Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Good morning all,

I am going in for surgery later today. I am hoping to finish the chapter for tonight before I need to leave, but if I don't it could drop late even possibly into the weekend.

I'm sorry that's the case, but the continuous negative reviews and ratings have been taking up a lot of my mental bucket honestly. Around half of them were found to be by people that never read my story so were removed by the mods, which is something at least.

The complaints from legitimate readers mostly centre on one narrative choice I made, and that was to "kill" Daniel. I am considering modifying the author note in chapter 7 to explain why.

It probably won't surprise any of you that I was in the military from chapter 1, while I was in I suffered an injury that left me physically incapable and with chronic pain (which is what my surgeries are about). Daniel's story is a thinly veiled metaphor about how that injury made me feel like I had died, I went from being a military fit, masters educated man in the prime of my life to someone that has limitations on how long I could manage to sit or stand unassisted, feeling like I was being burned alive every moment of the day and night.

Daniel's story should hurt, it should be filled with disappointment and sadness. Sometimes it doesn't matter how hard you try, and that sucks for anyone that experiences it. But Kit is the story of how what is left after tragedy can still be an amazing life. I am certainly glad that my life didn't end fully at my injury, even if everything I used to be effectively did.

This isn't a story I usually share with people, but I honestly can't stop getting a bit upset everytime the point of Daniels death is obviously missed, and honestly the accompanying half a star review tanking my rating doesn't help either.

So should I add something to the author note to give people the context for it?

I made an edit that essentially stitched Daniel's crash straight into the rebirth and couldn't stomach it. Not only because it strips what is a deeply important message to me, but also because without Daniels agency in the build I feel like it turns Kit into a very cookie cutter mc that just got kissed on the dick for no reason.

I look forward to reading your thoughts when I'm on the way to the hospital because I will be using the time between now and then trying to deliver tonight's chapter :)

Comments

Ashley Hilferty

Ignore them all. It’s very well written and reincarnation requires dying first…otherwise it’s just a straight up isekai…

Bratwurstmeister

I think the intro chapters are great as they are, gives Daniel some agency, he chooses to lose almost all his memory’s and decides to basically trust himself to make the right decisions in the future. The negative reviews are sad, but I still see the story on a pretty good rating on rising stars.

Kritzel Kreider

Good luck with your surgery. And I love how you handled Daniel's agency in his rebirth. It sets up his personality so beautifully and makes him unique within the many ISEKAI mcs. And if it has a personal background even better.

Ashley Hilferty

In fact if you want to do anything at all just produce more chapters 🤣 noooo…I’m not obsessed!

Plasmodious

I hope surgery goes well, and story is awesome so far! I personally like how you handled it, he's essentially become ship of theseus, I think it's an important part of the story and you are the writer at the end of the day it's all your personal experience and choices. I like how you've been putting pen to paper.

Corwin

Honestly. Fuck the reviews and comments. I haven't met an author or written a story that didn't have some argue or not agree with everything about it. If anything be happy. Kit is interesting. Daniel was interesting. Survive, adapt, and overcome. If someone is pitching about your choices, two things will happen, they either stop reading or they kept reading. If they kept reading then its not a big deal. If they stopped well you don't have to deal with them anymore. So be happy, write a story you can be happy about. You still have people reading and paying for more. To quote someone I love, "A solider is happy when they can bitch. Its when they are quiet you have a problem." So good luck on the surgery and remember be happy and write the story you want to

Rowsdower

Good Luck with the surgery! That said, 4.67 rating is quite good, and looking at the reviews i only saw 2 bad ones with plenty of others praising the story. While Daniel sacrificing his memories and being forced into the reincarnation is not something that i would normally want in the stories i read, the rest is really well written and emotional, and it wouldn't hit the same without everything that happens with the gods.

Mel S

Not sure that reading the comments on episodic fiction is good for any human author’s mental health. Daniel’s backstory was much more fleshed out and detailed than “truck-kun while trying to save a cat/child” and I certainly did not bump on it.

Dash of Salt

I'm shit at writing reviews, but I just wrote one for Royal Road.

James Gibson

I really liked it as written! I agree with the build agency part entirely.

Frosgods

Story is good, but I can totally see how someone would drop novel over what feels like bit of bait and switch with effectively creating character to change it in few chapters it might worked better with fewer chapter with Daniel or if there is some potential workaround he figured out with goodness, but both would require lot of rewrite, and latter would need eventual payoff. So it might be better to leave things mostly unchanged

Thomasaurus Rex

Hope the surgery goes well. The only part about the opening I didn't like was how it felt like the set up for a lets get back at the gods type story then just took away his memory of the whole thing so he doesn't even know he got screwed over. That aside the reincarnation story itself is pretty awesome and I'm loving it the system, the progression, and the pace. It just you got us all pissed at knowledge and the like then left us with no where to put it. IT would be cool for it to pay off in the future but either way I'm in the pateron cause i like what's happening.

Don Van Huyck

The opening is solid, while it turns some people off you shouldn't write a story tying to appeal to everyone. Lots of people are reading so be confident in what you wrote. Also RulerBoi69 was hilarious, that entire chat room sequence was really great.

Callie

Keep it. It made him feel more like Kit instead of Daniel. Yes they are the same soul but Daniel got the shaft and decided “Nah, fuck this. I am going to metagame the hell out of your game for the next me and you are not ready for what is about to happen”

SkippyARC

I agree it's out of place in the genre and I was not expecting anything good as the idea was introduced. However I think his spite about losing his identity pulled the idea together into something good in hindsight. I remember it feeling like we rushed through his feelings at the time, but he also doesn't have a lot of time to process them because of the situation.

Anonymonous

When you get feedback, you should care about errors, typos, plot holes and the like. What you absolutely shouldn't do is to change basic sorry concepts and ideas because somebody complained. You cannot make everyone happy. That's an occupational hazard of writing for a public audience. And trying to make random people happy is going to alienate others. For example, I didn't leave a review - I normally don't care enough to. I just lurk most of the time, both on RR and Patreon. Specifically about Daniel dying, I'm glad you did this. No, I didn't get exactly what you were going for. The way I read it, Daniel was put in an impossible situation. And he made the absolute most out of it anyway. With minimal fuss and a bit of humor. There was emotion, yes, but he *didn't stew in it*. He compartmentalized and acted. All the way to the end. As a competent and capable professional soldier should. So, no, I didn't feel sadness and disappointment, but I thought that was an excellent intro anyway That's a character I can respect. But it's also a character that's rare on RR, since it tends towards overly emotional YA protagonists. Besides, it told me a lot about the character, which continued into his new life as Kitteren. Kit's reactions to his stressful situations are similar. His mother trained him to have a noble bearing, and that's had a similar effect as in his previous life. Still, not everyone is capable of keeping a cool head through stress. To continue acting. And I thought it was a nice example of "show, don't tell" in showing me how how Daniel and kit are the same person, though separated by the loss of all memories that made Daniel, Daniel. I have issues with other parts of the story, but that intro and Daniel's ending aren't it. IMHO, if you edited that part to try and force me to feel a certain way, it would grate since the Authorial hand would be visible and annoying. If you edited it so that less of Daniel dies, it would cheapen the whole thing. I'm sure other people have different interpretations and come away with different feelings, but that's exactly the point - you cannot satisfy everyone.

Author Azraeil

Thanks mate, I appreciate you taking the time to do that.

Author Azraeil

Thanks, I certainly don't want to write a work around as part of the story is that loss can be permanent but that doesn't mean that what comes after can't be worthwhile experiencing.

Author Azraeil

Yeah, you aren't wrong. I'm just worried that if I leave it and don't respond to people that I am setting it up for failure long term. I'm glad there are so many of you that enjoyed reading Daniel's arc though.

Author Azraeil

Thanks mate, I appreciate the well wishes and you aren't wrong. It is a very small group that actually read the story that are negative and I should definitely focus on that. I'm glad you are enjoying the story :)

Author Azraeil

Thanks mate, I'm glad you enjoyed it and you're right. I should be focusing on the positive, so thank you for reading and enjoying the story.

Author Azraeil

Thank you for the well wishes and for reading mate, I'm glad you are enjoying the story.

Author Azraeil

Thank you for the well wishes and for enjoying the story mate.

Author Azraeil

Well I'm glad you are, seeing how many people are excited for every chapter definitely helps. Thank you for the well wishes, I appreciate it. :)

Author Azraeil

Thanks mate, I'm glad to have you here and enjoying the story despite the start not being something you would usually enjoy. Thank you for the well wishes, I appreciate it mate :) Most of the negative reviews that have been getting me down were personally targeted, and so removed by RR. A group of people decided that the only way I could be releasing a chapter a day without having written books before was if I were actually using AI to write my book. Kind of ignoring the fact that I work on my writing from 6am until after dinner most days to squeeze those chapters out because of how many breaks I have to take. Obviously the fact that RR also has used an AI scanner on my work now thanks to being in the writeathon hasn't helped, so I just have to wait for them to get tired of it I guess.

Author Azraeil

I'm glad that his spiteful streak helped save it for you mate. Thank you for continuing and enjoying the story enough to be here.

Author Azraeil

Thank you for the well wishes mate, and for being here and enjoying the story.

Author Azraeil

Thank you, and it makes me very happy to hear you enjoyed it. My only real regret is that I trimmed one joke when I was trying to tighten the chapters before release. Rulership asks creation how she changed his name and her response was "wouldn't you like to know RulerBoi" It's on my list for possible edits to put back in, I was just worried that it was too much with creation already interacting with love in that first chunk.

Author Azraeil

Thank you, I'm glad that you enjoyed it and are here enjoying the story :)

Author Azraeil

Thank you, I am really glad to see this feedback. I'm glad you are enjoying the story enough to be here mate :)

John Smith

Echoing what other folks are saying, I like how you set up the story and think you shouldn’t change the arc. It does a great job of setting up the “how is this one different” piece for the story

Author Azraeil

Thanks mate, I'm glad you are here enjoying the story.

Frosgods

I don't think any of changes are necessary, just given options of lessening impact of discomfort. They would fundamentally change story and it might be better to lose some readers early as there is no story that can make everyone happy

Alex O

Best to just try and ignore haters and non constructive criticism. Clearly the story is connecting well with some people as people are joining the discord and commenting.

Starkly Glim

Good luck and a speedy recovery!

Muhammad A

Good luck for the surgery. I honestly think that Daniel's "Death" and him choosing the build for the next him is one of the most unique things about this story, and it also justifies why Kit is such a broken charater (i.e. Daniel min/maxed the hell out of the resources he had as a f*** you to knowledge and others. It will also add depth to any future interaction with champions of other gods and will make sure at least us readers know why the champion of knowledge and others may potentially be hostile to him. Definitely do not delete it please.

Sammot

Wouldnt be suprised if its one person just making multiple accounts doing it. Just fuck em, i really like your story and lots of people do too so much that they wanna pay for more chapters! Make the story how you want to!

T3iain

It fit well leave it in

Author Azraeil

Thanks for the well wishes mate, just got out and everything went well. I'm glad you enjoyed it and are here enjoying the story.

Author Azraeil

Thanks mate, I'm glad you are here enjoying the story and I will :)

Author Azraeil

Thanks mate, I'm glad you are here enjoying the story. I will leave it, it's nice seeing so many people liked it even though or even because it is different. :)

Aristeidis Tsialos

Good luck with your surgery, wishing you a speedy recovery. Like everyone else said ignore non-constructive feedback. Any critique that's basically "this isn't how I would have written it" is not worth paying attention to. Regarding the lost memories, I think it might be a knee-jerk reaction precisely because it deviates from the usual tropes. I can't speak for anyone else but having read a good number of these I tend to sleep walk through the introductory chapters. It's usually just going through the motions. Your story forced me to stop and pay attention to the process of reincarnation. It was a bit jarring but in a good way. I wasn't convinced as I was reading it but it ended up working really well and I appreciated once Kit was introduced. Finally I really disagree about the lack of agency. Yes he didn't get his first choice, but he still could have reincarnated with most of his personal memories, he still could have been Daniel. He chose to become Kit and turn a setback into an advantage. That was awesome.

Author Azraeil

Thank you for the well wishes mate, I'm out now and everything went well. I'm glad that doing something different gave an experience that was ultimately good. I'm glad you are here and enjoying the story mate :)