ((red)) score) all the way up to 5700K! We're only getting better at making them. It isn't 2010 anymore, when everyone was using 7500K LEDs putting out 60 CRI. Here's a reading I just took of my own LED recessed lights with my cheap Opple light meter. They are 90+ CRI adjustable CCT LEDs, going from 2700K up to 5000K, with my current setting at 4000K: https://imgur.com/a/HIJwKLf I installed these lights myself, more than 5 YEARS AGO. (Yes Alec, I know you hate these disposable fixtures.) I can almost guarantee you would not be able to tell the difference between these and any random incandescent bulbs at the same Correlated Color Temperature. I am a huge flashlight nerd, and tint snob. CRI, Tint, and CCT are my biggest deciding factors. I own nearly 50 flashlights with all kinds of LEDs. More than 30 of them are at least 90+ CRI. If you would like to look at some datasheets for super-high CRI LED emitters, check out: Luminus SST-20 (4000K and below), Nichia 519A (R9080 Bins from 2700K - 5700K), Nichia E21A (Any), Nichia B35AM (The 4500K is particularly gorgeous, and incredibly neutral looking. But again, I believe you can get them ranked R9080 from 2700K - 5000K.) Even the (now discontinued) fan favorite Nichia 219b SW45K LED from _years_ ago regularly hits 92+ CRI (although they are infamously rosy-pink, which I subjectively love.) If 95+ CRI isn't enough for you, check out the Nichia Optisolis line. They are not particularly good for flashlights, as they are made for actual lighting products like the Halo fixtures I have. They are hitting 97-98+ CRI. TBF, I barely know HALF of what the proper nerds in the flashlight community know. If you want to hear some people who REALLY know WTF they're talking about, look up some of the LEDs I mentioned on BudgetLightForum. Those guys are geniuses. Apologies for the novel. With all that being said, I should probably watch this video lmao.

Stephanie

Open Sauce looks so cool! wish I could join. :D

Slartibartfast

Same! Never heard of it, but now I want to go next year :)

Witold Witkowski

Alec was paid off by "big lightbulb" and "big energy generator". It's all coming together now. He encourages wasteful electric cars, discourages home energy generation in the form of Rooftop Solar Panels, and now, is trying to tell us that long life lightbulbs are bad for us!!!! (s) (EDIT: ---Patreon won't let me use the standard symbol for sarcasm---)

Warren Adams

Speaking of planned obsolescence light bulbs. I could swear I saw a TC vid on the Dubai LED bulbs and how US LED bulbs are over driven to shorten their lifespan. But now I can't find it. Was it taken down? Did I dream it?

MrHammond

Good points, as usual, all well-researched! Funny that you mention washing machines: I don't know how the market there in the US is looking, but here in Europe, you can choose in a range of at least a factor 20 of different prices washing machines. When I bought a washing machine about 15 years ago, they told me that I could buy a €200 Indesit, a €500 Zanussi or a €3000 Miele. Expecting that the Indesit would last only a couple of years at most, the Zanussi 5-10 years, or the Miele which would last at least 20-30 years. Here you just pay for what you get.

Michael Steeves

Did you just spend half an hour confirming what I've always assumed, working from "first principles" engineering? Thank you!

Erik Granlund

BigClive has a bunch of videos on LED bulbs he buys and ‘hacks’ to run at a lower current to make the LEDs last long. Feels weirdly similar :)

Cameron Steel

Am I the only one who thinks the outro music is a little sharp in pitch?

Johnathan Reale

Wonderful aesopian moral. Consider that it may yet be somewhat true even in other “planned obsolescence” scenarios where the tradeoffs are less obvious.

Mr Fantastic

Worth noting some pretty direct paralells to the way Auto manufacturers are trending toward increasingly lower weight engine oils. I recently bought a car which uses 0w20 weight, which is harder to find and more expensive than more traditional weights like 5w30, 10w40 etc. Some new cars, especially brands like Honda\Toyota, come with even more exotic oil weights like 0w16 and even as low as 0w8. Besides the mechanical differences, one of the named reasons is a small (few percentage) increase of engine efficenicy, and despite burning off more readily during the normal combustion cycle compared to standard weights, and being more expensive to purchase, that few percentage gain in efficency makes a MASSIVE overall reduction in fuel consumption when scaled up to world-wide scopes, and ultimately is less costly over all. It's interesting to consider who is taking on those new costs, who decides which direction the world should trend, etc..

krallja

“Eek!” is a cat, “eke” is how you spell the word meaning “to scrape by” or “economize.”

Ben Fogt

You need to swing over to Dearborn MI to see a certain rebuilt lab that's all that was left of a certain lab in New Jersey in 1928. Amtrak's Wolverine line would get you to a station next to Greenfield Village. This video addresses half of the conspiracies I hear when I get to work in the lab.

Micah Gale

Umm actually Kelvin-radians are the better unit to use than Kelvin-degrees.

Mark L

great video. Some pushback on conspiracies and explains past limits of technology

Raul Ramos

I don't think you can argue for anyone specific being in control or guiding. A lot of this is convergent design and cost reduction pressure, not really advances as in patentable improvements.

Raul Ramos

I have this aeg vacuum cleaner to quit on me after three years... I am a bout sour about it still

MrHammond

And no warranty left? Or "just after the warranty" (which sucks of course a lot...) My Philips vacuum cleaner has a "soft start" (which is very nice on the electric system) which is based on a simple microcontroller. After a couple of years it wouldn't start anymore, I also thought: way too early. Then I had a look at the soft-start system, and figured out that the elco stabilizing the power for the microcontroller had gone bad, most probably because it gets hot during use. I swapped it out, the vac is still working fine now! Sometimes they mount caps in a too hot environment (near a power-dissipating resistor, or motor) and they're prone to go bad too soon. Another common problem is polyester caps providing the standby power for modern devices without a hard power switch: they're usually rated for the power dissipation needed in Japan or America (100-120V) and for 230V, they simply change the value, but not the rating for power dissipation, so they fail after a couple of years. Replacing them with the same capacity, but better values for temperature and power dissipation makes those devices work for many years to come!