Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Soooooo, I have an -ologist who is so so so passionate about.... ATLATLs. They are a type of spear, and this person knows just about everything there is to know about them.

This is going to be one of those episodes you walk away changed with renewed faith that EVERYTHING IS INTERESTING. Even spears you never knew existed and still can't spell. 

https://bladeaces.org/2018/02/06/atlatls-a-historical-perspective/#

Toss those questions about age-old weaponry below, my pals. 

- Dadward Von Podcast

Comments

Ashley Tunney

What is your favorite ancient weapon?

Liz Eckert

**What was the first kind of weapon that humans developed?

Jessie Dragon

Is there a registry for old weaponry? What’s the best preserved piece they’ve found? What’s the best way to preserve said weapons?

Riley McInnis

If this were a dungeons and dragons weapon, what should the range be and how much damage should it deal??? I love this.??

Joshua Reid

Do you play D&D and what ancient magic weapon does your character use?

Anna Thompson

How did you get interested in these specifically?

Declan Hoch

What’s up with Greek Fire? Is it a real thing?

Renee

Which ancient culture has the most unique weapons?

Anna Thompson

What's the hardest part about recreating weapons?

Riley McInnis

And do you think it's more of a finesse or strength based weapon??

Joe Porfido

Were there any civilizations throughout history that did not develop weaponry?

Sid Gopujkar

What were some unique weapons limited only to specific continents or areas?

Forrest Stotts

What’s more MacGyver badass than the Polish war-scythe?!? Like seriously... poor AF farmers, attaching scythe blades to the end of poles... to defend... their fellow Poles...

Christian Buettner

Do you ever do any experimental archeology and look into how the weapons are used/use them yourself?

Payton Palmerton

First time question asker!! What's your favorite type of siege weaponry??

Luna Lowery

**What kinds of toxins were used in weaponry? I know about harvesting poison dart frog poison, but what other kinds of cases are there?

Chell

Are there any parts of the world that did not develop both bladed and range weapons? How does the geography influence what types of weapons were needed?

Maren Mossman

Do you think that the invention of the cross bow revolutionized warfare at the time it was invented, since it did not require as much training in strength and technique as a bow and arrow?

Annie C

Why are trebuchets so damn cool??? I wish we had more practical uses for them nowadays...

Alexis Wallick

** No question but I am very excited about this episode. I have built and atlatl and can in fact hit the broad side of a barn.

Maren Mossman

What ancient culture had the coolest and most intriguing weapons?

Joshua Horton

Have you had the opportunity to recreate crucible steel? Any thoughts on just HOW people came up with the notion to mix carbon with their iron to make a superior metal?

RJ Doidge

Do we/is it possible to know who was the first to stab another individual? Perhaps what culture that originated?

Michael Aiguier

Do you think humans would have disappeared without this technological development?

Joshua Horton

I love your play on words here. Dad Ward, please ask this question just like it is written 😄

Maren Mossman

On the same vein, did the invention of the atlatl revolutionize hunting and warfare?

Forrest Stotts

As a Polish descendant, I appreciate that

Zachery Brown

What do you think is the most influential weapon throughout the classical and/or medieval periods? (I’m partial to the medieval European longbow)

Molly

Is there a large variety of weapon styles across various cultures of the same time period (say, pre-invasion native Americans) or is a spear pretty much a spear wherever you go?

Bennett Vanderbosch

In what ways do some modern weapons emulate ancient weapons? Whether purposefully or accidentally.

Bailey Jones

When do you think the first weapon was created? And what do you think was the first weapon?

Karen Ellyatt

Did this technology develop independently in so many places by chance? By human migration? What are the regional differences? Did you need more than one to kill a mammoth?

Emily Braibish

How did the first blacksmithing develop? Who decided, if i heat this up, I can shape it and make it sharp?

Molly

Also, what would you say is the relationship between weapon and art styles of a given culture?

Zachery Brown

What are your favorite differences between ancient ceremonial weapons versus ancient practical weapons?

Kathryn Vlasoff

What about ancient chemical or bioweapons? What kind of old crazy concoctions have people used as weapons? (I'm not just talking powerful farts)

Jen A.

What can we learn about modern society from studying these ancient weapons?

Adam Weaver

Is this a technology that has developed independently throughout multiple cultures around the world? Or is it specific to one culture? Are there similar weapons/tools in other cultures?

Annie C

Which old-school weapon would you least want to someone to be trying to hurt you with? (In other words, which one is scariest?)

Adalie Poland

In Star Trek there is a weapon called a Bat'leth. It is curved with four pointed prongs and can be held several ways. Would this be a good weapon in real life?

Kathleen Jones

WHAT IS THE WEIRDEST THING YOU HAVE HIT WITH AN ATLATL?

Zachery Brown

Ooh, yes, especially how this ties back into trebuchets and catapults because there are definitely accounts of people launching plague ridden corpses over walls!

Meghan McLean

When thinking about popular culture (movies, D&D, etc.) are there any weapons you think are either super preposterous or weapons that you think "wow, that would have been super cool if it had actually existed"?

Reuben Clamzo

Were atlatls used in playing chunkey? (Native American Mound Builder culture game, kind of a cross between skeet and bocci with spears) and is there much atlatl competition? Any world records?

Jordan Duhe

oh man so excited to learn more about atlatls! Never heard of them until I visited the Houston Museum of Natural Science last year. The exhibit info mentioned that there are some groups or cultures believed to have used atlatls, not because any were found in excavation, but because the skeletons exhibited common elbow overuse damage. or something. Am I remembering right? Can you tell by looking at a skeleton whether or not that person was an atlatl user?

Julie K. Rose

AAAAAHHHHHHHH!!!! I have no question. I'm too excited to even form words.

Zachery Brown

How often are polearms (glaives, halberds, spears) really used throughout history and are they typically tied specifically to cavalry or are there other instances of them being primarily used on foot.

Emily Okerlund

*** are there comparable weapons to the atlatl from other parts of the world? What does the timeline of ancient weapon development look like in different regions (ie, did most cultures develop weaponry around the same time) and what are the similarities and differences in how those different cultures’ weapon development proceeded?

Julie K. Rose

and yes EVERYTHING (and everyone) is interesting!! ❤️

Stefanie Freele

Why is called an Atlatl and why is it such a hard word to get yourmouth around.

SUTTON TAGGART

Were they orginally designed to be expendable or something you'd want /be able to get back?

Chris Baumann

What do you think about the reenactments of people learning how to use the old weapons? It feels like history returned and remembered!

Caitlin Fitz Gerald

Ooh, I first learned about spear-throwers via Mayan art. I did not realize it went so far back or was so widespread. Do we know about its age through depictions or actual found archeological examples? What's the oldest atlatl found? And what's your favorite bit of atlatl art, and why is it Spear-Thrower Owl?

Claire Meyer

Did spear-hunters get Atlatl elbow like tennis players get tennis elbow?

Schmitty Thompson

Are there crafting skills ancient people had that have been forgotten by modern humans? If so, how close are we to rediscovering them?

Claire Meyer

How did Atlatl use spread to six continents? Is it known where it originated?

Adam Drake

What were the most important improvements that were discovered in a given weapon? i.e.: Axe-heads. What was the biggest "look at THIS!" moment for that particular weapon. Which big improvement is your favorite?

Danielle Garrett

My husband loves atlatls and has like a billion questions but I’ll try to narrow it down. :) What are some of the most interesting and effective localized adaptations to atlatls that you’ve seen? There are various adaptations of atlatls throughout history. How do you feel time, cultures, animals hunted, etc has affected the design of the the atlatl? Do we see more particular kinds of points on atlatl darts than others? (P.s. Alie, you should do a blacksmithing episode.)

Shannon Patterson

Before the pandemic, I did archery. Can you tell me if flaming arrows were real, and how to make them if in fact they existed. The YouTubers seem split on this. My dad said I can shoot flaming arrows on the farm once the crops are harvested, so please say yes.

Sherry Burch

As an infrequent impaler of other humans, where does the spear show up in the timeline of weapons? Like looking to get a more hands on experience or hoping not to have to deal death blows by hand?

Lexi Reitz

How did a regions culture influence weapon design and production?

Ethan Bottone

Would indigenous peoples using Atlatls practice with them? If so, how and using what?

Hilary Larson

Did people really learn to fight with a Morning Star? Is this just a fantasy weapon? If so, where did it come from?

Vidie Pong

If I was marooned on an island that had game animals and trees, how reasonable would it be for me to attempt to fashion myself an atlatl, learn how to use it, and successfully hunt something before I starved to death?

Isabel M

What about a piece of metal tells you about how it was made and used? What are the marks, textures, colors, and things that indicate fabrication?

Caitlin Kupar

Were atlatls ever developed to be used from horseback? Camelback? Elephantback?

Langley Bradley

If you could combine any ancient weaponry, and it could be used effectively, what do you think would be the best combination??

Ava Schaefer

FTQA: How did ancient weapons play a part in the evolution of modern weapons and why are some (of the more interesting ones) no longer used? Follow up question: besides war combat, what were the uses for these weapons? (Today our weapons are used more for crimes and wars [that’s another can of worms] but I assume that without modern technology there would be more uses for a greater variety of weapons)

Ronda Grizzle

I've always wondered about how technologies spread and how people learned to make new or improved tools and weapons. When they changed from stone to bronze, did they start out just making metal copies of weapons they were making from stone? or is there evidence that they were traveling and trading widely enough to pick up new forms of weaponry from other cultures?

Michelle L. Pegram

Many archeological finds hold information about the life of the person the object belonged to - what can Atlatls tell us about social status, available/valued resources, or other aspects of culture?

Heather Shaver

What's the difference between an ATLATL and an Oxylotl?!?

Heather Shaver

Was old school weaponry originally created for hunting food? When and why did it shift to using it on fellow humans?

Ayshia Yaeger

How much do you LOVE forged in fire? They/them, name pronounced like Asia!

Brittany Panos

I was just gonna ask this and I gotta know what class they would play as!!

Sherry Burch

You make me snort on the regular, so it's mutual.

Rose "Comics" Turner

**my sister asks, what came first, the arrow head or the fish hook? For myself: I'd just like to know more about Native American weaponry in general.

L. Wink

How was the yo-yo used in combat? I can barely get the thing to come back up the string let alone fight with it!

Richard

Have archaeologists found any kid-sized weapons? Either doll sized or training? Mini atlatls or bows?

Seth Suchy

We're nunchucks ever an actual weapon?

Seth Suchy

What's the first complex weapon we know of? Not just a rock, stick, or rock tied to a stick.

Cass

Are atlatl dart (spear?) points fairly uniform across cultures? Also, how regional are variations on the tool? Are there patterns of similarity between cultures that might be unexpected?

Bee

Which is better: the trebuchet or the catapult?

Kile Mullen

**ftqa Is there any historical weapon you've looked at and said, "Nope, too dangerous to test."

Ruby-Leigh

FTQA: What was the deadliest spear ever? !!! (also what is your favourite mint... please be spearmint...?)

Deacon Raid

I want to know more about lantern shields. They seem super dangerous??

_motive

FTQA: What do you wish you could know about ancient weaponry, but are unlikely to because it wouldn't leave any evidence? (for example, whether users named their weapons after their moms, or put a daisy on their spear points)

_motive

What do you think was a better strategy for success in weaponry: inventing effective weapons, or stealing the ideas for effective weapons from others?

caitlin kirkwood

Are there any surprising or unique uses for spears that you know of other than basic weaponry?

Ted Hamilton

Is there any evidence of "customized" weapons in the same way people today have monogramed knives or pink pistol accesories?

Stacie Collier

*Is there any evidence for whether the atlatl was spontaneously invented by many different cultures or was passed from one group of humans to another?

Beth Monaco

At what point in time did humans begin designing weapons specific to fighting/killing other humans as opposed to weapons designed for hunting animals? Were there ever weapons designed merely for fighting as opposed to killing enemies?

Jen W

FTQA: If I wanted to make one of these, how would I go about it? Is that a good idea or a terrible one? We've done throwing knives and axes and archery - would any of those skills overlap with atlatls?

Rebekah Rodarte

Were catapults originally designed to be a weapon or were they created for other purposes?

Jennasis

Ooh! I saw these on the show Top Shot. It was really interesting to watch old school weapons in action. Did you watch the show?

Cranilation

Some societies develop weapons that others do not. Are there any weapons that one society created that you think could have been useful in other places?

Nikki DeMarco

Were there weapons made for women?

Evilh

Why are there so many different spears with strange names and weird blade bits?

Evilh

Are you asking if ancient humans had weapon skins like in video games?? I love it.

Jake Risch

do arrowheads around the world follow a similar progression over time (shorter, more triangular, and notched)? Or did different cultures make different improvements? Also what would a group do without ready access to flint or chert or obsidian etc.?

Nicole Negron

How do you figure out HOW people used some of these ancient weapons? Is it more from drawings and stuff or do you just throw replicas in the break room and brainstorm? I can’t imagine digging up an atlatl and being like “oh yeah that’s how that goes.”

John Worster

Do you know if the Atlatl was used to throw stones, or only used with spears?

Rhiannon Humeny

So... My BF thinks it would be weird to have a sword in the house. What's the best reason for a lay-person to just have a badass weapon because they're awesome?

Nyx

I know rock slings exist, thanks to Michelangelo’s David and Goliath sculpture, but what makes it so epic that he choose a 17 foot (5.17 m) chunk of marble for such an unassuming weapon? It’s got no pointy bits, and the closest thing we have today is the slingshot from Angry Birds lol

Richard

Thanks so much!

Patron Jake

If I may add to this idea: I've heard the Knife: Gun ratio of cause of injury or death is greater in places that have a less libertarian view of individual and public safety. How have we shaped our cultural views of what weaponry is considered appropriate over time and/or geography?

Patron Jake

How did we get those arrow shafts so straight?

Sarah Kulig

Wouldn't the atlatl make a totally dope D and D weapon? What would its cost be in gold pieces, and how many hit dice would its damage be worth, like how clutch of a weapon would it be for a character to wield in battle?

Patron Jake

More of a comment: fletching is a nasty sounding word

Clara Law

FTQA and future archaeologist! What are the differences/similarities between atlatls and woomera made by Aboriginal people of Australia?

Katie

how do you think wars today would be different if our weapons never progressed past the Common Era?

Clara Law

FTQA and future archaeologist! Sorry I have so many questions... What is the best type of rock (or your favourite) to make weapons/tools out of?

Robert Russell

How did the sword begin showing up all over the world?

Kathryn Vlasoff

I've heard of that too! Gross, morbid & genius.

Heather Densmore

Are you into axe throwing or are you strictly a spear person?

Sneaky Hamster

What there any weapon that was popular but relatively ineffective ?

Angelo Robledo

It is painfully hard to not answer these ahead of time haha. All of you have really really good questions!! Excited to be asked them officially by Dad Ward

Addie Cappello she her

This is awesome!!! How were these ancient weapons made and what was the primary driving force behind the creation choice? Can you shed any light on the physics behind their use? What were the advantages or disadvantages in battle? Thanks!!

Addie Cappello she her

Also: is there a way to learn the art of spear throwing in today’s society? Are there schools of ancient weapon wielding?

Robyn M

I’d be interested in heart my about the genesis for the different types of swords and why one part of the world has one style vs another.

Kethry Warren

Where are we on Damascus steel? Have we figured it out yet? What about weapons where the metal is folded many times? Is that just a cool thing that happens in fantasy books or is there a legit reason to fold metal? If so what examples do we have of the technique?

Kethry Warren

The Austin Historical Weapons Guild has classes on many different types of historical weapons (The Modern Rogue on youtube has a few videos with them), but not sure about spears

Erika Mittermaier

K - so if I've asked questions before but you have not read them - am I still a first time question asker? It does not matter this is for my bf anyways. He is an archaeologist and has questions so that must mean this is an interesting topic! Here they are! Was the atlatl brought to North America by its earliest inhabitants? Or was it independently invented later, like the bow and arrow? What is the earliest evidence for use of the atlatl in North America? Wouldn't fluted Clovis points have been too large for use as atlatl darts? - Jeremias Pink (He says "Thank Ali!")

jenna martin

So I’ve heard that the Spear King Tut was found buried with was made of meteorite. Is this true?

Zoltán Szászi

Oh this is absolutely excellent! I'm so excited! Okay, my question, the sword. From the katana through the gladius to the viking sword, seems to me, the sword looks like a default go-to weapon throughout history. Is that so, and how and why? Is it the most practical? Is it the coolest when turned into a laser weapon? Also is it true that the only thing a cavalry fears is _spear_ itself?

Michelle Jacobs

What's the coolest and/or craziest weapon you have ever seen?

Euan Munro

After having a read through the blog, I'm amazed by the worldwide prevalence of the atlatl by early man. Given that different resources would have been available depending on where people lived, was there a particular type of wood or feathers available in one area in particular that made the best spear? For example, was willow better than bamboo because it's more flexible, or particular bird feathers better for fletching?

Robin Kuehn

How did very similar types of weapons show up in different cultures worldwide? Were they traded? Are they older than the times when those peoples dispersed across continents? Or is it simple physics?

Nicole Kuha

How does one structure the shaft of the spear? like the wooden stick part? Is there a special way to carve it so the spear moves a certain way when thrown or anything? Or is it just a straight wood stick?

Clara Law

Thank you for your kind words!!

Gail Coogan

Are there any records of ancient weapons being used specifically for their look/aesthetic, and not so much for their functionality? I feel like especially rich nobles, royals, or warlords might wield certain weapons for the vibe only.

Scott Duncan

How big did battering rams really get? Movies make them seem enormous.

Anna Vallery

If I find an arrowhead on a walk, am I required to leave it or turn it in to a museum or something? I collected a bunch at our property as a kid, but now I’m wondering if that was super illegal!

Wells Howe

This, this! Definitely this!! (First time question asker- finally not lurking in the dark after a year of listening. Thank you Alie!!!!)

Kylie Torres

First time question: How heavy are swords, in Game of Thrones they just whip them around like it's nothing.

Kylie Torres

First time question: Is the colt gun from super natural real?

Joshua Odekirk

Are sling shots as dangerous as we are lead to believe?

The Project Project

How instrumental was the atl-atl in forwarding the development of humanity? With this tool, collecting protein now becomes a much, much less energy-expensive affair (compared to pursuit predation). And, related-- how big a developmental jump is it from the atl-atl and darts to a simple bow-and-arrow?

The Project Project

Forgive me, but the sling is still fairly widely used today in the Middle East and along the Silk Road, primarily by herdsmen. Simply made, easy to use (though mastery takes a lot of practice), light to carry, and the ammo is just lying there on the ground.

Abby Mandris

My brother is very involved in HEMA (Historical European Martial Arts). Aka he goes around and plays with swords. How much information do you seek in terms of construction and use/welding of weapons?

Kimberly McCall

1) what is the best stone for edged weapons, and why is it obsidian? 2) what are some unusual or unexpected materials that were used to fashion weapons in the past? 3) what was the process for becoming a jaguar warrior / eagle warrior? How were their roles different on the battlefield? 4) any other examples of throwing weapons that maybe aren't as well known? (So expanding from things like javelin, boomerang, bola, pilum, tomahawk)

Abby Cox

First time question asker! How did the earliest people figure out all the physics around developing an atlatl? Was it just trial and error? How did they pass down the information? Also - is there a good book that you recommend for learning more about ancient archaeology - specifically what day to day life was like for prehistoric humans?

Charli

What was the first real prototype of a gun? Do fireworks have an interesting history? What is the oldest known weapon in the world, and what defines a true "weapon" (e.g. would an old spoon be counted out? Even if it was involved in an old murder?)

Rowen Hill

First time question asker! How do you think the culture surrounding war and violence was different with earlier weapons, in comparison to present day?

Mariana Horta

What is the relationship between the earliest hunting weapons (were they spears?) and human evolution? Did hunting technology (and meat eating) really lead to larger human brains?

Laurie

My husband and I argue at least once a year about the pronunciation of atlatl. I feel like "how do you pronounce this" will be covered well before the listener question section, but either way I cross my fingers for an impending victory. Is there even a standardized pronunciation? Were they not used among many cultures, who would presumably have different names for the same tool?

Megan Lyn

HELL YEAH!!!! I’m a medieval fencer and I’m sooooooo excited for this ologist!

KARA JENNINGS

I really hope she asks this question. I couldn't articulate it. Thank you.

Michael Huffaker

I have made two atlatls and they have been interesting. It is remarkable how powerful they can be. I have 2 questions for your guest. What the guest's opinion on bannerstones? This is a somewhat controversial issue with many opinions. Also, what is the guest's opinion on detachable foreshafts, how widespread were they and the pros and cons of them?

Levi Stoyles

What would knights or people wearing metal armour, or holdin big long metal weapons do if a lighting storm came? would weapons be mostly be made for destruction of flesh or were they usually designed to be a multi purpose tool? Love from Newfoundland, Canada

Colin

What's their dream archeological find? P.S. Don't worry about mentioning my name, I just wanted to ask the question! P.P.S. I love this podcast.

Jess Bell

As a stone tool nerd (my BA is in Anthropology) I am super jazzed for this episode! Any recommendations for someone who wants to learn how to knap flint?

Elizabeth McKeighen

Wow, I joined five minutes ago, and this is one of my favorite topics! Question: what do you think sparked the idea for the Atlatl, because there is a lot of physics involved. Was it watching an animal? Random chance? Luck?

Laura Stacey

What is considered to be the first mechanical weapon?

Helen Langille

**When any given ancient war was over, what weapon was the most usable as a tool for daily life? (Y’know, other than a knife/bayonet)

Jenna Mace

Hi Alie! I am a long time listener and big fan who FINALLY signed up to be on Patreon! I am curious if our interviewee has any knowledge on the history of female hunting/weapon use? When weapons were first developed such as the atlatl is there any evidence that cultures did or did not allow women to hunt ? This may be a broad question but i have always been curious about ancient cultures and women hunting/ the general use of weapons.

colleeneebee

Have you ever used an ancient weapon personally, and if so, on a scale of 1 to AWESOME, how awesome (and insightful) was it?

Evi Rader

Has ground penetrating radar been used to locate old weapons?

Deenah

What was the most USELESS and UNPRACTICAL weapon created and how can I get one?

Chanelle Zap

This might be more of a bioarchaeology question, but have they determined any tell tale osteological indicators of heavy atlatl use? Like a "tennis Elbow?" Something that has been seen in remains and can be used to identify the individual as an avid or experienced user? Sidebar- if you're interested in interviewing a experimental archaeologist who specializes in flint knapping (stone tools and projectile points!) I had a guest lecturer who taught lithic analysis who would be fantastic!

Chanelle Zap

the department where I did my undergrad, we had a halloween mixer every year which included an "atlatl pumpkin smash" and a free drink for whomever got the farthest launch or hit the pumpkin!

Renee @itsdavidandrenee

Are medieval torture devices considered weapons? and if so, can we please talk about them?!

Reuben Clamzo

As a professor told me, when humans are given the same problem and similar available materials, engineering tends to develop the same solutions.

Danielle Garrett

Yeah, we just finished listening to the episode and you hit everything! Thank you; you were fantastic! I just added you on IG and we’ll probably be messaging you sometime soon with more questions. :)

Mark Donahue

The movie he is excited about doesn't appear to be getting good early reviews. bummer

The Project Project

A modern British smith has done some pretty good reproductions of several different swords. Having been given an opportunity to examine many different actual historic examples, his takeaway was his astonishment at how light and well-balanced they were. His name is Alec Steele, and he has a really good YouTube channel.

Euan Munro

Thanks Angelo ☺️

Michael Huffaker

Thank you for your reply. I have made basketmaker atlatls and they nicely provide a flat back for attachment however I have never have tried creating and attaching bannerstones . I guess we will never find out. Fore shafts do provide some handiness but do ad complexity I have found like getting the taper right so they don't fall out and even with sinew reinforcement, I can get a split of the dart at the tapered attachement receiver.

Ayshia Yaeger

Ah! That's a shame, every episode they try recreate a different historical weapon. You should give it a watch!

Sid Gopujkar

Thanks Angelo! Loved the podcast :)