Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

The study of willful ignorance, folks! Talking today with lauded Stanford professor Dr. Robert Proctor about climate-denying, flat-Earth-believing, non-mask wearing, research-ignoring behaviors and why and how they happen. 

Whooooooo boy, I am scared and excited to find out. Leave your questions below, friends!

Comments

Everest Chamberlain

Why. Just why. My friend and I were just talking about this, I truly do not understand how people can deny literal facts. It’s infuriating.

Meryl

Cults. How does that mindset manipulation fit into this study of misinformation?

Marylynn Skruck

Which gender is more willfully ignorant and why?

Kate Stomps

I agree with this sentiment. Why.

Hannah Feldman

What’s the worst question you’ve ever been asked professionally? Like after a presentation or class?

Maria Jouravleva

Can willful ignorance occur in animals? Or is it just exclusive to humans?

Karen Ellyatt

What, if any, strategies do you recommend for dealing with these folks. Especially when they are in positions of leadership or authority?

Ryan Clark

What are some alternative strategies we could use to convince people who are skeptical of science, evidence for climate change, evolution, etc.?

Panot

Why aren't facts good at changing people's opinions? How to convince people who don't accept facts?

Schmitty Thompson

What can we do? Especially when lives are at stake?

Quincey Robisheaux

Have there been studies about correlation between willful ignorance and levels of stress? Are there any indicators that willful ignorance is an act of saving oneself from high levels of stress?

Jay Gordon

What is your favorite conspiracy theory?

Jeffrey Doyle

Is it a learned behavior or genetics? Ye ol' nature v. nurture debate.

Vivus Ignis

A quote I've heard "you cannot reason someone out of an idea they didn't use reason to get to" so what's your advice on attempting to reason with an emotional belief?

Rachel

Just like how do they live in a constant state of cognitive dissonance? What are the psychological and physiological impacts of holding these beliefs for long periods of time?

Brendan Kaylor

How much does public education impact peoples beliefs? I feel as if red states tend to be the ones who don't provide 100% accurate information to students and are there any things being done to try and address this problem?

Aeriel Belk

I was going to ask the same thing! Is there even a point in trying, or are they mainly doing it for the attention and should we ignore them?

Aarika

What are predictors of willful ignorance? Age (like you become more set in your ways over x age), generation (we love to blame boomers, but is that valid?), education level, geographical location, gender?

Lynn Perry

What are the moral implications of choosing ignorance over facts when others are hurt or die as a result of your intentional ignorance? Can someone be held accountable legally as a result?

Misty Dulovich

Is willful ignorance more of a fear of reality and they’re willing to do anything to believe the lie or do they honestly believe some of these things?

Courtney Andrews

Misinformation is a good one! How do some people feel that they don’t need to listen to science is it just ingrained in some people to have to be right no matter what ?!

Kristina

First timer! Does a person's upbringing have a significant influence on what they believe is true and what sources they will trust?

Kate Stomps

How do flat-earthers believe that gravity works? And day and night? Do they just think map projections are how the world looks, darts and all??

Jessie Dragon

What’s the best way to help people be more open to actual facts and admitting that their ideas could be false?

Brendan Kaylor

Does the way the information is presented matter?

Kathleen Sachs

What advice does he have when it comes to convincing people who are being willfully ignorant to reconsider their opinions? In other words, how do I convince my friend Karen that the coronavirus is real and she needs to wear a mask at the grocery store?

L. Wink

We hear a lot about the Dunning Kruger effect in terms of experts and talking heads on tv. My question is is this the best theory that we should be using to understand the phenomena or are there other effects/studies/go to’s that the general public should keep track of. Thanks!

Morgan Casey

Is willful ignorance worse today than it was 20, 30, 50, 100 years ago or does it just seem like that because the internet gives everyone a platform to tell the world about their own ignorance?

Ashley K.

Is there a correlation between willful ignorance and education, class, age etc?? Are there any common factors when it comes to this phenomenon?

Annie C

Same! WHY????

Bonnie

I just second the questions that have already been asked about if there are any good strategies (at all) to getting through to people who are willfully ignorant

Aarika

What's the best way to argue against willful ignorance? When someone won't believe verifiable facts, how can you start to change their mind? Or at least get them questioning their beliefs?

Bryce

how much does the ego have to do with displays of willful ignorance? is it a conscious choice or is it a subconscious reaction that persists?

Katy V

What is the most successful way to persuade a person away from conspiracy theory-like thinking?

Danielle Dorman

Seconding this question & adding on: If yes, are there some religions where this type of willful ignorance is more commonly observed (or even applauded/encouraged) than others?

Kristina Weaver

Is there a religious component to willfully ignorance. Are religious people more likely than non-religious people to be more willfully ignorant? Are some religions or ideologies better than others at not being willfully ignorant?

Andria Marsh

We all know that talking to people like this can sometimes be like talking to a brick wall, so how? How do we get through to them? Is there a way or are we just doomed?

Peter Venable

Is willful ignorance ever a rational or wise option? When?

Ashley Herbel

What is the best approach to having a civil conversation and present facts to someone willfully ignorant? Or is it futile?

Lucy L.

FTQAsker! With humans being so community-oriented, how is it possible that selfishness to the degree of potential societal ruin hasn't been naturally deselected?

Maria Kumro

How has the internet really affected the things people will believe with no proof? Has it gotten worse, or have we just given the same numbers a platform that they didn't have before?

Jack Kelleher

Why do people believe in religion that can’t be proven but don’t believe in science that can be?

Mangoes And Limes

** FTQA Is there a framework you can use to steer a discussion to avoid arguing, subvert denial and have a fruitful conversation?

Jen A.

Can a single person really do anything in their power to slow down climate change? What are the top two things individuals can do? 🌎🌎🌎

Felix Lasselle

How do you feel about censoring people with these denial mentalities? Do you think it imposes on freedom of speech?

Courtney Malo

*first time question asker!* As a scientist, I sometimes struggle with communicating with non-scientists. How can scientists and other ologists talk with lay public and not come off as a snobbish/know it all?

Tamara Oliver

But like how do we not just explode in frustrated rage when dealing with people like this? How to best react and cope?

Laura

What is/are the main reasons for willful ignorance? Make room for more knowledge in a different field? Just no interest in the subject? Do they believe that ignorance is bliss?

sidney

What's the statistical distribution of willful ignorance? Has evolution played a part in willful ignorance, i.e. could it have been of any use for cavemen and it's carried over into modern humans, or is it a product of our times?

Felix Lasselle

What kind of mental gymnastics are these people doing in order to belligerently go against global scientific consensus?

Trudi La Rose

I came here to ask exactly this.

Michelle Lee

Are there any tactics or approaches to get through this willful ignorance in other people? Often for extreme versions, I feel like there's no hope for a discussion because a discussion means we're operating under the same presumptions of fact/fiction, which is of course not the case in these examples.

Lucy L.

+1 for this. I'm curious about hive-mind and if/how that's a thing for humans. What makes someone a more reliable, believable leader?

Jesse Markowitz

And are there any studies about the efficacy of those strategies?

Elizabeth Rich

Is ignorance actually bliss? Are the willfully ignorant "happier" than those of us that are tuned in to reality? Are the unwillfully ignorant happier than the willfully ignorant?

Jamie Pickles

Yes, this! And more recently too, like since Trump was elected? 🤔

Courtney Jones

Does ignorance come because of a lack of education or parents or adults in your life?

Jen Latimer

As a health educator I've been trained to appeal to aspects such as individual's perceived risks, benefits, susceptibility, locus of control, social norms, and other drivers of beliefs. Where does resistance to persuasion through facts fall in these models of belief?

Zoltán Szászi

How does one identify their own biases, and fight to reduce them? Is there a way for you to burst your own bubble and become better?

Jesse Markowitz

This question literally made my jaw drop. What a great question!

Elizabeth Rich

If it's willful, is it actually ignorance?

Diana Wueger

Is our current moment's embrace of conspiracy theories and willful ignorance significantly different - more widespread, more problematic, more insidious and hard to contradict - than in the past? In other words, is this moment unique, or does every society have this problem? And what historical conspiracy theories or cultish groups do you find especially fascinating?

Davis Born

This may not fit but how do you encourage someone to have greater empathy? Often when faced with certain examples these behaviors (i.e. not wearing masks) I’m just like “I don’t know how else to tell you that you should care about other people!!!”

Courtney Jones

Are there certain characteristics/regions/education levels/religions that are more likely to reject facts? And why?

Devon Robertson

How much of willful ignorance is rooted in fundamental fears of things like "the unknown" or change of a person's comfort zone? Is there something neurologically happening there, like mimicking the feeling of safety after being exposed to fear or danger?

Mariah McGregor

What are the precursors and/or personality traits that are common among people who believe in conspiracies? Paranoia is a commonly cited example but what else drives the likelihood of being convinced of something whacky?

Erin Unson

With so much knowledge at our finger tips (thanks, Internet!), how is willful ignorance still at play? Does the overwhelming amount of knowledge actually make it easier for people to just stick to what they know and not open themselves up to scientific truth?

Morgan Casey

Can you explain how willful ignorance is similar/dissimilar to cognitive dissonance?

Sara Holburt

Ooh cool topic! My question: Is ignorance a product of nature or nurture?

Kayleigh Douglass

What is the best way to approach a discussion/conservation with someone about topics such as climate change denial, flat-earth, chem trails, etc.?

Kjersti Chippindale

Mistrust of authority must play some role in this, right? Is there a way to "science" our way out of that mistrust, or do governments just need to get better PR teams?

Jesse Markowitz

How do we know that facts aren’t? (Aside from, I’m sure, our many anecdotes.) Are facts are all a necessary component of mind-changing? Or are they just completely besides the point?

juliebear

How has the Internet made this worse?

Shannon Ball

What are the most effective strategies for combating willful ignorance and actually changing people's minds?

Jesse Markowitz

Isn’t the point that they actually *don’t* live in a state of cognitive dissonance? That’s why it’s so willful!

Bentley the trans lator Bignell

Oh the proverbial people that take the blue pill! I drive by a sign for Flat Earth Canada twice a day 5 days a week Wonder every day why people can believe it! Is it just trying to fit in sometime?

Kieryn

How much did the rise in internet use contribute to more conspiracy theories/more people believing them and how can we use the internet to stop the spread of misinformation?

Michael Aiguier

How do traumatic incidents in youth affect one's stability in adulthood?

juliebear

Should we be more worried about the apathetic / low-information people who have given up in pursuit of the truth? Or more worried about the warmongerers on truth?

Molly Wyss

First timer! When do you give up on or walk away from someone spouting willful ignorance? In most of the cases I've seen (especially online), there seems to be no point in engaging because many are super entrenched in their beliefs.

Jesse Markowitz

Is it really even possible to change someone’s mind?

Zora Phoenix

How much does fear play a role in the unwillingness to examine facts? Does this behavior relate to a person's desire to have some level of control?

Brendan Kaylor

Why is it so fun to believe in conspiracy theories?

Jenella Dover

Exact same question!!!! Just, why?!

juliebear

What are some good questions to ask people who might be sowing disinformation to get them to question/examine propaganda?

Chloe Chambers

First time question asker! As a science teacher, what more can I do in the classroom to help? Or suggestions for us education folks? I have methods to handle uncomfortable topics such as climate change or evolution, but I had my first flat-Earther experience with a student. Normally I never engage in things like this in front of the kids but I was so curious about why they thought this, despite the rest of the class losing their minds, that I went down the rabbit hole. Didn’t really resolve anything, but made me aware that this (flat Earth people) most definitely are a thing.

Rachel

Is willful ignorance regarding matters such as COVID-19 consistent across the world or are some countries and cultures more suspectible to it?

Trudi La Rose

I've been seeing people suggest we simply ask science deniers why they think the way they do and keep asking why until they can give a coherent answer. Is this a less aggressive way to get across why they are wrong?

Aloi Johnson

*First Time question asker* Is there a part of our lizard brain/ instinct that lights up and rewards ignoring things that may drastically change our worldview? If so, what part is that and how do we fix it?

Kelsey Story

Why are people so willing to believe in 'wellness therapies' such as cleanses to remove 'toxins' from our bodies (uh, thanks liver), but so resistant to facts from actual health professionals? Is there something these Instagram charlatans are doing right that healthcare should be doing?

Natalie Rhoades

First-time question.. and what a relevant topic, wow. I get really uncomfortable seeing social media "friends" feed the misinformation machine and it takes a lot of energy to choose to respond, let alone write a response that doesn't come across insultingly as "you're not using your brain, please use your brain". Do you think it's worth engaging online when you know you're probably shouting into the void and opening yourself up to ridicule that is damaging to your mental health? Or is that the acceptable cost? Maybe it depends on the topic of misinformation? OMG and what if they're family???

Meghan Amsberry

Do people truly believe these things or is it a front?

Joel Michello

Is this Ology related to the Dunning-Kruger effect? I have discussed this with friends, some of which are PhD's in a variety of areas, and they relate that it is prevalent even in supposed "highly intelligent" people. Very scary.

juliebear

How much of willful ignorance is a result of man wanting to exert power and control others? (Thinking back to how the Catholic Church made Galileo recant prompted this question.)

Hydee Reeves

What has changed so much in America that “democrat” and “republican” have become synonymous with “morally okay” (d) and “morally wrong” (r)?

Erin Maglecic

How much of a role does fear play?

Katy Bock

Is there a correlation between level of education and someone's likely hood to participate in ignorant behaviors?

tamara brodinsky

First time writing here... Historically, do you believe that this willful ignorance is just a revisionist wave? Is it worse than ever thx to the unethical social media giants, or can we have some hope? Man. I hope we can hope ...

Jessica Craver

Is there a good way to handle talking with someone on a subject like refusal to wear a mask when any slight mention just makes them very angry and worked up and they are seemingly incapable of hearing any reason?

Stacie Collier

**FTQA Is willful ignorance related to the concept of bullshit (as posited by Harry Frankfurt and others)?

Urban Nature Walk

Can this be changed, on either an individual or societal level? Are we too far gone? Are all facts suspect forever?

juliebear

So much happens that we don't measure/observe—heinous crimes, microbiology, astronomy, etc... how do we overcome this stupid bias that some people have that if they don't see/observe/measure it themselves that it didn't or isn't happening?

Emily Meredith Lewis

FTQA: How much does vulnerability play into it vs entitlement?

Amanda J

Is willful ignorance more common for people with depression/anxiety? Sometimes I feel like I just can't take in anymore information and with so much condraticting info on a subject I just want to disengage.

Joel Michello

I have not found any tactics as yet and I concur with the "No Hope" feeling.

Anne Simonen

I've seen an article online about the connection between conspiracy and spirituality. Is there actually a link between what you believe from a spiritual perspective and what you believe from a scientific perspective?

Katy Baker-Smith

First timer...when did science become something to dismiss? Why do people feel that science is something to be believed? This is what I struggle with. I adore science and it hurts that so many people seem to want to destroy it.

Sara Amish

What is the level of self awareness of social ignorance? Do we know, at some level, that we are ignoring reality?

Mara Rosenbloom

FTQA: how exactly would earth as we know it be different if it were indeed flat? I.e. gravity? Speed? Light?

Euan Munro

Ask this please 😊

Sheri Bueler

Is it just the people that can't know? LOL! Were they just taught incorrectly as children by a trusted person (not so educated parent) and just didn't learn better later in life? I'm truly baffled by this behavior.

juliebear

Deep fakes and shallow fakes—how utterly f*cked are we?

Emily Arnold

Ahhh, this! I've heard people say things like "Comment to change the minds of people on the fence, not the person spreading the misinformation." But then you still have to get into it with the "friend" doing the spreading. And if feels overwhelming when they're armed with so much non peer-reviewed junk from all sorts of sources and it's SO effortful to dig up actual peer-reviewed and respected counterpoints from legitimate sources.

Marcy W

Is ignorance really bliss? A lot of people seem so angry!

Hannah Johnson

**FTQA. Has there been any research about the demographics of people who are more likely to be science-deniers? Do we see significant differences across gender, education level, income, etc.?

Louis Goldberg

Don't we all practice some sort of willful ignorance? If so, do you have any tips to recognize and combat it in ourselves?

Anna Gregory

In your opinion, whose responsibility is it to bring awareness to those who hold unsupported/misinformed ideas? Is it the individuals responsibility? The educational systems? Media? Government? --- ultimately what pathway should we be following to reduce ignorance?

Emily Arnold

Have people always been this way? Quick to latch on to whatever theory or idea is in their best interests (whether to maintain their own status quo, or to distance themselves from the "other")? Or are we just able to see this more because in the age of social media, everyone has the ability to publish their opinions for the world to see?

Cameron Siewert

Oooomg this is a THING? I have SO many questions, most of which look like they've already been asked, but here's one I haven't seen: is there a version of "willful ignorance" in any other species? Scenarios where members of another species seem to ignore a clear threat or diverge into groups that may act in ways that are obviously counter to their best interests? Or is this exclusively a phenomenon that coincides with self-awareness/self-consciousness?

Jennasis

Raising a kid in this age of rampant stupidity is difficult. Any tips on how to raise my smollogist to be a critical thinker or what resources to give her to do her own fact checking?

Michelle Lee

Can you speak to the groups (social, economic, etc) that willful ignorance is often observed in? I think too often willful ignorance is written off as a characteristic of people of a low socioeconomic status (those in economic or educational poverty) but clearly there are "highly educated" individuals who seem to blatantly deny fact + research. Is there any study or research done about this dichotomy?

Kelsey Stenglein

Yes!! Similar question. Do you have any advice for dealing with family/friends who aren't taking this pandemic seriously? It is so draining to always be the one saying we can't do the thing because it's not safe.

Angela Cohen

Are there any tips on how to cope with the massive uptick in willful ignorance? I find it to be emotionally draining to constantly see illogical conspiracy theories about anything and everything. The people who believe in them are so set on their belief that they don't listen to reason and often criticize logic 🙄😔

Christina Nichols

Why does it seem (to me) that the science-deniers are so much more comfortable spouting their brand of wacko than I (and others around me, it seems) am bringing up scientific facts? Is it because I'm often in spaces where the deniers are the mainstream culture? And if so... how does a culture/place shift so that the science-supporters are louder than the science-deniers? and/or how do I as one person deal with ALL THE DENIERS?!?! (TLDR: Send help!)

Ember

It seems like this is so related to trust. How can scientists/professionals/etc. start to build trust among those practicing willful ignorance?

Jennasis

If you had to pick, which outlandish false statement is your more rage inducing.

Alyssa DeForest

Hi Alie! My dad (although I love him so much) is unapologetically a climate change denying Trump supporter who firmly believes Obama will be in prison within the year. So many of the facts he denies "make sense" meaning that they are in line with how he sees himself and the world, and as a human, he is inclined to reject, rationalize, or ignore information that threatens his identity / world view. Recently however, I've noticed that his deny-er trend is going rogue. One example is when I shared with him some of the incredible facts I learned from the ants episode, he told me that NONE of them were real. He just believed nothing of what I said. Why!?!? In short, are there different kinds of denial? Are there levels? Why is my dad turning into somebody who rejects any information that he doesn't already know? This radicalization of denial is really pushing us apart, maybe Dr. Proctor can help me understand what's happening inside my Dad's brain??

D. B. Narveson

Within the realm of willful ignorance, how important is it that a person find others who think the same way they do? Without the ability to connect with people on the internet, would there be fewer flat-earthers, climate change deniers, etc.?

Erin Ryan

How can we connect/relate to these people in a way that will change their minds?

Amanda Richards

First time (rambling) question asker. I'm not sure how to phrase it, but I'm curious as to the thought process of those on the "MAGA" train, who are pro wall/concentration camps/etc and still think that they are doing "God's work" (I may or may not have several family members on this train..). How do they ignore the blatant disregard for humanity and support these things? I can't understand how they choose not to see it. (Totally understand if this one doesn't get read 😂)

Fwaeldling

oh this episode is gonna hurt right?? Cuz to protect my trust in humanity I tend to willfull ignore these ignorant peeps..

Michael Nichols

Is it morally wrong to feed their conspiracy theories in a way that encourages them to act in a positive way, such as explaining that facial recognition systems are trivially defeated by wearing masks whenever you’re in public or suggesting that they ride a bicycle instead of drive a car to make them harder to track?

juliebear

Why do most men think they understand women? But serious question—In fact, why do we (myself included) presume to know much about anyone else? It it because our brains need to simplify and categorize things and people to be efficient in living?

Kate Coldren

How do you learn to differentiate between opinion and fact and when does a person tend to develop this? Grade school? College? Never? Why is this different depending on the culture that a person grows up in?

Becca Bee

Ooh boy. What's the reason this happens to some of us? I want to know all the facts about all the things, but when it comes to certain people, I don't ask, I don't try to find out things. I avoid his street, or when I can't, I look away. He's an ex now, but even when we were together I didn't want to know who he was with. WHY?? I literally used the term 'willfully ignorant' to describe myself over the past 4 years.

Halley Nani

Is it possible to change willful ignorance in a population? Can you start with systematic changes with individuals and work your way to larger groups, or vice versa?

Laura Stacey

Can we do anything to help people become better critical thinkers on a large scale? Build something into general education? Because of the evolutionary history that has lead us to have such strong social dependence it feels a bit hopeless

Coleen Crouch

What's the most productive way to work through differences without creating additional stress on relationships? Are they any methods that have been proven to change willful ignorance?

Ethan Stoller

(eek, first time questioner!) How much of a role does the fear of the end of white hegemony play in today’s brand of willful ignorance? Whenever I try to trace the origins for this behavior it’s always distilled down to one common factor - racism.

Hilary Larson

Thank you for asking this! As a mega perfectionist, sometimes I HAVE to let things go (ignore minor errors) in order to move along with a project. Same theory applied to stopping indulging my ex's onslaught of text messages post breakup... no response turned out to be a more effective message than continuously trying to tell them, "it's over."

Mark Calonico

Does countering with facts/research make any difference to someone whose confirmation biases are already locked in? What responsibility to scientists have in communicating differently with those in denial?

Martha

Why do our knee-jerk reaction tend to be denial?

V.E. Griffith

(A little humor here.) When I run into these people, my two responses are to either set my hair on fire or gouge out my eardrums so I don't have to listen to so much brain-melting nonsense. Which is the better option?

Jessica Kanani

In an effort to gently correct family, I have become a pariah and likely permanently damaged relationships. As a scientist, I couldn't just sit back and let ridiculous ideas like microchipped vaccines go unaddressed though. It is so hard.

juliebear

How do we persevere in trying to promote truth, knowing that we won't change others' harmful, deep-seated beliefs?

Kevin Lahey

2nd time question asker! (I forgot to say it was my first question last time) How can we discriminate between people who are willfully ignorant and those that are "reachable"? Wondering in the context of science communication and trying to educate people about science.

Ruby Johnstone

Is willful ignorance usually considered to be a self preservation behavior, and if so, are there any good examples of it protecting people on a large scale?

Sasha VanDyk

Can evidence ever change the opinion of someone who is wilfully ignorant? Or will they always believe anything that goes against what they think is fake?

Aaron M

Is an intrinsic failure of Bayesian Modelling at play here? Or are models and updates still running normally, just on different data sets?

Cate Strehlow

Connected to this question, why do fact-based arguments seem to make them dig in more? Is it psychological? A fight (of their fight or flight options)?

Jessica Kanani

What responsibility do you think people spreading these types of ideas should hold, socially or potentially criminally? I'm thinking people with a large platform like Alex Jones. Do these people actually believe what they're spreading or are they just preying on people's willful ignorance?

Natalie Rhoades

That resonates so intensely, Jessica. Family gatherings have changed (and get smaller) and that's really disheartening, but some things are truly too ridiculous to not address.

Jessica Kanani

ugh. yes. It really all comes down to this question.

Sarah Iannucci

How can we overcome confirmation bias?

MacKenzie Campbell

How do conspiracies that have been proven wrong long ago pop up centuries later like flat-earthers? Is this a new theory or have there been flat earthers since the dawn of time and they're just seen now because of the internet?

SUTTON TAGGART

How much does fear play in continuing people's willingness to believe such radically false things? Including fear of being excluded from their "tribe"?

Dawn Zwart

I just want to know why willful ignorance is so rampant with Trump supporters? I have long time friends and even briefly dated (a complete d-bag) Trump supporter who are “so over” this and “it is all fake news” and “God will take care of them” and I am beside myself confused at how they think that because they do not acknowledge the virus that they are somehow immune to it. What the actual Fuck? No name please. I don’t want anyone to know I dated a Trump supporter.

Allison Tuuri

What are the factors that influence this type of behavior? Is it societal, personality based, upbringing based, etc ?

Susan Webb

1st timer: The internet. Facebook. How might we "react" without simply turning the worst offenders off and thus simply reinforcing all the Bubbles (theirs and mine)? Suggestions?

Amber Cooper

Is willful ignorance a result of social rejection? This might be a huge rabbit hole, but it seems like most of the ignorant people I know have really low self esteem and very few friends.

Davy R

Can they actually be persuaded to see the truth??

Cate Strehlow

This! Also a science teacher. My example was going to be that the moon landing was faked, and after a while, I just said, "Look, it's a conspiracy theory that is anti-science B.S. [bologna sandwich]."

Silvia Triverio

Oh, boy, what an ology! How to define the line between survival mode and irresponsibility when intentionally ignoring the news and it’s tragedies?

Nicole

I’m working on my thesis surrounding misconceptions in STEM right now, so this is right on brand. What, in your opinion, is the most effective method to help people change their belief system? I’ve seen a lot of short term improvements with conceptual change models, but it’s so difficult to get someone to change their hardcore stances.

AssortedGeekery

1st timer! I'm a high school science teacher, and I encounter a lot of trouble when we get to evolution. How do I handle explaining the topic to my students in a way that doesn't immediately say 'well, your parents are idiots'?

Todd Peterson

So, my brother-in-law is literally a "used car salesman" type (in fact, he has had that job previously.) I get the feeling that he actually believes the crap that comes out his mouth (as well as the Fox News crap he repeats.) Is there any evidence that "willfully ignorant" people truly believe their own b.s.?

Leanna Shuster

First of all WTAF?!?! But more constructively, are there methods actually shown to work to help people get past will fully ignorance and how do we minimize this for future generations?

Nicole

ALSO! Side note, the Behind the Curve documentary on Netflix really helped me understand flat-earthers— at first I was furious, but after watching that I understand that people who operate on the fringe beliefs (conspiracies and flat earths and lizard people of the sorts) usually get further marginalized and isolated with their thoughts, and since no one is engaging them with the correct information and they’ve isolated themselves from everyone that has a different set of beliefs, it’s really easy to retreat to the community bubbles that have the same belief set (like Infowars... or cults...). Super interesting stuff that should help inform how we communicate science.

Elizabeth M Stovall

What are some concise ways to counter dis/misinformation being touted by those with more credentials than you? For example, when someone with a P.h.D. goes on YouTube to claim that flu vaccines increase your chances of contracting Covid-19, and you know that it's bunk but you do not have a P.h.D.

Heather Shaver

What do you think of the Terror Management Theory as an explanation? (Ie when we are confronted with our own mortality in a more real way, we respond by trying to protect ourselves in our symbolic realities... which can lead to more racism, self-protective instincts, higher prejudice, and deeper allegiance to polarizing viewpoints and politics)

Kerri -Leigh

What makes people so willing to believe any old thing that they are on Facebook that might propagate a conspiracy theory but not believe things that are well backed with research? Is it just personal bias?

Michelle Mitchell

FTQA: What a timeless ology! I have questions! (1) How can I make sure I do not become one of the willfully ignorant? (2) How do I make sure I'm not following or buying into bullshit? (3) Is it possible to have a productive conversation with someone you love that is among those willfully ignorant (assuming I'm not, of course!) and (4) What tools can I give my kiddo for not taking everything at face value? Thanks for all you do, Alie and everyone! I love love love this podcast!

Sarah James

What is the most easily-debunked thing people continue to believe?

Nikki DeMarco

Is there a name for a type of person I call a Disney Princess? By that I mean someone who is happy to live in a fairytale land and get dressed by birds and chipmunks and actively avoid unpleasant news.

Alyssa Royse

Not really "ology" related, technically, but I'm wondering if Doctor Proctor has seen the opening sequence of Idiocracy, and if it scared him, or made him laugh. It made me laugh for a minute, and then.... well...

Sarah James

When is it NOT worth correcting mistaken beliefs? Do you think that some beliefs with little or no evidence can be mostly good by bringing comfort to people who believe them? Is every mistaken or debunked belief a problem?

mckenzie faas

Fascinating! Living in the RED-DIRT, RED-BLOODED, RED, RED, RED, gun and bible-clutching state of Oklahoma, I find myself constantly at a loss that so many people in my community are unwilling to believe truth (aka PAINSTAKING RESEARCH) over the obvious bullshit. My anxiety levels have skyrocketed in the past month as people in my state gleefully, almost smugly, reconviene in bars and gyms en masse. I'm genuinely afraid of being harrased for going out while wearing a mask. So, I suppose my question is: how do we deal with people like this on a regular basis without wanting to pull our hair out and scream? As much as I want people to understand the data-backed truth, I don't want to expend all of my energy trying to change someone's mind when they're as stubborn as a tick.

Kevin Beamer

FTQA - I volunteer at a museum where we present astronomy-related information, and do solar observing when weather and viruses allow. We occasionally encounter visitors who espouse things like the earth is flat or the moon landing was a hoax. We've been given guidance as to how to talk with those visitors, but I'd like to know if Dr. Proctor has any advice for how to handle those conversations, especially when there are other visitor around who may not know the facts from the bunk.

Dane Schuckman

As a parent who wants to leave a better world for our childen how much faith can we realistically put in Max Planck's principle of generational change? “A new scientific truth does not triumph by convincing its opponents and making them see the light, but rather because its opponents eventually die, and a new generation grows up that is familiar with it."

Heather Munday

How do I spot and stop this kind of thinking in myself? Thank you!

Kelly King

Is there even a point to trying to share facts with someone who is set in their beliefs?

Thomas N Wyndham

Why are people like in the fossil fuel industry allowed to get away with starting misinformation?

Heather Schier

What is the best technique to convincing a wilfully ignorant person that they can trust science?

Seth Suchy

How can someone just flip a switch and go from accepting masks and social distancing are a good thing, to thinking it's a lie to control us within a span of like 3 days?

Jessica Kanani

Is it better to ignore willful ignorance, or to call it out? It seems like drawing attention to people's beliefs, no matter how contradictory to fact, sometimes makes them even more resistant to change and potentially gives them ammo to "convert" more people.

Katarzyna Pylat

What is the best way to challenge ignorance and encourage actual learning?

Katarzyna Pylat

Is giving examples helpful. I'm a doctor and I've seen some tragic things including death in children who were not vaccinated. The mother of one of them regretted her decision so bad! And yet when I give the example to antivaxxers ... nada!

Katarzyna Pylat

Also, sorry. How do I stop myself from becoming infuriated?!

Andrew Pedersen

One of the things I've seen a lot from science deniers is a conviction that scientists have ulterior motives (especially financial) for what they are publishing. What do you think is the best way to counter that thinking? Is there an easy way to determine where a study's authors' funding comes from?

William Andrews

How to get a person to get out the sound bite answers need? So many people want a simple answer to a question to prove or disprove something. Related, how to deal with explaining something that has "multiple moving parts" as it were? Society has moved away from the old format of "Let me explain things as I see it" for 10-30 minutes, then it is your turn, then my turn. Also, how deal with and ever so gentle point out to some one logical troubles with things. (Strawman arguments, ad hom, non seq, etc.)

Brenna Ziebol

What's the appeal to these essentially faith based opinions/beliefs? Is there even a way to stop this phenomenon?

Andrew Pedersen

You hear a lot of "Scientists have been wrong before, so why are they right now?" what's the best counter argument to that?

juliebear

What topic is the most frivolous waste of time to debate about with someone and it might be better if we were all just willfully ignorant rather than pour time and money into? I am so very tired of seeing the debate about whether or not "squirting" is real, just pee, etc.

Heather Densmore

How do you respond to: ‘but there are experts on both sides’?

William Andrews

My advice would be to say: "I can address your personal concerns 1 on 1 at the end. Please let me get through the things in this presentation."

Nicole Kuha

In your opinion, what is the most concerning example of willful ignorance at the present time?

juliebear

I just realized this is sort of ... an OLOGY ON FLIM-FLAM!

ML

As a scientist (and I'm sure many science-supporters feel this way too), it's difficult not to challenge ignorance with evidence based ideas. But, this approach rarely seems to improve the situation. How can we personally, or as a society, counter these disbeliefs?

Julia

Is there a correlation between education level and willful ignorance?

MissKitti

I have too many words and feelings. Thank you. Thank you for covering this ology. Thank you.

Arianna Mattson

It seems that there are more white males that practice willful ignorance, is this true and is there a cause? How big of a factor is organized religion, education and economic status? Can we do anything to help them fix their thinking on a wides scale or is this something that happens in waves throughout history?

Kai Kishimoto

Does the US have the highest concentration of people who are anti-science, or does it just seem that way?

Breauna Sanchez

What type of character background (childhood, economic, culture, etc) is most likely to be willfully ignorant?

Queen Jean

I'm so excited for this episode! I have so many thoughts swimming in my head. How do you navigate willful ignorance with family/loved ones when you don't want to argue and you know that research shows that arguing with people with fringe views only reinforces those views? It hurts my heart to have people I love believing irrational theories.

Charlie Shrimplin

When an individual is ignoring or denying information on topics, do you see a critical analysis occurring with those who deny the information presented to them?

Rachael Thompson Panik

Is willful ignorance driven by a particular value system or set of beliefs or personality trait?

karen blaisdell

As a science teacher, how do I tolerate my flat Earth, anti-vaxxer, essential oils cures everything, China is after us, sister?

poppy

Is there an evolutionary or biological root to this behavior? Like did our brains develop to keep us from dwelling on scary things as a coping mechanism so early humans didn't just curl up in a ball of anxiety and were able to get out to hunt and gather.

Rosa

Are there certain types of political/social structures that cause more ignorance to flourish in some types of societies more than others?

Wayne Brantley

Is there ANY way to convince someone, that you know in your heart, a person in their life is toxic and dangerous, but they persist on walking around with "rose-colored glasses" and deflect and ignore you? Asking for a friend.

Corrie Navis

Has it always been the way it seems to be now, or has social media (etc.) just allowed us to be more aware of willful ignorance in recent years? If it has become more prevalent, what is thought to have driven that shift?

Rosa

There are people who are willfully ignorant, and then there are also people who are just very gullible and don't investigate their sources. How do you tell the difference between these types of people? And how do you approach talking to them about real science according to which of those categories they are in?

Earl of Greymalkin

How would we recognize/fight willful ignorance happening in our own brains? And how do we not despair for the future of humanity?

Rosa

Ignorance can be very damaging and can lead to real life violence, hate crimes, and more. Are people who intentionally perpetuate ignorance more likely than the average person to also be involved with other deviant or criminal behavior?

Doug Stewart

It's been shown that knowing you're susceptible to advertising doesn't make you less susceptible. It can actually make you more susceptible. Is the same true for willful ignorance? Or does knowing inoculate you in some fashion? And if not, what can I do?

Katie Winchester

I'm somebody who left the religion I was raised in and managed to do a 180 on many things I'd believed. I did that in my early 20's, and I'm wondering if there's an age limit to that kind of 'realising I was wrong' and a willingness to change my mind? It seems like older people are treated as a lost cause.

Rosa

Does willful ignorance go hand-in-hand with low amounts of empathy? For example, promoting or buying into fake news about covid seems to signify not caring much for others' suffering, plus a lot of fake news has gone towards racism which contributes to suffering along racial lines.

Ronan

Why does this happen? What creates these people? I've heard that a lot of the time alt-science people are usually smart, like medical doctors who believe COVID-19 comes from radio towers or whatever, why is this the case?

SamSo

First time question asker :) I feel like willful ignorance has taken up a larger roll in the US in the recent years - what is the history of this, what were the things that led to this? Are there records of communities and societies that were able to overcome widespread ignorance and distrust of science? How can we engage with people who are willfully ignorant in a way that is productive, especially when it seems that a whole portion of the population doesn't care about the basic rights and wellbeing of others? What are ways that we can become more self-aware of our own willful ignorance? I know that was a $h*t ton of questions - I'm just so excited to learn about this topic - especially as public health professional. Thank you Alie and the whole ologies team :)

Ed Matesevac

To steal your phrase “oh boy howdy” do I have a few. 1. Is there any relationship between the Dunning-Kruger effect and willful ignorance? Like is there a correlation either direct or indirect or are they mutually exclusive? 2. How does ingroup social norming or norms engineering factor in? 3. Is being willfully ignorant amplified by certain cognitive biases such as sunk cost fallacy or availability/confirmation bias? 4. Is this purely a conscious phenomenon or are there structural or chemical brain pattens common among this cohort? Thanks for all you do!

Timothy Dykes

Is there a correlation to region and level of willful ignorance? I plan on moving to another state someday and want to pick a good one.

Ted Vician

What is the benefit to the individual who is "willfully ignorant"? What do they get out of it?

Chase Penix

I see confirmation bias and willful ignorance going hand in hand. How do you successfully point that out when someone is trying to “prove” to me that birds are actually extinct and all that’s left are government spy drones?

Brad del-Munns

Will Darwinism take care of the willfully ignorant or will they, like cockroaches, prevail?

Josh Beatty

FTQA: People often complain that their right to free free speech is being violated when they're censored or deplatformed by Facebook or Twitter for spreading misinformation. What obligation, if any, do social media companies have to uphold the rights of citizens of democratic countries, and where does that mesh with these companies' obligation to not be a launching point for fake news and potentially harmful misinformation?

Samantha Heinicke

Is selective hearing related to this? If so, is selective hearing more prevalent in males or females?

Frank

I'm old enough to remember during the 60's and 70's the distrust of the government, medical experts and corporate spokesman that I believe was at that time justified. It seems that this distrust has moved from leftists to the extreme right. Could it be partially explained by the aging of my Boomer generation?

Nicole Howley

Has the internet increased rates of skepticism? (No clue how you would measure this) I feel like people are able to put more of their ideas out there without question and people looking for information to confirm their beliefs have more access to less reputable sources. Would love to hear thoughts on the Dunning-Kruger curve.

Deli Dames

Any tips on how to check what topics you may be willfully ignorant about?

Sneaky Hamster

What are the best ways to address willfull ignorance

Teagen Andrews

Oh heck yes! What I want to know is, Is the rise in fact checking/fact checkers actually making willful ignorance worse? Does it make people who know they're wrong dig in deeper or only seek out facts that support their belief? Or does fact checking make people stop and change course?

Kelly Semon

How does the research we have concerning vaccine hesitancy and best practices for respectfully bringing vaccine hesitant parents back from the brink of anti-vax denialism apply to today’s polarized environment? How do we find the balance between cautiously approaching those who’ve been misinformed while also quickly disseminating possibly life saving information (ie potential risks of HCQ or unprescribed insulin!)?

Kata Zarándy

Man! I've been thinking about this lately, especially because of my older family members... How do you become prone to contheos? Is it age related? Does it matter how religious you are? Family (if you are married, or a parent)? Upbringing? Political views? Does everyone have one stubborn idea?

Kata Zarándy

How old are conspiracy theories?

R Holmes

My older family members are all mathematicians and engineers, but lately they've become climate change deniers, sprinkled with a bit of conspiracy theory on top. How can highly educated people suddenly turn like this? Is it simply because grandpa discovered Youtube, or is something deeper at play?

tamara brodinsky

If we measure and prove and show that these fake facts and conspiracy theories are spread by bad players (or simply put - putin's bots and trolls), is there any research measuring the effect of it/ will it change someone's mind?

Wild Honey

Ah man! This is so interesting!! I would like to know, is it human nature to be sceptical or trusting? i.e. was it evolutionarily beneficial to believe what we were told by those "in charge" or was it better to question everything?

Clare Dean

It is common to hear the idea that, as people age, they become entrenched in their beliefs and opinions. How true is this? Is there a general relationship between age/experience and how a person responds to new or conflicting information? Thank you :-)

Jonathan Malinconico

I have heard taking on these views by going to the extreme of even their own views will make them rethink their own opinion, is there any truth to this? (first-time excited question asker!)

Troy Langknecht

****How do we get through to people who ignore and deny science? How do we change their minds, or should we even try??

Jeanne Blue

How much does the repeal of the Fairness Doctrine, allowing mass media outlets to focus on one view, and one view only, contribute to furthering these "beliefs"? Or does feeling the need to present "both sides" make it worse. How can there be both sides to decided science.

Jeanne Blue

Also, do people really BELIEVE, or do they present these theories as mere contrarians? Fred Singer, the initial climate denier, WAS a scientist, and a noted contrarian who would argue against anything. You should shout out to the podcast Drilled, which explored the concerted efforts by the oil and gas industry, represented by American Petroleum Institute, to connect fossil fuels with patriotism and climate concerns to crazy tree-hugging liberals. Also, listen to how they learned from and built on anti-science marketing by Big Tobacco. In the 50's, after studies showing cancer links, doctors were telling the public that cigarettes are GOOD for people. (And the cigarette filters that finally came from the health concerns were MANUFACTURED by Chevron and 'big oil') Whew, can't wait for this one.

Michael Ellsworth

What differences are there between ideologically-motivated false beliefs (climate change denial) and more-or-less crazy, random, misinformed, ones (UFOs)? Is it possible to engage with ideologically-motivated false beliefs without debating with the ideology itself?

Ashley Moore

How do you try to explain to those closest to you the reality of disease risk, climate change, racism, etc. etc. etc., without alienating them? I feel that staunch science-deniers are so stubborn and defensive that even mentioning these things will turn into them shutting down or yelling for no reason!

Britta Nelson

1. If you want to change someone's mind, what kind of information or presentation of information is most likely to accomplish this?

Britta Nelson

2. Can you speak to the Venn diagram of people who maintain these false beliefs or debunked theories, and religious extremism in the United States?

Adrienne Hollister

I am really excited for this one and have so many questions (see comments below).

Adrienne Hollister

1- How do we know when we're deceiving ourselves? I have spent way too much time in fruitless internet debates with climate change deniers, antivaxxers, and (more recently) COVID-conspiracy theorists. But I also used to believe some crazy things myself. Example: I grew up in a very conservative church, and was taught many supposedly "scientific" reasons behind creationism (or the more scientific-sounding "intelligent design"). My beliefs and worldviews have radically changed since then, but this huge shift in perspective has left me wondering how I can ever know if *anything* is true. As an ologist, my go-to source is generally peer-reviewed science, but it's impractical to look up the original scientific paper for every single piece of knowledge that we take for granted (i.e. can you cite the original paper proving that the earth revolves round the sun?). Furthermore, humanity's beliefs (both scientific knowledge and ethical views) have COMPLETELY shifted over the decades/centuries/millennia. So how can we be certain of ANYTHING? And how do we know when we're intentionally deceiving ourselves, or if we're just working with the best (albeit incomplete) evidence we have?

Adrienne Hollister

2- How do you convince someone of something if they don't even trust science? Are these debates just pointless?

Adrienne Hollister

3- What are the most dangerous/exasperating/frustrating false beliefs that you've studied/heard? Climate change deniers and antivaxxers spring to mind, but I'm sure there are a ton more.

Megan Younce

No questions other than "why?" but I'm excited and scared for this fascinating topic!!

Jack Brownfield

Is there any evolutionary benefit to willful ignorance? (I'm so excited for this topic!)

Holly Andrews

I study climate change and find this topic fascinatingly frustrating. Is there a connection between gender, class, religion, ethnicity, sexuality, political affiliation, etc., and willful ignorance? Saw an article the other day that wearing masks was seen as "emasculating" to many men and so they were more likely to choose not to wear one, wondering if that applies to willful ignorance broadly. I also wonder if there is a cultural connection to willful ignorance i.e. more individualistic vs. collectivistic cultures, cultures that value freedom vs. order, etc.

Makenna Hopwood

How do I refrain from punching climate change deniers in the face? Lol but seriously is there any chance of convincing them of facts or are they hopeless? Am I wasting my energy?

Rachael Cavanagh

How many of these deniers actually believe in what they say? How many are spreading what they know to be lies? Can we even get a number on this?

Ann Over

How much denying is driven is driven by genetics, how much by environment? (FTQA)

Sara Satkowiak

1st timer! How much does willful ignorance stem from a desire to hold themselves above the “sheeple” and feel better/superior about themselves? Or does it serve a more fundamental psychological purpose about the amount of control they feel they have over their lives? Most likely a blend of both?

Liz Moretti

FTQA here! My question is similar to Sara Satkowiak's but with much less clarity. What is in it for them? Is it the need to be right? Is it denial? Brainwashing? All of the above? And last, but probably never least, how do I not lose my shit over the absurdity of it all?!

Teresa Gleason

Is there a correlation between willful ignorance and people’s education level, age or life experience?

Kasia Wisniewski

Just became a Patreon! 1st ever question! Woohoo! Why are people so willing to just not accept hard proof? How can I go about having a conversation with someone with these beliefs that maybe won't get confrontational? I work for a company for my work terms for University that monitors greenhouse gasses with a satellite at a facility size level and I can tell you from experience, there's a lot of shit going into the atmosphere (Checkout GHGSat Inc, cause they're super cool..)

Vikki Timler

Just tell me there is a cure!

possum girl

My friend's mom feeds stray cats and wild birds in her backyard, even though she knows cats kill tons of birds. What's up with that?

Jeanine Moore

A painful lack of basic science education

Hardy Kern

Are there cases where being doubtful is advantageous?

Emily

As someone who is in a field where I depend on people trusting my expertise (veterinarian),how can I persuade others that my education and experience really is more valuable than their google search/husband's uncle/what that guy at the pet store said?

Charli

Is ignorance truly bliss? Could willful ignorance be considered something of a stoic pursuit? How did we first identify a case of willful ignorance vs. outright ignorance?

Nicole Story

What's the best way to get through to people who seem denser than a brick wall and are unwilling to accept facts? Trying to educate/debate with these folks makes me want to smash my head on said brick wall.

Caitlyn Powell

Has this been a constant phenomenon in society and we're more aware because of the internet or is it really increasing as of late? And what research is being done on the societal ramifications?

AK

What is your favorite or most impactful cognitive bias?

Jennasis

283 questions already asked :)