Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Hello there! It's a new video. File it under More Pumping More Now.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DTsQjiPlksA

So - there's a lot in this. There's drama. Angst. Snark! And exasperation. But also - hopefully lots of useful information.

As a programming note, the core concepts are applicable no matter where you are but this is very heavily focused on the reality in the US and Canada. I have a pretty strong feeling that these same issues are happening the world over, and I hope that the suggestions on how to combat them are helpful no matter where you are, but I didn't bother to directly address the many other kinds of heating systems that are out there. Although, having said that, now I'm wondering how real the retrofitting problem with radiator sizes and lower-temperature water loops actually is ...

Anywho, it's going to be quite some time before captions are completed given the videos length. And, as I said in the update post, I'll be working on a shorter, condensed version to put on the second channel in the next few days. Until that's done, this won't get released publicly. But - that should only take me a few days to piece together.

OK, well, thanks everyone! Hope you like it.

Files

Old HVAC industry practices are holding us back and costing us money. But we can fix it.

More Pumping More Now

Comments

squix

This is the best news I could have hoped for today!

NeonCoding

Yup, he's still writing them.

NeonCoding

Is this the new office? If so, set's come together really well.

Paul

The only argument I could still see against going to the absolute minimum size for my hvac is that it will accumulate way more hours of runtime than if it's a bit oversized. I certainly don't want it very oversized, but I feel like I might need repairs sooner if it runs an average of 14 to 18 hours a day instead of 6 to 10 or some such. 🤷

Tom G

That meme-worthy expression at 25:07 😄

CRAIG BILODEAU

I haven't finished the video, but did you consider duty cycle? If your system is only running 25% of the time, isn't that an appropriate duty cycle for a typical heating system?

Technology Connections

I understand the impulse here, but this is less and less a thing to worry about. With modern inverter-driven system, the compressor simply slows down to match load and rarely ever stops. Arguably the most wear happens at start-up because the oil pools into the sump and the mechanical parts are run dry until the internal oil pump builds pressure. I don't know of any studies on this or anything (though I'm sure they're out there) but it is completely fine for the system to run constantly on occasion.

cole

someone please make a nice T-shirt I can buy that says HEAT PUMPS ARE JUST AIR CONDITONERS

Technology Connections

What is appropriate is the whole issue here - it's completely normal for a system to need to operate at 100% duty cycle at design conditions. They are built to withstand that, and with compressors that need lubrication and only get it when running, that's arguably going to produce less wear than more frequent, shorter cycles. Compressors are a sealed system and don't typically fail. There's a saying in the industry that they don't die, they're murdered. Plugged condensers lead to high operating pressures which can indeed harm them, but the plugged condenser was the issue. Not the compressor. Modern systems also have way more monitoring of what's going on inside them and they will do everything they can to protect themselves.

NeonCoding

Sidenote, I love your near-snap message to Google.

Aleksei Besogonov

Around 22 minutes in the video, you're missing another source of energy: the fans. It takes 500-800W of power just to run the fans that move the air through the ducts. Of course, this energy gets dissipated as heat inside the house. This is not insignificant, and we observed it affect the heating/cooling demands by quite a bit when people switch from central ducting to much more efficient split units.

Technology Connections

I deliberately missed this because it would cause arguments if I brought it up. In the context of heating, that only helps - it just lowers apparent COP somewhat. In cooling mode that does become an additional load, but the good news is that blower motors in centrally-ducted systems are getting more efficient, too. In my folks' new system, it's variable speed and throttles up and down depending on staging. I don't know what its power draw is but my understanding is they're much improved compared to multi-tap motors of old.

Robert Sanges

Come for the snark, stay for the angst.

CRAIG BILODEAU

Thanks for the reply. Not an HVAC guy so I was curious what a 100% duty cycle would do to longevity of the system. Gut instinct is that a 100% duty cycle is bad but if it's only for those extreme circumstances of the design conditions, I guess it's ok. Just wondering if you took it into consideration. Thanks for the video. I own a 150yo home in MA heated by gas with radiant baseboard. Have been thinking about heat pumps since your last video on the subject as it would add AC to the home as a bonus. But my uncle who was an HVAC guy and owned the home before me, installed an amazing system that still has many years of life in it as he didn't skimp on components and installed everything perfectly. It was kind of his thing. He passed a few years ago and frankly I think it would break his heart if I ripped it out. My idea was mini split systems where I could install one zone at a time which would add AC and eventually transition the heat in that zone to that system. There are no ducts in the house so this would be the easiest way to transition over time as the system ages and needs replacement. Anyway thanks again for another deep dive on a subject. You do a great job on this stuff. Keep up the good work.

Aleksei Besogonov

Yeah, agree. Unfortunately, fans are not really getting that much better. Unless you have a comically oversized system, variable speed blowers are only marginally more efficient than good old asynchronous AC motors.

Micah Gale

I live in an apartment building in Wisconsin on the top floor with one exterior wall, and about 700 square feet. We have a water source heat pump. It is 1.5 ton, and it is way oversized. When it was -9 to 0 F it only ran 4.5 hours.

Brooks Moses

I was sitting here in my slab-on-grade house thinking about ductwork as you were snarking about having an "octopus-of-flexible-ductwork" in the attic and ... yes. That is an excellent description of what we have, connected to a decidedly old gas furnace. On the other hand, this is the S.F. Bay Area, so our worst-case design temperature is probably 30F or something like that, and we're probably not losing that much heat up there. The problem would be if we wanted to put in air conditioning; it gets over 120F in the attic in the summer. Anyway, yes, definitely considering a heat pump. Especially after this video.

Aleksei Besogonov

One thing about oversizing, is that it doesn't actually cost that much. It's just a hundred extra dollars in case of gas furnaces, and even for a heat pump you're looking at the difference of around $1000 between 30000 BTU and 60000 BTU systems. And the difference in true hardware cost between 20000BTU and 30000BTU systems is so small, that had the hardware manufacturers been a bit more technologically advanced, they would have used software to limit the power of smaller systems instead of manufacturing multiple SKUs. Unfortunately (fortunately?), variable-speed HVAC systems are still in the stone age. They are utterly incompatible with anything but their manufacturers' crappy thermostats, which have software written by minimum-wage drones. It's seriously amazing how many low-hanging fruits are present in this area.

TheEdgeOfRage

I always find these American heating/cooling videos interesting, since meanwhile in Serbia, we have city-central heating with hot water pipes running to the streets and then attached to radiators under your windows. But since this is shithole country, you can't control the radiators in a lot of old apartments, so they just go full tilt all the time and people open their windows when it's too hot (which is usually 28C/82F for the average Joe). hOoRaY fOr eFfIcIeNcY

Technology Connections

There is some good news on thermostats! The system my folks have has some sort of daughterboard on it to allow control from a conventional two-stage T-stat. Now - I don't know the details on how the unit itself handles staging, but my assumption is that it tries to operate most efficiently on stage 1 calls and then goes full-tilt on stage 2 calls. It may very well be dumber than that, but with a system knowing indoor and outdoor temps, it's not too difficult to put some fuzzy logic in there which helps it predict loading. Of course, that could fight with the thermostat's programming so I don't know precisely what they did - but luckily at least some OEMs are seeing the light and allowing for universal controls now even with vari-speed equipment.

Technology Connections

I'm glad you like them! I'd be... in a very bad headspace if I were living in your situation. Knowing that the system has the *potential* to be extremely efficient but the implementation where the rubber meets the road is so poor would probably require therapy for me.

TheEdgeOfRage

It is slight hyperbole, but only slight. For most people over 50y/o living in buildings that are from the 80s or earlier, that is the sad reality. Heating is just so dirt cheap and you pay the same regardless of how much you use that people don't care. It is getting better thankfully. My SO and I bought a new apartment that had a proper thermostat to regulate the incoming hot water with a calorie meter to actually only bill you for how much you use. It even has thermostatic radiator valves, can you imagine that :D

Andrew Maltby

I'm a structural Engineer with some experience helping my local university after graduating. I would say that this experiment would be better than most thesis 4th year students do. You should hit up your local university about getting an honorary engineering degree.

Aleksei Besogonov

Ha. Nope. Variable speed thermostats have always been controllable through the conventional dry-contacts interface. A lot of them can also emulate the traditional 2-stage interface. They are super-dumb in this mode, so don't expect anything fancy from them. And if anything, the industry is moving backwards. One of the large manufacturers has recently added encryption to the wire protocol between their thermostats and the compressors. It's the same crap as is happening with TVs, the margins are razor-thin, so manufacturers are trying to either sell user data, or to push users towards subscriptions.

Leslie Deana

two things: I'd rather have a vehicle with an engine bigger than needed... running anything at 100% of design will shorten the life. Second GAS is better in my book - instant on / instant off. (Cooking wise - do you EVER see chefs cooking on electric stoves? Not to mention our Power Grid....

Martín Hoecker-Martínez

You should reach out to the national renewable energy lab to suggest a calculator. They (and the Dept of energy) are the kinds of folks who can make an authoritative online tool.

triggthediscovery

It's worth considering how much heat you're getting from your neighbors. I had an apartment in Pittsburgh and even when the temp outside was well under zero, the unit would never drop below 70 degrees, without any heating at all. I frequently ran the AC in winter, with below freezing temperatures outside, because honestly 70 is too hot for me. I think that makes me a monster, but it's not my fault my neighbors refused to set their apartments below 85 or whatever the hell they were doing.

Kris Pockell

I'm an app developer. I'll take a look!

Technology Connections

Well first, they can indeed run at 100% without being damaged. In fact, since that keeps the oil pump in the compressor running, it's probably better for it than continuing to stop and start. But that's a rare occasion anyway. Just as you rarely ever need to go full-throttle in a car but you can when you need to, a heating system rarely needs to run at full-tilt but can when it needs to. Also - lots of chefs are making the switch to induction stoves! They greatly reduce energy needs (especially because that reduces the need for make-up air and cooling in the kitchen) and ALSO offer much higher power levels than gas, yet just as much control. Gas cannot innovate. It's just fire. But we can and indeed just keep on innovating with electricity. The future is electric, and if you're not able to see that - frankly, my channel's not a great fit for you.

Z

I loved your videos on appliances and home energy when I was a renter (and couldn't put the info to use). But now that I own a home, I get stupidly excited for videos like this one.

Steven Nicklas

Lots of pieces of equipment, especially those with compressors have lives determined mostly by number of starts, so running at 100% actually increases the life, not the opposite.

Christopher Thomas

I’m not sure that’s correct. One of my friends got a fancy new system and reported that even when running full-speed it’s a couple hundred watts less, and it often runs at low speed with significantly more power savings.

Christopher Thomas

Great video! One thing you didn’t mention when making this brief YouTube Short was code requirements. Code where I live has a design indoor temperature requirement too, which is quite a bit warmer than what I actually keep my thermostat set to. It’s not a huge adder to the absolute temperature delta, but could matter for someone right on the edge (well, ok, no inspector is ever going to rerun a load calc). 56:23 “wedder” 🙂

Jason Pagliaro

It's pretty bad that I'm happy the captions aren't ready because I get to watch this one again with the "correct" captions. They're always a treat and have excellent little easter eggs in them.

DrKOS

I successfully persuaded my heat pump installers to "only" install the size I wanted. I explained that I knew that it was slightly undersized, but that we would be shortly doing an insulation retrofit and I did my own manual J. I'm a thermal engineer, so it wasn't much trouble, but I imagine most people weren't lurking on "Green Building Advisor" to know about manual J calculations. Good on you for bringing this to a wider audience!

Jon Snyder

I have an old house from the 60s, that has hydronic heating powered by gas. So I'm not sure I could get a heat pump, since my house doesn't have any air vents. I'm curious what I could do to get off of gas!

Technology Connections

If you want to add cooling, you'll be a good candidate for a ductless mini-split system. But if you're just looking for heat, you're going to be looking at air-to-water heat pumps which generate hot water. They're going to be very common in Europe since hydronic heating is more or less the default there, and I'm sure they will be available for the US, too. I'm sure some are available now but it will be more niche.

Technology Connections

Oh, also, yes! This is at the office. Still want to do a bit more acoustic work to cut down on reverb but otherwise the setup is working great.

Ben's Eco Adventure

Just want to say Thank YOU for this video. I have come to a lot of the same conclusions as you regarding how/why the HVAC industry does what they do. I’m in the early stages of getting a heat pump for my house to replace the furnace and want to document it on my channel. Being able to point to your video is a massive time saver so I can focus more on the particulars of the process

Eric Nelson

During the winter, my thermostat is set to 70° when I'm home, and 60° while I go to work. When it's around freezing, the inside temperature usually drops to ~65° during the 10 hours I'm away at work. Of course, this varies above and below that if it's warmer or colder outside that day. Would graphing the inside temperature drop (actual heat loss) vs. the outside temperature over time be an alternative way of calculating heating requirements?

Mark Hesse

That slow pan across all the space heaters at 31:05 gave me the giggles (and a few creeps as well). You know how people are always noticing faces in fairly mundane images? You had just mentioned that space heaters were as dumb as it gets and the next thing I see is a slow pan across 7 of the dumbest-looking faces (and creepiest too😬) that I've seen for a while. Very apropos!

Kris Pockell

Obviously, this is just the best I could do in 45 minutes, but I'd love for someone who has more insight into how the *actual* calculation needs to be done. It's written in Flutter, and I plan to make it open source on GitHub. https://imgur.com/eNkG49s

Ewen McNeill

Given what you’ve said it sounds like “let’s install heat strips that are basically never used, to account for the coldest 3 days a year” is probably the fastest path to “right sizing” the heat pump installs. It ensures ample capacity for anything, avoids the space heater discussion, and assuming the heat pump / insulation do perform as expected the heat strips never run so them being less efficient basically doesn’t matter. Ewen

NeonCoding

Yknow, watching this as a Brit where heat pumps are basically the first time air conditioning is being introduced to the market, it's quite novel to hear all of the complaints regarding history and price gouging, despite knowing for a fact it's definitely happening here, almost moreso - it's why I was very tempted when we were speccing one for mine and my partner's new home, to just do the install myself - if it were legal, I absolutely would've. But I fully expect that when we come to installation, the price gouge is going to be ludicrous

Brian Underwood

I was thinking about building something too, though I don't know much about the topic. But I'm thinking a webpage app makes sense so that it would be easy for any device (android/iOS/PC/mac/etc...) could use it. Though if it's going to be something used by sales people / technicians in various situations, it would probably make a lot of sense for it to be an offline web app so that they could bring it up even if their phone doesn't have connection because they're visiting a basement or just in a house which is far away from cell towers Given Alec's problem where all of the data went away when he closed the tab, it could be worthwhile storing the current session in the browser and either allowing for multiple sessions or for the user to choose when they want to "Reset".

Brian Underwood

Seems like the discussion is on Discord :)

David K

The little controls engineering nerd inside me LOVES this experiment. I really want to whip out Matlab and work out the math on paper. The electrical engineering nerd in me is SCREAMING at almost 115 amps of current draw just for the heaters, and that's before the extension cords, lol.

Brandon L

I dunno... this is pretty prime time friendly. I'm already itching to share it around.

Technology Connections

(copying here what I replied on YT) I understand your concern here, but it's more complicated than that. For a start, you can't just build in any arbitrary amount of margin. The next size up from 3 tons is 4 tons which, while it may have avoided the use of heat strips altogether, could have presented cooling issues in the summer in addition to needing an upgraded circuit to the outside unit (though, the particulars there vary from model to model). And by the time the temperatures drop so low that heat strips are coming into question, the COP of the heat pump won't be much above 1. For all those reasons, I think you should think of the heat strips themselves as the margin. And how often any home will rely on them will vary based on many factors. Consider that for my parents, the heat strips ran for a grand total of about 3 hours over an entire year. Sizing the heat pump to avoid that wouldn't make sense, even on the context of the power grid. There, everything becomes an average. So while a 15kW load did appear five times in the middle of the night from their house, because it was only on about 1/3 of the time, it functions as a 5kW load. That could even become an actual 5kW draw with finer staging on the heat strips. In the end, I'm not sure this is something that you need to be worried about.

Technology Connections

Oh, it wasn't 115 amps! Only one heater was actually on high - every other was either paired and sharing a circuit or by itself on medium. In total it was about 55 amps @120V, but the loads were at least partially balanced across the two legs so the apparent draw on my electrical system @240V was between 30 and 40 amps.

Technology Connections

Oh absolutely. I think in a climate like mine, it makes sense to size the heat pump to the 99th percentile and rely on heat strips for that 1%. But go just a bit South of me and heat strips may not even be needed anymore. If the lowest temp you ever see is ~5 F, then with these cold climate heat pumps they don't even lose any capacity. Which is awesome!

The Great Quux

I want to go to a heat pump as soon as I can, especially given gas prices. But In a 170 year old house with basically no insulation, I think re-siding and wrapping the house is probably something I should do first. It’s complicated by the fact that my current siding is asbestos tiles and not everyone is licensed to remove it! 🙄

Tinkerman

Absolutely go for the siding first. Then you can size your new equipment properly down the road. Lower ACH (air changes/hour) is your friend. I would love to have our siding and sheathing replaced with zip-R sheathing, but that would require a loan on a house of our size.

Technology Connections

Oh sure, and that's a big part of why my heating loads are so minimal. But you don't have to count the shared walls as a load when doing calculations - even if you have somebody next to you keeping their home at something nuts, the differential between the walls is still tiny compared to outside. The only way that would become a load is if a neighbor shut off their heating entirely which, while I guess that's a possibility, isn't something you need to consider (and in the case of most townhomes, the shared walls are actually constructed as two exterior walls separated by an air-gap. So there is plenty of insulation, too).

MrHammond

I just live in an old rental apartment, but also have way to much heat here, I don't have a thermostat, just unregulatable floor heating. As long as it doesn't freeze outside, I hardly need to turn it on for more than half an hour per day. If I put it on for more than 1 hour, it gets too hot... But I don't know yet about -20°C (-4°F for you, no, I'm not French! :-P), it hardly doesn't get that cold here anymore...

triggthediscovery

Sorry if it came off as a gotcha, I just occasionally have traumatic flashbacks to hearing the AC kick on in the middle of winter and had to inflict that experience on others.

Aleksei Besogonov

Older systems used notoriously undersized fans rotating at high speed. They waste quite a bit of energy this way. Newer fixed-speed fans are more optimized and rotate at a slower speed. If your equipment was manufactured after around 2006-2010, you won't see much (if any) savings when switching to variable-speed fans.

David K

Fantastic planning on your part, and well executed. You have much better restraint than I do though, I would have given it the full beans, "just to see what would happen".

Peter

When replacing the siding, also consider adding a few inches of exterior insulation. It's a relatively easy way to boost the R value of your walls.

Peter

On your second-channel, shortened version of the video, I recommend avoiding the rant about the placement duct work in sub-optimal locations. The larger audience for that video isn't in a position to build a new house and may not be able to afford relocating ductwork in their existing house. Despite the poor duct design, they can still benefit from using smaller equipment (and don't need to switch to mini-splits to get it).

John K.

When I had my house insulated I also had an air seal done on the attic and basement. The installer said the priorities are attic first, then basement (rim joist seal), and the walls third. But if you’re doing a siding job anyway, don’t pass up the opportunity to wrap and insulate.

John K.

It would be nice to see some discussion on house tightness and wind. I have great insulation in the attic, but my windows don’t have a good seal. Windy days have a large impact on my furnace runtime. I have ecobee temperature sensors in every room in my home and I can see the temperature gradient based on the direction of the wind. R value doesn’t matter much if the wind is causing a complete air change.

John K.

Regarding the oversized being good for hitting the set point faster, smart thermostats can mitigate this need. Ecobee has a predictive mode that will turn the HVAC on early so that it reaches the desired temp at the time you want it. If you’re exactly right sized your system it might even ignore your lower set point at night on a really cold day.

Mark L

Great and much needed video. One objection to some smart thermostats like Nest is you cannot turn on the house fan unless AC or Heat mode is on. Sometimes I just want to run the fan to move air around, filter out dust while cleaning, etc. I can turn on AC with a silly high setting to prevent the AC from running, then turning on the fan, then resetting things when done is a pain. Come on google, dump thermostats have a fan On setting that works even when the heat is off.

Mark L

Two useful formula if you are trying to figure out things for yourself: 1 kW of power is 3412 BTU/hour (pure resistance heating). And when looking at heat pumps and ACs, if you take the BTU rating (1 ton = 12000 BTU) and divide by SEER, this is the power draw in watts when running the heat pump/AC. For example a 2 ton AC/heat pump = 2*12000 = 24000, and if the SEER is say 16, the heat pump draws 24000/16 = 1500 watts when running. Note 2 ton resistance heating would be over 7000 watts. Using these figures you can estimate how much a heat pump can save versus resistance heating and compare electricity rates versus other heating source costs.

Technology Connections

Oh absolutely, that's not staying in the short version. But for clarity, that rant is aimed at builders and not individuals. YT keeps recommending me shorts from a home inspector out in Arizona and even *there* they are still running all the ducting through the attic. In Arizona! The attic's gonna get hot as hell there and the insulation on those ducts is paltry compared to the solid foot of blown-in cellulose covering the ceiling. I just cannot understand how that practice continues. I would wager homes in a climate like Arizona are spending at least 20% more energy to stay cool due to this ridiculous practice. It might even be much worse than that. More people need to be aware that there are alternatives.

Philip Chapman

You can control the fan manually with an Ecobee thermostat. You can also say “run the fan for 10 minutes every hour” for example.

Technology Connections

Oh - you can control the fan like that with Nest, too. What Mark is talking about (an irritation that I share) is that you cannot run the fun with the system set to Off. It will just complain at you that the system is off and force you to pick heating or cooling mode before it will let you run the fan, which is stupid and annoying. The only workaround is to force it into eco temperatures. There are several core functions of thermostats that all the smart ones just refuse to implement correctly. And I *hate* how Ecobee doesn't distinguish between overrides and holding. Hold mode should be a single toggle that makes the thermostat a dumb thermostat any grandparent could figure out **until further notice**. Overrides are one-time deviations from the program which will end at the next program point. Every basic-ass programmable thermostat out there makes those two things distinct and obvious, but Ecobee conflates them and makes it needlessly confusing. But - at least you can do it. Nest doesn't even let you hold a temp for more than 24 hours. At some point I will make a Connextras rant about this because it's so infuriating.

Mark L

Something to consider for that Connextras: these smart thermostats like Nest measure humidity, but do not let us humans set a "feels like" temperature. For example, high humidity makes higher temperatures feel hotter since high humidity slows down evaporative cooling (the main way us humans cool ourselves). Just once I would like them to take Heat Index into account. Appliances like Alexa too when checking the weather. Here in Florida 84 degrees can feel great or terrible depending on the humidity. And wind chill up north skews things. We have the technology. They should use it.

Mark L

He is right. Wind over the roof gives a near constant stream of cold air to pull away heat. If you have good attic access, consider a radiant barrier which is easy to staple to the rafters. It reflects heat in and on the other side, radiates less heat to the roof. Shiny surfaces do not radiate infrared as much, which is one reason a thermos bottle works so well. And radiant barriers are cheap if you install it yourself. Helps with AC as well.

The Great Quux

Thanks everyone. We actually did have a company add extra insulation to both our attic (which had zilch) and between the (unfinished but useful) basement and 1st floor. We even got a new roof with better insulation last year. That all helped, but just touching the plaster walls in winter you can feel how cold it is. So getting better siding and insulation all around the house is what I hope will really bring it down and then I can properly size a heat pump.

OllieShenanigans

My Grandmothers house has 2 furnaces and 2 heat pumps, 2 furnaces downstairs, a heat pump or the upstairs, and a Minisplit in the basement(Which is not original). I don't even know why They needed a single heat pump just for bonus room. I'm pretty sure 2,800 sqft doesn't need 4 HVAC UNITS.(Also this is in Georgia so heating and cooling needs are not as big.)

Crash Cash

Yes, the idiots in Florida do that too. My heatpump is in a small closet, but the output goes straight up into the attic. We use the thick insulated flexible ducting and it doesn't get hot/cold to the touch, but that stuff ages and cracks.

Crash Cash

Oh yeah, and if you want a giggle... the heatpump I just replaced was 7 SEER. Yes.

Benjamin Kier

Ok, after watching the entire 62 minutes long video, I think there's one variable you didn't take into account with your tests, much to my surprise after the amount you talked about town homes. You have two heated walls, and you're assuming that both of your neighbors continue to have their homes next to you heated to the same temp they do now. For all you know there could be a situation in the future where both homes are shut down for the winter and winterized. Sure these spaces would probably remain largely isolated, but you would still have additional losses though those walls that you don't have today. Now I doubt that changes your conclusion that your unit is still considerably oversized (especially since you're 3x oversized you could literally heat both of their homes on top of your own), but it's probably a larger potential source of error than the other 4 you mentioned.

Technology Connections

It's not that I didn't account for that - it's that in the load calculations, you don't count shared walls. Assuming the home is occupied, the largest temp differential across the walls (which are insulated anyway) will be ~20 degrees. That's simply not going to be enough to factor in. While you could add one of the walls into your load calc as an exterior wall, it just doesn't make sense to do so. Even if someone were to entirely shut off their heat, the worst thing that will do is cause the indoor temp to drop slightly which can be countered with the heat strips or a space heater if necessary.

Max M

I live down in Austin and experienced a similar “oversizing” phenomenon when I moved into a new build. A 3.5 ton single stage had been installed when only a 2 ton was needed. Turned out nobody had bothered to produce a manual J. The home had terrible humidity problems (80%+) the first summer I was here as the ac was short cycling. I ended up threatening to take the builder to court and he relented, paid about 12k to swap out the whole system and redo a lot of ductwork the original installer had botched upon closer inspection. I opted for a two stage as well. Anyway, oversizing ac units isn’t just an inconvenience but with humidity issues can be a significant health issue. This is to say nothing of the fact they forgot to include any kind of outside air exchange on a very well sealed spray foam house, so co2 was actually above 1200 throughout the day. Would be fun to get a video where you explore a few more of these issues for us down here in the hot parts.

SignalEleven

As an avid user of home assistant, the setup with a million kill-a-Watt and thermostat switches and data logger felt very manual. I think I could replicate it with hardware I already have in my home. But it's hardly a reason to go all in to home automation (and no, I'm not going to try that at home 😅). This video was fantastic, it's 100% what I love your channel for.

Grosporina

I enjoyed the video, thanks. Though I think the "wow" face you made when showing your furnace closet will haunt my nightmares tonight... worth it for the entertainment.

Mark L

Our home in southern Florida has these. They are insulated (about 3 inches of insulation) so not super horrible, but really fixing would take away a lot of space inside. I did an experiment measuring the air temp going into the ducts in the attic and coming out and the heat difference was about one degree over a 20+ degree temp difference, so overall less than I expected. This improved a lot when I added radiant barrier (which looks like fabric aluminum foil) to attic rafters, since this greatly reduce attic temperatures. For people stuck with homes like mine. I suggest looking up "radiant barrier." It is a cheap, do it yourself project if you are good with a staple gun and do not mind crawling through your attic. And I think you can get credit on your taxes when you do this too.

TJ

Absolutely loved the 'tude. Wish I could click like on the video more. Great job as always.

Jonas

I was missing this in the video. I would have loved the addiitonal 30 mins (or more, yay!) :D

Colin Grimshaw

Maybe a little too niche and deep for viewers outside of the states? I'd stick to topics that are more widely appreciated for all Patreon members around the World.