Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Agnotology is the study of willful ignorance and is a term coined by Stanford professor, Dr. Robert Proctor. 

https://www.sup.org/books/title/?id=11232

We happen to have had this scheduled for a few weeks, and I'm talking to him later today. Leave questions below. Also this week's episode is a two-part celebration of #BlackBirdersWeek and will be out later tonight -- I'm just running a little behind with it. 

Be safe and stand strong. 

Ol' Popsward

Comments

Will Plewa

Favourite cognitive dissonance combos?

Jennasis

Didn't you already call for these questions? Not complaining just checking :)

Kjersti Chippindale

Will questions from the previous call for questions on this topic be used?

Courtney Andrews

I love that this is coming out on black out Tuesday. During times like now we need this ologies

Jennasis

Raising a kid in this age of rampant stupidity is difficult. Any tips on how to raise my smollogist to be a critical thinker or what resources to give her to do her own fact checking?

Sarah James

Can't wait for this one!

Zachery Brown

Is willful ignorance observed in any other species that we know of and if so what are some examples?

Reuben Clamzo

Science denial: why? I understand religious objections, but why would people deny ideas like man made climate change or even that Neil Armstrong landed on the Moon in 1969?

Jennasis

If you had to pick, which outlandish false statement is your most rage inducing.

Francesca Rodriguez

What’s the best way to bring awareness to someone’s willful ignorance? The post polite/effective way to call someone out on their willful ignorance?

Allan Palmer

What's the best way to engage a person or people who are willfully ignorant?

Nadine Duke

Is there a tipping point when a person can’t be willfully ignorant anymore? Is it even possible to get through to someone who is willfully ignoring the truth of a particular topic?

Zoltán Szászi

Dear Dadward, wasn't this call for qusstions already posted? In any case, this is my question: How can one identify their own ignorance and biases, and work to break their own bubble?

AssortedGeekery

First timer: how do I, as a teacher of teenagers, combat willful ignorance without being aggressive with my students?

Teagen Andrews

Oh heck yes! What I want to know is, Is the rise in fact checking/fact checkers actually making willful ignorance worse? Does it make people who know they're wrong dig in deeper or only seek out facts that support their belief? Or does fact checking make people stop and change course?

Schmitty Thompson

How to we get through to people when willful ignorance puts lives at risk?

Samantha G

What is it that makes us feel safe sticking to clearly wrong or disproven information? Why do we get so emotionally charged over being ignorant?

Tracy Michael

Could willful ignorance be considered a coping mechanism, and/or are there other psychological phenomenon that go hand in hand with willful ignorance?

Maria Kumro

Bless this perfect topic choice.

Kate Stomps

How can we combat our own propensities towards willful ignorance? (We all have something.) Why do we dig our heels in so deeply when we are in denial?

Kate Stomps

Less serious: what do flat earthers imagine that the world looks like? A map projection? What?

Emily Okerlund

What’s the best approach to reaching people who are willfully ignorant?

Mae

What can you do to notice the ways that you're ignorant (willful or otherwise) in your own life?

Emily Okerlund

As a teacher of young students, what can I best do to give them the tools they need to avoid willful ignorance in their future, especially when they might be surrounded by it at home?

Jon Erik

Alie! Thank you for all the wonderful work you do with this podcast

Emily Okerlund

Are there any specific qualities/factors that minimize willful ignorance tendencies? If so, what is the best way to instill those qualities in our youth?

Hardy Kern

Is there a cognitive difference between conscious and unconscious willful ignorance?

Michael Aiguier

How much of a person's feeling or need of being unique play into willful ignorance?

Emily Okerlund

Are there any tips on identifying where you yourself are being willfully ignorant? How do we combat this within ourselves?

Sam Merrick

What are the common excuses folks give for their ignorance and how do we respectfully address and breakdown those reasons?

Jessica

I second this!

Ashley Curtin

Are ignorant people using a different part of their brain to process thinking/emotion? Is something like their amygdala more active?

Natalie

Why is it so much easier to ignore evidence and keep arguing even when we know we're wrong than it is to admit we were wrong, listen, and try to learn? Why are humans so opposed to admitting to our own shortcomings or mistakes? Asking for a friend. The friend is me.

Diana Stephens

How much does ego play into willful ignorance? Is it ego or personal paradigm or a combination?

Savannah

I imagine people who are willfully ignorant probably think the opposing views are in turn willfull ignorance. How do we know what is real?

Susan Altman

Do agnotologists also study antidotes to willful ignorance, and if so, what can people do that will actually be effective to change minds? Also, what an excellent and important career!

Laura Stacey

What can we do societally to help people become more critical in their thinking?

karen blaisdell

A friend of mine used to say, "Ignorant people aren't stupid but stupid people are ignorant." I tried to get him to elaborate but he never did, was he just ignorant or stupid? or maybe a little bit of both.

Bennett Vanderbosch

What patterns do we see across history of people being willfully ignorant? Any patterns or recommendations on combatting it?

Joseph Cruz

1st time questioner: Is the Bystander Effect a form of willful ignorance?

Jesse Markowitz

Do more facts/info actually help change someone's mind? Or are they just beside the point or even harmful to the conversation?

Blank

How can you deal with willful ignorance at large scales, not just one-on-one? I think there is a particular ... em ... political organization in America that is very skilled at exploiting this. They play on their audiences desire to believe certain things. It seems like they're trapped in that media bubble, because they will simply ignore and reject anything and anyone that comes from outside that.

Ellen Skelton

Why are people (especially nowadays it seems) so unwilling to admit they're wrong or change their minds?

Emily Taylor

First time question asker! What's the best method for changing someone's mind about something they resist, and how can we harness that to effect change (example: convincing people that man-made climate change is real and is a major threat)?

Rayden Marcum

Who benefits from willful ignorance? Given that convincing people is inherently violent (it's in the linguistic root), what are some models you'd recommend for spreading information and understanding?

Marcel Ward

How much has the Internet been an enabler of willful ignorance? What ways did like minded people find to spread their willful ignorance pre-Internet? And how has this influenced key players' ability to monetise, e.g. through books, talks?

Julianne Gibson

Why are people so quick to believe that they know more than experts and people who have PHDs in certain sciences?

Gwen Kelly

I know it's defined as "willful" which suggest conscious effort, is it always something people are aware that they're doing, or can it be 'willful' but unconscious ignorance (like unconscious bias)? Also, how does this relate to confirmation bias?

Juliette Delforge-Melia

Why aren't more people (including myself!) happy to be corrected on factual issues?

Janna Wisniewski

What are some red flags that I can look for to recognize when I am being willfully ignorant?

Alicia Geilen

First time question asker. Does being willfully ignorant include instances of hypocrisy (e.g., being pro-life and also pro-gun). And Is willful ignorance more common with issues seen as "emotional" or "moral" (e.g. immigration), or are people willfully ignorant on all sorts of topics? Thanks for all your awesome work, Alie!

Cassidy Williams

First time question asker! I saw someone earlier mention the Bystander Effect which we know is common for almost everyone to fall to. Is willful ignorance the same? Is it possible that most will fall to willful ignorance, but in varying degrees? (Ex: flat earthers vs people that ignore racism or credit card debt?) How can we avoid falling into this moat?

Greg

So if willful ignorance/blindness are primarily about self worth/ego, is it possible or are there ways to overcome individuals who are so narcissistic that they can't even acknowledge their ignorance or blindness? Is this a phenomenon that has no counter measure so to speak? I mean, look at what's happening right now as I type this right? How do you get someone who is so insulated and psychotically egotistic to acknowledge they have faults and could change to better themselves if they are too afraid? (I'm also assuming fear plays a big role in this).

Nyx

Many people choose to cling to their beliefs, so is willful ignorance psychologically beneficial/comforting/rewarding in some way? Maybe it is proof of their devotion, like martyrdom?

Arica Starlinger

Favorite example of someone being willfully ignorant and changed?

Sam Correia

does willful ignorance come from a fear of being wrong? how can we encourage people that it's okay to grow and change as as person once we learn new information? how can we emphasize that learning is a process?

Chell

First time question asker - are men more prone to this than women? Thank you for all you do!

Trevor Flowers

How can we teach and encourage younger folks to recognize and address willful ignorance in themselves?

Michael in Seattle

What a great, timely topic. Do you suppose this could explain the reluctance of most men to see a doctor? :)

Cody Albert

Why does it seem like certain groups of people (my older, white, hyper conservative father in law or Boomers) tend to be more willfully ignorant than others? Is it generational or more based on socioeconomic status... or something else? Also, why can’t these types of people recognize when/if they’re being willfully ignorant? Can you ever explain that to them in a way that they will understand, or Is it a lost cause?

Louise

As someone from Asian decent, it's sometimes hard to discuss politics and socioeconomic topics with my parents who grew up in a very conservative time and culture. How can we get past the frustration of willful ignorance to make meaningful conversations with our parents about topics like race inequality?

Nic C

data that contradict their beliefs, still hold on to those beliefs? For example, I have friends who griped about the protests and how it "wasn't doing us (aka me, a black person who my friends somehow feel too comfortable speaking for) any good"...I showed them SO many sources indicating that white supremacist and undercover cop provocateurs are actually responsible for much of the destruction and looting. Their response? "Oh well, I'm sure some of the protesters are doing bad stuff, too" WHY ARE HUMANS LIKE THIS???

Fyllys

First time questioner. How does willful ignorance dovetail with Dunning Kruger syndrome?

Nic C

Also (because I am new to this and did not realize that pressing ENTER did not make more space but instead submitted it) why are we as people so strongly against being proven wrong? In fact, I think counter-evidence makes people double down on their untrue beliefs...is it cultural or evolutionary or...???

Morgan Coburn

How do I best approach and educate my conservative parents that respond with rapid anger and comments in the tune of “all lives matter”

Tallulah Pollard

First time question asker here. What is the best way to confront willful ignorance, in order to dispel it and change it? I’m extremely interested in how best to do that.

Vanessa Vazquez

How can I ensure I am not passing on the willful ignorance of my parents on to my own children? What can and should parents (or educators) focus on to make sure our children grow to be open minded, educated, and thoughtful members of society?

Michelle Lee

Repeating a comment from the original Call for Questions: Can you speak to the groups (social, economic, etc) that willful ignorance is often observed in? I think too often willful ignorance is written off as a characteristic of people of a low socioeconomic status (those in economic or educational poverty) but clearly there are "highly educated" individuals who seem to blatantly deny fact + research. Is there any study or research done about this dichotomy?

Michelle Lee

Are there any tactics or approaches to get through this willful ignorance in other people? Often for extreme versions, I feel like there's no hope for a discussion because a discussion means we're operating under the same presumptions of fact/fiction, which is of course not the case in these examples.

Lynn Rowicki

Can you explain how you test for ignorance and how you determine influencing factors?

Margaret Matera

Is there a pattern to it? Such as religious belief?socio-economics? Community culture?

Emily A

How is willful ignorance related to mental health? Like is avoidance due to anxiety a thing? Also, what do you suggest to dispel unconscious willful ignorance in ourselves?

Silvia Triverio

Oh, boy, what an ology! How to define the line between survival mode and irresponsibility when intentionally ignoring the news and its tragedies?

Silvia Triverio

Why is it sooo hard to admit to others (and often to ourselves) that you don’t know?

Kata Zarándy

Who do this? What's the demographic? Are older folks more prone to it? Do political views or being religious matter? Also can you protect yourself from it? Or does everyone have a blindspot?

Kata Zarándy

How old are conspiracy theories?

Sean Luchs

First timer, here: How does one recognize when someone being willfully ignorant is too far gone? When can a person realize if their energy in reeling someone back is doing any good, and when is it time to cut off and let that person go? Asking for a friend who's had a very rough morning. But also me.

Beth Monaco

We all get attached to our narrative, and it's difficult to accept information that doesn't fit, even though it's ultimately enlightening. But willfully embracing ignorance is different, isn't it? Is willful ignorance rooted in fear? How closely related to conspiracy theories is willful ignorance?

Beth Monaco

This is an awesome ology and I can't wait to learn about it!! Thanks, Alie! I absolutely love your interviews and learning from your awesome guests. I love listening to you while I'm gardening or doing housework. Love!!!

Taylor Lee

What’s the best way of dealing with confrontations with people who are willingly ignorant?

Laura Dusbabek

How does someone get to the point of willful ignorance? I've heard about people in cults engaging in it because to admit some part is wrong is the same as the whole world views is wrong and it's reality shattering.

Suzanne Gurton

Are there any benefits to willful ignorance? It just feels like cutting off your nose to spite your face.

Laura Dusbabek

Can people be groomed into willful ignorance?

Chris Brewer

Would people demonstrating narcissistic traits be more likely to be willfully ignorant?

Kate Ravenson

At which point do we have a communal moral responsibility to step in and - for lack of a better word- force educate the willfully ignorant to realize they're a danger and a threat not only to themselves but others around them? For example, the PA democratic legislator Brian Sims who discovered his Republican counterparts were HIDING the fact that they had tested positive for COVID-19 and were perfectly ok self quarantining and keeping their own families safe, but exposed an unknown number of PA public servants solely because they wanted to push the "re-open America" agenda. At what point does "willful ignorance" become a dangerous cognitive disability that MUST be addressed for the safety of, at this point, the world. Yes, I am coming in hot because that's kinda how I roll? Hey, I am that random intense feeling you have when you KNOW someone is staring at you, and you see them, and they just keep looking, awkwardly...

Davy R

Is there a way to make them see the truth?

Ellen Silva

What are some tactics for creating even small cracks in the edifice of a closed mind?

Alex Quinton

Where is the best place to start? How do you recognise it and enact change?

Agrias Oaks

How do we recognize when we ourselves are being willfully ignorant?

Vikki Timler

How to respond? Is there a cure?

Johanna

why does it seem like willful ignorance is becoming a lot more common these days? are we just exposed to each other more on social media etc?

AussieColin

I know that I have a habit (which I try to fight) that when I am trying to make a life decision I tend to ask a number of people... until I find someone that agrees with the way I'm leaning and then I take that as verification that this is the way to go. I'm guessing that this could be taken as 'willful ignorance' in a way in that I'm not fully investigating.

AussieColin

I suspect that part of it is that social media has made it far easier for ignorant but opinionated people to be very visible and drown out the quiet knowledgable ones.

Chance Autwell

What’s the best way to overlook it? Deep breathing? Biting of the tongue? Block it out as soon as they start talking?

Matt Ceccato

Can willful ignorance be unlearned?

Jessica Kanani

More of an observation here. White privilege, I feel like there is a lot of willful ignorance going on there. help.

otterkel

+ white fragility. Oof.