Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

About to record with a constitutional law professor so toss some questions you'd like answered! She's an incredible badass whose professor was... Obama. I know very little about law but NOT FOR LONG, KIDDOS. 

Comments

Andrew G

How long does it take to amend the constitution from start to finish? On average? Thanks, love ologies to death 😁

Lindsey K Trotter

Did the founding fathers purposely leave any loopholes in the constitution, and if so what are some examples?

Andria Marsh

How many times has trump actually violated the constitution? What does this actually mean to violate it?

Adrian Belmontez

Why is it so easy for the Constitution to be left to interpretation. It’s never black and white

Charlotte Milling

Can you please explain why the authorization and appropriation process are decoupled (both require congressional action in both the House and Senate) and whether that is still necessary today?

Chelsea

Can you use executive privilege to just withhold evidence? (Is executive privilege part of the constitution?)

Anna Flaherty

So excited! How difficult is it in practice to change/adapt the constitution? Has that difficulty changed since it’s beginnings?

Joe Porfido

Do we need to start over? Maybe we need a fresh modern translation of the constitution

Kacey Wight

Do they really have the original on display at the national archives?

Anna Thompson

What is the biggest flim flam about the Constitution out there in popular culture?

Malcolm Guidry

Is there anything in the Constitution from preventing a former 2-term president (say... Obama) from running for president again a few years after he or she leaves office? Or are they strictly limited to one 2-year term?

Mike Melchior

Do you feel the First Amendment to the US Constitution is under threat?

Anna Thompson

What are various schools of through on interpreting the Constitution. I think one is called literalism or something along those lines?

Jason Goodwin

What can we do about ending the slavery that is allowed by the Bill of Rights? Prisoners are currently trying to unionize and fight for fair wages, but I believe ending the slavery at the constitutional level is the only fair way to end the injustice

David McWilliams

Does anyone really know what the emoluments clause actually means and how it is triggered?

Haley Yerxa

What was the original purpose of the second amendment and is it cited incorrectly in today's society?

Carla Kennedy

So many people worry about a writers’ meaning and intent. Wouldn’t Jefferson and Madison be more worried about there being the flexibility to do what is needed and relevant now and not just what would have been right in their day? How much would the founders want us looking back to them?

Meredith

Okay - what is the deal with the right to bear arms and how does the part about 'an organized militia' come into play?

Brian Chappell

How can we, the constituents, interpret the constitution, conforming it to today’s day in age?

Olaf Doschke

Last week tonight was about impeachment pros and cons. If you've seen the episode: Do you agree with the points made? What's your point of view?

Courtney Jones

What is the most misunderstood amendment?

Aliza B

Why do we continue to base our government off the constitution? Times have changed, shouldn't the way we approach governing humans change as well?

Lauren Zino

Have you seen Hamilton, or are you familiar with the music? Do you feel that there’s been a rise in interest in law and the Constitution since the show came out?

Tino H. A. Bratbo

How closely are we actually following the Constitution in modern times and, perhaps more importantly given how much has changed, should we be following it closely?

Aliza B

Also is there a part of the constitution that takes into account indigenous people?

Meredith Loy

Is there a *right* way to interpret what its authors meant? Obviously this changes over time, but how do we prevent people from using the authors words for evil?!

Anna Thompson

*shyly raises hand* That's on the Declaration of Independence not the Constitution. I don't know what the actual reason is but the story goes Hancock wanted "King George to see it all the way from England"

Paul Ohainle

Science crossover- In interpreting the Constitution, what does she think about the Supreme;s use of "penumbra"?

Lea Schilke

What are the chances of changing the way that the Electoral College works and how Supreme Court Justices are chosen? These are reasonably charged issued with these processes. How does the Constitution protect or allow changes?

Anna Thompson

Why did we all have to memorize the pramble in elementary school? What purpose does the preamble serve in general?

Crystal Pisano

Is the constitution still serving the purpose it was intended to serve? And what types of changes could be made to it to make it a more helpful document in modern society?

Danielle Loth

Constitutional interpretation seems very fraught & tricky. Each side (originalist, non) seems very convinced their way is the right way to interpret the document. In your opinion, how do we interpret the document to keep in line with it's main themes and goals? OR is it really better to not feel too beholden to what a bunch of white dudes thought was important at the time?

Rachel Polivka

what way do you, the ologiest, interpret the Constitution (originalist, textualist, original intent, etc)?

Renee Coley

Why didn’t The Framers set up the House of Reps so that Reps had to live in the district that elected them?

Julie Noble

(follow up question) Or to prevent them from serving as a Vice President?

Aarika

**Oh heck, this is so interesting and I don't know where to start. What influenced the US Constitution? What other constitutions have been influenced by the US constitution? Are there objective measures of what makes constitutions "better" or more ethical, less likely to be exploited? Is it better to have a more simple document or more complex one?

Maria Kumro

We've changed drastically in the over 200 years since the Constitution was written. Why is the idea of making changes to it that would make more sense to our world now so horrifying to people?

Anna Thompson

Yup! At least when I interned at the National Archives ages ago. We had a whole part of our training dispelling myths from the National Treasure movie!

Alex G

**Is there a process of changing the Constitution to reflect the more modern aspects of our society today? Also, what was Obama like as a professor?

Brian Madsen

I'm sure I won't be the only one to ask, but: please cover fact and fiction and urban legends about the need for an electoral college, both then and now. Back then, what did they see as the pros and cons? (I've read commentary, but I'm not sure how historically accurate those are. I suspect that at least some of the commentary I've read is really modern and ahistorical wishful thinking that's been superimposed on the Founders against their will.) Meanwhile, in this day and age, isn't it better to count the popular vote and do away with the EC? I can imagine that counting the popular vote might have been challenging in 1787, but we have better tools for that now.

Renee Coley

Why don’t people invoke Article 6, Section 3 when debating separation of Church and State (Specifically the religious qualification clause)?

Deanne

The second amendment says a well regulated militia. What does that mean?

Maria Kumro

The leaving out of the "well regulated militia" every time people complain about their gun rights makes me crazy! The point is you get guns to form a well regulated militia, in case the government needs you to take up arms against an invading power. It's basically a citizen military to protect the country, not the right to have as many guns as you want with no regulations on them.

James Irvine

Are there any passages actually in the US Constitution that gives any hint at how the authors actually intended it to be interpreted?

Jen A.

What was the paper like that the US Constitution was written on? Made from? Made by?

Jen A.

They do!

Dave Miller, PhD

Have certain parts been hijacked by special interest groups, and if so, how do we recover from that?

WiGeekMom

And a follow up, why is it the second amendment?🤣

Ducksfloat

why is it so hard to pass the fuckin equal rights amendment

James Irvine

Could congress enact any laws that would impact the precedent set by the Marbury v. Madison?

Robin Kuehn

How does the age of our constitution compare to other countries, and when does writing a new one make more sense than trying to amend the old one?

Ira Gray

If the ERA gets ratified by one more state will the deadline keep it from being added as an amendment?

Carolina

As a non-US, can you explain what it is? Is it laws? Do you have to follow them or something bad happens? Can you explain to me like I'm five?

Chelsea McKee

How is it possible for a case's outcome to be deemed to be a constitutional violation but then, years later, deemed to be the opposite?

Kari Brigham

Ah! So many questions! But I'll start with this one: Please explain to me how the "Dual Sovereignty" doctrine isn't just an end run around Double Jeopardy?

Chris Brewer

If the US were to overthrown by another governing body, would it have to rewrite the existing Constitution or still use the same one at the time it was overthrown?

James Irvine

Any constitutional obstacles for combining the Dakotas....cuz who needs two Dakotas? Amirite? ;)

Meredith

Right! I'm always scratching my head because that part never comes up, and my reading of it makes it feel Very Important. So I'm wondering what I'm missing!

Ira Gray

Why do we still care what the founding fathers thought? Its a living document and theyre dead

Chelsea McKee

Are there other constitutional articles and amendments that you believe have been misread due to confusion over grammar? (I am definitely referring to the Right to Bear Arms).

Jana May Purington

If the Constitution is a living document, why are some people so determined to interpret through the eyes of the dead white men who wrote, especially when they used vague language so that it could evolve over time?

Brian Madsen

… also, because I've always wondered: how is the EC a "college"? What did that word mean (or what does it still mean) if it's not an educational institution for higher learning? The etymology of the word "college" in this case has always puzzled me.

Jana May Purington

Is it true that Thomas Jefferson (or one of the other founding fathers,bi might be misremembering) ran away because he was afraid to sign the Constitution and went into hiding for several months

James Irvine

Hypothetical: You have a magic wand that will insert a new amendment into the US Constitution - What does your new amendment say?

Carla Kennedy

How much do Madison’s detailed notes of the Constitutional Convention shape our understanding and interpretation of the constitution?

Benjamin Harrison

Is there actually a missing comma (or smudge) in the Takings Clause, as Toby states on the West Wing? Does fiction actually mirror fact?

Carla Kennedy

I think you and I (in my first question) were aiming at the same target.

Maria Kumro

Do you think we will ever change the law about having to be born in the US in order to be elected president, considering how much of our population is made up of (and hopefully will continue to be) immigrants? Sorry I asked two, I'm really excited for this episode and have so many questions!

Dylan Manthei

*first-timer: Have we drifted far from the initial intent of the Constitution because we have to interpret its meeting relative to today's technologies and developments? For example, large technology companies "terms and conditions" that "allow" them to legally collect and store every moment and decision you make because you checked a box.

Meghan Layton

Have you seen or listened to the soundtrack for Hamilton? What are your thoughts on the show as it relates to the Constitution, the Bill of Rights, etc.

Rick Gillespie

How many countries that have been founded since 1776 have adopted clauses similar to the US Constitution/Bill of Rights? In particular, how many have something similar to the 2nd Amendment?

WiGeekMom

I've always been frustrated that the only recourse a citizen has to have the Constitutionality of a law evaluated is to go through a lengthy and expensive lawsuit. Does this create an impediment to those who cannot afford to do so?

Renee Coley

Doesn’t seem like it’s used enough.

Renee Coley

Electoral College- should it stay or should it go now??

Colette Ayers

I’m English so I don’t have a full grasp on the constitution but what’s the deal with it being re written? Is that a possibility can it be amended? It seams like it’s the ultimate law, like is sacred and will never be changed? But can it? Will it? Thoughts?

Brian Madsen

I asked a conservative friend to help me understand how he reads that amendment. The answer I got back was that a well-regulated militia is necessary to the security of a free state, and that's one reason why the right to keep and bear arms shall not be infringed, but it's not the ONLY reason why, and we shouldn't expect it to be. So he says. His assertion was that that first clause is meant to be a partial, not a complete, justification for why the second part of the amendment exists. It's one example, but there are more, he says. And therefore, he says, the second part of the amendment can stand on its own, logically speaking, and doesn't need the first part to justify its existence. I can kinda see how someone could hold that view. I'm not sure I buy that that's an accurate reflection of what the Founders were thinking though.

Peter Dupuis Jr.

Here's my question... What th fuck? But seriously most of the questions I want to ask are the ones that I already know you will ask. Like what drew her to become a constitutional lawyer.

Michael in Seattle

First, I .♥. Alie. Thank you for sparking all these conversations. Question: was the concept of Amendments part of the original Constitution. If so, why has that process been so rare and difficult?

Meghan Layton

There has to be a better way to select Supreme Court Justices, right? Why is the most important job in our country - the one that makes the most profound decisions and sets the course for the entire nation for a hell of a long time - left up to a single individual to fill?

Graham Tattersall

Are there any badass constitutions from other countries you really admire?

Rachel von Morrigan

Probably already asked, but just in case. Was our Constitution meant the be amended, changed, or to shift with the times?

Amy Salley

Does the constitution protect us from/provide redress for actions taken against us by private citizens as opposed to government bodies? If not, why and if so, how? I mainly ask because Twitter never seems to know when someone's freedom of speech rights are actually being violated.

Brian Madsen

I don't think there's a limit to how many questions you can ask. :)

Maria Kumro

There isn't but I don't wanna be greedy.

Heather Dekle

Do you think we should make amendments based on new knowledge and ideals of the United States?

Caroline lewis

Entering law student here with a big interest in Con Law!! I would love to hear, if the ologist knows about other countries' constitutions, how the US's Constitution compares to others? Are there any provisions or characteristics in ours that are very rare to have, or anything that seems to be universal across most countries?

Elon Sloan

How can lawyers, legislatorsr, and everyday people reconcile the gap between the explicit protections and rights the law provides and the actual inequalities and injustices people face in their lives

Michael in Seattle

Do any countries have constitutions that keep them from being involved in the internal functioning of other countries ?

JCTheFluteMan

Why hasn’t Trump been impeached yet?

Mandii Smith

Which is better, a vague constitution that can be used to infer what is okay and what isn’t or a very specific one that is clear what is okay and what isn’t?

Andria Marsh

Why don’t we amend the constitution to match the current times? What’s different with ours compared to say a country like Uganda?

Elaine Barr

**The 2nd amendment is particularly relevant as many states try to increase gun control measures. Can you explain what rights it actually gives americans in regards to gun ownership?

Ellie Abbott

Ok so this is a really weird question - but why are we so attached to the constitution? It’s treated like the absolute final word in what’s good and what’s bad, but the founding fathers weren’t gods. We can’t be sure we’re interpreting their intentions correctly and even if we are, who says they get to make the rules for every American ever until the end of time? Why are they so much more qualified for that than other people?

David M Williams

What are the main differences in interpreting the Constitution/Bill of Rights, and how has it played out, such as interpretations of 1st and 2nd Amendment rights for Americans?

Mae

Everyone thinks of the founding fathers like super heros, do they deserve all of the credit they get?

Saer

What are the main reasons we’ve not had constitutional amendments in recent history?

Jake Dickerson

What is the worst reasoned SCOTUS decision of the last 50 years, and why is the answer D.C. vs. Heller (2nd Amendment individual gun rights)?

Saer

What would it take to make enslavement fully unconstitutional? Like, not even able to be used as punishment a la the 13th amendment?

Saer

Are there any federal laws, stemming either from the constitution or other legislation, explicitly outlining what taxes should be used for?

Saer

If you could write the constitution over from scratch, what would that look like?

Nicole Smith

Why is the congressional appointment amendment of 1789 still pending?

Nicole Smith

There hasn’t been a constitutional amendment since 1992, what do you think will be the next? Possibly the ERA?

D. B. Narveson

What's the deal with the 2nd Amendment?

Hayley Everson

Why do you think the constitution and the Supreme Court cases which have lead to constitutional changes are such a significant part of American identity, every other country in the world has a comparable constitution but none of them are so well known by the general public, why? Is it a good thing?

Lee Ann Potter

The Supreme court is the final arbiter of what is constitutional; since we now have a majority that seem to believe that their personal religious views should guide their decisions, do we now run the risk of the court declaring (in essence) a christian theocracy? Is there anything in the Constitution that would prevent that from happening?

Todd Peterson

I guess the most obvious question right now is: What exactly is a "constitutional crisis" and are we currently in one?

Todd Peterson

Why did we need the 21st amendment? (repeal of the 18th.) Why couldn't we just say "hey there isn't an 18th amendment anymore"?

Todd Peterson

I think we often times lose context when we talk about the 2nd amendment. The people who wrote it were revolutionaries. As much as I despise the use of the 2nd amendment to thwart all common sense gun laws, I actually do think it's more or less having its intended effect (that the government can't and shouldn't be able to take away your guns...especially and specifically in case said government needed to be overthrown.) Unfortunately, they never envisioned assault rifles or private citizens with their own arsenals, or that the government would ever have such superior firepower (tanks, jets, missiles) that no militia - well regulated or not - will ever be able to overthrow our government (not that I'm suggesting it needs to be overthrown...I'm not NOT suggesting it either ;-))

Britton Skuse

*First timer💁🏼* Could you chat a bit about the equal rights amendment and also about how heckin’ badass Ruth Bader Ginsburg is?

Sara Amish

Okay, the penumbra that covers individual rights. Is that going to actually stand up long term?

Kim Bonacker

What would you tell someone who knows nothing about what you study if you wanted them to "geek out" with you??

Meredith

Context is definitely important. I'm very interested to know how a constitutional law expert interprets the fact that the authors included the phrase "a well regulated militia" in the same sentence as "the right to keep and bear arms" and why the first part seems to get so little air time in the debate. How does the term "well regulated" impact the amendment as a whole? What did the authors mean when they used that phrase (why didn't they use a different phrase, or omit "well regulated" altogether)?

Kimberly Fajardo

For all intents and purposes, the constitution was written for the white, property-owning male. Is it time for a do over for it to be more inclusive of the very diverse world we live in today? What would the process even be like to try and promote a new constitution in the current divisive political climate of today?

Michelle Minert

What amendment(s) do you want to see added to the constitution?

Penny Lee

Why are corporations seen as people? How has this affected elections and is there any momentum to change this craziness?

Lacy Gilbert

Hypothetically (this might be stolen from the show Scandal) what would be the standard protocol according to the constitution if the president-elect were to be assassinated before being inaugurated? Please don't arrest me, I got this from a TV show

Penny Lee

Any chance we can say "so long" to the electoral college anytime soon?

Jessica

Does the existence of slavery-entrenching provisions force us to reconsider the overall value of the constitution today? (Full disclosure, this is from my husband who is a history teacher!) Thanks!

Sarah James

I thought the constitution was like, "Hey also there are other rights that we can't think of right now, but just cause they aren't listed doesn't mean they aren't legit." So why all the fuss that the word "privacy" doesn't appear when there are all of these amendments that seem to protect it? Why is the default often that if the constitution doesn't give the people a right, they don't have it?

Katherine Marsh

Why is there such a strong fetishization of the American constitution?

Sarah James

Would the constitution work in a place where citizens weren't engaged or have accurate information about the government?

Bruce Gordon

Was the constitution written to be known by all law makers and if so, did they ever have to recite it or at least reference it before being sworn in. What would the American people need to do to make it mandatory for all incoming presidents recite at least what each advent meant

Richard Jensch

What is the biggest flaw in the constitution, in your opinion?

Richard Jensch

Looking at western european constitutions, what is the thing they do way better or worse than the US constitution? (Greetings from Germany)

Richard Jensch

How would you combat the flawed two party system, on a constitutional level? If you wouldn't, why not?

Melina Filomia

Can you ask about article 2? The president references it in a way that makes me question what it really means, that I’m not getting. Reading it only gets me so far, as a non-lawyer.

Rachel

What pitfalls do you see with states/locations that have too easily amendable constitutions (looking at Colorado with its 100+ pages of amendments) and places where it is too set in stone? Should constitutions be more living documents or do they better serve us when they have a wide reaching but slowly changing foundation?

Tyler Q

I've heard that every country has a constitution, including us here in Australia. So, why does no one mention it or amending it, even when we make big legal changes as a country? Why does it seem to be only the US that brings up its constitution?

Elise Knowles

Several other patrons have touched on aspects of this, and it's not really a question...can she discuss originalism a little bit? I hear about this a lot these days, especially in regards to judges and justices. I mean, a lot of things have changed since it was written, in ways that the founders could not possibly have imagined. Does an originalist interpretation of the constitution serve the people (or shall I say the People) well? I also second patrons who question why the constitution is considered by some to be sacrosanct.

Ryan Marston

What is the legal and philosophical rationale for Originalism?

JCTheFluteMan

Anywhere between three months and 200 years

JCTheFluteMan

Why is the US constitution seen as such a big deal? Most civilised countries have a constitution but it’s not fervently held as gospel as it is in the states.

Clayton Cromley

Long time listener, first time querier! The Federalist Society: net boon or detriment to American jurisprudence?

Steph

I'm an Aussie so I know nothing - can the Constitution be rewritten or only amended, and can Amendments be rewritten? What are the processes for any of these things to occur?

Meagan white

Howdy! So I recently got all sorts of excited about the constitution and have been listening to the podcast More Prefect to get a better understanding. So I understand a lot of the conflict regarding the second amendment has to do with grammar, and that you can read it two different ways. If it’s so ambiguous is there any way to change it? Like as a county can we decide that it’s not clear enough and rewrite it? Is that at all possible, and if so what would that look like?

Daniel Hatfield

Are there any parts of the constitution that are just completely useless or annoying now after so long like a vestigial tail, or is everything still relevant for contemporary interpretation?

Corrie Navis

How does the U.S. Constitution compare to other countries' (that have them) constitutions, in terms of how often it's amended or its role in assessing laws?

Sierra Venus

Among the more obscure signers of the constitution is there anyone with a weird or quirky backstory?

Phyllis Brower

What are some of the most common misconceptions surrounding the US Constitution in terms of its functionality and interpretation?

SQuark

Is there a particular clause of the US Constitution that just...gives you joy or frustrates you, or you just like the wording?

Heather Munday

Is there a practical upside to strict constructionists pointing to what the drafters intended as a reason, or is it just another way of saying “we’re doing it this way because we’ve always done it this way.” How do they even know the intentions of the drafters?

HugsForBugs

I just recently learned about the penumbra of the 9th amendment and how it was used to make birth control available and wondered why it doesn’t apply to basic healthcare for all? Or is that the debate that is happening right now?

Wayne Brantley

Is the tale of John Hancock signing first and so large so the King would see it apocryphal or accurate?

Jake

Is anyone trying to change the 13th amendment to make slavery *actually* illegal? (It's still legal if the person has been convicted of a crime)

Karen Battenberg

How did Andrew Jackson (legally) get everyone to "sign on" for the Manifest Destiny?

john newcomer

When something is said to be "unconstitutional", does that mean it is illegal, or just not in 'the spirit' of the Constitution?

Carley Cross

Do you think the drafters of the Constitution intended for it to be "strictly" construed or intended it to change with the times, or did they not even attempt foresight in that way?

Sweet Chili

Will any of this last? Are we destined to collapse like Rome?

AussieColin

I gather (I'm an Aussie) that one of the fundamentals of your constitution is the separation of the church and state. Yet your govt seems to be more and more operating on a fundamental Christian agenda. The abortion "debate" simply being one example. Is this something that you see as possibly being the cause of a constitutional challenge in the future?

Simon Sakatos

Can you discuss the importance of stare decisis?

Sarah Wieczorek

Why do we still rely so heavily on such an old documdnt? Like technology, law, etc. why has the constitution not also evolved?

Kai

Do you believe that the Constitution has adapted into the modern age?

Jessica Inman

Do you think the founding fathers ever expected the majority of citizens to have a voice and access understanding of the laws of our nation?

Alex Rouse

How was the 14th Amendment used so effectively to make corporations people?

Izzy M.

What are good resources for learning about the constitution that are unbiased/don’t lean one way or another?

Kevin Schuette

I would imagine that he only thinly veiled a threat to scalp their children if they didn't instead of actually doing it. Technically legal. lol :P