Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

First off: I don't know why it's an -alogy instead of an -ology but family histories and ancestry is too good to skip on that technicality. So ready your questions for THE Stephen Hanks, a 30-year genealogist, author of the book "1619: Twenty Africans" and contributor to many documentaries about genealogy. So so so excited to talk to him. 

Also: Part 2 of Diabetology with Dr. Mike Natter, MD is up with allll of your questions! This one we cleaned up so it's kiddo-safe, plus Jarrett worked on a kid-friendly Part 1 in case you want to send it to anyone in need.

Part 1, kiddo-safe: https://drive.google.com/file/d/1gv_ITy7mIp9JIy7YcWOyLXddl4_9hwf8/view

Part 2, also kiddo safe! 

https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/diabetology-blood-sugar-part-2-with-dr-mike-natter-md/id1278815517?i=1000463944010

Okay: GENEALOGY questions below, fam. Eeeee, soo excited to chat with him. 

- Dadward Von Podcast 

(put a ** before it if I've never said your name on the show before so I can note you're a FTQA)

Comments

Cece Tincknell

If I do a DNA test kit can they share my DNA with the government or any other organization?

John Sansone

How reliable are sites like Ancestry.com? Are there other credible sources?

Michelle Minert

With so many lay-people researching their family history, how do you know if the information you’re finding on sites such as ancestry.com is accurate?

Anna Thompson

Why are Americans so obsessed with tracing their family trees? Specifically using genetic testing?

Gary Jungling

Can my DNA data trace my heredity back to ancient civilizations, examples Rome or celtic, vikings etc?

Camille Plemmons

What’s with the gene that makes cilantro taste great to some people and awful for others? Are there other characteristics that that gene is linked to? Do we know if it’s dominant or recessive?

Anna Thompson

What's the best way to trace your family tree?

Jessie Dragon

Please answer! My mom doesn’t understand how my sisters and I could have different percentages of genes from different areas, can the Ologist please explain so I can show my mom!

Danielle Lavoie

** What's the deal with second cousins versus first cousins once removed??

Jessica Janssen

One day will it be very difficult to identify ancestory as we diversify further?

Chelsy O'Leary

**What is the easiest way to get into Genealogy? My family is from a small town in Maine and its pretty hard to narrow down some of the details!

Deenz and Anchovy the kittens 🐱 🐈‍⬛

Not sure if a genealogy question but I would love to know more about genetic memory. Is it a legitimate thing? How extensive is it in humans if so? And how long does it take to happen? Thanks and Love

Margaret Ebacher-Rini

This is the same question I have! To what extent does genealogy differ between siblings?

Aleah

What's the best way to try and track "long lost relatives" when you have almost no information on them?

RJ Doidge

As part of the LGBTQ acronym, I'm always curious about research that shows other members of the same family that have generations of queer folk. Do to know of any research being done that can shed any light on the nature v nurture debate?

Maggie Fraser

** I second this! I loved cilantro, and now I REALLY DONT, so I don't think mine is gene-based? But I am still very curious!

Stephanie Broertjes

What is your view on the ethical implications of forensic genealogy being used in cases today a la JJ DeAngelo/GSK?

Rachel_C

I’ve heard that out of a group of three people - 2 black and 1 white - it is just as likely for a black and white person to be more related as it is for the two black individuals to be more closely related. If that really is the case, what the heck is race anyway? And why does it persist in modern times?

Lisa

**as someone who’s adopted and doesn’t know her biological family’s medical history, how much confidence can I put in consumer-grade genetic testing kits that claim to tell me about my medical history?

Maggie Fraser

** How much can we learn about ancestry from our DNA? I just sent a whole glob of my very own spit to Ancestry, and I should get the results back by the time this episode airs. Any flim flam in this practice?

Emm

**Are sites, such as Ancestry.com and Myheritage.com, legitimately reliable ways to discover ancestry? And if so, which one is recommended as most accurate?

Lindsey Beasley

**Can you speak about generational trauma? How does that work?

Christina C

** Just wanna say, I'm from Utah and we loooove this stuff here! thanks for the podcast! Are there areas or populations in the states or elsewhere that we are lacking good data (DNA or otherwise) in order to trace genealogy ?

April Perry

** I'm a forensic scientist (DNA analyst more specifically) and our field has been all a buzz with genealogy the past few years as cold cases are being solved using public database searches. Was curious what the ologist's take on that is, including possible ethical dilemmas.

Kyla Kelly

How do the services like '23 and me' - that tell you what percentage of your DNA is from what country - work? How accurate are they?

Kendyll Burnell

** Are the DNA tests that Ancestry and such have total bullshit- because they tend to have a lack of DNA samples from non-white populations?

Erin

Do you have any thoughts on how people keeping their own last names after marriage will affect future genealogy/ ability to trace back lineage?

Maggie Fraser

** not sure about this one, but I have Scottish ancestry. My great grandpa came to the US from Aberdeen. I visited there a few years ago, and there were SO MANY Frasers (my last name, i think its in my patreon username?) in the cemetery downtown. Any idea how many of them I am actually related to? Does that depend on lots of other info??

Maria Kumro

How can you not reliably trace family when they have incredibly common last names for the country they originated?

MainelyKacie

** I’ve been on 23andme me since 2016-my dads adopted and I’ve always wanted to know who/what am I. Long story short, I have Ashkenazi Jew in my ancestors..I’ve never heard this term-can you enlighten me?

Kelly Semon

** I would love to hear any ideas about how to get into tracing one’s family history without selling your DNA to corporations like ancestry/23&me. My family is from the Bahamas so I’ve actually worked with some cousins to trace back a long way to the 1800s on the island! But my Grandma was definitely the family black sheep because she got a divorce (oh! Scandal!) and remarried an American (my grandfather). I’m having a hard time tracing any of my family history there, the only thing sort of helpful is all the records the Mormons have!!

Ahmad

** So, is it true that a large percent of the people living today are descendants of Genghis Khan? Are there any other notable figures that many of today’s population are descendants of?

Sid Gopujkar

Why is it that my genetic structure is such that I gain 10 pounds every time I breathe in but my brother loses 10 pounds after he eats an entire chocolate cake? What causes that difference? Also, how can I change this injustice?

DONALD McLeod

There's a bunch of different internet memes about Genghis Khan, so what's the actual percentage of poeple who are related to him? Is he (aside for Lucy) the most related-to, identifiable human being in history?

Jessie Cole

How accurate are the tests? I have heard you can get extremely varied results dependent on following the maternal or paternal lines

Ren

What's the deal with the Habsburgs?

Jillian Shaw

** does submitting my DNA to an ancestry.com or 23&me mean that those companies then own that data to do with as they please? Am i foregoing all rights to my own genetic information? Can they use it without my consent? Should I be as freaked out about this as I clearly am?

Sneaky Hamster

Is it true that genealogy is the second most Googled thing (behind porn)?

Kathleen Sachs

What are the best companies that test DNA to trace what regions your family comes from? And what companies are better at screening for risk of disease? Is there a company that can do both well?

Maggie Fraser

**I second this! (I asked it but now can't see my comment?)

Kelly Semon

Oh I didn’t even know I had this question but now I second it!!

Molly Rupp

**Why does it feel so important on a base, instinctual level to look into or understand where we come from?

Wild Honey

** How much of our life is down to genes, compared to experience/upbringing? In other words, what percentage is nature and what percentage is nurture?

Bennett Vanderbosch

**How much validity do you put on paid DNA services for finding out your ancestry? My sister is adopted so I like that we can learn some potential health risks we should be aware of, but I'm skeptical of actually learning about ethnic ancestry. I've heard it's incredibly difficult to keep DNA samples clean of stray DNA and kind of doubt for-profit businesses do a ton to try to minimize that anyway.

Meghan McLean

My mom lost contact with her dad when she was a kid, and recently became reconnected with him after about 45 years. This has sparked in her a passion for tracing family history and genealogy. Are there any unconventional tools that can be used to trace genealogy?

Larissa

**where is the best place to start to actually look into my family history? What are some questions that I should be asking myself, family, and professionals like librarians in order to look into my history?

Kathleen Sachs

What is the coolest / most unexpected family tree you’ve put together?

Wild Honey

** What makes a gene dominant? Is it prevalence in the gene pool, or is it more to do with "winning" some kind of race?

juliebear

How good are the non-EU databases? A few years ago, I was told that the Asian databases weren't very helpful given low volume for non-Han Chinese.

Madelyn Dunkle

*** why do we always hear about mitochondrial DNA when tracing genetics, even for those with male chromosomes rather than tracing through paternity?

Renee

**i recently did 23&me to learn more about my dads family. I knew we are Jewish and was hoping for more specifics on where we can from. Why can’t it provide that information and only told me I was Ashkenazi?

Sarah Jean Horwitz

Where is the best place to start researching one's genealogy, after (or alternatively to) asking family members? Do you have a favorite website or service?

Jennifer Tran

Please explain second cousins, third cousins, etc. How are they really related?

juliebear

Is it true that even though you may not have submitted your DNA that because enough people have submitted, your privacy is essentially compromised and is being used on these sites anyway?

juliebear

What are the big ethical questions yet to resolved or addressed when it comes to genealogy and the criminal "justice" system? (I put it in quotes because...)

Chelsea

**How do I try to find out my family history without paying Ancestry.com or websites like it?

Jennifer Tran

Where do family coat of arms / seals originate from and how are they designed?

Meegan Walker

**do you believe in inherited trauma? what is your take on inherited trauma? Do you think that inherited trauma plays a role in the everyday lives of native peoples around the world whose past generations (and maybe current generations) have been oppressed by others?

Alexis Wallick

** Any tips on researching ancestors who were slaves? I have hit a roadblock for one branch of my family. Also, why are the genealogy services so expensive?!? Thanks!

juliebear

Is genealogy predominantly available and informative only for white, wealthy people?

Jen A.

Evidence seems to point to nature over nurture for personalities. Is there a trait that is most likely try for this? Anger, happiness, etc. Does any of this skip generations?

Sam McCarthy

What is the significance of the concept of Mitochondrial Eve? And can we estimate how many generations separate us from her?

Jen A.

What are the major downsides of doing an online genealogy test?

Rachel von Morrigan

And the whole “once removed” etc. It hurts my brain and I don’t understand.

Jen A.

What CAN we really learn from our families history? Best place to find information?

Mary Adams

**What is the deal with Cândido Godói and all the twins? Is there merit to the thought that the horrific and evil Josef Mengele had some hand in the staggering amount of twins in this small town? And is evil genetic?

Shannon Bartels

** How do you feel about websites like ancestry.com? Are they a good place to start searching, or is the same information easily found in other places without paying for it? Any advice on how to start researching?

Joe Porfido

What is the oldest genealogy on record and what do we know about that family.

Haley Vandewall

Many self proclaimed "shamans" on the internet are saying that those with RH or RH negative DNA are a more highly evolved species of human. Is there any truth at all to that?

Lauren Goulet

**As humans gets more globally connected and breed, where do you see ancestry as a whole headed? Could there eventually be one fairly unanimous/continuous "race" of humans? Or do you always think we were have sets of extremely different geno/phenotypes by geographic distribution? Big bio nerd here 🤓

Jen A.

I'm 42 and was born with red hair. It was VERY recently that a doctor mentioned physical traits tied to the 'red hair gene'. How do they find this stuff out? Was there a specific study for this one? #gingerpower (annndddd, I can't find a red haired emjoi 😠)

Mangoes And Limes

** FTQA! How legit are those 23 and me style kits? Like, I've been eyeing those up for nearly a decade. Oo, also, personalised medicinal gene therapy. Fan or no fan? Tricky ethics... Also, pleeeease debunk as much bull as you can. It's infuriating.

Todd Peterson

I have heard/read something about DNA only being traced only through the maternal line. Something about mitochondrial DNA, I think (?) Could you please explain what that's about?

Sara Løquist

** FTQA On 23andMe, it says that a 2nd cousin on my dad's side is related to me on my Mom's side. It won't even let me override to switch to correct side of my family. How is this possible? We have not found any common ancestors yet.

fullmetalknee

I've heard that immigrants' last names have often changed when arriving in a new country to avoid potential stereotyping and cultural violence. What are the given (and actual?) reasons that 1) people have changed their own names and 2) people's names were changed for them when entering a new country?

Todd Peterson

Is it true that redheads are not going to exist in the future? How is that different from blue eyes? Aren't they both recessive genes? I haven't heard anything about blue eyes going away. For that matter, can you explain recessive genes? How is it that siblings don't always have the same hair or eye color as each other?

Melissa Huston

**My mom found some family tree online showing that we were related to Ramesses, the Egyptian pharaoh (not sure I or II - not sure if they were even related). Anyway, do mummies possess enough genetic material to determine who their descendants are?? (i.e. could we 23andMe a mummy?)

fullmetalknee

Seconded! And what tools are good and affordable to do this? Technology is great and all but I haven't found a free/easy tool to keep track of people besides the world's biggest sheet of paper and note cards.

Jessica Drew

**Is 23andme and other kits like these stealing my DNA and my identity??? HALP!

Zoltán Szászi

Hi! So if in traditional Western families only males "pass on" their names, and if there are only female children, the name "dies out", shouldn't we run out of family names? Also was there ever a more egalitarian system? (E.g. girls inheriting their mothers' family names, boys their fathers')

Lizzie

*FTQA my dad is adopted and knows some of his biological family's background. What does that mean for our genealogy? Do we trace the adopted family's history? Do we trace the bio family's history? Both?

Todd Peterson

I'm A-positive-certain that's a bunch of flim-flam. OK, I've never actually heard that :-P

Todd Peterson

Please debunk flim-flam about what can and cannot be passed down. Speaking of which, what is "genetic memory" and is it real?

Haley Vandewall

I'm pretty sure it's flim flam too, I'm just taking this chance to have it officially debunked by an expert.

Haley Vandewall

I think these people just took way too many psychedelic drugs and now they're just really weird at parties.

Katherine

Are designer babies a threat to the human species? How is a twin different from a clone (other than how they're made)?

James Jakes

Do men inherit their mother's father's chance hair (chance of baldness)?

Matthew Charleston

** I work at a genetics testing company and I am curious about your thoughts on the ethics of computed genealogy. What is the role of direct to consumer genetic testing companies who may report life altering news?

Chase Penix

I have several genealogy buffs in my family and I intend to throw them a curveball. We want to have a closed adoption until our child is old enough to decide for their self if they want to know they’re background. What will our kid’s tree look like once his biological family is brought into the fold?

Matthew Charleston

** More recently white supremacy groups have used genetic tests to reinforce their European heritage. How else has genealogy been shaped by racism?

Nadav Levintov

What is the weirdest Gene discovered? From either it's purpose wise or any other metric :)

Jessica Chance

Is our fascination with tracing our genealogy a modern phenomenon, or have people always wanted to draw their family trees as far back as possible?

Jamie Pickles

What is the farthest back you have traced someone's lineage? Noah? Moses? Kevin Bacon?

Sarah Howell

I'd love to hear something about epigenetics and how environment can affect the expression of our genes. Also interested in whether generational trauma has a biological basis/expression.

Jessica Gray

First time question asker. How much is our personalities and interest are DNA based? Also, why do siblings who share both the same parents only related by 50% DNA?

Ashra Kolhatkar

Can they speak about the differences between ancestry and genetics, the social constructedness of race, and the dangers of claiming certain identities (e.g. Indigeneity) based on the results of genetic tests like 23andMe?

HangryAuntie

Why do many of the online "services" trace us white people back to royalty? Were they that promiscuous? Or is it lack of historical record-keeping? Like, only the important people were noted for their births, deaths & marriages; and, everyone in Western Europe was named Elis/zabet/h around the same time, so one is as good as another?

Diane Mahar-Daiken

**should we be concerned about big brother when it comes to DNA testing services?

cardi_gan

are DNA testing companies working on being less crappy when it comes to accurately identifying non-white ethnicities? (I did a MyHeritage test and it showed clearly where my European genes come from but the data on my African and Native South American genes - which I know I have - were vague to say the least, and I've heard about more people with the same problem)

Laura Merriman

How do you feel about the use of genealogy to solve cold cases? Super cool resourceful science or invasive?

Kevin Kostka

**How far back is genealogy largely accurate for the average person? That is, at what point do mistakes in historical records, people making intuitive leaps with the information, and historical infidelity/adoption/etc. mean that genealogical conclusions are unreliable? I've done some research on my own family history, and I'm very skeptical of some of the info I've found.

Sam Correia

**what's the farthest back that anyone has ever traced back their family history through genealogy?

cardi_gan

in the future where DNA tests become widely available, will it be impossible to hide from children the fact they are adopted or born from someone who is not their "official" parent (in cases of egg/sperm donors or cheating)? I always think about that

Jess_Lin

**A law in Quebec (Canada) forbids a woman from taking her husband’s surname after marriage. Are there many cultures/countries in which women traditionally do not take their husbands name, and does this cause issues when tracing back families?

Cat Lindsay

How far back can you really go with Genealogy? Where is the best place to begin researching our family tree? What can we really learn from our family history?

Andrea

How does the cultural assimilation of Native American children affect genealogies? Any thoughts on Native American tribes requiring specific percentages of blood to be tribe members?

Tyler Q

Where did the word "step" come from in a family tree context?

Euan Munro

What's Stephen favourite analogy to use to show how closely everyone is related when you go back up the generations?

Deanna Juan

How reliable are the generic testing kits? I’d like to believe in research-supported science but people keep telling me that there are instances in which people gave the same dna twice and got different results from the same company.

Amanda J

If I dont know my biological father how likely is it that I will still display traits of his. And is there anyway to combat this if the traits aren't positive.

MissKitti

Which cultures have tended to keep the best or most accurate genealogy records and how do we know if they are accurate?

Rebecca Baker

**ftqa maybe? Posted a "urinology" query earlier today My mom is an identical twin, so is my Aunt Judy also my bio-mom? My husband's dad was an identical twin, too. And so our our children. All the twin books claim that there's no genetic link to identical twinning and it has to be a fluke since the rates are basically the same across all racial/geographical/etc categories, but that's gotta be wrong, right? Also it seems to be changing due to ivf and I'm guessing implanted embryos are like slightly unstable and more likely to split(?) but anecdotally it sure seems like identicals also can run in families? And what is the deal with eye color? I've heard there are about eleventybillion genes that determine eye color?! Husband and I both have green eyes and our kids somehow have blue.

Brittany Kaufman

How much travel is involved in genealogy research these days? Is it all online? How do you get a paying gig? What's the oddest source you've ever found information from? And what's the weirdest family story you've come across?

Brittany Kaufman

Also, what can us modern people do to help our family records survive?

Kat Wiseman

**what's the strangest connection you've found through genealogy? (for yourself or between other people)

Bee

My grandfather was adopted when he was ten months old, and he never wanted to know anything about his birth family, so when his adoptive parents passed, and then him, we lost everything we may have known. I’m desperately wanting to know who he was before he was adopted, but I only have his birth last name to go on. What’s a good place to start from here? (Note: he was adopted in the late 1930s, if that helps!)

Bee

How far back is it possible to trace a genealogical history?

Barry Jarman

How does mitochondrial DNA differ from regular DNA, and does it really trace back to 7 distinct women?

Brittany Kaufman

How are genealogists adapting to changing family structures and use of family names?

Wynter Fenn

** How do companies like ancestry.com locate, source and categorize the wealth of information on a single person, let alone billions of people?

Sara Meredith- Smere Tactics

Like Bee Wilson, I would love to trace my lineage back through my grandma but she was adopted when she was 2 and is not interested in knowing her ancestry. How difficult is it to track down info like this without much information to go on? Is it even possible?

Jamie MacNeal

While in therapy, I learned about ACEs (Adverse Childhood Experiences) and the idea that DNA can be permanently affected by trauma during childhood. Is this something valid, and if it is, can an age range be pinpointed as to when this would happen, such as before puberty?

juliebear

What stake does the Mormon church have in the private genealogy sector? How does the privatization of the big databases (Ancestry, 23andme) affect bias from the public forensic databases which might be built up through involuntary participation like law enforcement?

Jacqueline Ruff

** With the arrest of the Golden State Killer, what are your thoughts on forensic genealogy? Should police have access to the genetic genealogy databases?

Victor Lewis

**How many generations back is it that everyone is related to everyone or no-one?

Josie

How accurate are the dna tests? What’s the best way to find your ancestors when a family member (in my case, grandfather) was adopted and didn’t know/didn’t talk about their birth family?

Carrie Cimo

**Do you think the rising curiosity in researching genealogy could be sowing a deeper divide between people (fostering racism)?

Carrie Cimo

**Are all genealogy services created equal? (Are they equally accurate?)

Carrie Cimo

**What role does genealogy play in one’s health or personality predispositions? Any? (Would someone with a Mediterranean heritage be more or less likely to be ... fill

Carrie Cimo

in a stereotype.. oops, hit return before i was done i guess!! 😜

Heather Fargis

** How accurate are the tests from sites like Ancestry.com and 23andMe? Why do the results keep changing? And if I have 1% African DNA, how far back in my tree would I have to go to find that ancestor?

Emma Fiori

How can I learn more about my ancestry when my family only knows a few generations back, and can't confirm connections found on Ancestry.com? Does it just become a guessing game at that point?

Mika LD

** Has the increased understanding of epigenetics affected the field of genealogy in any interesting ways?

Bee

My grandfather was adopted at ten months old and we have next to nothing in documentation of this. We have recently come to find his birth surname, but that’s literally it. Is there even a way to begin searching for his missing biological genealogy?

Schmitty Thompson

Whats the deal with people do genetic tests find that they have neanderthal ancestors? And do you have any advice for people trying to find family members who illegally immigrated to America? (for context, my many times great grandfather came here as a stowaway in a potato barrel).

Alanakamakaila

This is kinda how it is traditionally done in many Polynesian cultures, the girls claim the mother's line, and the boys claims the father's line. But the idea of lastnames were introduced when Westerners colonized us. So I am interested if the tradition is/can be returned.

Krystyna Dallaire

** What are your thoughts on how our stories about where we come from impact our sense of identity? And how does the rise of genetic testing impact or change that (especially if we discover our genetics don't necessarily align with our expectations)?

Meryl

I'm not really sure how to phrase this as a question, but I want to learn more about the impact of mass genocide on genealogy. I'm specifically thinking about the Holocaust, but I know there are other events that would fall into this category as well.

Meryl

I really do wonder how much of this is science and how much of this is flim-.

Meryl

Yes. This. Since I've heard about this I've really wondered about the consequences of generational trauma.

Drake Bruner

What’s the deal with trauma being passed through generations?

Alanakamakaila

** first time question asker! Thank you so much for helping us learn! I was wondering when did the importance of males' genealogy over females genealogy (i.e. lastnames) start? On my Native Hawaiian side, no-one really cares who the father is, but on my white side, the tree only looks at the fathers (maybe the mothers if she was very high status). Traditionally, I was taught, most Polynesian cultures, the girls claim only the mothers line and the boys only claim the "fathers" side (even if they are adopted, or don't know who the real father is).(And then we got colonized by Westerners so now we have lastnames.) Do other cultures also do this?

Gegg

***Nature vs. Nurture. Obviously, we are influenced by both but is there one category that impacts us more than the other? Is it 50-50, 60-40? Or is it a total person-to-person basis? Is there a way to measure the amount of nature and nurture levels in a person?

Kristina Weaver

How far back in time has some traced their ancestry to? Could it be traced to a time in the Before Common Era range?

Lily G

What is the absolute furthest back an American could expect to trace their European ancestry?

Gegg

***How much does our genetic heritage affect our daily lives?

Lisa Uhrich

***I don't know how to phrase this, but I really want to know more the connection between genealogy and true crime. For example, the golden state killer, How did genealogy play a role in that case?

Michael Aiguier

What is the most satisfying part of doing one's own geneaology? The stories? Is that part of geneaology?

Everest Chamberlain

So many questions already!! Any tips or resources for tracing your heritage and tracking down documents when you don’t speak the language?

Breana Gretsky

Why did royal families choose to breed within their family lines regardless of the result of children with disabilities, disorders, mutations, diseases, etc...?

Heather Fargis

Me too. I keep hearing it's mostly flimflam. I'm really interested in his opinion!

Jenella Dover

Someone probably already asked this, but what is the best way to start researching your own genealogy if you don’t have anyone to ask for more information?

Felix Wolfe

** In what ways have racism and colonialism played a role in the way we interact with genealogy? Like DNA tests and white folks claiming POC status or the erasure of POC histories through slavery and assimilation, also the idea of blood quantum in some indigenous communities that have had so much history stolen?

Stephanie Hancock

Have there been any new discoveries or developments regarding the grizzly-polar bear hybrid? Can these hybrids breed?

Felix Wolfe

how is intergenerational trauma passed through our genes and lineage?

t.persephone

Are there any good ways to research ancestry in the Americas? My family has mixed heritage from New Mexico -- Spanish and Native American -- but my family doesn't know anything about the NA. Were these records kept? Do I have to talk to the Mormons about it? Thanks! Tana

Mowana Lomaomvaya

** What is the foundational concept around ancestry DNA test? How do they use your results and data? Why is there no good data for Native Americans in these tests...is it because Native Americans aren’t taking the tests?

Glenn Thompson

*** I inherited all the old family photos when my mom passed away last year. Add to that, with Ancestry.com I have my entire family, except one individual, traced back 4 to 5 generations to where they got off the boat. My only connection to the past, my uncle, that I had planned to sit down and go over the photos with, ironically passed away 3 days ago. (Ali, plz paraphrase all that) . The question: What is the methodology to match up names with family photos when you have both, but not the connection? Question 2 - the whole damn family came from Germany between the 1840's and 1860's. With two world wars, a possible communist occupation and a probability they did not leave from a German port, is there any chance of back tracking records in Germany?

Janna Wisniewski

What will my great-great grandchildren know about me and how will they know it? (I am a regular person who has no plans to bury a time capsule.)

Nathan Ahlgrim

I've always been confused how genetic markers are "assigned" to certain heritages. So many people discover previously unknown roots when they take a genetic test, so why are we so confident that the samples that defined Northern European or Southern Asian or whatever didn't also come from people with diverse heritage?

Dawn Zwart

My brother and I both did DNA tests and we had different percentages of each country of origin Is that an error in the test results, or did we each get different bits from our parents’ DNA? Also, how can they narrow down by specific European countries? I feel like that is saying I have Texan and you have Iowan. 🤷🏼‍♀️. Thanks Dawn

Bonnie

Do you have any interesting stories about someone discovering a long lost/unknown relative through genealogical research?

Kerri -Leigh

Ahh so excited for this. I fall down the ancestry hole every other year and find a little bit more of my tree but I've hit a wall when it comes to German and some Irish records. Any good websites out there for people who want to go outside the bounds of ancestry.com? Or tips for how to find a genealogist in a different country to help? Ahh so excited for this episode

Lauren Tanenbaum

**Dear Alie and genealogist, If you belong to a relatively small ethnic group, (for example, Ashkenazi Jewish people, like myself), what are the chances that if you marry someone of the same ethnic background...you guys are actually related? Sincerely, people keep saying that me and my boyfriend look alike and I'm starting to wonder if I should be concerned...

Morgan Reel

**Why are so many people obsessed with genealogy? I feel like it’s something people just want to brag about like being related to some famous person or whatever. It is just interesting or actually important? How does genealogy contribute to scientific or historical understanding? Convince me why it matters; I am a skeptic!

morbidbarbie

What's your favorite thing you've learned about your own family history?

Gerry Priebe

** What are the most economical means to do ancestry research?

Cedric Zeller

**What interesting studies can we do/are being done with all the genealogical data dna testing services are collecting?

Jules

** Recently have thought and heard a lot about how genetics and specifically tracking DNA is further marginalising BIPOC (thinking specifically about the problematic requirement of blood quantum). Would love to hear more about this, and any thoughts about how to dismantle that. Thanks!

Andrea Levinson

the whole recent fad of tracing our genealogy through companies like 23andMe has me thinking about Henrietta Lacks and the ethical implications of giving our DNA to these companies. Also can you explain how spitting in a tube tells you your ancestry? like how does the DNA get you there?

Enrique Idael

What are the future applications of knowing our ancestors or information about them through DNA tests? I know that some of these techniques can help us to solve criminal cases, but I'm also worried about the legal issues of this.

Carolyn Wolfram

**FTQA - what are the top resources both online and IRL that you would recommend someone start with to trace their genealogy?

Brian Madsen

The New York Times Daily podcast did a couple of fascinating episodes about this not long ago, FYI.

Patxi Amuchastegui

** Why most everyone in one's family tree is a cousin sometimes x times removed in English, but it differs in other languages, like in Spanish, where those cousins x times removed can be great-great aunts and uncles or even nieces and nephews?

Patxi Amuchastegui

** Please explain how to interpret the shared DNA values in centimorgans that come in ancestry reports for peoples from clusters with significant familial aggregation, e.g., Los Altos in Jalisco, Mexico. Thanks!

Carolyn Figurelle

Ancestral DNA question- last year my father-in-law and his brother (who are 100% biologically related) took the same company's DNA test. My father-in-law came back 90% Italian and his brother came back 90% Greek. How is that possible?

Helen Langille

FTQA - I’m from rural Nova Scotia where people are /obsessed/ with genealogy and how Scottish they are - do you have any insight as to why certain regions seem much more tied to a specific ancestry than others?

Mira Basuino

** I have a question from my dad who has been trying to work on expanding our family tree. He said, "I am at the point of trying to get relatives from Italy, and I would like to know the best places to go get that information and how to go about getting that information. Are there web sites, city records, etc. where I can do research?"

Laura Stacey

What's the forecast for genetic testing in the future?

Ruby Johnstone

Are there any gaps in the genealogical information universe that you would like to see addressed? Asking as a professional archivist.

Lauren Quebral

** how does 23 And Me know your traits such as how likely you are to match pitch, if you’ll have dry or wet earwax, if you’ll be afraid of heights etc. and also is 23 And Me worth my money? these trait results seem like a fun thing to read (my friend got a kit) and i’m wondering if i should do it too or is there another one that’s more accurate or more worth my money? thank you!

Ruby Johnstone

Any insights into the USCIS genealogy program and their recent hike in fees for access to historical materials?

Cheryl Freund

How likely is it that I am distantly related to my husband being that we are both Ashkenazi Jews?

Wonder

Technically three questions but they’re all interrelated: how accurate are at-home DNA testing kits? Do testing kit results vary all that much between brands? And can results vary drastically amongst biological siblings/family members?

Kelsey Stenglein

**I always see commercials for ancestry/DNA testing. I am curious to learn more about my ancestors, but I’m also uneasy about a company having that much information about me. How accurate are the results anyway? Am I right to be freaked out by this?!

Greg

Which family has the oldest recorded tree and how big is it?

Mandy Binder

Yes! Iooooove cilantro but my half sister can't stand it!

Marco Guererro

So I did a 23andme and it told me that my body/brain best wake up time is 8:30am. Is there such thing?

Rhea Smith

**For the casual (and frugal) family historians out there: Are there any free digital resources available for researching census records, birth certificates, death certificates, military records, and marriage licenses?

Janet Sebastian-Coleman

how can DNA testing companies claim a certain percentage of "European" or even "British" descent? It seems to me that 1) our divisions between different states and areas are -- in the grand scheme of human history -- relatively new and 2) that depending on how far back you go in a genealogical history you could be "from" a lot of different places. (For example my great-grandparents came to the state from Italian, I'd always thought of myself as Italian-American and recently my grandpa mentioned that further back the family had moved from Spain to Italy)

Robin Kuehn

Favorite cultural or family tradition you've encountered that lends itself to genealogic study? E.g. oral histories, songs, portraits, hair books?

Joe Weinhoffer

** Can you please explain the proper usage of extended family tree nomenclature? What makes someone a first or second cousin? What makes someone once, twice, or thrice removed? This has confused me forever.

Dale LeMaster

Do I have an unusual family tree trait? With about 4K people in my Ancestry tree, I have three instances of unions in the second half of the19th century that would be illegal today. eg: Uncles marrying nieces or marriage between first cousins. Such unions are noticeable because they really convolute your tree! :-)

Taaren Haak

Have you noticed that Americans are more interested in their ancestry than in other countries? My friend from Kuwait has remarked that he thinks it's bizarre how Americans are obsessed with saying "I'm this percent from this country, etc." I imagine it has something to do with our relatively recent recorded history and colonization?

Taaren Haak

Name pronounced Tair-en Hay-k, she/her 😊

ConnoisseurA

I have an interesting family tree mix as I am part indigenous and part white European pioneer stock. My white grandparents who do the most genealogy sometimes have a hard time coming to terms with various troublesome aspects of our lineage like colonialism and slavery (ol grandma, “I’m SURE they were GOOD slave owners”). What are some suggestions you would have for people running into this aspects in coming to terms with it, accepting it, and then using that knowledge to guild how we build our own lives and legacy’s?

Noam Sienna

** What tips do you have for someone who is interested in making a "family history" book, for example to celebrate a big anniversary or birthday. How much do you include? How do you gather information? How do you organize it (chronologically, by family member, etc.)?

Ashley Sayre de Rivas

** ok so my mom is a twin (fraternal), and also my aunt and uncle are fraternal twins. My gram always said to be prepared because twins skip a generation, is this true or just my weird family? I kind of want to mentally prepare myself if/when the time comes to start a family... which at 33... who knows will happen 🤣 thanks!

Heather Densmore

How can it be that my spouse’s dna test results came back 2% Camaroon and Bantu people but his 3 siblings who also were tested, did not have similar results?

Leanna Shuster

Many of us have significant holes in our family records due to the Holocaust, both from the lives lost directly and from the widespread destruction of what records did exist within Jewish towns across Europe. Could you comment on the ways in which major world events impact the search for family records and any advice you'd have on filling in these difficult gaps?

Leanna Shuster

In my own family history searches, Ive had to Wade through handwritten census and other government, which often include different spellings of the same name and even different dates or years of birth for the same person. Could you share a favorite story or two where these sorts of anomalies in family records gave you an interesting mystery to solve?

Amber-Leigh Noelle

**how closely related are we to the oldest human beings ever found?

Carla B

**My paternal great grandmother is 100% American Indian from a tribe in the Great Lakes region. Besides her name and birthday, that's about all the info I have. How should I start to investigate her lineage more? Do tribes keep records? Are there any cultural faux pas I should avoid?

Dig

**I might be too late since this was yesterday. What are the current thoughts in the field about the existence of biological races? Races as a cultural concept I completely get, but I've always thought it strange that we put ourselves into these specific groupings when our genetic makeup is composed of millions of humans before us in our ancestral tree. I've seen arguments both for ("races" are just subspecies) and against (basically my thoughts above).

Andrea Devlin

** what is the truth about red hair? I know that it's a genetic mutation, but does it skip generations? I have red hair, but no one in my family does.

Ace Lane

Is there any aspect of the modern genealogy market that you think is racist? I know even databases have biases because humans program how they are used!

Ace Lane

Why are mitochondria such rock stars and what is the craziest trait you have traced using mitochondrial dna??

Ace Lane

Also what are your thoughts on the recent HBO’s series Watchmen and its concept of a sci fi genealogy database descendants of victims of the Tulsa Massacre?

Anna Elizabeth

How accurate are the dna ancestry websites. Like am I actually related to these random people it says I’m related to? And should we really be giving our DNA to these companies? Would also love to hear them talk about epigenetics like how stuff that happened to our great/grandparents can effect how our genes are expressed? Idk if that actually fits into the ancestry category but I’ve always been fascinated with epigenetics

Belinda Kuo

** FTQA What are companies like 23 & me doing with our DNA? How much risk is there in giving your DNA to them? And, most importantly, would you recommend it?

Emily Maloney

I wonder this too. I have something like 5% German ancestry. How far back in the family tree is that person?

Heather Circle

What is the most reliable and in depth ancestry test available to the public?

Heather Circle

What percent of personality genetics is passed down from generation to generation?

Jennifer Coil

Any tips when you hit a dead end when researching an ancestor? I mean fairly recent, like in the last 100 years.

Emily Maloney

**What can you *actually* learn from genetic ancestry testing -- what are the limits of what these tests can tell you?**

Michael Sherman

I used to be a Mormon and at the time they held some of the best records on ancestry. Are there any other data bases that don't require me to give up tea and coffee to get access to?

Sarah Senula

In tests like 23andme, how do they come up with their reference samples for nationalities, like, who do they use as their reference points for being “Italian” or “German”... basically how do they know what people are... i hope this makes sense...

SarahDez

**What are some of the best free public resources for searching up family history (aside from speaking with relatives)?

R.C. Hoover

Should we be buying into services like 23AndMe and AncestryDNA if there is no guarantee of privacy? What are the risks involved with participating in these kinds of companies?

Wayne Brantley

I have heard that long ago “the family bible” was often the repository of a family’s genealogy, updated generation after generation by whoever inherits it. I would hope this practice is both true and still practiced today, in case digital records are lost or corrupted. Keeping hard copies is essential! However, let us be frank, exactly how much faith can we really place in genealogy records being true? I mentioned to a coworker recently that in every person’s lineage there is likely at least one case of (unreported) rape. Paternity testing of a child could not be preformed until recently in human history. People lie. People cover up rape, infidelity, adoptions. You might think you know your family history, but might in fact be part of a complete different tree. I had a friend recently learn in his mid-thirties that his “father” was not his father. His mother had been married before, then got divorced, remarried and had two more kids. Rather than send “another man’s child to school,” his “father” adopted him, and my friend had his name changed before entering kindergarten. His brother and sister were in fact his half-brother and half-sister. His mother and the family of his birth father (long deceased) had no intention of ever telling my friend. He only learned the truth when his mentally unstable “father” flew into a rage in a Wal-Mart aisleway and told the sister. My friend is getting to know all these “new family” members now, including a half-brother that looks just like him. So can genealogical records even be trusted, family bible or no family bible?

Britta Nelson

*** How granular can the data be if access to science/the option to pursue science is largely a privilege based thing? How can we be sure to not propagate the gender/racial/classist bias if we choose to participate in services such as 23 and me, or similar?

Ashley Herbel

Regarding people who are adopted: if they consider their adopted parents their family wouldn’t they want to research their parents’s ancestry even if it wasn’t their (the adoptee’s) genealogy, what would they consider their family history? This seems like an internal conflict.

Paulina Tarr

** Many People care a lot about their backgrounds and take great pride in their lineage. how has this been beneficial and detrimental to history?

Casey Handmer

Talk about Iceland's incredible records!! Why is genealogy so addictive? DNA testing and digitized records are improving the efficiency of genealogical research by a huge factor. How far back can we get with this? (Subtext: I have DNA cousins who are, eg, 7th cousins 4 different ways and there are hundreds of possible family trees that are equally likely. It seems to me that at some point the genetics data "washes out". I don't think we can do perfect reconstruction back to 100,000 years ago!)

LimsKaren

** In Belgium and the Netherlands, there are a lot of people with "silly" last names, as a revolt to the Napoleonic forced implementation of name records for everyone in the population and not just landowning aristocrats. Can you tell more about the influence of historical figures like Napoleon on family trees and lineages?

Hannah Raddatz

How related are people in countries where they had closed off borders or were geographically isolated for centuries (or more)? Like island nations or tribes separated by mountains or glaciers? Or even countries where traditions/culture make marriage outside of the larger community uncommon?

Hey, Art3mis!

** Im asking my Dad what he wants to ask because he'd been doing Ancestry.com and other genealogy stuff for our family for a long time. He's a history buff and loves learning, so I'll post his question as soon as I get it and if you could give him the shoutout it'd make my (and his) day <3

Gabrielle Charbonnet

**The cliche that “Blood is thicker than water” is a cliche because it’s still often obvious in today’s society—that, right or wrong, one needs to stick with one’s family rather than non-family. Is this just learned behavior or is there something in the structure of ancestry that fosters this? Also, in a construct such as a “royal family,” do they ever worry about going back a couple of generations to see who is actually not related by blood to various monarchs? Does that matter? I love the idea of a royal family, but it seems that it’s been quite diluted, over hundreds of years. Thanks—love this podcast.

Emily Simons

**I'm adopted and did a DNA test a few years ago to figure out my ethnic ancestry. In doing so, I discovered that I have a half sister I didn't know about (WHUUUTT?) and I've also found my birth mother. She raised my sister. Members of my paternal side have also popped up, but this is all a story for another day... Here's my question: on 23andMe, there are Maternal and Paternal Haplogroups. What the heck is that?? What does a H3 group mean? Also, what are Neanderthal Ancestry varients? Mine is 276. What gives???

Katie Viles

** What’s up with some people doing DNA tests and practically finding out the street in Ireland their ancestors broke bread on and others getting super vague answers? Does this come down to the credibility of those types of tests or is it possible some people’s genes are harder to “read” than others? My mom did the ancestry one knowing her great grandparents were Slovenian and it didn’t mention Slovenia at all but rather that she was some 40% or something Northern European. Clearly I don’t remember exactly what it said but the point stands that it was super vague and has kind of made me weary of doing my own test. Thoughts?

Katie Viles

** I’m not sure if this is even remotely up your avenue of expertise but I’m here asking it anyway. How accurate are dog DNA tests? I’ve worked with dogs for several years and have gotten decent at recognizing some key traits in various breeds. That said, I am no expert. However some folks will tell me what their dogs are reported to have in them from those tests and sometimes they leave me saying respectfully... there’s no way in hell that’s what’s in your dog. Others however totally seem to make sense. I want to do one for my dog but I also don’t want to get swindled.

Erik Pohanka

What are the implications of genealogical services when it comes to having your DNA on file in a private company? Is there potential for them to sell your information to insurance companies for instance?

Marissa Laws

I was so excited a few episodes ago to hear my name when I was a FTQA! Now I am hooked on asking questions :) My Q for this time: How do you feel about the benefits to genealogy that DNA testing has brought, and how do you contrast this with potential downsides (for example, I know that knowing you have the E4 variant of the APOE gene, which puts you at a much increased risk for Alzheimers, may have to be disclosed to some insurance companies and result in complicated issues)?

Kylie Torres

**Where do you start if you don't have much to work off of?

Zoe Jane

What is the oldest known family tree?

Zoe Jane

There always seems to be the one person that enjoys spearheading the genealogy research and documentation for the family. Why is it important for us to continue documenting our family lineage?

Katherine PG

**To what extent are tools like 23andme an approximation, and how big a grain of salt should we take those results with?

Diana Tiley Latsha

**Among my paternal grandfather's brothers and sisters (I'll call them Smith), three of them married siblings from the same family (Miller). So there are three branches of the tree that have Smith/Miller parents. Does this make their families any more closely related than normal?

Six Digit Sauce

FTQA: how good are these dna testing services? How useful are they truly for connecting to your ancestry? My mom got a me one for Christmas and it's breakdown was pretty lame because it only pointed to regions within Europe like "the British isles" or "West and Central Europe" I was expecting more granular results. Is that a unreasonable expectation for Gene testing?

Laurence

What is the most interesting story he discovered while making research? / Does he think that future generations will have a better or a worse time trying to figure out who their ancestors (aka us) were? What I mean is that WE have only "physhical" clues or what remains of them to make our own research. Which can be sometimes difficult or impossible to work with. But future genereations will have access to a whole lot of things about us via internet, servers, data, etc. Does he think that the data that we are creating right now will be enough for future generations to understand who we are or that it will be as vague or difficult to find as the data that is currently available to us about our past? (Not sure if my question is clear and well written since english is not my first language, but I hope so. Thank you!)

jenna martin

I live in Utah, Mormons are obsessed with genealogy. Not really a question just telling you.

Rose Micke

FTQA - What is the earliest genealogical record we have? What makes a genealogical record valid?

Sabina Ciardi

Will we be actually capable of choosing our children’s eye color and make them resistant to particular viruses?

Tara McNee

Oh oh can you talk about the ethics or techniques for using familial genetics to solve cold cases?!

William Andrews

** What about messing with those DNA services? Could I submit to them a sample saying I am Franklin Roosevelt from Toronto, instead of say Jim Jones from Salt Lake City? Would that mess with them too much? ** Many families in the USA have lore that there is a Native American back in the family tree somewhere. How often does this pan out or not? ** About how often do they find out that there is a sibling that is only a half sibling in an otherwise normal family? Particularly 'back in the day'.

William Andrews

Their kids are called "double cousins". They can share more DNA with some of their cousins than with their parents.

Cynthia McQueen

Same same. I want all the criminals caught, and I have contributed to the great genetic swab bin myself. While it is amazing that this science and technology has resulted in the Golden State Killer being caught, and other crimes being solved, there is something that seems somewhat suspect about the proliferation of these genetic testing businesses, and how you're consenting to having your DNA made available. It makes me wonder how criminals may respond to this in the future (I may read/watch a little too much sci-fi).

Nadine Duke

Dude, my friend’s sister found out she was only a half sister when the whole family did dna testing last year. 😬

Kelly Semon

Alie Ward I would like you to know the mere mention of this topic revived my previously shelved family history project and I spent at least a week at my mum’s house going through old photos and may or may not have discovered my grandmother owned land in the Bahamas when she died! So yeah this has surely opened a can of worms!!

Bree DeVries

Ahh I don't know if you're still taking questions, but my brother-in-law was adopted and he's trying to find his birth family. What is the cheapest and most successful way for him to do that?

Ang

** What are your tips for researching people with common names?

Ang

** Native American genealogy. My boyfriend's grandmother was Cherokee, however, I'm having a hard time directly linking them to any Cherokee/Native American documents (dawes roll, etc.), though I've found a few distant relatives in those documents. Any tips on Native American geneaology?