Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Oooooh let’s get ready to unpack and heal some stuff, shall we? I’m sitting down with Dr. Nick Barr tomorrow to talk trauma and I cannot wait. Submit a question below! Also here’s his bio:

“Nicholas Barr received his BA in comparative religion at Columbia University, and studied mindfulness practice and Tibetan Buddhist philosophy at the Institute of Buddhist Dialectics in Dharamsala, India. After returning from a Princeton in Asia fellowship in education and capacity building in Laos, he received his MSW at UCLA. He completed his internships at the West Los Angeles VA psychiatric inpatient unit and Harbor UCLA Medical Center’s Adult Outpatient Psychiatry clinic, and has been extensively trained in cognitive behavior therapy, dialectical behavior therapy for borderline personality disorder, and prolonged exposure for post – traumatic stress disorder. He provides evidence based treatments to clients at Harbor UCLA Medical Center, and serves as a co-instructor for the Los Angeles County Department of Mental Health Advances in Cognitive Therapies course for clinicians. He received his PhD in Social Welfare at USC. His research interests include the use of mindfulness based interventions in therapy and dissemination of evidence based practices in community mental health settings.”

(And add a ** before your question if I’ve never asked any of yours before just for fun.)

So excited about this one.

Have mic will travel,

Dadward

Comments

Megan Younce

Why does trauma sometimes take years to surface?

Courtney Myers

What are some long term effects trauma can have on the brain?- also, how do some people get ptsd and some don’t?

Mae

Is there a way to prevent yourself from becoming traumatized by something traumatic before it happens?

Schmitty Thompson

**How does mental/psychological trauma physically affect a person? I've heard a lot about trauma affecting things like weight gain, cardiovascular health, etc.

Maren Mossman

Have you seen an increase in reported trauma since the #metoo movement really started to gain momentum in the last couple years?

Rachel Polivka

can you discuss the mind/body connection with PTSD/trauma?

killerqueen

How often do trauma victims display symptoms of echoism? I just learned about this term and think it’s really fascinating that we just very recently came up with this term.

zane Liebrum

hello, can early childhood trauma cause panic disorder later in life? And can practicing mindfulness and meditation help with it?

Lacie J Scheuer

Is distracting children with games shortly after a traumatic events beneficial or does it delay the mental healing process? ... If it does what kindof games are helpful to help children through the immediate time during\shortly after the traumatic event? (Asking as a bio-nerd paramedic)

killerqueen

Should have added ** woops

Julie K. Rose

I've often heard it said that trauma is held "in the body" but I've never really understood what that meant. Can he explain - is it metaphorical? Physical?

Julie K. Rose

And I'm talking about mental / emotional / spiritual trauma, rather than physical trauma

erica smith

I’m starting a Mindfulness group in the next couple weeks as well as some 1 on 1 therapy...any suggestions for how to get the absolute most out of the therapy? Things I can do on my own time to prepare? Meditations? Cheers!!

Justin

I work as an educator with court adjudicated male youth in a residential treatment facility, many of whom have experienced severe trauma in their lifetime. Do you have any suggestions specifically for working with young men? That you know of, is there any experiential variation between the trauma that white men might face versus the trauma black men may face?

Rachel Polivka

do TRE (tension and trauma release exercises) work? (does embracing our natural response to trauma, shaking, help prevent symptoms down the road?)

Shane Byrne

I've heard that sleep deprivation after a traumatic event can help because it stops the brain recording the traumatic memories as vividly. Any truth to this?

MacKenzie Campbell

**Has science proven a link between auto-immune disorders and trauma? My mother was in a childhood trauma support group with about 30 women and only a few didn't have auto-immune issues. Anecdotally, we've found lots more people who follow this trend but want to know more about if this is just the effect of general stress or if trauma plays a role too

Amy Greenan

** If someone has been through multiple traumatic instances of abuse in the distant past, but won't get professional help to deal with the lasting emotional/mental effects, is there something they can do on their own to help themselves through it? (Asking for a cherished someone who would never ask for themselves.)

Meghan McLean

**Can you talk a little on how animals (pets, therapy animals, looking at a fish tank, etc) can help people who have experienced trauma? How does it help in long/short term?

Mikey

Why is it so SO hard to accept compliments and people just being nice to you after being abused? Why is that trauma the hardest to work through in regards to positive and negative talk?

Julie Noble

**Is there a way to reduce or better prepare for trauma in a situation where you are able to (ex. receiving a cancer diagnosis, witnessing a planned c-section, etc.)?

erica smith

Thoughts on hypnotherapy? EMDR?

Jack

Do you think that there are ever people who successfully “bottle things up”, or does trauma always fester when left unaddressed? Also, does trauma need to be shared with others in order to be adequately addressed, or can people come to terms with their trauma on their own through mindfulness and meditation? I am frequently concerned with whether or not it is inconsiderate to share the stories of the trauma I’ve experienced, as it feels like it might become burdensome to the person I share it with.

Ira Gray

How does exposure therapy work for ptsd? Its hard for me to imagine exposure to a stressor when that stressor is something like rape. How does exposure therapy not retraumatize the patient?

Jasmine Poole

** Can trauma be measured person to person? It seems like what counts as a 'trauma' is so subjective - Some people can experience PTSD from objectively 'small' incidents wheras for others it can be a very obviously traumatic event. Is there a cause for the disparity?

Isabelle B Holper

Trauma or the stress of trauma impacts your memory. That you might actually forget the trauma happened but also will impact your overall memory.

Kelly King

**How can you support someone, such as a friend or family member, dealing with a trauma?

Natasha Bharj

I read that communities that experience racism often show symptoms of PTSD as a result - does that trauma look different to more individual forms? Do you think its something that might end up in the DSM one day? How can we help [other than dismantling white supremacy :) :)]?

Kira Lichtenfeld

How can someone without experience or schooling in this field get involved with helping people suffering from traumatic episodes.

Rachel Polivka

do different kinds of trauma bring about different symptoms?

Kelly King

Also, is it best to acknowledge it or let them bring it up first?

Jasmine Poole

**Does time really help in recovering from a trauma?

Julie Noble

Is there a biological or hereditary connection between a person’s reaction or experience when witnessing/participating in a traumatic event? How do some people experience the same event and react differently?

Alora Fernandez

How does an individual's brain/body determine what it considers a traumatic event? Can the same event happen twice and the first time it's traumatic and the second it's not? Or the other way around?

Jessica Vitarelli

Is there a way to tell what sort of therapy will resonate with a person better, or is it more trial and error?

Phoebe Fraser

As a person who’s had a slow-burn type of trauma for most of my life (a very sick parent since I was 3, I turn 30 next month), am I more likely to be susceptible to health problems that are associated with the stress hormones/chemicals released by traumatic events? I’ve always been pretty good at compartmentalizing the emotions/responses to the most distressing parts of my mum’s illness (probably too good and to my detriment); is that helpful or making it more likely to be festering somewhere deep in below my conscious mind and ready to manifest later as a trauma tumor or something?

Nik Castle

**Clinical trials for using MDMA to treat PTSD are nearing completion. Do you see this or entheogenic/psychedelic substances as potential companions for mindfulness-based approaches to therapy for treatment-resistant patients?

Kelli Brockington

Can incidents - such as lack of praise from a young age or emotional abuse in a relationship - cause PTSD or cause a person to become less empathetic (Ice queen)? Asking for a friend ;)

Laura Merriman

Yay to this topic! I work with refugees many of whom have mental health concerns due to trauma but are often uninterested in getting treatment because of cultural stigma. How do we encourage them to seek help? What strategies can we use to help our clients who may have cognitive symptoms caused by trauma (forgetting things, avoiding certain task)

Corvin

**Is there an average amount of time it takes to recover from trauma or the average amount of time you experienced people need? Thanks for your (often lifesaving) work

Brianna McPherson

How do you feel about people identifying / self diagnosing as “been through trauma”?

Katrina Ternus

**How do different traumas manifest in behaviour? Is there a technique for tracing a behaviour to a trauma?

Jenni Huntly

* I’ve recently started EMDR therapy and am a bit embarrassed to ask how exactly EMDR techniques address trauma and traumatic experiences. I’d love to know more about the theory.

Cher Gallaugher

What are some of the best ways to prevent and treat vicarious trauma, especially for empathic educators and counselors?

CT

I am currently doing research on posttraumatic growth in my graduate studies and was wondering whether you have any opinions or insights on positive psychology's contribution to trauma work? What have you seen anecdotally in your work with respect to growth and positive change post-trauma?

Laura Evans

What are some of the main differences between EMDR Therapy and other forms of therapy like CBT? Is EMDR effective only for certain types of issues? And how do you know what type of therapy will work best for you?

Taboo Science

I'm also doing EMDR therapy and am ALSO a bit embarrassed! From what I've read it seems like it might be BS, scientifically, but I've had some legitimately good results. I'm super interested to know his thoughts on it.

Craig Curry

Hi Alie! I would love for Dr. Barr to talk about the sympathetic nervous system. How does it work in people with PTSD.

Jen A.

**What are some of the best ways to support someone who is considering therapy for the first time? My freshman college roommate confided she's finally considering therapy, 23 years after I first suggested it. I wanted to pump my fist and hug her so tightly. However, I took the tips from the victimology episode, listened emphatically and gave her quiet and humble witness to her pain. Any websites or podcasts that can help me help her? (Don't have time for books but audio editions are good).

Kate Freeman

**Why is it that different states of mind (like consumption of alcohol, or tobacco) or different seasons (summer/fall) affect/trigger PTSD? For example, if a traumatic event happened when a person was intoxicated, why would they be able remember more when they are at that a similar level of intoxication? Or if a trauma happened around a certain time of year, why would a person experience changes in emotions and moods around the same time each year?

Brandon Timm

** As a High school teacher, what are some suggestions for helping students who have had unhealthy mechanisms (cutting, eating disorders) for dealing with trauma find ways to be successful in school?

Emily Losey

Hi! I’m an MSW and work in crisis response/intervention managing a lot of volunteers. So, I’m often managing their vicarious trauma, while focusing on the client, and also remembering that I’m a human who is also affected by vicarious trauma. Most of the time it’s not that hard as I’m a professional, but how do you hold space for the times when it’s not as easy to manage those feelings?

Natalie

** How much overlap is there between the symptoms of trauma and symptoms of other mental illnesses? Could this lead to trauma being missed or misdiagnosed as something else?

Sam F

** Since you have a history with religion, I'm curious as to what you think of people who have come out of religion and feel that they've had some kind of religious trauma. There's an organization called Recovering from Religion. People talk about experiences of shame and guilt, some evolving from LGBTQ issues, some just general life issues, some just disagreeing with doctrine. Do you have thoughts on harm religion may cause on some people's psyche? Even if it may benefit others?

Jenny S

**Is it possible for PTSD to be caused by an emotionally abusive employment situation?

Janna Wisniewski

*How do the symptoms and treatment of trauma differ when an entire society has been traumatized (through war, genocide, disaster, etc.)? What can be done to reduce the generational trauma that is passed on in these societies?

Carla Kennedy

Is there a way to trace the effects of a trauma through multiple generations? Separately, can chronic trauma experienced in childhood lead to narcissism (or other personality disorders) to develop as a defense mechanism in the victim?

Maggie

What kind of neurological changes have been found in children who have experienced trauma versus those who have not?

Sam F

** Also, I have chronic pain. I've had it since I was 12. I'm 26 now. I would probably consider it traumatic. But I'm sure it's a specific type of trauma, correct? Is there a different type of psychological trauma that occurs when something physical happens versus something mental?

Evan Jude

** While counseling is obviously ideal, not everyone has access to affordable healthcare. So aside from therapy, what are some of the most important things a person can do to avoid developing ptsd after a traumatic incident?

Sabrina Furches

** Hi there. As a newly diagnosed BPD patient, I am curious about the stigma surrounding treatment of BPD and what methods have you found the most success with in "treating" this "un-treatable" disorder?

Amanda Rincon

** My best friend has gone through sexually traumatic experiences. Even though I am educated about trauma and psychology, I never know how to help her appropriately when she reaches out for help. How can I help her without trying to be a professional therapist?

Aarika

**I've heard that trauma may be "inheritable" through epigenetics. What is the latest science on this, and how would you treat someone who didn't experience the traumatic event themselves? (PS Alie my name is pronounced like Erica)

Natalie

**Can trauma cause mental illness or can it only exacerbate the symptoms of existing mental illnesses? (I understand that this would be incredibly difficult to prove, either way. Is anyone studying this?)

Jess Perrella

**What made you choose to pursue a PhD in social welfare versus victimology/forensic psych?

Sabrina Furches

** Additionally, how does being a ~TRAUMATOLOGIST~ affect your day to day life/mental health and how do you like to unwind / distance yourself from your work in your personal life? xx

Madelaine Simmons

** Why does PTSD induced psychosis sometimes happen?

Evan Jude

**What are your opinions on the research around epigenetics and generational trauma?

Jess Bauzá de García

**Oh god I have so many questions! In my practice I try to be as trauma-informed as humanly possible! Have you done research around Occupational Therapy’s role (functional approach) in helping those affected by trauma? Do those affected by trauma see better outcomes with a multidisciplinary team or one targeted approach? Do you think taking a trauma-informed approach to training of public servants (public school teachers, police, first responders, etc) would help in reducing additional trauma? How do you feel about those who have been effected by trauma testifying in court? In general, does it help with coping or is it more of a trigger (speaking generally, it will obviously vary from person to person)? Do those who experience vicarious trauma receive treatment similar to those who were the primary targets of the traumatic event?

RocStarr

**Is there a societal or biological predilection towards PTSD, and if so, how do we get rid of it?

Graham Tattersall

** Is it true that playing Tetris following a traumatic event can help lessen the trauma?

MacaroniArt

Was gonna ask something similar, super curious about this too

Kathryn Vlasoff

I've heard of inherited/transgenerational trauma that effects descendants of larger scale traumatic events genetically. How does this work and what are some of the symptoms?

Tammy L Fotinos

**Is it likely that someone could never uncover the base trauma that caused their mental illness? Their brain or subconscious would prevent them digging into that as protection? Is it important to know what is the root cause or more important to get treatment regardless?

Tammy L Fotinos

**Is all trauma BIG? Or can it be small things over time to cause trauma?

Evan Jude

**Does having sensory processing issues like those common in adhd and autism make a person more at risk for developing ptsd?

Brian Langlotz

**2 part question. What are some ways do deal with the trauma of surviving something while know someone has died (War scenario). And 2nd part whats are the best ways to deal with PTSD when it comes to war and seeing things like the results of Ethnic Clensing and other atrocities of war? Okay maybe 3 part. What’s the best way to deal with flash backs induced my common sounds?

ejvanwonk

** Someone I love who lives with CPTSD regularly blows up on people (seemingly for nothing) and blames it on this. While we have tried to be understanding and give them as much support and room for this as possible, many of us are being worn down by repeated abuse from this person, and have oft wondered together, how do we know what behavior is caused by their CPTSD, and what is just them being a jerk?

Ashley

What is the difference between having trauma and simply being affected by distressing life experiences?

Spencer Gillespie

Have you researched/seen research regarding trauma in people who have gotten wanted abortions? Any thoughts/tips on everyday coping when that issue is HIGHLY politicized/misrepresented and argued by loved ones? And I won’t remove myself from advocating for reproductive rights...

Mara Spensieri

What is your opinion on trigger warnings being put on everything? What is the difference between a trigger reaction and just a negative reaction? Should this term not be used for trivial, every day things, or am I just insensitive?

Paul D Simmons

**Are there any evidence-based, reliable approaches to preparing, for example, soldiers or police officers for the inevitable trauma they will face, providing them tools to cope ahead of the trauma?

jbcard

** Do service dogs truly make a difference in helping someone with PTSD, especially those in the military.

Miumiu and Bowie

**Hi! I live with C-PTSD and structural dissociation / fragmented self, how do I explain it to people in simple terms and also EMDR causes me to dissociate, are there other things, maybe less traditional I could try? (Am in therapy with an awesome therapist)

Heather Densmore

How are children impacted by death of a parent? Does the age of the child make a difference?

Evan Jude

Why isn’t c-ptsd (complex ptsd) recognized in the DSM?

Angelica Urquizo

**What are your thoughts/research on people who abuse others because they were abused? Do you think people should be more understanding because they too dealt with trauma or do you feel like there's just no excuse period?

Miquela Mangum

**Would you explain the differences between PTSD, STSD (secondary traumatic stress), and compassion fatigue as they relate to emergency service workers? My husband is a firefighter/EMT of 13 years, and my wish is that more people really understood the differences and how each can affect the individual and their immediate families. Thanks!!

Brittany Kaufman

** Can you talk a little bit about ICU-induced PTSD? Is it a real thing that therapists look out for?

Brittany Kaufman

Also, are there any good PTSD resources out there for non-veterans?

Karina V. Rodriguez-Gonzalez

** Religious Abuse, what are your thoughts? Religious abuse is abuse administered under the guise of religion, including harassment or humiliation, which may result in psychological trauma. Religious abuse may also include misuse of religion for selfish, secular, or ideological ends such as the abuse of a clerical position.

Sara Amish

What do you think about the crazy ex girldfriemd series? Accurate? Not?

Maddie

**Lsd/other hallucinogen is to treat ptsd… how why and does it actually work? Also VR therapy. Also I see a lot of research in the media for alternative treatments for PTSD but it is almost always in the setting of veterans. Like the VR. Would that even be helpful for a sexual trauma victim?

McManasaur

What’s with suppressing traumatic memories and why can they just suddenly come flooding back to you at a totally unrelated time?

Chelsey Kraft

**Do you think that religious abuse is real? If so, what kind of resources are available for those who have been impacted?

Euan Munro

Also interested in LSD for PTSD treatment, as it seemed like such an out there treatment at first but seems to generally be pretty helpful.

Lacy Gilbert

Do you have any suggestions for individuals experiencing trauma, but do not have the funds available to pay to go to a therapist? Also, I often feel silly for saying that my family "traumatised" me, but after years of emotional and mental abuse, I have horrible anxiety and I cry ALL the time about almost ANYTHING. My therapist also feels as though my childhood has contributed significantly to this issue. Is it insensitive to victims of severe traumatic experiences (like sexual or physical abuse) for me to say or feel like I have been traumatized by my family?

Kelly Henderson

**I do pro bono legal work (like asylum and immigration for unaccompanied minors at the border), and often the clients have experienced trauma. I treat them as sensitively as I can but still have to ask pretty detailed questions so I can make the strongest case on their behalf (and prepare them for skeptical questions from the government).. I always explain that and apologize beforehand. Does that help, or do you have any other suggestions on how to handle this more delicately? Thanks!!

Sasha KD

I am currently going through the process of adopting a child through Project Wait No Longer, for kids who are above 8 years old. What are some of your thoughts about creating safe spaces in the life of a child who has gone through trauma? I will of course work with therapists but any advice about day to day would be wonderful . Thank you!

Twilight Retold

**Can undergoing something very traumatic make dealing with future traumas easier? Is this affected by the age you are during the first trauma? Or perhaps affected by the type of trauma? (My personal example would be that my mother died a year ago --- I am 23 --- and I'm wondering if, even as I'm processing this trauma, will I "relapse" in any way if something else traumatic happens?

Lacy Gilbert

Also, do you have any suggestions/reccomendations on how to deal with or interact with family members who have caused trauma? As well as the mixed emotions that come along with that?

Charity

My spouse is 43 and had a stroke 2yrs ago (artery dissection); he deals with the after-effect of the stroke, but there aren't any physical markers for doctors so we hear PTSD thrown around a lot. Why does this seem to be a default for people when (from our side) they don't want to dig deeper into health issues??

Todd McLaren

I’ve heard that certain games, particularly Tetris, distract the mind after a trauma, and can make a big difference in recovery. Is there truth to this and how much difference can it make?

Rachel von Morrigan

Yoga and meditation have helped tremendously, EXCEPT when it’s time to go to bed. I try to tune into my breath and practice mindful meditation to calm down, but it’s really difficult. I don’t understand it. Is there something about bedtime or sleeping that’s a weird trigger or that you’re more vulnerable?

Julie MW

** I found out a couple years ago that a "friend" of my dads (who is now dead) sexually assaulted me when I was 2-4 yrs old. I have no recollection of this happening. When I was 18 (Im now 38) I was raped by a co-worker and when it was happening I froze up, I literally couldn't speak, couldn't move, couldn't do anything even though my mind was racing with all the things I could/should do. Ive had a hard time even using the term "rape" because of my inability to do anything at that moment. Ive seen countless therapists/psychiatrists over the years and have been on 33 different medications for PTSD, Major Depression, eventually diagnosed with Persistent Depressive Disorder (Dysthymia) as well as anxiety. Nothing has helped and a GeneSight test proved very few medications will even work for me, that Im basically medication resistant. Is it possible that even though I have no real memory of being assaulted when I was younger that it still affected me and may have even caused me to "freeze up" in the other occurrence? Is it possible that these traumatic experiences (remembered or not) (and along with other circumstances) could have contributed to 25+yrs of depression/anxiety?

Aleks

** how should trauma be approached in relation to patients (specifically those with traits typically gendered female) with autism spectrum disorder? every time i have raised the issues of my childhood trauma with any therapist, they have only triggered me more when trying to approach it with "normal" therapy methods and as an autistic person with mental health as a special interest, i am curious if you know why this could be.

Helen Bobiwash

** I'm an Indigenous person. People talk about inter-generational trauma experienced by Indigenous people. What causes trauma to be inter-generational?

Rebecca Wancelotti

**What can family members do to help people who've experienced trauma. My sister was in the building that got shot up in the Marjory Stoneman Douglas shooting. Her classroom was untouched, but I can't imagine what she heard or saw in the halls when the police got her out. She also lost a friend. I'm afraid she's trying too hard to distance herself from it and avoiding feeling anything about it.

Jennifer West

**Several bodywork practitioners have told me that trauma can be "remembered" in parts of our bodies and that modalities like massage can help release the trauma. Is this flim-flam?

J

YES. THIS.

Kate Freeman

Why and how does a human brain “black out”? What is happening neurologically during that time? What is the brain doing?! 🧠 and how does that protect humans from PTSD ?

Michelle Minert

In graduate school, I learned that EMDR works but no one really knows why. A professor described it as “magic” when we asked (he was joking). Any word on why Francis Shapiro’s treatment technique is effective?

J

**Can you speak about the different ways that trauma manifests in different people? (Dissociation, ADHD, OCD, eating disorders, etc)

Linda Cobbe

** Do you think there can be a genetic change in people's DNA after severe trauma and that it may continue in future generations?

Ruth Anthony Vernotico

What connections exist, if any, to a persons emotional well being and how quickly trauma heals or doesn't heal? Can someone will themselves to heal?! Or... phlim phlam phlegm?

J

How do you feel about the new college board SAT “adversity score?” I’m in college admissions and do a lot of equity work, but I also have a big personal and research history in trauma. How do we relay to them that adversity isn’t just zip code and wealth? It’s about trauma and adverse childhood experiences.

J

Separate note: Alie, you have no idea how long I’ve dreamed that you would interview someone in trauma!!!!!! THANK YOU.

Mandii Smith

** My boyfriend has night terrors because of a childhood trauma. What can he do to stop or at least lessen how often these happen?

Katie Pinette

**One of my best friends has recently been reliving some childhood trauma. Thankfully, he has gotten help, but before he did, he would start down these thought spirals and start telling the same stories over and over again. (I almost reached out to the Ologies group to ask for this advice about this before he got help.) I've also dealt with anxiety and depression (on a much less severe level) and have experienced that downward thought spiral myself and have a super hard time stopping it. Any good ways to intervene and stop someone else's or your own downward thought spiral so they don't relive the situation again and again?

Creme de la cremily

**Can people's brains completely block out memories of traumatic situations (like sexual or physical abuse) to the point where they have no clue that it ever took place?

Lisa Allard

**when people say it is all in your head I believe they are speaking the truth. How do we match the person with the method that would best help them to get it “out of their head?”

Sean Manson

**false memories: where do they come from and how can we distinguish them from events that actually happened?

Becca Bee

The loss of a shitty 17 year relationship left me with PTSD (and anxiety meds and a psychiatrist!)... 5 years out and I feel better, but I'm still triggered by the past traumas occasionally. It's screwing with my current relationship. Will it eventually go away, or is this a forever thing?

Micah Eckard

Why do we sometimes not realize, until much later, that we've had a traumatizing event?

Carla Hickenlooper

It feels as though our society as a whole is living in a constant state of trauma and fear. What can we do to heal on a societal level to prevent the cycle of hurting/killing others on mass levels because of our unhealed traumas?

Amanda Lotz

**How does someone retain the memories of a traumatic event, in order to try to prevent it happening again, but not let them be haunted by them forever? I have trouble not re-living minor embarrassments that happened 20 years ago again and again let alone the traumas I have endured.

erica smith

I’m trying to start EMDR!! I’d love to chat about y’alls experiences...maybe find me in the FB group?

Jayna Densmore

** Since losing my dad at age 5, I’ve felt almost desensitized to and comfortable with death. Is this a normal reaction to being exposed to grief so early on? How does trauma affect children opposed to adults?

Lord Fool

I have a similar question to Amanda above - involving memories. My trauma was all kind of added on top of one another with few instance of Big Traumas(tm). So my memories of trauma are fuzzy and when my PTSD is triggered I don't get flashbacks, per se. Is this normal to have a lack of memory of trauma? Does your brain actively lock these away?

Lord Fool

I'm in a similar boat. I'm in a much healthier relationship, and my partner understands. They say time heals all wounds but that's a really long time - it may go away, it may not, and I hope this ologist can help bring you an answer and some comfort.

Emily

**Katie, it's like you're in my head. I have the same question but for my sister who has BPD. I want to know the best way to help when they are having a spirally sort of day/week.

Cody Albert

A lot of people right now are saying they have PTSD or are triggered by things, but how do we know if this is really accurate? There’s a sense nowadays that we have to respect everyone’s boundaries (reasonable) and it can go so far as to coddle people (not very reasonable) but where do we draw the line between an actual trauma or trigger and a perceived trauma a or trigger?

Brianna Lites

**Most people I know don’t remember anything before kindergarten, but I’ve got accurate memories from as young as 3 (I’m 25 now). My psychology professor attributed it to a traumatic event in my early childhood; mom and I were hit by a car crossing the street when I was 2. His theory was that the trauma jump started my long term memory development. Sort of like a, “Hey! This was terrible! Remember this forever so we can avoid it,” from my brain. Could he be right? Or is it straight flim flam?

Emily Bergman

**My husband used to be a paramedic, and I always wondered about the impact some of the more serious calls could have on first responders. Have you ever worked with first responders, and is there PTSD within those professions that isn’t recognized because it’s not commonly acknowledged?

Melina Filomia

**I want to ask about multi generational effects of trauma, but I don’t know how to phrase it.

Addie Markham

**What is the best way to end the stigma around mental health, and encourage people who need help to seek it without feeling ashamed?

Emily Hoban

What is the best book on trauma for beginners on the topic

Hypnophile

** I am a recent grad working the Marine Biology/Ecology field, and I struggle daily with the enormity of the threat of climate change. The fact that I want to start a family in the future makes this even more distressing and definitely causes me some anxiety. What sort of protective actions/habits do you recommend to help counter the effects of secondary trauma-related to climate change and it's effects on my own and my future children's generations?

SADIE DURNING

**Is it possible to have trauma about things we don't remember? Or is it more likely that those reactions are from events in my life that I may not realize is traumatic? Also, how can we heal trauma we don't remember?

Rayna Marshall

**I'd love to hear his thoughts on the use of attachment-based family interventions with parents/caregivers and young children to break intergenerational cycles of abuse and trauma. Thanks!

SADIE DURNING

I'm glad to hear that i'm not the only one. My mom died at 12 and I have a similar reaction to people dying.

Duran Drea

** I'm wondering about how emotional trauma manifests in the body. I have a friend who gives trauma informed massage and I've heard times when a tight area gets worked on and released, there's an emotional release as well. Is there any science or study in this? area?

Jessica Chance

**Does Tibetan Buddhism speak to dealing with trauma specifically? How do his experiences in India inform his work with his patients today, and are there any situations where his philosophical/religious training and his psychiatry/CBT training are in tension with one another?

Ashley Herbel

** I’ve had severe anxiety about losing close family members after I experienced a traumatic incident when I was 14, I have worked through different types of therapies but a recurring technique by practitioners is to “ask if what you are anxious about will matter 5 days from now, 5 months from now, 5 years from now”. I understand the idea behind this technique but if your fear is about death then “yes” is the answer to all those questions. Do you have a better way to combat the negative thoughts?

theREALtortoise

**Are there cross-cultural differences in the understanding and expression of trauma? If so, what are they?

Elon Sloan

How can trauma be better addressed in classrooms and in education generally?

Paige Moreth

**What's the deal with trauma anniversaries?

Alina Pritchett

Is there any evidence of how dissociative disorders develop? Anything similar between people who have this coping mechanism for trauma or is it random? I dissociate during stressful situations and I didn’t know this about myself until adulthood. Is it possible disorders like these are more common than people realize? Are children of people with PTSD more likely to develop psychiatric disorders?

Savannah's Scent Library

**Would it be beneficial for patients with a history of trauma who are currently experiencing a mental health crisis to practice mindfulness meditation?

Makenzie Castillo

Do you think PDTR is a legitimate way to treat trauma? Beyond just whether or not it works for some people, I’d like to know if it is considered legitimate by mental health professionals.

Andrew G

**In practicing mindfulness what are the major do’s and don’t of it?

Aurum Douglas

**What is the strangest/most interesting manifestation of someone's mental state that you have come across?

Sarah Patten

Is there anything you would do different for a patient who has suffered a traumatic brain injury (TBI)? Has there been any research on how an injury to the brain affects how it processes or handles trauma?

Nicole Graham

**What are some explanations as to why some people develop PTSD after traumatic events and other's do not?

Nicole Smith

***How does social constructs such as race, gender and socioeconomic statues play unto how we deal with trauma?

Christopher Rougeux

** Facing your fears. Does this mentality work for trauma? Can talking to someone about a traumatic childhood help you change negative impacts it has had on your personality?

Ellen Golding

** inherited trauma/ PTSD ???? Does it really exist and how does it work?

Angie H

How does using trauma informed care benefit the person who has experienced trauma? What are the benefits for the clinician providing care?

Angie H

Is virtual reality being used in the treatment of PTSD?

Cristy Vega

**How can we help others understand that is not their fault if they unintentionally cause or trigger another's ptsd? Also, is there any way that your partner can help or know what to do once you've been triggered when the trauma was caused by a previous relationship.

Cassy Flint

How much do you tailor treatments to individuals or is there a one-size-fits-most?

Abigail Campbell

Is it possible for your brain to actually forget, suppress super traumatic events as a defensive mechanism? If so, is that restrictive to kids only or young adults as well?

Jason Krobatsch

**How/why can an event be traumatic for some people, but not for others (e.g. car accident)? Are some people more prone to trauma?

Luana Pomponet

How to talk (or not to talk) to someone who went through a traumatic experience? What can we say to be helpful?

Blank

** How do you evaluate the evidence around mindfulness treatments when it seems like such a "stretchy" idea? I would guess there are about pi*abillion different mindfulness strategies, some of them overlapping, and you still want to compare against placebo, you still want to think about lurking variables ... It sounds like a statistician's nightmare trying to suss out what, if anything, the evidence is saying.

Charlotte

** How much do we know now about inherited trauma? I know there's some research about descendants of Holocaust victims, but what about other things? e.g., can you inherit guilt from ex-Catholic parents? (Might call for some speculation)

Alicja Muir

** How do "side-effect" mental health disorders like OCD (particularly dermatillomania and trichotillomania) arise from traumatic events? Is it the mind's way of trying to be in total control?

Katie Pepera

** Do you think esoteric modalities will become increasingly popular as we learn more about healing trauma? Can various modalities (EMDR, Reiki, CBT, mindfulness exercises) be used to treat something like PTSD all at once and by different practitioners? Do we need to pick a practice and a guide and stick to them or can we diversify our healing path?

Hannah Sheppard

**Traumatic incidents don’t affect everyone the same way. What are people who don’t develop mental illness as a result doing? Is there something that might predict who will be truly traumatized?

Kayla Marie Figard

***as someone who suffered significant trauma when I was a child, I have had to deal with this even into my adulthood. I’m much better than I was in my late teens and early 20s but even though I recognize where my panic attacks or flashes of memories or my behaviors are coming from and I can logically think about that, I can’t stop these behaviors or change the bad thoughts that follow. Can you explain what is happening in people’s brains when they experience and deal with trauma in their adulthood?

Bee Davis

** what are your thoughts on EMDR for the treatment of PTSD, particularly in first responders? How is it supposed to work? Is there any proof that it works?

Heather Sewcyck

**how can a person express to family that even though I was never hit physically that emotional abuse has a true impact? Also, how in the hell am I supposed to date after 10 years of that abuse??

Katie Pinette

Unfortunately, it seems like a very common thing with mental illnesses. Let's hope there's some advice out there for us!

Debra Diller

** my mom was held hostage 25 years ago and tells me even after so much counseling that every year around that time she gets depressed and has PTSD symptoms all over again. Is there any new things she can do to work though this? She is in a real funk for a few weeks every year. Thanks for your help!

Emily Anne Fix

**Addressing trauma openly: Advice on how to deal with my family's "It wasn't that bad" or "Don't talk about your Mom/Dad that way!" if I summon the courage to talk about my trauma at all in a possibly public way? Tired of hiding /fibbing about my past to everyone just to save my family's feelings.

Emily Anne Fix

**Also, how to deal with people who treat you weirdly when you reveal something traumatic happened to you? Like, my parents are dead and have been since I was a teenager...and sometimes it becomes unavoidable to clarify that in certain conversations. Then, that person acts like I revealed something too horrible for them to hear (like, I really tried to get out of this conversation about Mother's Day, Karen...but you kept asking me what gift I got for my mom? Sigh). Sorry, my questions are so personal and so long, lol.

Maria McSharry

** It seems like some traumas are easily recognized and others are more difficult to spot. How is trauma defined and how do we determine whether a given experience is a trauma? How can we better support and recognize people whose trauma is a result of lower-level incidents across time (in contrast to those whose traumatic experiences were more explosive/more easily identified)?

Becca Bee

Yes! Jane McGonagall said this in the gaming episode! I was so excited I downloaded tetris right away.

Suzanne K

** as someone with cptsd ..why is ptsd so hard to diagnose and find appropriate therapy for? none of the therapists i went to, treated me for ptsd, instead i figured it out and had it confirmed by a therapist (my 5th therapist) which was all too frustrating and painful in itself..i haven't gone to a therapist since.. but i did find other ways to heal.. somatic healing .. thank goodness for the internet.. also have tried emdr by therapist not trained in trauma (realized later) .. therapists seem to do more harm when not trained in trauma.. wtf? sorry if that was too much..

Rachel McMullen

**question from a fellow trauma professional here (MSW, TCTSY-F): Our field is moving deeper into the realm of understanding and utilizing the mind-body connection for treating complex trauma with somatic modalities, i.e. yoga, somatic experiencing therapy, TRE and other polyvagal based work, etc. I work primarily with adult survivors of violence and abuse, though through that work naturally come into contact with many children and teens who are impacted by their parents/guardians' situations. What are your thoughts on utilizing somatic-based therapies to address stored trauma in younger folks who are still in a rapid growth period? Thanks so much!

Rachel McMullen

Good news! Lots of evidence exists for the benefits of EMDR. Glad to provide resources if you like!

Rachel McMullen

You may be interested to look up (TRE) tension/trauma release exercises and somatic experiencing therapy, there's a wealth of research on somatic based modalities :)

josh borlase

Ask about psychedelic assisted psychotherapy

Rachel McMullen

Good news, it's not film flam :) I recommend pulling up work by Dr's/researchers Peter Levine, Bessel van der Kolk, Bruce Perry, Daniel Goleman, and Judith Herman. ~ fellow mental health worker/researcher

Cora Cobblestone

I was recently diagnosed with PTSD and was referred for EMDR therapy. My therapist had trouble explaining what it is and how it works. I know it probably isn’t a kind of electronic dance music, but could you talk about what it is?

James Irvine

Newb patron here...so here goes... ** Not to get all epistemological on ya'll, but with the complexity of psychological studies in general and the added complication of it being a skosh unethical to run a controlled experiment on trauma, what kind of empirical data are you collecting to create evidence based practices? Meditation/mindfulness practices would have another set of challenges. TL;DR version - How you know what you know?

James Irvine

** Has there ever been any studies looking at the epigentic effects of trauma? If so, what kind of trauma is more likely to cause it? Could there be an epigentic effect of a more acute trauma? And a bonus Q for Alie - How you going to keep this one upbeat, sister?

Inked Sakura

**What is the efficacy of remote EMDR for CPTSD with certified therapists? Are there any recent peer-reviewed studies on this topic? Thank you for your time

Stephanie Shirley

Gosh. I know I'm late to the game but i did want to ask, what does he think of generational trauma? I.e. the genocide committed on Indiginous peoples around the world