December Prompt (2020): Come Back (Patreon)
Content
Notes: Hey everyone! Here's the next prompt. It's Interference, an alternate scene where Jordan tells Taylor about her feelings while sober, from Taylor's POV. The drunken hotel scene still happens, Jordan just doesn't confess her feelings that night. Happy reading!
January 17
I was standing at the front desk sorting through a mountain of paperwork when the last game on Jordan’s rink finished and she came up to the front desk. But she didn’t just turn in her scoresheet and say goodbye. She stood there until I looked up at her from beneath the brim of my hat.
“So…” she murmured, “did you want to skate tonight?”
I nearly shook my head because I was already going to be up late with all the work I had to do, but I hesitated. We hadn’t spoken or hung out since the tournament... Since she showed up to my room drunk and finally told me why she’d been so depressed lately, and about her family, and her past. There was no telling how much she remembered from that night, and she clearly wasn’t mad at me for leaving her asleep in my bed in the morning if she was asking to skate, but I didn’t know what to say to her. Didn’t know how to bring up all the things she told me if she didn’t remember, or the few words I’d said to her, and I especially didn’t know how to do it without saying more words. More than anything, though, I didn’t want her to think I was avoiding her.
So I glanced down at the paperwork I’d be up all night doing if I took a break, and then smiled at her and nodded.
“Cool,” she sighed, “I’ll see you out there.”
My eyes followed her all the way to the locker room, and then I sorted through what little documents I could as the other game finished and the rinks cleared out. I pulled on my hockey pants and skates while the last few people filed out of the building, and then locked up and met Jordan on the rink.
She was already halfway through shooting a pile of pucks at the net, and when I rolled out, she passed one my way. “If you can hit the crossbar from the bottom of the center circle,” she said, “I’ll let you win tonight.” I huffed a laugh and took the puck to center rink, then stopped to raise an eyebrow in challenge. “Scared?” she teased.
I narrowed my eyes at her and pushed off, skating forward to get some momentum behind my shot as I wound up, and when I reached the edge of the circle, I fired. The puck sailed through the air, the very tip of it striking the crossbar so that a metal ping filled the air.
“Oh,” she said, sucking air through her teeth and then grinning at me, “I forgot to say no slapshots.”
I rolled my eyes, holding back a laugh as she passed me a second puck. I handled it back and forth a couple times before cradling it against my blade, and then took a deep breath and lunged forward to shoot. She didn’t stand a chance, and the puck clanked even more solidly against the crossbar than it did the first time.
“Fine,” she laughed, “I’ll let you win tonight.”
I gave a grateful bow, and as we pushed all but one of the pucks into the net and started our one versus ones, I was glad she seemed back to normal. At least enough so that she was smiling again. She laughed any time I pinned her to the boards, she slapped her blade teasingly against my skates to make me stumble, and she did a victory cheer every time she scored. It was almost like she didn’t remember even coming to my room at all.
But maybe it was all an act, because after half an hour when we both collapsed against the boards to sit for a much-needed break, the tone of our session changed. She didn’t tease me about being out of breath, or about the fact that she was winning because I was still too much in my head about the whole situation to play well. She sat there as silently as I did while she caught her breath, and then sat quietly some more.
What would I do if she brought it up? What if she did and she needed me to answer? To speak? It was one thing to open up to her like that when she was drunk and probably wouldn’t remember, but she wasn’t now. And once I let her in…
“Taylor?” she whispered.
My heart skipped at the hesitation behind her voice, but I swallowed down my nerves and nodded that I was listening.
“About the other night… at the hotel, I-” She stopped and took a deep breath. “I don’t really remember it – I know, big surprise – but, um, I wanted to apologize, and also say thank you.” She slid her gloves off and busily flicked one of the fingers back and forth. “I don’t know exactly what I said or did, but I know that I felt less… I don’t know… hollow the next morning.”
She looked over at me and asked, “I told you what happened, didn’t I?” She swallowed hard and added, “With my brother?” Then she waited until I nodded to sigh and nod too, her gaze falling back to her glove. “I’m sorry for dumping all of that on you, and for keeping you up when you had an early game the next morning.” I shook my head to let her know I wasn’t upset about it, and she gave a small smile. “I don’t have to remember it to know you were good to me.” She shrugged. “But I knew you would be, right? That’s why I went to you… and why I needed you to seeme, even if I was too scared of how I feel to do it sober.”
My heart skipped several beats before it jumpstarted again at a million miles an hour. What was she saying? What was she implying? Because she was implying something, wasn’t she? And now she was waiting for a response, her eyes wide like she was scared of how I’d respond. And I should give her something. A smile, a nod, anythingto let her know that I wasn’t rejecting her.
But I didn’t know how to accept that, not without facing my own greatest fear, and I was terrified. Of the glimpse of hope behind the fear in her eyes. Of the fact that she’d laid herself bare to me and I’d yet to do the same, but doing so would be painful. It’d be risky. Because all she’d done was imply that she had feelings for me, and I was already afraid to lose her. I had been for a while now.
And so I didn’t respond, because I didn’t even know where to start, and I waited too long and she filled the awkward silence with, “Anyway.” She cleared her throat, but the breath she took afterward had a tremor to it. “Thanks for being there for me. I should, uh…” She blinked rapidly to clear the moisture building in her eyes as she shoved her hands back into her gloves and grabbed her stick. “I should go. I’ll see you later.”
She stood and headed for the door without saying anything else, and even though I inhaled to call after her, I was too chickenshit to let it out. I knocked my head back against the boards instead, silently cursing myself for hesitating.
I like you too. How freaking hard was that to say out loud? Not being able to say it didn’t change the fact that I felt it. Or that I was scared of losing her. All it did was hurt her feelings when her life was already hard enough, and in spite of it all, she still had the courage to tell me. And what had I done? I sat there like an idiot and let her leave without saying a damn thing. ‘You’re welcome’ would’ve been better than nothing. At least that would’ve let her know she hadn’t just completely ruined our friendship.
I couldn’t just let her leave. It didn’t matter if my heart was racing so wildly that I felt lightheaded. It didn’t matter if I had to choke on the words in order to get them out. I had to tell her. Before my silence made me lose her anyway, I had to.
I left my gloves and stick on the rink and raced to the locker room. Her stuff wasn’t there, so I dashed through the halls toward the front and flung open the door to try and catch her in the parking lot. Her car was gone, but those were her taillights disappearing up the street.
Shit.
No, that couldn’t be it. I turned and bolted back inside, tearing down the hall to my room where I’d left my cell phone. And I’d never done anything but text her, but I went straight to her contact and hit ‘call.’ It rang once. Twice. My heartbeat hammered away in my ears as I skated back to the door, so nervous and scared that I could throw up. But I wasn’t scared of her answering. I was scared that she’d spend the rest of the night kicking herself when she deserved to know how I felt.
“Taylor?” she answered.
“Come back,” I blurted.
The single stunned second it took for her to ask, “What?” felt like an eternity.
“Please, Jordan,” I begged, staring at her taillights as she waited at the intersection’s red light. “Turn around. Come back.”
The light turned green, and her car sat there for what felt like another lifetime before she finally decided to make a u-turn. I breathed a shaky, nervous breath as I ended the call and tossed my phone from the door to the front desk, and as she pulled up to the curb in front of the building, I skated around to meet her. Her eyes were red as she opened her door and got out, closing it behind her.
“You didn’t have to call me all the way back to turn me down, you know,” she said, reaching up with one hand to wipe at her cheek before she folded her arms across her chest. She sniffled and whispered to herself, “I shouldn’t have said anything. Stupid.”
“Jordan,” I said, and I reached up to cup her face. “I am so sorry I let you walk away.”
Her brow furrowed as fresh moisture brimmed in her eyes, and I thumbed away a single escaped tear before leaning down to set my forehead against hers. And I waited one long moment for her to pull away. While she sniffled again. While her staggered breath fell hot on my lips. While her soggy eyes stared deep into mine like she was afraid to close the distance because she might be misreading this. But she didn’t pull away, and that was all I needed to press my lips to hers and finally kiss her.
And her entire disposition changed. All the air and tension she’d been holding onto deflated as she heaved a sigh of relief and melted into me. Her arms slid around my waist and her body softened into mine. Her lips parted slowly with acceptance and there was nothing I wanted to do more than kiss her even deeper, so I did.
I slid one hand around the back of her neck to thread my fingers through her hair as I opened my mouth to hers. I closed my lips against hers again while the thumb of my other hand caressed her cheek. I cherished the trembling rush of hot air that she breathed against my upper lip as her mouth opened a second time, and I was gone. I wasn’t experiencing anything but the heat of her and the softness of her lips. I wasn’t thinking about anything but the way she felt and how I almost let my fear keep from it.
I could’ve kissed her for hours, and when her lips parted again and her fingers clutched tighter against my back, I already couldn’t tell if we’d just started kissing or if several minutes had gone by. More importantly, I didn’t care. I wasn’t going to be the first to end this, at least not on purpose. But the next time our lips closed together and she tried to pull me closer, it shifted my weight, and I’d completely forgotten that I was wearing my skates.
I rolled forward off balance, flailing to keep from falling and accidentally slamming her backward into her door as our lips broke apart. I managed to catch myself on the car, and she helped by staying as steady on her feet as she could and not letting go of my waist so I didn’t fall straight on my ass.
“Sorry,” she snickered.
My face had to be as red as it felt as I gave an embarrassed laugh and asked, “Are you okay?”
“I’ve been boarded harder than that,” she answered.
I chuckled and nodded, but now that our kiss had ended, I didn’t know what to do. She still had her arms around me, and she was still sandwiched between me and the car, but my hands were on the frame and she was staring straight into my eyes like she had so many questions.
“I like you, Jordan,” I said, “and I should’ve said it right away.”
She gave a pursed-lipped smile as her eyes fell from mine. “I thought everything I told you was too much.”
“No,” I said instantly. “I mean… at first, I think it made me scared for you. Like, what if I hurt you after everything you’ve been through? And I couldn’t bear the thought of that.”
She shrugged, her eyes still locked on her feet. “I trust you,” she said. “And that’s not a small thing for me.”
“I know,” I told her, bringing one of my hands to her face to cup her cheek again. “I don’t take that lightly, and if you knew the way I felt then you’d know that I could never hurt you, not even if it killed me.”
“I feel it too,” she said, finally meeting my eyes, and I pressed my lips to her forehead as her arms tightened around my waist, pulling me into a hug.
“I hesitated because I’m scared of losing you,” I admitted, resting my cheek against the top of her head. “I haven’t talked to anyone but Mitch like this since I was fourteen. Nine years, Jordan.” I inhaled deeply and then sighed. “But not talking to you didn’t change how I felt, and when you left it felt like I was losing you, and it was my own fault.”
She didn’t say anything, but she somehow hugged me even tighter, and it was all the comfort I could have needed. All the assurance I could have ever asked for to know that I didn’t need to be afraid of losing her, and I wasn’t going to be the first to end this hug either. I stood there with my arms wrapped around her shoulders, my cheek laid comfortably against the crown of her head, and my eyes shut as I simply enjoyed the feel of her breathing against me.
It lasted a couple minutes before she took in a deep breath, said, “What now?” and loosened her grip.
I let her go and leaned back enough to look at her. “I’m going to kiss you again,” I told her, “and then I’m going to kick you out because I’m going to be up all night doing paperwork and I won’t get a single thing done if you stay.”
She laughed, lifting her arms to slide them around my neck as she said, “Better make it a good one then.”
I didn’t hesitate to kiss her again, and it was a good one. My hands wrapped around her waist as her arms tightened around my neck, and she kissed me so deeply and openly that it was almost impossible to pull away, especially when everything in me wanted to do the opposite. My fingers dug into her back to draw her closer. My body pushed forward to press her against the door of her car. My tongue teased at the edge of her bottom lip. And once again, I wasn’t going to be the first to end it, and it was only after another minute that she seemed to remember where we were.
She stopped kissing me, her lips brushing against mine as she said, “Okay,” and then pecked me one last time and let me go. “I’m going now.”
“I changed my mind,” I told her. “You should stay.”
She grinned, but stretched upward to kiss me on the cheek. “Goodnight, Taylor.”
“Goodnight,” I said, backing up so she could open her door and get in. “Drive safe.”
She nodded, gave me one last lingering look and smile, and then started her car and drove away. And I stood there beaming until I couldn’t see her taillights anymore, but that smile stayed on my face even as I went back inside and locked up to get back to work. Not that I’d get anything done anyway, because there was no way I’d be able to stop thinking about her now.