Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Um, is there a professor in Nebraska who teaches chemistry based on Harry Potter spells? Sure is. And am I interviewing her tomorrow? SURE AM.

Leave questions for Dr. Rebecca Lai below, fronds. This one will be bananas.

http://chemweb.unl.edu/lai/

Comments

Mikey

Are you a real wizard? Be honest.

Crystal Mendoza

What’s her favorite Harry Potter spell and why?!

Ashra Kolhatkar

**On a scale from 1 to 100, just HOW cruel is transfiguration when it comes to animals? Are they in pain? What happens when you mess up a switch and now your beetle is half button and half beetle?

Sydney Brown

What spell makes the best chemistry?

Madalyn Rogers

How were spells thought up (in theory)? How complex is it to create a spell?

Lauren Wheat

Have you seen improvements in scores since introducing Harry Potter into your teaching? Also, what’s your Hogwarts House?

Chelsea Carl

Does magic defy the law that mass is neither created nor destroyed? Where *DO* vanished objects go?

Ashra Kolhatkar

**What are the (meta)physics of vanishing or summoning spells. Are the things that are vanished sent somewhere? Are the things that are summoned brought from somewhere? Or are they being dissipated into / created out of the atoms around it?

Joe Porfido

What happens if you start a chain of imperious curses that circles back to the originator. Who would be controlling who?

Reuben Clamzo

Is organic potions all about hexes? I'll see myself out.

Ashra Kolhatkar

**How does creating spells work? Based on the names of existing spells (e.g. Lumos / Nox), we know the spells have Latin / Greek roots. Does that mean you could stumble upon a spell accidentally by saying random stuff in Latin or Greek? Or does the incantation have to have some kind of intention behind it, in addition to the correct words, in order to work?

Radha Vakharia

Have you been sorted on Pottermore? What house are you in?

Chris Brewer

Who do you think would win in a wizard fight? Gandalf from Lord of the Rings or Dumbledore?

Michelle Grondine

OH MY GOSH DADWARD ITS LIKE I’VE BEEN TRAINING MY WHOLE LIFE TO ASK QUESTIONS FOR THIS TOPIC

Destiny Rector

I know a lot of spells and their names are based in Latin, are there any based in other languages that are maybe a little less common or are completely made up by Rowling for the books?

Sydney Brown

What elements are needed to make the best spells?

ejvanwonk

Why is it “LeviOsa”, not “LeviosA”? - what if someone has an accent, like if they’re German wizards instead of English wizards?

Aoife Casey

**What Harry Potter subject is the most like chemistry in your opinion (mainly between Potions and Transfiguration) ?

vendretta

What decides the form of someone's patronus?

Jessica Beard

Chem grad student here, so yay chemistry! What reaction makes you feel most like you're in potions class when you run it, and why? (Personally, big fan of anything that requires an acetone/dry ice bath for max boiling potion feel.)

Michelle Grondine

If you could teach any class at Hogwarts, would you teach potions or is there secretly another class you most desire to teach? (a la Prof Snape’s potions vs DADA debate!)

Carrie Weber

Favorite spell? But more importantly, spell you’d use the most?

MacaroniArt

Has the field of study ever changed due to a JK tweet? ALSO UMMMMMM HOLY SHIT is it too late to go back to school to study this??

ejvanwonk

Are there any potions in Harry Potter that would *actually* work, and are potions only useful if made by a wizard, or can a muggle learn and use potions? Are potions even magic??

Jam Cruz

What potions might actually be medically useful for us muggles?

Monica

How is this a thing?! And how do you get started?!?!?

Chris Brewer

How do you include elements that might exist in the Harry Potter world with elements that exist on the Periodic table?

Laura Kinney

I am too excited to think of a coherent question so I am just here to voice my support!

Elle McCall

Second the LevisOa vs LeviosA question

Jen A.

**Is there a real life Love Potion? May I have that pretty pretty please?

Margaret Hammersley

**What is the best lab demo to get people interested in chemistry/science because it looks like magic?

Chris Brewer

What would be considered the “dark arts” of chemistry?

Kyle Wilkinson

Do you start with Harry Potter spells and try and find applicable science or take science and find a place for it in the universe of Harry Potter

Elle McCall

Are any of the spells in Harry Potter completely unique, made up names? And how are you translating spells into chemistry? Are you trying to recreate what the spells do? Or translating elements of the name of the spell into a chemical reaction?

Elle McCall

Do students who haven’t read HP take your class? ⚯͛

Jessica Beard

If you could perform only one spell, what would it be?

Sarah Terry

Are there any other chemistry related things you've studied that have to do with other fantasy things? Such as- LOTR? And Star Wars?

Jessica Beard

What moment in your research felt most like magic?

Elle McCall

In your opinion, should JK Rowling shut the hell up on twitter and just write us more books? Or do you like slightly ever changing cannon as she has been letting things unfold? Do you think that beloved authors from history like J RR Tolkien and CS Lewis would have tweeted about their stories today?

Kyle Wilkinson

The website mentions Fantastic Beasts, so, would it be possible if we wanted to play God (which we don't, of course,) to create fantastic beasts from pre existing creatures.

Sarah Terry

Are there any types of bezoars in real life besides ipecac syrup (i know that's kind of out dated)? I'm talking like an actual stone you can swallow for an antidote for poison. I guess activated charcoal id's kind of close. Do you think that's how JK rowling got her inspiration? Haha :)

Sarah Terry

Are there any types of poison that bezoars do not work on and is there any type of real life poison that activated charcoal doesn't work on?

Sarah Terry

Also, do you have a wizardry periodic table of elements?

Sarah Terry

Are the sparks that come out of a wizards wand noble gases?

Ashra Kolhatkar

**What allows some spells to continue to have an effect after the spell caster dies (e.g. Mad-Eye Moody's protective spells over Grimmauld place after his death), while others stop working immediately after the spell caster dies (e.g. Harry no longer pinned to the wall after Dumbledore dies)?

Sarah Terry

Sorry for all the questions. I love chemistry. And HP.

Michelle Grondine

If you lived in the wizarding world, where would you want to live, & what magical career would you want to have? Would you teach? Be an Auror? Work for the ministry? Research? Alchemist? And what magical pets would you have, if any?

Michelle Grondine

Which magical school would you have gotten your education at? Hogwarts? Beauxbatons? Illvermorny?

Rachel Polivka

have you discussed your theories/methodology/Potterogy with JK Rowling?

Michelle Grondine

Oh I’d also LOVE to know the answer to this question!

MissKitti

Thanks to the good Dr for combining to amazing subjects!

Michelle Grondine

What is the most interesting spell ingredient you have encountered and how hard was it to procure?

Aracely Contreras

Do you think it's possible to create magic in this world like the potterverse? Do you believe in Wicca/witchcraft?

Zak Martellucci

How obsessed were you with Harry Potter as a kid? If not, how did you get into this?!

Kirana Bergstrom

Golpalott's Third Law states that "The antidote for a blended poison will be equal to more than the sum of the antidotes for each of the separate components." How do you actually find the antidotes to poisons, and are there any similarities to the method suggested by Golpalott's law?

Maren Mossman

My question is for Alie - have you read the books yet (in the very little time you have)?

Maren Mossman

Are there any unforgivable curses in chemistry?

Yoonji Kwon

How would you create a love potion in the Muggle world?

Yoonji Kwon

Also, any comments on the safety hazards of potions classes in the HP films?

Sarah Klein

Can any scientific progress/discoveries be credited to HP? And what is the most problematic/frustrating/offensive scientific inaccuracy in the HP universe?

Nicole Larkins

Firstly: WAT UP, FAM??? Huge HP fan here. I have the deathly hallows symbol tattooed on my inner ankle. Do you have any HP tattoos or special memorabilia? Secondly: are there any magical potions in the Harry Potter universe that could conceivably be concocted in our own?

Rachel von Morrigan

Holy guacamole, that page link! Dr. Lai, your brain is pretty amazing. If there’s not a picture of you in black robes mixing “potions,” may I just say: Golden opportunity. Do you use this super awesome special skill for association or is this something much bigger that probably/definitely would have helped me get into science? Do you create your own Potter-esque spells and phrases to teach? Reveal your secrets! PS- Alie, I think you’ve been in my brain with these recent episodes and I’m super okay with that.

Ali Bravo

How much does the consistency of the ingredient really matter in chemistry? Harry is always getting in trouble for not dicing his eye of newt well enough.

Mary M. Matthews

A. How did you get this course approved, and B. When will you have an online version available?

Michelle Grondine

In your opinion, do you believe it would be possible for someone to create something akin to Nicholas Flamel’s endless youth providing Philosopher’s (or Sorcerer’s) Stone in the forseeable future? Do you know if anyone who is currently conducting research in a similar product or potion/alchemical solution?

Maria Ruemenapp

Is phoenix tears or basilisk venom used in any potions? How does the Philosopher's Stone keep Nicolas Flamel alive?

Michelle Grondine

I have three HP tattoos! One of which is the deathly hallows symbol on my inner right wrist! symbol friends!

Christine Thompson

No real question, but this Ravenclaw struggled mightily with chemistry. A class like yours might have done wonders for me. Rock. On.

Brandon Nimon

My wife is a librarian at a public library, she curious if there are resources for Harry Potter-based education she can use with her teenage students. There are so many Harry Potter fans among all age groups!

Claudia Chiang

***What does your syllabus look like? Do students read excerpts from the books or watch scenes from the movies first?... 2. What about the magic in HP seemed so compelling? Are you into other fantasy books/movies?

Rebecca Hall

What is the weirdest Harry Potter potions ingredient that you're like WOAH THIS COULD NOT BE A REAL THING but really it is a real thing?

Rebecca Hall

Do you ever get people taking your classes who haven't read the books or seen the films and just do not get any of your references?

Rebecca Hall

Do you do any cool outreach or public engagement?

Hannah Reilly

What’s your favorite Hogwarts “subject” that’s discussed in the books? Transfiguration, potions, charms, etc. Obviously they don’t go into a lot of detail about what they’re learning in class, with a few exceptions, is this frustrating for you?

Lauren Rosner

Do you know J.K Rowling? Because she should know you. This is amazing..

Kacey Wight

Have muggles invented their own self stirring Cauldrons yet?

Cath

How can I have your job

Bethanie Spuck

Also a Ravenclaw who struggled in chemistry. Struggled really hard. If I wasn't so intimidated by it I would have gone to vet school but I couldn't do it in high school and I barely got by in my veterinary technology B.S. course so I never ended up pursuing applications😔 that being said I believe chemistry is magic and I may be a squib😂

Claire Simpson

1. Do you wear the token robes? 2. Do you consider yourself more of a McGonagall or a Snape (I mean potions fits obviously, but chemistry is all about transformation of substances through reactions). 3. Do you really get paid to be obsessed with Harry Potter and where can I sign up?

Graham Tattersall

What's a spell that seems obvious to you that wasn't included in the books?

Christa Avampato

OMG! Dad Ward, this is as exciting as the ep about dogs! My questions: 1.) Are the spells in Harry Potter based on any type of historical spell book? 2.) What's the best reaction that you've had from someone when you tell them the class that you teach? 3.) Are there other books that you'd like to base classes on? 4.) HOW CAN I TAKE YOUR CLASS IF I DON'T LIVE IN NEBRASKA? Please tell me it's on an online platform, too!

Emmy Bee

How do you navigate the problematic aspects of the series with your class (racism, anti-Semitism, etc)?

AussieColin

I just read a fanfic in which it was assumed that any vanished objects went into another dimensional 'garbage dump', reduced to their component atoms, which were then used as source material when things were created. Which produced a very loud "Ewww!" as students remembered all the nasty things they'd vanished and all the created meals they'd eaten.

Jack

What languages does she tend to draw from in order to create the words?

Nicki D.

First of all- this is AMAZING. Secondly- how did you get this approved by the school!? So many schools were trying to get the series banned because of “witchcraft” bullshit, and you just go ahead and teach an actual class for credit based on the series. You’re a badass.

Janessa

Literally don't know what to ask but my husband wants to know how do you brew liquid luck and how are the imperious curse mind control effects related to the chemicals in our brain?

Jennifer Daley

**1. What are your classes like? 2. What subject do you pull from the most? (Potion, transfiguration, charms, etc. ). 3. What if someone does not understand your references because they've never read or seen HP?

Elizabeth Gonye

First question: Can I come do a sabbatical with you after I do my advancement to candicacy exam in July? I'm not exactly sure yet how to spin Harry Potter and chemistry to apply to the neuroscience of breathing, but I will make it work. Second question: What are some of your favorite potion ingredients that are mentioned in the books? Are the certain ingredients that are mentioned that were thought/are known to cause the desired effects of the potion? This is amazing!!!!!!!!!

Megan Bourassa

**Do you require your students to wear robes? Do you wear robes? Have you noticed an increase in enrolment and engagement in your class since making it Harry Potter themed?

Dave Miller, PhD

oh heeeeeey....will we one day actually be able to aparate?

Laura Schulte-Weich

Have you ever improved upon a spell or potion from the books?

Ruby Oestreich

Has she listened to the podcast Harry Potter and the Sacred Text and what does she think about it if yes?

William Russell

In the Harry Potter series (and a number of current TV shows) magic is described as having great abilities outside what we normally perceive as possible, but reachable to anyone with a certain innate ability - anyone with a gift. It’s taught with established curriculum in formal institutions. That appears very different from how magic was perceived in the past, with line wizards and fortune tellers carefully guarding their mystical skills. One still had to have an ability, but it was much rarer and exclusive. What do you make of the broader reach of magic in stories such as Harry Potter, or TV shows like “The Magicians”?

Anna Elizabeth

1. I am greatly regretting my choice in school at the moment. 2. Which is your favorite book and movie. And why? And is science just muggle magic?

McManasaur

Omg this is soooooool amazing. Do you that using something cultural that a lot of people have interest in such as Harry Potter yields better results in interest in the subject you’re actually teaching? Asking as a former gen chem tutor who struggled to motivate people.

Becca Bee

What. How? Does chemistry lend itself to this "ology" simply because of the Latin J.K. put into the spells? I wish I had something smart to ask, but I'm just so surprised this is a thing. O_o

Jennifer Lewis

First, how freaking awesome! Secondly, my son is defending his undergrad thesis today (12ET) in Chemistry: shout out to RILEY ❤️❤️❤️ and starts his PhD program in the fall at U of Minnesota. Proud much 😬👏🤷🏻‍♀️ ?! Ok, my actual question is: since I homeschool my littles and love to teach in non traditional ways, what resources can I use to blow shit up with my kids? I already subscribe to Mel Science which is a pretty nifty kit out of the UK that goes into more depth than say, making slime and the usual colloidal suspension caca. I’d love a base for more advance chemistry concepts for my middle and high schooler. Can I take a correspondence course? Have you made a horcrux? Ha, cal for questions literally came in last night when we were building the Harry Potter LEGO Castle cuz we’re a house full of nerdoes.

Rachel

**Which spell from the books is the closest to being possible in real life? (Like most tied to the reality of the substance or we have the tech to make real?)

Sarah Terry

Have you written any books on the subject? I'm really interested.

Claire Meyer

Aaaaah! This is amazing; did you have a drop of Felix Felicis with your morning coffee to luck into this interview? Second: Are there actual substances that could mirror the effects of the Imperious curse, for example (mind control!)? Do you find potions have easier correlations to the a̶c̶t̶u̶a̶l̶ Muggle world than wand-work (transfiguration, charms, curses, jinxes)? Third: is your field related to alchemy in any way, as in, are you trying to create a Philosopher's Stone? (Share the gold, please.)

Annika Harrison

What are your favorite Latin-related spells, what are your favorite non-Latin-related spells? Which should be real? :D

Kristen Burgess-Udall

If you could drink polyjuice potion, who would you want to morph into and for how long?

Samantha Panepinto

What magic do you think wizards use for sex stuff? Polyjuice potion? Wizard viagra spells? Transfiguration? Body binds? The potential for wizardy kinks are so vast!

Rebecca Zaunbrecher

Ron comes up with his own spells in Harry Potter. Do you believe using Latin makes them more powerful or is in the rhymes? Are there other languages associated with Magic spells?

Michelle Grondine

What’s a potion she wishes she had around when she was a child?

Samantha Panepinto

What’s the difference between Veritaserum and sodium pentothal?

Daniella Buchanan

I AM SO EXCITED FOR THIS EPISODE ALL MY LOVES ARE COLLIDING. Ahem, sorry for yelling. What’s actually going on with transfiguration? Does an inanimate object that you transfigure (ie: teacup to mouse) actually become alive? Will that object stay in its transfigured form?

Lindsey K Trotter

If you were to make your own wand, what magical item(s) would you use for the core? (Other than the standard dragon heartstrings, unicorn hair, Phoenix feathers)

Christopher Smith

I consider myself a squib, not a muggle. Could you help me harness the magic inside? Please?

Lu Myhill

Neko (9yrs) would like yo know if you’ve ever been injured in a chemical reaction . i.e a spell going wrong like Seamus Finnigans exploding ‘water into rum’ spell.

Lynn Rowicki

what is your favorite potion and house.

Wayne Brantley

It sounds like most Potterverse potions and spells are based on Latin, like much of chemistry and the physical sciences, thus making it universal "language" for people in nations around the world to discuss matters; however, language barriers still exist with regards to pronunciation of words (ex aluminum or yellow). Since we know precision of pronunciation is key to spellwork how might racial and regional differences affect magic?

Wayne Brantley

Similarly, with regards specifically to potion making, just like in chemistry accurate measurement is key or bad things result, are we to assume the wizarding world (including America) is on the metric system or some weird amalgamation of measuring systems? Sure the recipe calls for wing of bat and eye of frog but is that grams, ounces, drams, ort, pennyweight or zolotnik?

Will Plewa

Referencing the Halfblood prince’s notebook where the spell worked better with the thing crushed instead of sliced or whatever- are there situations where techniques are more of a factor than concentration or even ingredients? Ta

Rachael Lehmann

Aww dang. I am greatly disappointed that I didn't see this early enough to beg you, Alie, to come meet me, a fan and future ologist, at my lab. Regardless. Hope your time in the capital was fun.

May Jernigan

Where did Avada Kedavara come from? What is it’s etymology?

Francina Martinez

Do you really think the Malfoys were true Slytherins through and through? Were they borderline Slytherin and another house but chose Slytherin because of family expectations so that's where the sorting hat put them? Thoughts?

Ace Lane

What roll would magnetism play in spells that involve moving objects, such as “Aceo”? Would magnetism play other rolls in spells that move physically?

Ace Lane

There are lots of kinds of fire with special properties in Harry potter such as fiendfyre (seen in the malfoy squad vs potter squad fight in the room of requirement) and gubraithian fire. I know fire burnt from certain chemicals also have powerful and unique properties. Are there any actual crossovers in qualities of magical fires and more “rare” fires in real life?

Ace Lane

if real life humans were to try to simulate spells, what tech would you see being involved? IoT, perhaps? Sense hats?

Ace Lane

Which potions in harry potter universe are based on actual substances? For example, i noticed veritaserum sounds a lot like scopolamine (used in the USA back in the day)

Ace Lane

Which psychoactive spells are easiest to cast in real life, using substances or psychology or what have you? (Eg imperius)

Ace Lane

Also, how do we know if we are posting questions for an interview that hasn't happened yet or if we are posting questions too late?

Ace Lane

What is a chemical reaction, physical phenomenon, or biological process you have seen in nature that you think is worthy of the magic in the harry potter universe?

Ace Lane

What type of magic do you think has the least amount of pliability in our muggle world? The least amount of alternative means to a spell?

priscila V Wilcox

I couldn't stop myself. They were true Slytherin. They only cared about themselves. At some point Draco became grateful. But that didn't stop him from being selfish. TBH, Just like Dumbledore mentioned "sometimes we sort too fast" I doubt Severus was a true Slytherin. He was so brave, and did so much to save Harry due to his love for Lily. I think he was sorted incorrectly, or just goes to show us how a Slytherin can go against their nature. Also, Horace Slughorn is another example that a Slytherin can change.

R Holmes

Which spell has the coolest etymology? I've heard JK Rowling hid many an easter egg in the names! (PS Apologies for my impossible Viking name, I can barely pronounce it myself.)

Katlynn Russo

Do you think witches/wizards could be able to do genome editing with spells? And if so, how do you think that would change the course of evolution for them? Would it cause a speciation event to occur?

Laurence

Easy one : What is your Hogwarts house? :D

Benjamin Harrison

Why is Latin the base root for spells? Wouldn't Sumerian or some other ancient language open additional (and potentially, more powerful) realms for spellcasting?

Michelle Grondine

Wooo we need a Captain Planet esque theme deathly hallows theme song!

Debra Diller

I may have missed the question spot, but can’t wait to hear this! Getting my first tattoo of HP soon! Potions would be my favorite class. Does she call her class “potions 101” I wonder. What does she think too of those chemistry sets that get mailed to you monthly? MEL I think they are called.